#1 of 22 in my personal (and rather random) challenge to read Abbot's Makers of History series. The series is most famously known for influencing Abraham Lincoln.
Jacob Abbot's historical biographies were famously read by Lincoln, who credited them for all his understanding of historical figures of power. I decided to start with his biography of Elizabeth I, the subject I felt I knew most about already. Despite being published over 100 years ago, it was a fresh read, engaging.
A couple things were impacted by the time it was written though. Some details were omitted, probably to avoid shocking people of Abbott's time. For instance, there was no mention that one of Anne Boleyn's accused lovers was her brother and that Anne was accused of incest. No discussion of Queen Mary's fertility issues and possible cause of death (uterine cancer). Basically anything sexually scandalous beyond adultery was omitted. Understandable not just because Abbott was writing in a different time, but also because his work tended to gravitate toward younger readers.
Another oddity. Abbott made several comments comparing Mary Queen of Scots and Elizabeth, suggesting that people of his time loved and romanticized Mary Queen of Scotts and had little interest in Elizabeth. He mentions how visitors to their tombs in Westminster Abbey pause only briefly at Elizabeth's tomb, but stand mournful in front of Mary's tomb. With all the interpretations of Elizabeth in recent decades, I think Mary has become more of a footnote to Elizabeth's life. Interesting how we view people of the past differently depending on our own world. I think feminism changed our perspective of her, making Elizabeth look more empowered and less power-hungry. Personally, I think Elizabeth's choice to not marry has nothing to do with her desire for power. I think it has more to do with witnessing her father's abuse of marriage during her formative years. At any rate, this biography gives us the benefit of another historical perspective. You won't see the pretty, regal, feministic Cate Blanchett in this work.
Queen Mary (Elizabeth's sister) on the other hand is viewed the same as you find in contemporary perspectives, pious and cruel, an unhappy woman in an unhappy marriage. Abbot's description of her relationship with Phillip of Spain was colorful, as was Elizabeth's similar torment with Essex. So despite the delicate handling of some subjects, Abbot still managed to invoke the passions of his subjects. He also maintained an honest representation of Elizabeth, who he admired for her cunning, but called out on her pettinesses.
A good, relatively quick read. I'll probably check out his Mary Queen if Scots biography next.