When a new rule goes into place, the Sweet Valley High cheerleading squad is forced to choose a faculty advisor, and co-captains Jessica Wakefield and Heather Mallone are determined to find one who won’t interfere too much. When Elizabeth suggests Nancy Swanson, the timid library assistant, they decide she’s the perfect choice. Nancy is quiet and awkward, but she attends every game and knows a lot about cheerleading and, best of all, she won’t try to be in charge. Meanwhile, Elizabeth is helping out on some research for a magazine article on the past cheerleaders of Sweet Valley High. What she finds is far more tragic and deadly than she could have imagined, and history has a way of repeating itself. Trigger warnings: death, car accidents, drowning, abduction, captivity, guns, illness, bullying, ableism, infidelity.
I always loved Sweet Valley as a kid, and I should have realized that a special fondness for the horror/thriller editions was eventually going to turn into a love for both genres. I have a high bar for both though, so I wouldn’t call this terribly thrilling. A good portion of it is given over to Jessica’s pursuit of Brad, an especially sleazy love interest who flirts with everyone, including her twin sister. (There are so many reasons Elizabeth was always my favorite Wakefield twin.) He killed a lot of the book for me.
Aside from that, it’s a fun plot with plenty of twists. It’s creepy when the cheerleaders start disappearing one by one, although there’s not much mystery involved. It’s clear early on that Nancy is behind it and also that she needs a therapist, not a basement full of dead cheerleaders, but the 90s were a different time for mental health representation (and it’s still always not top notch, let’s be real). Almost thirty years later, I’m not sure this book would be published, since making the villain of the story a traumatized and disabled victim of bullying is pretty gross. The ending gets a little silly, but it’s entertaining overall, if not one of my favorites in the series.
I review regularly at brightbeautifulthings.tumblr.com.