The Beauty of Dirty Skin: Surprising Science of Looking and Feeling Radiant from the Inside Out looked like a promising read for anyone wanting to improve their skin. Dr. Whitney Bowe seemed to be ahead of slow western medicine - instead of treating everything with drugs, you can change your lifestyle and treat the cause instead of the symptom! However, that wasn't the case. Bowe still is happy if you're using drugs, including f**king antibiotics. Disappointing.
Since I've already done in depth research on the gut-brain-skin axis and probiotics, the science was still complementary but I wanted to know how she was going to apply it to lifestyle.
The science in this book about the human microbiome and its connection to skin seemed accurate and interesting. However, there were a lot of flaws in this book that gave a major hit to its rating.
So, the bad things...
Order of topics. This book gives you a lot of science (as promised), but only gives you the lifestyle changes/recommendations much later on. I was getting bored of the science (albeit, it is interesting, but I got the book more to hear her recommendations) and wanted her to get to the juicy part.
Lack of probiotics suggestions. I was excited to hear what strains she recommends and why, and a good product suggestion list. Instead, I had to wait until around page 200 to see the strains and she gave ZERO product recommendations. She kept saying "visit my website! visit my website! Do you want this info? GO TO MY WEBSITE!!!" and I was like "was this designed to be a book, or a redirect to her website?" Another disappointment here...
Vitamins.
Wrong, wrong, wrong... GTFO of the nutritional recommendations if you don't have the proper knowledge.
VITAMIN D
"Should you get tested for a Vitamin D deficiency/ As of now, the jury s still out as to whether healthy people should get screened. USPSTF says evidence is insufficient to assess the risks versus the benefits of screening in people who have
no symptoms of a true deficiency, including muscle weakness and bone pain...
. So even though Vitamin D testing is widely available, we don't have enough data showing that screening people who don't have symptoms or risk factors does any good!" (188).
ZINC
"Zinc (10-30mg daily)" WTF? Women are supposed to get 8mg daily. Men are supposed to get 11mg daily. Why tf would you take 30mg ON TOP OF the zinc you get in your diet??!?!?!?!??! Too much zinc can lead to high blood pressure, digestive problems and other complications (as I know personally, from others & from research). 10mg is more likely to be safe. And if you're already getting a good amount of zinc from your diet, it really can cause complications.
COPPER
She recommends possibly taking some as a supplement. I tracked what I ate for 3 months with a nutritional profile and found 99% of the time I was getting 100-200% DV of copper. I don't get why most people would need to take a supplement here... (I know, anecdotal evidence, but copper deficiency is super rare unless you're messing with your zinc).
This:
Probiotics don't replace drugs. Just try taking some with your drugs. -Dr. Whitney Bowe
Antibiotics = 👍. To be fair, Dr. Bowe does acknowledge the risk of antibiotics. But instead of denouncing them (especially considering there are other, better drugs out there for majority of skin problems), she still is fine with people using them and probably prescribes them too. WHY TF would you be okay with wasting antibiotics on people with skin conditions like acne that can be cured with SO MANY OTHER treatments??!! There are drugs, topical creams, and natural methods. I just don't understand. Antibiotics are so unnecessary here and it's not even like they have a 100% success rate and are super amazing at treating issues. Any person using antibiotics for an unnecessary reason is contributing to our bacteria-resistant-to-antibiotics problem.
Ummm
Early in the book she says, "don't worry, your diet won't be too restrictive and hard and missing desserts! My plan is soo great and you get the best diet and not too many restrictions!" And then...
EVICT:
"All forms of processed and refined carbohydrates, sugars, and packaged foods (chips, crackers, rice cakes, cookies, pastries, muffins, donuts, sugary snacks, candy, most commercial energy and protein bars, jams, jellies, preserves, ketchup, other condiments with sugar, processed cheese spreads, fruit and vegetable juices, dried fruit, sports drinks, commercial bread and English muffins, soft drinks and soda, fried foods, refined sugar (white and brown), corn syrup."
Also: dairy milk/ice cream, processed fats and vegetable oils, artificial sweeteners
REPLACE WITH
Protein: meat, meat, meat, meat, meat, meat, meat, meat oh and also legumes. maybe.
Real sweeteners: unrefined brown and white sugar, maple syrup, honey, stevia...
I was expecting no sugar, but okay then... I don't know if I agree with that recommendation.
She says you're allowed one serving of carbs a day. HA that's not hard at all.
Recipes aren't inclusive???
90% of her recipes are meat-reliant and at least 40% of them use stevia, sugar or maple syrup or some sweetener. I basically had to ignore that section. I think she gave one vegan salad option and that's it. Stupid.
idiot
"Also note: there's a lot of unnecessary fear surrounding chemicals in products and whether or not organic is the way to go. Just because something is organic doesn't mean that it's safe. Remember: anthrax and poison ivy are natural and organic!" (229).
FACEPALM x1000.
>> *Correction: There's a lot of NECESSARY fear surrounding chemicals in products. Toxins in cosmetics are DISEASE-CAUSING, awful for the environment, and can come from animals/be tested on animals who were tortured/in horrible situations. If you haven't bothered to do the research on these toxins, don't spread misinformation about there being no harm when you have no idea what you're talking about. | Anthrax and poison ivy are "organic", but they aren't "certified organic" as in no synthetic pesticides, etc. Natural means literally nothing on cosmetic labels, so don't know what your point is there. A product made with cancer-causing toxins like toluene and parabens could be called "natural" by its producer. Of course being organic doesn't mean it's safe - but the chances of it being safe are slightly more if the manufacturer cares about making its product organic.
Good to know:
EMULSIFIERS
"Emuslifiers act as blending agents in food products that contain otherwise unmixable ingredients (like oil and water), as well as being a preservative. They include carrageenan, soy lecithin, polysorbate 80, polyglycerols, locust bean gum, guar gum, and xanthan gum. They are "gut disrupters"." (p. 60)
Recommended strains:
Lactobacillus plantarum, acidophilus, rhamnosus, paracasei
Bifidobacterium breve, bifidum
Bacillus coagulans
Section on importance of exercise and sleep was good. None of that was news to me but the reinforcement was fine.
Overall, I probably would recommend this book to people. However, there is a bit of misinformation and you should be prepared that it takes a long time to actually get to the recommendations. If you care about the science, this book is for you. If you care about the application, this book isn't as much of a winner.