If he takes their life, they can never truly leave.
That's the mantra Noah Wilmington has lived by for years. He picks up whores and deviants from the local taverns, enjoys their company for an evening...and then hides their bodies in the woods.
Edward Yorke has approached the same man in the same public house time and again, never deterred by the cool dismissal he receives. There's something about Noah that calls to him. A shared pain, a shared sadness...
But Noah doesn't trust himself. It's too risky to permit someone too close, and Edward is the one person in the world whose life Noah wants to spare. So, every time Edward has asked to buy him a drink, Noah declines.
Then one night, out of sheer loneliness, that "no" becomes a "yes."
When Edward's night with him sheds light on some of Noah's dark secrets, Noah cannot simply let him walk out the door. But if he doesn't want Edward dead, and he can't let him leave, only one option really remains...
(Unchained is a gay Victorian-era romance novella with a HEA.)
This was such a interesting and unique premise and it was also a wonderful story! The writing was amazing, the historical atmosphere was great and I loved everything that the author was doing with this story. Before diving into what I loved about the story, I want to give the author additional kudos for the beautifully simple yet meaningful title and the equally minimalistic but meaningful cover. The title Unchained and the old fashioned key on the cover meant nothing to me when I started the story but like the best stories, the meaning of both became clear as the story progressed and they're both absolutely perfect. Both of these things were fantastic choices and it emphasizes how well this author understands her craft. Now onto the story itself!
I'm usually wary about captor-captive situations because they tend to involve instalove and romanticize the captor too much, but I was instantly intrigued by the unusual captor-captive situation that the author created here. This was such an incredible unique premise!
In addition, the author did a fantastic job showing the difficult balancing act that both characters went through as they struggled to adhere to their dual roles in each other's lives. It was great how the author used this dichotomy to make both characters (especially Noah) more sympathetic to readers and to make us root for them as a couple. I would shake my head many times, thinking that the situation is impossible and there's no way that these two can ever reach an HEA but the author cleverly steers the plot along further interesting routes that seamlessly leads to that HEA.
Another thing I adored is how wonderful the romance between Edward and Noah was.
In particular, I love the way the climax put Noah and Edward into a situation where they were forced to choose between doing the morally right thing versus fighting for their future as a couple and the way the entire thing was resolved was perfect in terms of who these characters are and their arcs throughout the story. But fair warning - .
Another thing I loved was how well the author handled Noah's many mental health issues. It's implied that he's one of those serial killers who was born being genetically inclined towards violence which makes him a dangerous individual. But on the other hand, he's suffered horrific abuse during his childhood and he has severe abandonment issues, which gives him a vulnerability and shyness that Edward helps him with. I loved how the author had Noah flip between being a cold, dangerous killer versus being a gentle man who is wary of other people and the hurt they might bestow upon him. I also adored the pacing of Noah's development throughout the story as his self-confidence slowly grows and he makes gradual progress on trusting Edward and allowing more physical contact between them.
The only things I wished had been done slightly differently is the balance between plot and sex. For a short story, I felt there were too many sex scenes and the story had the potential for much more plot than the author provided. But I still highly recommend this due to how much this story stands out in the sea of historical Victorian-era MM romances. The characters were fantastic, the romance was interesting and the story is one of the most unique and clever ones I've ever come across. I'm devastated that this author has only published one story and I'm keeping my fingers crossed that we'll get something more one day.
For anybody interested, there are two similarly themed stories that I know of:
For those who adored the gothic-horror Victorian vibes of this story and enjoyed the morally corrupt characters, I highly recommend Resurrection by MildredMost, which is free on AO3. I read it a few years go but the beautiful writing, creepy vibe and wonderful romance have stuck me ever since and Unchained is very similar to it. Resurrection takes place in pseudo-Victorian England and involves a romance between a grieving widower mourning his recently deceased husband and a grave robber. Incidentally - one of the MCs is called Edward!
Another similar story would be The Damnation Of Leander Welles by Ashlyn Drewek, which also features morally corrupt MCs who are head over heels in love with each other and won't allow anybody or anything to threaten their relationship.
Edward and Noah are both tremendously lonely people.
Noah, abused by his parents and honestly just mentally unwell, tries to relieve his sadness by indulging in his urge to kill. This does happen on page and it's not gory but this book is probably not suited for the faint-hearted. Noah has deep abandonment issues which does seem linked to his killings, Edward suggesting that it's a way to avoid being left by anyone.
Edward's family is dead, and the only company he has in life is his cat. He's working an uninteresting job, doesn't have any friends, and spends his free time in pubs mostly having his advances rebuffed.
This is how Edward and Noah meet. They've both been admiring the other from afar, each time Edward asking Noah if he can buy him a drink, and Noah turning him down. Not because he isn't interested, but because he is, and he doesn't quite know what to do with that. When Noah finally agrees to a drink then invites Edward home for dinner (not murder), things don't exactly go to plan.
After Edward accidentally uncovers Noah's box of trinkets, pilfered from the corpses of his victims, Noah still doesn't want to hurt him so decides to hold Edward hostage until he can make up his mind on what to do. ______________
I liked this quite a lot. Both characters were actually really lovely.
Edward is sort of like a puppy. There's this very endearing softness and innocence to him. His previous life is pretty dreary and all he really seems to want is to be loved and cared for so he falls fairly easily into this new existence once he sees how much Noah cherishes him.
And Noah, poor Noah. He was just so damned lonely. Look at me over here, empathising with a serial killer. I do think I would have enjoyed a bit more detail on Noah's past and his urges, but overall I'm glad that the author neither tried to justify his acts nor condemn him in any moralistic way.
I think my favourite part of this was Edward grappling with the knowledge that Noah has killed a number of people in the past, and trying to work out how he would feel if Noah were to continue killing. Maybe I'm a bit unhinged too, but I love reading about moral dilemmas like this particularly when it's done in a very grey kind of way. The climax of this shows it perfectly as they have to decide how far they're willing to go to protect their love.
It was satisfying to watch Noah come out of his shell and slowly grow to trust Edward and be vulnerable with him. I thought it was fitting how Noah took on a caretaking role and I think the physical caretaking (cooking, cleaning, bathing) was a good proxy for the emotional aspects that were alien to him.
There was probably a bit too much focus on the sex here, though I liked the growing intimacy of the acts. In the beginning Noah has a real aversion to touch and even though he doesn't want to, he shies away from Edward. As he becomes more comfortable, this becomes less of an issue and it did mirror their relationship development quite nicely.
I did think this was well-written though the setting was a bit ambiguous to me. I think the main thing that threw me off was how easy and comfortable it seemed for Noah to be picking up men in public houses and taking them home, though I suppose it would be in Victorian England as long as you were in a place known for that.
Overall, a very engaging read which I'd recommend to anyone looking for a morally dark atmosphere but with a soft and caring relationship.
Thanks to AngelFire for bringing this one to my attention!
This was nothing like I imagined. It was more dark (not too much though), twisted and unexpected than it first appeared. Even if it's not a long read, the characters are complex, polar opposites actually as Noah and Edward couldn't be more different.
The mystery and goth elements add to the allure, secrets and lies hide in plain sight and the truth of Noah's nature is not something he's ashamed of. I think he's one of the most interesting characters I've read about. And Edward is one that can understand things beyond the obvious, I liked his sweet nature.
It's a captiving read, written with care, that can surprise and keep you glew to its pages. I hope to read more works from the author, maybe even a sequel.
So, by now you all know I love historical romances, right? Especially if they're MM since there are so few. Christina Lee, one of the authors I follow, suggested this book on her FB page and once I saw the cover (so elegant in its simplicity) and read the blurb, I was hooked.
Noah is a serial killer, picking up whores and deviants in local pubs and after killing them, disposing of their bodies in the woods near his house. The one person he refuses to kill is one that has been insisting for Noah to share a drink with him. Until one night in which Noah can't find it in himself to keep denying himself.
Edward is lonely. He's been attracted to the dashing stranger he sees at the tavern every once in a while for months, and every time Edward's asked to buy him a drink, the man has refused. When he finally says yes, Edward has no idea that he has gotten himself into.
Noah can't bring himself to kill Edward, as he's done with countless others, but that doesn't mean he can let him leave, either.
I haven't read all that many Gothic romances, three or four maybe, but I'm loving the added horror/mystery element to them. In this case, Noah is a killer and has been one for years. He's a dichotomy. For one part, he's completely unapologetic about what he's done, at least until it might affect how Edward sees him. And for the other, he's so sweet to Edward, even when he kept him chained and locked inside Noah's room. He went out of his way to cook food that Edward would enjoy and to make him comfortable, despite it taking Noah so long to trust Edward. And Edward, well, he was adorable, nice and loving and even when he found it difficult to come to terms with Noah being a killer at first, once he realized he had feelings for Noah, he fully embraced Noah and worked for his trust. They fit together like puzzle pieces, both lonely and longing for something that they never thought they'd have. Of course, it doesn't hurt that they have amazing chemistry together and the sex scenes are passionate and sweet.
Overall, this was a wonderfully written book, intriguing and captivating. I was completely enamored with Noah and Edward and very invested in their HEA, which didn't disappoint. Highly recommendable!
*** Copy provided to me via BookSprout for my reading pleasure. ***
This was a truly thrilling read! Loved it!! I don't make a habit of reading stories with criminal or murderous MC's, because I find them difficult to like or relate too, but this one came so highly recommended (Riley Hart, Christina Lee) that I felt I needed to take a chance. And wow... I'm so glad I did!
It's an odd & slightly uncomfortable feeling to be rooting for a serial killer, a rather unrepentant one at that, and not even one who tries to stick to killing "other monsters" like, say, Dexter. The places our mind can go to in a fictional world... If nothing else, this is a great testament to the incredible skill of this author. Showing us the many shades of grey there can be.
There's such a scary atmosphere permeating this book. Danger lurking behind every corner. You're never at ease, because even when things seem to be going alright and you're tempted to let down your guard...you're really just waiting for that axe to fall. And for all that I knew something was coming, must be coming...I was still completely taken aback when it did.
The writing is beautiful and evocative. Words flowing smoothly along, setting the mood perfectly and drawing us a wonderfully clear picture of enigmatic Noah and Edward and the world they live in. The late nineteenth century serves as an ideal background for their story. Both Noah and Edward are very compelling MC's, flaws and all. And though at first glance they seem really different, because duh "serial-killer", they also have something important in common. They have both known great sadness and pain in their youth, and as a result are very much alone, and lonely, in their own way.
In a wonderful twist, we also have the prey actually stalking the predator. Unknowingly, of course. I also loved that Noah, though the most dangerous one of the two men, is physically the least imposing, being smaller and less muscled than Edward. Brilliantly done!
This book put me in mind of the fable of the Scorpion and the Turtle, with the Scorpion staying true to his nature, no matter the consequences, even for himself. What would be the stronger force here? Nature or...?
A very unique kind of plot, I was intrigued when I read the blurb and as I read this unusual tale I fell in love with it, something completely different, weird, intense, but different. It's so bloody hard when you know you should very much dislike Noah, but somehow you can't, it's frustrating, you want to understand why he's like this and why he has skidded to a halt because of Edward. Each chapter blows me away a little more, this is an historical mm romance on a bloody high trip, crazy, breathtaking but you can't stop reading it. I say "Well done!" to this author, you did something amazing, you found a new genre ' historical mm romance while murdering the rest'. Sadly it seems like this author wrote this about 4 years ago and nothing since, according to Goodreads anyway, if true then that's a crying shame.
This is not your usual cuddly romance. It's not a sweet, loving little book, it's a truly dark story which is beautifully written. The beginning repels you, but intrigues at the same time.
It's such a strange read, I don't want to give anything away, but I actually found myself sympathising with a serial killer! The story was compelling, it's the kind of book you think isn't for you, but you can't put down.
It's a testament to the author that I found both MCs extremely sympathetic, and was rooting for them. The atmosphere throughout the book is reminiscent of Gothic horror, combining fiction, horror and death.Very highly recommended.
An ARC was provided by the author via Booksprout. The full review can be read on Dog-Eared Daydreams.
Ainsley Gray has penned a story with an antihero who doesn't demand anyone's sympathy or understanding, but Noah Wilmington earned my empathy nonetheless. There's a reason why he does what he does--why he can't quite stop himself from taking the lives of those he's chosen when he heads out to his local haunts. He carefully selects each of his companions, but there's one person--one man--who has made it a point to engage him in conversation every single time their paths cross in the tavern, and every single time the offer of a drink leaves the man's lips, Noah has politely declined...until he doesn't. But what's he to do with Edward Yorke once he gets him up close and personal?
Yes, this is a novella, but there is a great deal that goes on in the less than 130 pages that contain Noah and Edward's story. There is no over-romanticizing nor is their any sort of glossing over that occurs. Noah is very much a murderer and anyone who tries to sugarcoat that fact would basically be them trying to make Noah into someone he is not. Now, I did mention earlier that Noah earned my empathy, but I can't fully explain why without giving away spoilers, and well, this is the sort of story that needs to remain spoiler-free in order for those who have yet to read it to fully appreciate what unfolds. What I can share is that there's amazing tension in the book, as there should be for a dark-themed novella that belies an actual romance evolving between Noah and Edward. With admirably effective writing and notable characters, Unchained is a remarkable five-starred debut not to be missed. ♥
Gray. Gray area. It’s a fitting last name for the author of this novel, because it inhabits a liminal space, a gray area between romance and thriller. From reading the description, you might have an inkling of what’s in store for Noah and Edward, but until the final chapters, there is never any clear indication of where this will lead.
Edward is alone in the world, visits the same location time and again, just to be around other people. Each time he offers Noah a drink, the handsome man declines, but Edward keeps trying. Finally, Noah agrees, and Edward is delighted. Noah is not so sure of his decision, but can’t help himself.
Then, one moment of curiosity changes the situation forever. The chains that bind come in many forms, and neither man is quite certain where they will end up or what will become of their love. Edward will have to alter his perception of their relationship, and Noah will need to learn about trust.
I’m a huge mystery fan, had five scenarios in mind until the end, and read it in one sitting. If you’re like me, already gearing up for the Halloween season and dark of the year, you’ll likely enjoy this novel. It’s unusual, and the romance is a sweet one, if you’re willing to let the links draw you in.
This book revolves around Noah, a man who has murdered numerous men and women and Edward, a man who has wanted to be with Noah for a long time. Noah takes Edward hostage and keeps him chained and drugged. As time passes they fall in love with each other and Noah begins to trust Edward when he says he will not leave him. As the story progresses, the police come looking for Noah and they make make to leave the country. These are two lonely men who have come to rely upon each other for support and love. The book makes you feel sorry for the cruelty Noah has previously suffered and how it leads him yo his current situation. The book is well written and I would recommend it but at the same time it may not appeal to everyone.
I wasn't quite sure what to expect with this book. I love Victorian romances and what makes it better than one between two men. This book captured my imagination from the very beginning. I was trying to guess where the author was taking us, so many twists and turns and never where I thought we may end up. I found myself hating Noah but also loving him much like Edward. Even though Noah is a deviant soul you find yourself routing for him, cheering him on and hoping for the best. Edward is a sweet, lonely soul who brings the best out in Noah. I absolutely adored these characters and their story. I couldn't put the book down. It is hands down one of the best Victorian novels I've read in a long time. Definitely one of those books worth re-reading.
When I started reading this book I was unsure if I would like it, the blurb made me curious enough to try it, but it had me hooked quickly.
It's dark and thrilling, drawing you in with Noah and how his hands fit around the neck of a young man. I will say that part was what made it for me, I simply loved the way it was written and it gave me chills.
With the shift in the Noah's mood you never knew how things would end up and how disruptive Edwards entrance in to his life is.
My only regret is that it wasn't longer, I could easily have read more about Noah's escapades and the dark could have been pitch black. But that is merely my preference.
He has a dark deep secret which he has to keep hidden. He is a killer, he takes people off the street and has one with them before killing them. He hides the body. There is one he does not want to end that way so he refuses to buy them a drink. They finally have that drink but he cannot kill them. See what will happen in the end
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
4 🌟🌟🌟🌟 for them for being murder husbands xD. "The only people who’ve slept overnight in Noah’s bed were asleep on a very permanent basis, and now and again…Noah couldn’t bring himself to move them right away. He’d curl up beside them, cheek pressed to their motionless chest. At least for a short period of time, until the body went cold, he could close his eyes and pretend someone was holding him. That someone was there, and they would not leave." :?<)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
It is a very interesting tale in a dark atmosphere full of surprises. It takes you on a trip to the darkest and most tortuous of the human soul. You get invested in the story of the characters hoping for the best.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This was a different type of story. No fairytale romance, or good vs. evil. Noah is not a good man. He has a terrible secret. When Edward discovers what it is, he is afraid, but slowly ends up falling in love with Noah anyway. Great writing. I was intrigued and interested. I enjoyed the book.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The intrigue around Noah was great. Edward seemed like a lost soul. He helped Noah get over his problems. Starting by unchaining Edward brings out trust. They ended up falling in love. Great story.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This wasn't a bad story I liked both characters as well... The murder thing didn't bother me... Actually I wanted more of that... The plot was a little boring for me...but again not bad it was well written just wish it had more bite....
I’m not really sure how to start this review, but to say that this book is a beautiful romance about a serial killer and his crush on a likewise smitten man set in I’m guessing the late 1800s. Unexpectedly sweet.
Честно сказать, прочитав аннотацию, ждала крутого триллера с любовной линией. Но нет, ничего подобного тут нет. Триллер мимо проходил. Любовь какая-то чудная, взявшаяся из ниоткуда🤷♀️ Странная книга, правда. Да, неплохо прописана эротика. На этом все😔 Жаль.
Great story with unique characters. Noah and Edward meet at a bar, Edward asks Noah if he can buy him a drink and Noah shoots him down every time, until he doesn’t. You see Noah is a serial killer except when he meets Edward, he invokes feelings that scare Noah. But this time he excepts the drink and invites Edward to his home. There is so much that can be said about this book however, I don’t want to spoil it by getting into to much details. With that being said I highly recommend this book as not only is it unique, but you should expect the unexpected.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.