I have been reading Robert B. Parker’s “Spenser” mystery series since the 1980’s when my English professor introduced the first book in the series “The Godwulf Manuscript” to me and invited me to write a paper comparing and contrasting Spenser with some classic character that I can no longer remember.
However, Spenser I never forgot. I grew to love him over the years and looked forward every spring to a new outing with my private investigator hero. Then Parker introduced the “Jesse Stone” followed by “Sunny Randall”, which was the result of a request from the actress, Helen Hunt, a fan of “Spenser” and friend of Parker’s who was trying to create a serious role which could be built into a franchise, and she wanted him to write it. Parker agreed but struggled with writing a script, and instead produced “Family Honor”, the first Sunny Randall novel. Parker hoped that if he wrote the books, Hollywood could use them as a resource to create scripts. However, that never came to fruition, and with Parker’s passing. Sunny Randall was left on the sidelines while other writers continued the stories of “Spenser” and “Jesse Stone”.
Finally, in 2019, the adventures of Sunny Randall are being continued. The Parker estate has put her in the hands of Mike Lupica, a well established and proven sports writer, columnist, and commentator. He is also a longtime personal friend of Parker.
The results of Lupica’s first outing with resurrecting Sunny is “Blood Feud”. Sunny is a former cop in her late thirties, has definite authority issues, and is someone who's a little less certain of herself. She has a very complicated relationship with her ex-husband Richie Burke, who is Mafia connected. She’s never stopped loving him nor really ever let him go emotionally. When the book starts off, Richie has been shot and almost killed, dragging Sunny into the middle of his family’s business to try and find answers behind the hit before a mob war breaks out in her hometown of Boston. However, the deeper Sunny investigates, she finds herself with a big target from an unknown enemy, who is plotting revenge against the Burke family in the most personal of ways.
Lupica’s first attempt at capturing Sunny and the rest of her cast is off to an interesting start. I give him kudo’s for introducing a strong, multi-layered layered plot that creates conflict on several layers. Conflict between Sunny and her ex-Richie, his father, their family, and other mobsters wanting her to stay out of their business. Lupica creates longtime family secrets and history that threaten Richie’s family and his relationship with Sunny. It turned out to be an excellent way to re-introduce Sunny Randall and those close to her in hopes of building future momentum for the series.
Another one of the ways in which this novel works well is Lupica’s libera; use of already established characters from Parker’s established world of Spenser’s Boston. During her investigation, Sunny crosses paths with mobster Tony Marcus, sarcastic but lovable crusty copper Frank Belson, the beautiful and super-intellectual psychologist Sr. Susan Silverman (and love of Spenser’s life), FBI resource Nathan Epstein, and my personal favorite, the greatest shooter Vinnie Morris. Each of these nostalgic personalities brought a certain strength that enhanced the quality of the story.
Even with the good things, Sunny Randall is still a character that I find myself struggling with, and this plot brings that struggle to the forefront. Sunny, in many ways, is modeled as a female version of Spenser, a strong-willed investigator who never played well with others in the sandbox. Sunny doesn’t like to be told what to do and puts her nose into the business of others, which usually works because someone has hired her to perform the work. However, in this book, she really sticks her nose into her ex-husband’s family business in a way that to me, borders on arrogance. She is asked over and over to stay out, and when she continually refuses, it almost feels more selfish than good intentioned. For me, this behavior took away from liking her character as much as I wanted. Hopefully, other readers won't be bothered by that behavior as much as I was.
In closing, there are several things to like, especially seeing the life of another Robert B. Parker character resurrected and given new life. Again, Lupica’s plotting and use of classic Parker characters was a plus. And to be fair, taking over another award-wining writer’s series is never easy. It takes time to find the right rhythm of an established character. However, Lupica is going to have to work harder to make Sunny’s character more likable and present herself as less spoiled. Until then, this was a worthwhile attempt, and I look forward to her next outing.