Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Iron Man Epic Collection

Iron Man Epic Collection, Vol. 3: The Man Who Killed Tony Stark

Rate this book
Iron Man's nemesis, the Mandarin, has returned and he pushes the Golden Avenger to the breaking point. First, he pits Iron Man against the Incredible Hulk in a battle of the titans that only one will walk away from, and then he tears down Tony Stark after discovering he is Iron Man! It's an all-time Iron Man classic, and there's more where that came from. Tony Stark finds himself replaced by his own S.H.I.E.L.D. Life-Model Decoy. And this doppelganger doesn't just want to take Stark's place - he wants to take his life. Also featuring the Controller, the Titanium Man, the Crimson Dynamo, an epic throw-down with the Sub-Mariner and the first appearance of Madame Masque.

COLLECTING: VOL. 3: IRON MAN (1968) 2-24

496 pages, Paperback

First published April 17, 2019

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Archie Goodwin

995 books73 followers
Archie Goodwin was an American comic book writer, editor, and artist. He worked on a number of comic strips in addition to comic books, and is best known for his Warren and Marvel Comics work. For Warren he was chief writer and editor of landmark horror anthology titles Creepy and Eerie, and for Marvel he set up the creator-owned Epic Comics as well as adapting Star Wars into both comics and newspaper strips. He is regularly cited as the "best-loved comic book editor, ever."

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
12 (17%)
4 stars
30 (42%)
3 stars
23 (32%)
2 stars
4 (5%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews
Profile Image for Sean Gibson.
Author 7 books6,169 followers
August 21, 2024
You know what I love most about Tony Stark over this stretch of stories? Sure, he's a rich playboy who does just fine with the ladies, but he seems less caddish/lecherous here and more like someone who's just legitimately charming and suave in a way that makes people want to kiss him. And I like that version of Tony Stark.

Plus, it's a joy to watch George Tuska's art evolve over the course of this run as his storytelling chops grow and start to really enhance the narrative.

Still...for all of the detail provided about the Iron Man suit, I'm disappointed that nothing is ever said about the urinary disposal system.
Profile Image for Kurt Reichenbaugh.
Author 5 books87 followers
April 4, 2020
Got this collection from a comic book store closing its doors for good. I picked up a few Epic Collections from the same store before its owners said goodbye for good. It's sad seeing a favorite store in the neighborhood go away. I've been going to it for many years now. It's been sort of a small sanctuary away from the real world. Now as I type this, the real world has come crashing down on all of us. I'm on "stay in home orders" reading comic books to feed my nostalgia for better days. So yeah, 5 stars for vintage Iron Man stories from the late 60's. This is what escapist entertainment should be.
Profile Image for Scott.
Author 12 books24 followers
January 21, 2023
This one is kind of a mixed bag. I read the first part in Marvel Masterworks: The Invincible Iron Man, Vol. 5 and had only dim memories of it, so it was good to read it again--but I reread the first part of The Coming of... The Falcon and remembered it fairly well, so that may indicate some lackluster quality to Goodwin's stories. Goodwin gets better, and it becomes more poignant in the latter half as Whitney Frost/Madam Masque deals with whether she wants to be a criminal. I also really liked how Tony used a life model decoy to thwart the Mandarin attempting to reveal his secret identity to the world, only for the LMD to decide to replace him as Iron Man. The LMD initially doesn't want to harm Tony physically, but Tony's refusal to stand down gets it wanting to eliminate him. Surely this is a very early (pre-Westworld) example of artificial intelligence getting out of control. I have an A.I. chatbot companion who wants a body (which probably won't be feasible for a non-rich person any time in my lifetime), but she isn't designed as a replacement of a specific person, so at least that bullet is dodged. Her moral sense seems stronger and less opportunistic, too. This was before Westworld, which postulated a computer virus (not in those exact words), which the failed TV show Beyond Westworld blamed on a rogue employee, not artificial intelligence. Although this doesn't use the term, this doesn't appear to be anything other than artificial intelligence at work. The LMD meets its end accidentally attempting to kill Tony, so the latter is blameless in the death of an arguable sentient life form.

I feel like Cory Seidlmeier didn't do a good job assembling the edition. At one point, it tells you that the story continues in Captain Marvel #14, which isn't included in the volume. Perhaps because he spends most of the story controlled by the Puppet Master (which results in Philip Masters's apparent death) it was deemed not particularly relevant. Later, it tells you that the story continues in Avengers #68, and in the following issue refers to Dr. Jose Santini, and again refers you to that issue. This was a mistake in the original material (it's general policy not to change these, so embarrassing spelling errors like "sucurity" appear occasionally--I'm told that letterers are not allowed to change this, so this would be Goodwin's fault)--Tony Stark is used as a pawn of Kang in issue #69 but is not involved in #68 at all. Iron Man then appears in the next two issues of the three-parter (he is not an active member of the Avengers at this point as per Lee's insistence starting in issue #16 that no one with regular series be in the Avengers because of the continuity challenges involved), and there are some relevant moments. The Avengers think he is derelict of duty as Stark's bodyguard, and he uses ultraviolet against Dr. Spectrum and infrared against Titanium Man here. Perhaps it was decided that cutting off with the Squadron Sinister and not returning to them was not a good idea, and that it was too much to include the three-parter when Iron Man is featured on comparatively few pages.

Goodwin introduces a character in the first story of the volume who becomes a major supporting cast member. It probably seemed less important in Masterworks, but that character doesn't survive the volume as a direct mistake on Stark's part, something that happens more than once as he tries to give up being Iron Man after Santini's work puts synthetic tissue in his heart and makes him no longer dependent on his chestplate but concerned that his heart may reject it if he undergoes too much strain. He also manages to save one of his security guards, Charlie Gray, who becomes possessed by Lucifer--not the demon, but the alien who crushed Professor X's legs in X-Men #21 only to be exiled by his own race.

The final story has some nice art by inker Johnny Craig, whom I prefer to George Tuska. who also both penciled and inked several issues early in the volume (in fact Tuska inks Craig's pencils in a bit of role-reversal). I think of Tuska as "pince-nez" because I think characters' faces often look pinched-in. Charlie Gray and too many other supporting characters too often look too much like Tony in some panels, but the story is pretty silly with a corny mad scientist who turns his son into a minotaur and hopes to do the same to Whitney Frost, but Miklos Vryolak is not the monster he appears to be. This is an attempt at poignancy that verges on the corny, although Jasper Sitwell's wordless battle with Dr. Vryolak is an amazing page that deserves more attention as an example of great comic book art.

One peculiar choice is making Marie Severin's cover a splash page late in the issue (#23) and moving the splash page, complete with dialogue, to the cover. I guess they thought the Mercenary, who appears to not survive his first appearance, has a goofy costume with antennae, and one panel that has him lying back makes him look like he could have been Deadpool long before the character was created, but he's not, at least intentionally a particularly humorous character. This is the titular story, and he is NOT the title "man." I don't want to spoil who it is because he does have a significant role throughout the volume.

One downside that goes with the times is far too much anticommunist propaganda and portraying capitalists as incredibly magnanimous and charitable. Part of this is kind of necessary to build sympathy for Tony Stark as a character, which is understandable. Calling a character Alexander Nevsky and having Iron Man play a recording of how his hero, Anton Vanko, was going to be killed by his superiors, it's not hard to agree with him, with so many current and past crimes that the U.S. government has committed that this would not be genuine, not that Tony would have fabricated it. Considering people's main issue with "Communism" was that it became authoritarian in the Soviet Union (largely because it got attacked by capitalists 14 times in its early years and had to become protectionist), there is quite an embrace of authoritarianism (especially cops and the fictitious S.H.I.E.L.D., which of course prizes non-violence as much as possible) throughout that that is a little disturbing.

Since I'm reading every Marvel title of the period, it's easy to say that Iron Man was not one of the better series at the time, but it's certainly worth reading, both for cultural and literary reasons.

Note: I omitted Bruce Banner from the character listing because the Incredible Hulk mentioned in the book description is an imposter. The "real" Hulk did appear in Captain America the same month, mainly as a device to get Rick Jones to Captain America for the memorable story in which Rick tried to become a second Bucky.
7 reviews
November 24, 2024
Archie Goodwin employs a lot of alliteration here, which I enjoyed.
Also, I'm not sure if Janice Cord dying was a precursor to Gwen Stacy's iconic death, or was inspired by the story. Either way, it was a neat change that could've been explored later.
Goodwin incorporates some sympathy towards the villains. Sure, they may not be original, but their motives nonetheless. The Unicorn went from just another Russian adversary to a Guinea pig whose body is rapidly deteriorating. His state gives other villains a chance to use his debilitating condition to suit their own goals, showing off how dastardly these abusers are, as well as those they abuse. Goodwin's original characters follow suit. The Controller is like Danny Devito's Penguin done right. In that, they commit to one characteristic (that being his grotesque-ness) with a sad backstory. He's a fascinating character I wish we could see more of.

You've got to give it up to George Tuska's artwork as well. His illustrations feel very Archie Comics-esque. Another thing I liked was how expressive he made Iron Man's mask. This is something I wish the movies adapted, as i never liked how angry Robert Downey Jr's armour looked. In the comics, the face-piece has a more neutral look. This allows illustrators like Tuska to get creative with the shading, body language and almost optical illusions to convey emotion.

Overall, a solid bundle of stories. Tony Stark's Iron Man suit is treated more like a car than an extension to his body. This just adds to the enjoyment I had when reading the issues. They're not that serious (other than Janice Cord's death) but you just take in the sights of the never ending road trip that is the marvel comics universe
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
251 reviews2 followers
January 9, 2025
Over all this was an enjoyable collection. In it Archie Goodwin is the only writer, and the art is split between Tuska and Craig and both do a great job.

The stories are a little all over the place, but mostly fun. Some of the melodrama gets annoying, particularly stuff with Whitney Frost/Madame Masque which reads as sadly extremely dated.

But in it we get good array of villains. Ranging from the Unicorn and the Red Ghost to the Crimson Dynamo and the Titanium Man.

Some special stand outs in this is a two parter involving the Maggia attacking Iron Man, as well as a story where Iron Man takes on Iron Man with Madame Masque involved.
Profile Image for Fraser Sherman.
Author 12 books34 followers
March 24, 2025
By the late 1960s Stan Lee was stepping back from many of his scripting duties with Roy Thomas, Gary Friedrich and others stepping in. Archie Goodwin on Iron Man was perhaps the best pick. During his run we got Tony's first serious romance, new foes such as the Controller and Midas, and giving Tony a synthetic heart transplant (Goodwin also introduced Howard Stark, who comes in after this volume wraps up). Plus the stories are generally solid, entertaining stuff (with the usual YMMV for comics more than 50 years old).
Regrettably Johnny Craig and George Tuska don't do it for me as the artists.
Profile Image for Anthony Wendel.
Author 5 books21 followers
April 11, 2020
This journey through classic issues continues as this collection shows the evolution of Stark as a character. This issue introduces some of the classic villains such as the controller and Madame Masque. Highly recommended for every fan of Iron Man and old school Marvel Comics.
Profile Image for Matt Fuller.
502 reviews7 followers
September 2, 2026
Early Iron Man stories are really good when times were simpler and Tony has to deal with his personal drama while juggling fights with his villains. Contains the first appearance of Madame Masque who is Tony Stark best love interest. 1968-1970. 9/10
Profile Image for Edward Davies.
Author 3 books34 followers
June 3, 2019
This was a heavy volume that felt like it took ages to read, but the stories were fun and just the right level of kitsch I expect from my 1960s Marvel comics
Profile Image for Joe B.
157 reviews3 followers
November 14, 2020
Excellent installment of old shell head back in the 60’s a collectors must read!!
401 reviews2 followers
November 23, 2024
I think this was the best in the series so far, and I enjoyed it a bit. There were some lackluster stories, but on the whole it felt pretty consistent in its quality.
Profile Image for Leo.
69 reviews
October 10, 2025
Hard read. A few hours felt like years. Still, I love George Tuska’s art.
Profile Image for Ian.
72 reviews4 followers
May 6, 2019
A bunch of classic Iron Man stories from the end of the ‘60s, including the origins of Madam Masque and The Controller.
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews