What do you think?
Rate this book
Justice Flanagan #2
Hudson's Kill
Set in 1803 New York, Hudson's Kill is the riveting next historical thriller from NPR reporter and producer Paddy Hirsch.
New York in 1803 is rife with tension as the city expands, and whoever knows where the city will build can control it. And violence builds as a mysterious provocateur pits the city’s black and Irish gangs against each other.
When a young black girl is found stabbed to death, both Justy Flanagan, now a City Marshal, and Kerry O’Toole, now a school teacher, decide separately to go after the killer. They each find their way to a shadowy community on the fringes of the growing city, where they uncover a craven political conspiracy bound up with a criminal enterprise that is stunning in its depravity.
Justy and Kerry have to fight to save themselves and the city, and only then can they bring the girl’s killer to justice.
At the Publisher's request, this title is being sold without Digital Rights Management Software (DRM) applied.
New York in 1803 is rife with tension as the city expands, and whoever knows where the city will build can control it. And violence builds as a mysterious provocateur pits the city’s black and Irish gangs against each other.
When a young black girl is found stabbed to death, both Justy Flanagan, now a City Marshal, and Kerry O’Toole, now a school teacher, decide separately to go after the killer. They each find their way to a shadowy community on the fringes of the growing city, where they uncover a craven political conspiracy bound up with a criminal enterprise that is stunning in its depravity.
Justy and Kerry have to fight to save themselves and the city, and only then can they bring the girl’s killer to justice.
At the Publisher's request, this title is being sold without Digital Rights Management Software (DRM) applied.
310 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 24, 2019
23 people are currently reading
437 people want to read
About the author
Paddy Hirsch
12 books79 followersPaddy Hirsch is an author and Murrow award-winning journalist. His first novel is The Devil's Half Mile, an historical thriller with a financial twist, set in New York in 1799.
He is the author of Man vs Markets; Economics Explained, Plain and Simple. Publisher's Weekly called the book " “A straightforward, accessible, and often hilarious overview of our financial and economic systems, products, and concepts."
He works as a supervising editor at NPR's planet Money. He is also the creator and host of Marketplace Whiteboard, an award-winning video explainer of financial and economic terms.
He is the author of Man vs Markets; Economics Explained, Plain and Simple. Publisher's Weekly called the book " “A straightforward, accessible, and often hilarious overview of our financial and economic systems, products, and concepts."
He works as a supervising editor at NPR's planet Money. He is also the creator and host of Marketplace Whiteboard, an award-winning video explainer of financial and economic terms.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews
November 9, 2024
Take a walk through the tense and seamy underbelly of New York City 1803, mingle amidst the Black, Irish, and Nativist gangs, all fighting for control of this expanding city - a place where lack of sanitation means cholera outbreaks are a regular occurrence, and where treachery, political conspiracy and violence are just a part of daily life.
In a dark and filthy alleyway frequented by prostitutes, and used by men with a belly full of beer who wish to relieve themselves, a young black girl lays dying, and breathes her last amidst the stench and decaying detritus.
The victim has been butchered, there’s no other way to describe what her killer has done. She’s discovered by school teacher Kerry O’Toole, who sends for her friend and ally Mayor’s Marshal Justy Flanagan to investigate.
Justy reckons the victim was no older than 13 or 14 years old, and yet no one comes to claim her - nobody knows her identity. One thing’s for sure, this was no common prostitute, her clothes and shoes are of the finest material, worn only by the wealthy, and her hands show no sign of calluses that one would expect to see on a slave or housemaid.
Justy and Kerry are determined to bring this killer to justice, but decide to go their own separate ways. Justy also needs to find out who the victim was, and why no one has come to claim her body for burial. Their investigations lead them separately to a high walled compound on the outskirts of the city, a community of which little is known - and that’s how it’s inhabitants intend to keep it, but for both Justy and Kerry this will be an extremely dangerous assignment, and they will have to fight to save themselves , as well as New York City itself.
New York in 1803 was run by racketeers via means of violence and intimidation, with little in the way of law enforcement officers. Against this background Justy and Kerry have to face up to some extremely dangerous individuals who appear to have no moral compass, and to whom human life has little or no value.
This was a tense, violent, yet atmospheric historical crime thriller, and (thanks to meticulous research) managed to vividly capture New York as it would have been in the very early 19th century. Though the narrative focuses on Justy and Kerry, it also introduces secondary characters who are equally as interesting. The pair of them manage to uncover many secrets, leading to some truly action packed scenes later in the book - scenes that left me breathless, and wishing I could read at twice the speed! Very enjoyable and entertaining, with a useful glossary at the end to explain certain words and phrases.
*Thank you to Readers First and Corvus Books for my hardback copy for which I have given an honest unbiased review in exchange *
In a dark and filthy alleyway frequented by prostitutes, and used by men with a belly full of beer who wish to relieve themselves, a young black girl lays dying, and breathes her last amidst the stench and decaying detritus.
The victim has been butchered, there’s no other way to describe what her killer has done. She’s discovered by school teacher Kerry O’Toole, who sends for her friend and ally Mayor’s Marshal Justy Flanagan to investigate.
Justy reckons the victim was no older than 13 or 14 years old, and yet no one comes to claim her - nobody knows her identity. One thing’s for sure, this was no common prostitute, her clothes and shoes are of the finest material, worn only by the wealthy, and her hands show no sign of calluses that one would expect to see on a slave or housemaid.
Justy and Kerry are determined to bring this killer to justice, but decide to go their own separate ways. Justy also needs to find out who the victim was, and why no one has come to claim her body for burial. Their investigations lead them separately to a high walled compound on the outskirts of the city, a community of which little is known - and that’s how it’s inhabitants intend to keep it, but for both Justy and Kerry this will be an extremely dangerous assignment, and they will have to fight to save themselves , as well as New York City itself.
New York in 1803 was run by racketeers via means of violence and intimidation, with little in the way of law enforcement officers. Against this background Justy and Kerry have to face up to some extremely dangerous individuals who appear to have no moral compass, and to whom human life has little or no value.
This was a tense, violent, yet atmospheric historical crime thriller, and (thanks to meticulous research) managed to vividly capture New York as it would have been in the very early 19th century. Though the narrative focuses on Justy and Kerry, it also introduces secondary characters who are equally as interesting. The pair of them manage to uncover many secrets, leading to some truly action packed scenes later in the book - scenes that left me breathless, and wishing I could read at twice the speed! Very enjoyable and entertaining, with a useful glossary at the end to explain certain words and phrases.
*Thank you to Readers First and Corvus Books for my hardback copy for which I have given an honest unbiased review in exchange *
July 4, 2019
I loved The Devil’s Half-Mile, the first book in the series, and in Hudson’s Killthe author once again transports the reader to the powder keg that is New York in 1803, where gangs and other power brokers are seeking to stake their claims to areas of the rapidly expanding city.
The author brilliantly conjures up the sights, sounds and smells of early nineteenth century New York. Aptly described as ‘a dangerous place to live’, the city is overcrowded, many of its inhabitants are prey to gang warfare and disease, and the contrast between the slums and shanty towns of the poor and the lavish homes of the rich is stark.
The story’s told in the same colourful, lively prose as the previous book. Generous helpings of period slang (nimgimmer, dimber), imaginative curses (‘tossy-locked florence’) and memorable one-liners (‘Just because I’m togged in buntings and a snicket don’t mean you can treat me like some judy hick’) add to the sense of authenticity and atmosphere. You’ll definitely want to make use of the helpful glossary at the back of the book and it’s only right to give a shout out to the copy editing and proofreading team. And, if you’ve ever wondered about the hierarchy of prostitutes in early nineteenth century New York, well, Paddy Hirsch has done the research for you. As Kerry learns in preparation for an undercover role, it goes ‘bunters’, ‘buricks’, ‘curtezan’ and top of the tree, ‘gentry-mort’.
I was pleased to see many of the larger-than-life characters from the first book make return appearances: Justy’s uncle, Ignatius Flanagan, known as ‘The Bull’; Justy’s friend, Lars Hokkanssen, the tough red-bearded sailor; streetwise Kerry O’Toole; and Kerry’s cousin, Lew Owens. But there are also new characters to get to know, such as the memorably named Hardluck. And, of course, there’s the man himself, Justy Flanagan. His moral complexity makes him a fascinating and engaging leading character. He’s shrewd, observant, resourceful and pretty handy with a ‘chive’ or in a ‘clutch’. (Sorry, you need that glossary again.) But Justy, a word – Eliza is definitely not the woman for you. You need to listen to Lars.
The gruesome discovery in the opening chapter sees Justy and Kerry each embark on their own inquiries into the death of a young girl. Whilst for Justy it’s largely professional, it also speaks to his sense of justice and desire to see everyone – rich or poor, black or white – treated equally under the law. As he says, “We have to speak for her. We have to act for her. And that means finding her killer”. For Kerry, there’s a very personal reason why she’s equally determined to see justice done.
However, if you ask questions, especially questions that bring you to the attention of criminals and murderers, then you court danger, as both Justy and Kerry find out to their cost. Throw in a range war between competing gang leaders, corruption and conspiracy in high places and you have all the components for a conflagration – and not necessarily just metaphorical. Oh, and remember there are spies and informers everywhere so be very careful who you trust.
The plot takes advantage of the febrile state of New York at the beginning of the nineteenth century to create a page-turning crime mystery but also touches on issues of contemporary relevance, such as immigration, racial discrimination and segregation.
Paddy Hirsch certainly knows how ‘to spin a cakey dit’*. Hudson’s Kill is as fast-moving and intricately plotted as its predecessor with the same fantastic period atmosphere and great cast of characters. I absolutely loved it. On behalf of historical crime fans, I fervently hope there are more adventures awaiting Justy Flanagan.
* to tell a good story
The author brilliantly conjures up the sights, sounds and smells of early nineteenth century New York. Aptly described as ‘a dangerous place to live’, the city is overcrowded, many of its inhabitants are prey to gang warfare and disease, and the contrast between the slums and shanty towns of the poor and the lavish homes of the rich is stark.
The story’s told in the same colourful, lively prose as the previous book. Generous helpings of period slang (nimgimmer, dimber), imaginative curses (‘tossy-locked florence’) and memorable one-liners (‘Just because I’m togged in buntings and a snicket don’t mean you can treat me like some judy hick’) add to the sense of authenticity and atmosphere. You’ll definitely want to make use of the helpful glossary at the back of the book and it’s only right to give a shout out to the copy editing and proofreading team. And, if you’ve ever wondered about the hierarchy of prostitutes in early nineteenth century New York, well, Paddy Hirsch has done the research for you. As Kerry learns in preparation for an undercover role, it goes ‘bunters’, ‘buricks’, ‘curtezan’ and top of the tree, ‘gentry-mort’.
I was pleased to see many of the larger-than-life characters from the first book make return appearances: Justy’s uncle, Ignatius Flanagan, known as ‘The Bull’; Justy’s friend, Lars Hokkanssen, the tough red-bearded sailor; streetwise Kerry O’Toole; and Kerry’s cousin, Lew Owens. But there are also new characters to get to know, such as the memorably named Hardluck. And, of course, there’s the man himself, Justy Flanagan. His moral complexity makes him a fascinating and engaging leading character. He’s shrewd, observant, resourceful and pretty handy with a ‘chive’ or in a ‘clutch’. (Sorry, you need that glossary again.) But Justy, a word – Eliza is definitely not the woman for you. You need to listen to Lars.
The gruesome discovery in the opening chapter sees Justy and Kerry each embark on their own inquiries into the death of a young girl. Whilst for Justy it’s largely professional, it also speaks to his sense of justice and desire to see everyone – rich or poor, black or white – treated equally under the law. As he says, “We have to speak for her. We have to act for her. And that means finding her killer”. For Kerry, there’s a very personal reason why she’s equally determined to see justice done.
However, if you ask questions, especially questions that bring you to the attention of criminals and murderers, then you court danger, as both Justy and Kerry find out to their cost. Throw in a range war between competing gang leaders, corruption and conspiracy in high places and you have all the components for a conflagration – and not necessarily just metaphorical. Oh, and remember there are spies and informers everywhere so be very careful who you trust.
The plot takes advantage of the febrile state of New York at the beginning of the nineteenth century to create a page-turning crime mystery but also touches on issues of contemporary relevance, such as immigration, racial discrimination and segregation.
Paddy Hirsch certainly knows how ‘to spin a cakey dit’*. Hudson’s Kill is as fast-moving and intricately plotted as its predecessor with the same fantastic period atmosphere and great cast of characters. I absolutely loved it. On behalf of historical crime fans, I fervently hope there are more adventures awaiting Justy Flanagan.
* to tell a good story
July 15, 2019
I was unsure at first as to whether I would like this book. The cover of the book did not initially grab my attention, but as the saying goes, 'you should never judge a book by its cover' as I found out, because when reading, it certainly kept me wanting to turn the page. It was action packed and full of twists.
I have not read a book by this author before, and I felt that this was very well written and researched, highlighting many issues in New York in the 19th Century. The writing was so descriptive that it made me feel like I was actually there.
I have not read a book by this author before, and I felt that this was very well written and researched, highlighting many issues in New York in the 19th Century. The writing was so descriptive that it made me feel like I was actually there.
July 3, 2019
Hudson's Kill by Paddy Hirsch is very well written, with murder, mystery and conspiracy.
The story is set in New York on September in the year 1803.
What had me personally hooked into this story was the discription of words and sentences that just flowed from page to page.
When a young girl had been found dead, the body is carried to the morgue hidden by a blanket.
I really felt the tension and growling in the air with the crowd of black men. The way the scenes and words played out, I could even imagine the men shouting angry accusing a sergeant with what have you done.
Quite a bit more happens within this story that I haven't mentioned.
My only regret is I didn't read the first book by Paddy Hurst. I think I need to read that too.
I know authors think that writing a second book is the hardest, but I'm very honoured to have read this second book.
A beautiful well written book that I highly recommend.
The story is set in New York on September in the year 1803.
What had me personally hooked into this story was the discription of words and sentences that just flowed from page to page.
When a young girl had been found dead, the body is carried to the morgue hidden by a blanket.
I really felt the tension and growling in the air with the crowd of black men. The way the scenes and words played out, I could even imagine the men shouting angry accusing a sergeant with what have you done.
Quite a bit more happens within this story that I haven't mentioned.
My only regret is I didn't read the first book by Paddy Hurst. I think I need to read that too.
I know authors think that writing a second book is the hardest, but I'm very honoured to have read this second book.
A beautiful well written book that I highly recommend.
September 17, 2019
“Hudson’s Kill” by Paddy Hirsch is set in 1803, New York City, and chapters are conveniently identified by day to facilitate continuity. The crush of people make New York a dangerous place to live, and as more people arrive, more people die. Mistrust is rampant, and overt religious discrimination is everywhere in every section of society. The story is conversation driven in the vernacular of the time and immerses readers into that place and time.
Hirsch’s vivid descriptions set the stage. “A blanket of cloud had rolled in across the city with the dusk, and the night was pitch dark. There was no street lighting in Canvas Town, and no torches for fear of fire, but two of Owens’ men carried lanterns, attached to long poles.”
The characters, both main and secondary, are well developed and colorful, reflecting the atmosphere of the time, and readers see them clearly. “He was a balding, pug-faced man of about forty, whose belly was barely confined by a yellow-and-black-striped waistcoat. He wore a single watch chain, stretched so tight it looked as though the timepiece attached to it might pop out at any moment.”
Into a dreary scene, come Marshal Flanagan and Sergeant Vanderool who kneel beside the body of a young woman, murdered in an alley. The murder of a young woman is rare, and this young woman in not a typical street inhabitant. Investigation strategies in 1800 are different from those of today; however, the role of the police department is still the same. This is murder; a young girl has been slaughtered and dumped. Flanagan and Vanderool must speak for her, must act for her, and must find the killer. Readers are taken back to a time of paid informants, intimidation, and roughneck interrogation to bring justice for victims. However, a lost life is still a tragedy, a crime that must be solved. The plot progresses carefully and deliberately as clues are uncovered, suspects develop, and questions are answered, leading to an exciting and dramatic end. For readers there is also an update six months later.
“Hudson’s Kill” transports readers to a time when people in New York were struggling for both control and existence. It is intense, violent, and at the same time realistic and compelling. I was given a review copy of “Hudson’s Kill” by Paddy Hirsch and Forge Books. It is a captivating thriller that reflects New York in 1803.
Hirsch’s vivid descriptions set the stage. “A blanket of cloud had rolled in across the city with the dusk, and the night was pitch dark. There was no street lighting in Canvas Town, and no torches for fear of fire, but two of Owens’ men carried lanterns, attached to long poles.”
The characters, both main and secondary, are well developed and colorful, reflecting the atmosphere of the time, and readers see them clearly. “He was a balding, pug-faced man of about forty, whose belly was barely confined by a yellow-and-black-striped waistcoat. He wore a single watch chain, stretched so tight it looked as though the timepiece attached to it might pop out at any moment.”
Into a dreary scene, come Marshal Flanagan and Sergeant Vanderool who kneel beside the body of a young woman, murdered in an alley. The murder of a young woman is rare, and this young woman in not a typical street inhabitant. Investigation strategies in 1800 are different from those of today; however, the role of the police department is still the same. This is murder; a young girl has been slaughtered and dumped. Flanagan and Vanderool must speak for her, must act for her, and must find the killer. Readers are taken back to a time of paid informants, intimidation, and roughneck interrogation to bring justice for victims. However, a lost life is still a tragedy, a crime that must be solved. The plot progresses carefully and deliberately as clues are uncovered, suspects develop, and questions are answered, leading to an exciting and dramatic end. For readers there is also an update six months later.
“Hudson’s Kill” transports readers to a time when people in New York were struggling for both control and existence. It is intense, violent, and at the same time realistic and compelling. I was given a review copy of “Hudson’s Kill” by Paddy Hirsch and Forge Books. It is a captivating thriller that reflects New York in 1803.
June 27, 2019
I enjoyed reading this book very much. It was an easy read and I loved the descriptions the author writes in this book. I could see in my minds eye the awful conditions and the dark streets of New York. This is a second in a series but it didn’t matter. My thanks to Readersfirst for this book in return for an honest review.
June 27, 2019
New York, in 1803, is a city filled with tension, as black and Irish gangs fight for control on the streets. Violence is never far away.
When a young girl is found murdered in an alleyway, Marshal Justy Flanagan undertakes the difficult search for the killer, before the mob takes the law into their own hands.
Kerry O'Toole, Justy's friend and ally, was the one who found the murdered girl. The killing haunts her and she decides to look into the murder herself to find out the truth behind why a young girl was left butchered in the mud.
Justy and Kelly's inquiries will lead them to a shadowy community living on the edges of the city, but there is more at stake than the search for the killer of a young girl. They are about to find themselves involved in a web of deceit that runs deep into both the political and criminal hierarchies.
Justy and Kerry must fight to save the city and for their own survival.
I cannot tell you how much I loved, loved, loved this book!
This is actually book two in the Lawless New York series - historical thrillers set in the steaming cauldron of the early days of New York city, around the turn of the 19th century.
The days when the black and Irish gangs ran the seedy side of the over-crowded city, while the "nobs" concerned themselves with money and high living. Tension abounds and violence is always close to the surface, as the few Marshals try to impose some sort of law and order.
Justy is desperate to do the right thing, for the good of the city, but has just the right amount of disregard for procedure necessary to get to the truth. He is a good man in a city of brigands, but has enough contacts on both sides of the law to get the job done, and is not afraid to make enemies along the way.
Kerry is living a more or less respectable life, but her past on the wrong side of the law, and relations in the criminal underworld are very helpful sometimes. She too has a passion for doing what is right, even if she finds this hard to admit to others. She makes a good partner for Justy, but they need to trust each other more - their simmering, but unspoken love for each other gets in the way at times, but all works out well in the end.
There are some great supporting characters in this book too, such as Justy's friend Lars, and I particulary enjoyed the part played by Hardluck, the slave carriage driver.
Great villians abound, who you will love to hate and long for them to get their come-uppance.
As someone who has devoured the entire Richard Sharpe series, I can detect echoes of Bernard Cornwall in this book - which is a very fine thing indeed. Paddy Hirsch has clearly done his homework on the origins of New York here and this tells.
If you are looking for a fine historical thriller, with good guys you can get behind, and bad guys you can detest, then this is exactly the book you are looking for.
I adored it and devoured in in practically one whole sitting, while on a flight back from Cyprus. In fact, I liked it so much that I have bought book one, The Devil's Half Mile, so I can fill in the back stories of Justy, Kelly and co!
When a young girl is found murdered in an alleyway, Marshal Justy Flanagan undertakes the difficult search for the killer, before the mob takes the law into their own hands.
Kerry O'Toole, Justy's friend and ally, was the one who found the murdered girl. The killing haunts her and she decides to look into the murder herself to find out the truth behind why a young girl was left butchered in the mud.
Justy and Kelly's inquiries will lead them to a shadowy community living on the edges of the city, but there is more at stake than the search for the killer of a young girl. They are about to find themselves involved in a web of deceit that runs deep into both the political and criminal hierarchies.
Justy and Kerry must fight to save the city and for their own survival.
I cannot tell you how much I loved, loved, loved this book!
This is actually book two in the Lawless New York series - historical thrillers set in the steaming cauldron of the early days of New York city, around the turn of the 19th century.
The days when the black and Irish gangs ran the seedy side of the over-crowded city, while the "nobs" concerned themselves with money and high living. Tension abounds and violence is always close to the surface, as the few Marshals try to impose some sort of law and order.
Justy is desperate to do the right thing, for the good of the city, but has just the right amount of disregard for procedure necessary to get to the truth. He is a good man in a city of brigands, but has enough contacts on both sides of the law to get the job done, and is not afraid to make enemies along the way.
Kerry is living a more or less respectable life, but her past on the wrong side of the law, and relations in the criminal underworld are very helpful sometimes. She too has a passion for doing what is right, even if she finds this hard to admit to others. She makes a good partner for Justy, but they need to trust each other more - their simmering, but unspoken love for each other gets in the way at times, but all works out well in the end.
There are some great supporting characters in this book too, such as Justy's friend Lars, and I particulary enjoyed the part played by Hardluck, the slave carriage driver.
Great villians abound, who you will love to hate and long for them to get their come-uppance.
As someone who has devoured the entire Richard Sharpe series, I can detect echoes of Bernard Cornwall in this book - which is a very fine thing indeed. Paddy Hirsch has clearly done his homework on the origins of New York here and this tells.
If you are looking for a fine historical thriller, with good guys you can get behind, and bad guys you can detest, then this is exactly the book you are looking for.
I adored it and devoured in in practically one whole sitting, while on a flight back from Cyprus. In fact, I liked it so much that I have bought book one, The Devil's Half Mile, so I can fill in the back stories of Justy, Kelly and co!
June 29, 2019
3.5 Stars
I have not read the first of the Justy Flanagan series, The Devil's Half Mile, but I am happy to report that did not spoil this book for me. There doesn't seem to be much in the way of re-capping that tale either and there is enough information given about the characters that you can get to know them through this book without having read the first. Overall a win-win, if you have read the first you don't have swathes of text to skim through that are covering the first book and if you are new to it then this is almost a stand alone tale.
The setting itself is evocative and completely believable. When reading you can almost hear the sounds and, regrettably, smell the air. This is helped by the language used throughout the book, how accurate the "Flash" is we will never know but a glossary is provided at the back of the book to help you out if you don't understand a term or can't figure it out from context. The sources for the language are also cited so any inaccuracies are definitely not the author's. In fact, the research that has gone in to the whole book is incredible and gives it not only a sense of veracity but also a freshness; almost as if the author has transported themself back to the earliest days of New York and is writing from there.
Characterisation is very strong and not necessarily sympathetic. Kerry O'Toole and Justy Flanagan are our main protagonists and both are very flawed human beings. I like this in a fictional character, it makes them feel whole and more relatable than a perfect literary protagonist does. Justy in particular has a wonderfully warring personality, where what is right is not necessarily what wins through - more what is right for the situation.
Discussions of class structure are also dealt with well and there is a real separation between the "haves" and the rest of the populace. The delineation of the gangs between The Irish, The Negroes (contemporaneous term and not used to denigrate) and The Nativists is clearly described and there is a real sense of menace between the warring factions; all of whom want control of this burgeoning city. I also found the blurring of the lines between The Watchmen/City Marshals as the infancy of a regularised police force and the gangs to be interesting and well handled.
My problems came with the plot, I just couldn't really buy in to it. Far too much seemed to rely on coincidence and hot headedness. The initial discovery of the mysterious, murdered girl is handled well and a sense of intrigue builds up well. Somehow it then all got lost in a miasma of plots at the highest level of society, warring gang factions and a charismatic preacher. Such a shame as so much about this book is completely wonderful. It would probably have benefitted from one or two fewer "incidents" and concentrated on honing the whys and wherefores of the main plot.
THIS IS AN HONEST REVIEW OF A FREE COPY OF THE BOOK RECEIVED FROM READERS FIRST
I have not read the first of the Justy Flanagan series, The Devil's Half Mile, but I am happy to report that did not spoil this book for me. There doesn't seem to be much in the way of re-capping that tale either and there is enough information given about the characters that you can get to know them through this book without having read the first. Overall a win-win, if you have read the first you don't have swathes of text to skim through that are covering the first book and if you are new to it then this is almost a stand alone tale.
The setting itself is evocative and completely believable. When reading you can almost hear the sounds and, regrettably, smell the air. This is helped by the language used throughout the book, how accurate the "Flash" is we will never know but a glossary is provided at the back of the book to help you out if you don't understand a term or can't figure it out from context. The sources for the language are also cited so any inaccuracies are definitely not the author's. In fact, the research that has gone in to the whole book is incredible and gives it not only a sense of veracity but also a freshness; almost as if the author has transported themself back to the earliest days of New York and is writing from there.
Characterisation is very strong and not necessarily sympathetic. Kerry O'Toole and Justy Flanagan are our main protagonists and both are very flawed human beings. I like this in a fictional character, it makes them feel whole and more relatable than a perfect literary protagonist does. Justy in particular has a wonderfully warring personality, where what is right is not necessarily what wins through - more what is right for the situation.
Discussions of class structure are also dealt with well and there is a real separation between the "haves" and the rest of the populace. The delineation of the gangs between The Irish, The Negroes (contemporaneous term and not used to denigrate) and The Nativists is clearly described and there is a real sense of menace between the warring factions; all of whom want control of this burgeoning city. I also found the blurring of the lines between The Watchmen/City Marshals as the infancy of a regularised police force and the gangs to be interesting and well handled.
My problems came with the plot, I just couldn't really buy in to it. Far too much seemed to rely on coincidence and hot headedness. The initial discovery of the mysterious, murdered girl is handled well and a sense of intrigue builds up well. Somehow it then all got lost in a miasma of plots at the highest level of society, warring gang factions and a charismatic preacher. Such a shame as so much about this book is completely wonderful. It would probably have benefitted from one or two fewer "incidents" and concentrated on honing the whys and wherefores of the main plot.
THIS IS AN HONEST REVIEW OF A FREE COPY OF THE BOOK RECEIVED FROM READERS FIRST
June 30, 2019
Set in 19th Century New York, Hudson's Kill, is a gritty crime novel, that will have the reader thinking of Peaky Blinders and Murdoch Mysteries, (though a little darker ) where black and irish gangs fight for control of the streets, and when.a young girl is found dying in a dirty alleyway, things take a turn for the worse.
Marshal Justy Flanagan needs to find the killer, before the lynch mob do, with his friend Kerry O'Toole decides to do her own investigation, she soon realises there is more to this murder than they though., Political intrigue, and conspiracy, murder and criminal enterprise, It's all here in Paddy Hirsch's Hudson's Kill, it will have you reading until the early hours and longing for more, I'm off to get The Devil's Half Mile. Paddy's first book.
Marshal Justy Flanagan needs to find the killer, before the lynch mob do, with his friend Kerry O'Toole decides to do her own investigation, she soon realises there is more to this murder than they though., Political intrigue, and conspiracy, murder and criminal enterprise, It's all here in Paddy Hirsch's Hudson's Kill, it will have you reading until the early hours and longing for more, I'm off to get The Devil's Half Mile. Paddy's first book.
June 27, 2019
I thoroughly enjoyed this book's predecessor, The Devil's Half Mile, and this instalment brings more of the non stop action as it hurtles through life in New York in 1803.
Once again, our main characters are Justice (Justy) Flanaghan and Kerry O'Toole. This time they are working "together" to solve a murder - after Kerry finds an almost dead young girl slashed in an alleyway. However she looks well kept, well clothed and clean - not your average victim of the time.
Their investigations lead to a secretive encampment on the marshlands - a place where girls (white prostitutes) seem to go but never return from. What is going on and who is bankrolling the charismatic leader?
There's a fair amount of bloodshed and lots of authentic dialogue from the times - which really makes you feel like you're living and breathing the book.
A great second outing for these characters - I can imagine there may be many more.
Once again, our main characters are Justice (Justy) Flanaghan and Kerry O'Toole. This time they are working "together" to solve a murder - after Kerry finds an almost dead young girl slashed in an alleyway. However she looks well kept, well clothed and clean - not your average victim of the time.
Their investigations lead to a secretive encampment on the marshlands - a place where girls (white prostitutes) seem to go but never return from. What is going on and who is bankrolling the charismatic leader?
There's a fair amount of bloodshed and lots of authentic dialogue from the times - which really makes you feel like you're living and breathing the book.
A great second outing for these characters - I can imagine there may be many more.
April 1, 2025
It was spot on for what 1800 New York would have been like, the gangs, rivalry, and mystery was accurately portrayed. If you like a good mystery in a simpler (more complicated) time then I recommend it. Only reason it’s not a five star is a couple parts were a bit dry but overall it was well written.
August 24, 2019
This is a murder mystery read that also has a lot of conspiracy and tension mixed in as well. It is New York in 1803 and Kerry O’Toole finds the body of a young girl a back alley. Justy Flanagan is called in to investigate the identity of the girl and also the killer. Together Justy and Kerry kind of work together, I say kind of because they both want to find the same answers!
This is a book that has a lot going on in it. What I thought was going to be a murder mystery read, which it was by the way, also had gangs, conspiracy, rivalry and, tension. All these components added to the mixing pot that made up New York at the time. People from different, countries with various backgrounds, religious beliefs and traditions all arrived in the area. They all bring their own language and ways of speaking, and this is where I began to notice the research aspect of the book. The speech was very evident from the off as I cam across words that I recognised as being Welsh, Scottish and Irish.
The speech adds to the diversity of the setting and the people who inhabit it. The descriptions of bars, brothels, alleyways and the like bring home the fact that this is not an affluent area. The author has used the tensions to their advantage and played on it, escalating feelings between rivals. In someways this overwhelmed the investigation, but it was also part of the investigation, if you know what I mean. I just felt that the murder had been sidelined a little bit, but, at the same time I know that
This is a good read and even though there were a couple of things I struggled with, I did enjoy it. I thought it was quite a complex story and maybe this is what caught me out as I wasn’t expecting that when I started.
Earlier I mentioned about speech and I was incredibly glad to see a glossary at the end of the book, while there are some terms that I could work out, there were some that had me scratching my head. I love the inclusion of the old languages and phrases.
This is the 2nd book in the series, and as is my usual form I have not read the first one yet! So, I can say that this owrks well as a stand alone but, I would suggest reading in order as there are things mentioned that I assume are from the first book. There is also a dynamic between Just and Kerry that I am curious to know more about. So I will be reading the first book at some point to squash my curiosity.
Hudson’s Kill is an addictive if complex read and I really enjoyed it and would recommend it.
This is a book that has a lot going on in it. What I thought was going to be a murder mystery read, which it was by the way, also had gangs, conspiracy, rivalry and, tension. All these components added to the mixing pot that made up New York at the time. People from different, countries with various backgrounds, religious beliefs and traditions all arrived in the area. They all bring their own language and ways of speaking, and this is where I began to notice the research aspect of the book. The speech was very evident from the off as I cam across words that I recognised as being Welsh, Scottish and Irish.
The speech adds to the diversity of the setting and the people who inhabit it. The descriptions of bars, brothels, alleyways and the like bring home the fact that this is not an affluent area. The author has used the tensions to their advantage and played on it, escalating feelings between rivals. In someways this overwhelmed the investigation, but it was also part of the investigation, if you know what I mean. I just felt that the murder had been sidelined a little bit, but, at the same time I know that
This is a good read and even though there were a couple of things I struggled with, I did enjoy it. I thought it was quite a complex story and maybe this is what caught me out as I wasn’t expecting that when I started.
Earlier I mentioned about speech and I was incredibly glad to see a glossary at the end of the book, while there are some terms that I could work out, there were some that had me scratching my head. I love the inclusion of the old languages and phrases.
This is the 2nd book in the series, and as is my usual form I have not read the first one yet! So, I can say that this owrks well as a stand alone but, I would suggest reading in order as there are things mentioned that I assume are from the first book. There is also a dynamic between Just and Kerry that I am curious to know more about. So I will be reading the first book at some point to squash my curiosity.
Hudson’s Kill is an addictive if complex read and I really enjoyed it and would recommend it.
July 21, 2019
Engrossing, atmospheric, informative and accessible historical fiction set in 1800’s New York.
Hudson’s Kill is the second novel in the Justice “Justy” Flanagan series set in New York around the turn of the nineteenth century and having not read the first, The Devil’s Half Mile, I approached this book without knowing the background or the protagonist. I can comfortably confirm that this didn’t prove a hindrance to my understanding and entertainment from a rousing story and a meeting with Justy Flanagan, a flawed protagonist who fights for the truth.
1803 Manhattan and crime is escalating as the city expands and the Irish, black and American nativist gangs fight for control and with immigrants flooding into the city, neutral territory is scarce. Whilst the powerful men who dominate the city are protected and attended by slaves, for other citizens the streets can be lawless and the atmosphere bristles with tension as the melting pot threatens to spoil over with violence or an outbreak of fire. Intimidation and maiming might be prevalent, but an obvious murder is far less frequent and when twenty-year-old Kerry O’Toole discovers a dying dark-skinned teenage girl with a horrific knife wound she immediately sends for Marshal Justice Flanagan, knowing that he will do what is right by the victim. However, feisty Kerry is equally determined to find answers, all of which is compounded by the fact that nobody comes to claim the victim.
Justy has spent four years acting as one of five Mayor’s Marshals having oversight of the city but lacking in power to stave off the rising wave of crime. Whilst his superior, High Constable Jacob Hays, lobbies the Mayor for a permanent police presence, the upper-classes are opposed to what is essentially an English idea. And with his military background, imposing stature and strong moral compass, Justy, is a man who loathes injustice and is not afraid to fight dirty if he has to. His very unofficial ally is mixed-race reformed pickpocket, Kerry O’Toole, the daughter of an Irish gangster and a runaway slave with links - and protection - from the two most powerful gangs, who together rule the city with their racketeering.
Through a series of observations (skin colour, religious tattoos and expensive attire), delicate inquiries and the word on the street, Justy and Kerry separately arrive at the same conclusion that the victim hails from inside the walls of a secretive compound beyond the slums of Canvas Town. Both have their own ingenious ways of getting beyond the walls but discovering the real reason why the victims body was never claimed is a far more sordid one. As the Muslim encampment and their leader, Umar, prove openly hostile, the heads of two rival gangs (Justy’s uncle Ignatius ‘The Bull’ Flanagan and Kerry’s cousin Lew Owens) start circling..
Not only is the research that has gone into the story phenomenal but it is made incredibly accessible by Paddy Hirsch with a constant drip-feed of the knowledge needed to enable the story to flow and be comprehensive. The Manhattan setting is richly described with every aspect from the unsavoury to the hard realities brought to life and the brutal pecking order that dictates the class hierarchy explored. A continual underlying debate on morality and social hierarchy rumbles on throughout the story making for a thought-provoking aside to Justy’s endeavours. The story draws in the good, bad, rich and poor across the city as Justy leaves no stone unturned and refuses to be treat the entitled as off limits or beyond answering to wrongdoing, meaning his interaction with the lowly to the most eminent of men has a charged edge.
There is a liberal smattering of ‘flash’ (underworld slang) in the narrative and although much of it can be understood in context, there is a handy glossary included. The violence is graphic and frequent but feels appropriate for the dog eat dog culture of the era. Admittedly the plot contains quite a number of convenient coincidences, however this feels necessary in order to keep the pace brisk and momentum high.
Justy and Kerry are both credibly flawed characters with Justy street smart and not beyond violence but inherently kind-hearted with a respect for all, regardless of status or creed, and genuine compassion. In this quality he is united with Kerry, who although internally wrangling with her own background and path in life, sides fiercely with the oppressed and disenfranchised, whether it be through their gender or class. Although Justy and Kerry don’t work in tandem, both of them are loosely aware of the others activity as they vie for the same cause. And with clear romantic tension between the pair with Justy wearing his heart of his sleeve and Kerry’s tough exterior making her reluctant to reciprocate, who knows what the future has in store for this dynamic duo..!
This is definitely a series I intend to follow with the first book already on my list!
With thanks to Readers First who provided me with a free copy of this novel in exchange for my honest and unbiased opinion.
Hudson’s Kill is the second novel in the Justice “Justy” Flanagan series set in New York around the turn of the nineteenth century and having not read the first, The Devil’s Half Mile, I approached this book without knowing the background or the protagonist. I can comfortably confirm that this didn’t prove a hindrance to my understanding and entertainment from a rousing story and a meeting with Justy Flanagan, a flawed protagonist who fights for the truth.
1803 Manhattan and crime is escalating as the city expands and the Irish, black and American nativist gangs fight for control and with immigrants flooding into the city, neutral territory is scarce. Whilst the powerful men who dominate the city are protected and attended by slaves, for other citizens the streets can be lawless and the atmosphere bristles with tension as the melting pot threatens to spoil over with violence or an outbreak of fire. Intimidation and maiming might be prevalent, but an obvious murder is far less frequent and when twenty-year-old Kerry O’Toole discovers a dying dark-skinned teenage girl with a horrific knife wound she immediately sends for Marshal Justice Flanagan, knowing that he will do what is right by the victim. However, feisty Kerry is equally determined to find answers, all of which is compounded by the fact that nobody comes to claim the victim.
Justy has spent four years acting as one of five Mayor’s Marshals having oversight of the city but lacking in power to stave off the rising wave of crime. Whilst his superior, High Constable Jacob Hays, lobbies the Mayor for a permanent police presence, the upper-classes are opposed to what is essentially an English idea. And with his military background, imposing stature and strong moral compass, Justy, is a man who loathes injustice and is not afraid to fight dirty if he has to. His very unofficial ally is mixed-race reformed pickpocket, Kerry O’Toole, the daughter of an Irish gangster and a runaway slave with links - and protection - from the two most powerful gangs, who together rule the city with their racketeering.
Through a series of observations (skin colour, religious tattoos and expensive attire), delicate inquiries and the word on the street, Justy and Kerry separately arrive at the same conclusion that the victim hails from inside the walls of a secretive compound beyond the slums of Canvas Town. Both have their own ingenious ways of getting beyond the walls but discovering the real reason why the victims body was never claimed is a far more sordid one. As the Muslim encampment and their leader, Umar, prove openly hostile, the heads of two rival gangs (Justy’s uncle Ignatius ‘The Bull’ Flanagan and Kerry’s cousin Lew Owens) start circling..
Not only is the research that has gone into the story phenomenal but it is made incredibly accessible by Paddy Hirsch with a constant drip-feed of the knowledge needed to enable the story to flow and be comprehensive. The Manhattan setting is richly described with every aspect from the unsavoury to the hard realities brought to life and the brutal pecking order that dictates the class hierarchy explored. A continual underlying debate on morality and social hierarchy rumbles on throughout the story making for a thought-provoking aside to Justy’s endeavours. The story draws in the good, bad, rich and poor across the city as Justy leaves no stone unturned and refuses to be treat the entitled as off limits or beyond answering to wrongdoing, meaning his interaction with the lowly to the most eminent of men has a charged edge.
There is a liberal smattering of ‘flash’ (underworld slang) in the narrative and although much of it can be understood in context, there is a handy glossary included. The violence is graphic and frequent but feels appropriate for the dog eat dog culture of the era. Admittedly the plot contains quite a number of convenient coincidences, however this feels necessary in order to keep the pace brisk and momentum high.
Justy and Kerry are both credibly flawed characters with Justy street smart and not beyond violence but inherently kind-hearted with a respect for all, regardless of status or creed, and genuine compassion. In this quality he is united with Kerry, who although internally wrangling with her own background and path in life, sides fiercely with the oppressed and disenfranchised, whether it be through their gender or class. Although Justy and Kerry don’t work in tandem, both of them are loosely aware of the others activity as they vie for the same cause. And with clear romantic tension between the pair with Justy wearing his heart of his sleeve and Kerry’s tough exterior making her reluctant to reciprocate, who knows what the future has in store for this dynamic duo..!
This is definitely a series I intend to follow with the first book already on my list!
With thanks to Readers First who provided me with a free copy of this novel in exchange for my honest and unbiased opinion.
July 7, 2019
My first read by this author and what a read it is! A gritty crime read. It conjures the sights and smells of New York in 1803. A city where violence rules and life is cheap; especially if your female.
Kerry O'Toole finds a young girl dying in a putrid alleyway which prostitutes frequent and men relieve themselves. She informs the city watch and they inform the Marshall who starts an investigation.
In a city where gangs fight for control of the streets; where life is cheap and corruption is rife, the Marshall Justy Flanagan faces an uphill struggle. We see Justy fighting to uncover the killer before a lynch mob takes to the street. Kerry and Justy find themselves combining forces to solve the murder
This book will appeal to fans of Peaky Blinders. Also readers of C.J. Samson.
Kerry O'Toole finds a young girl dying in a putrid alleyway which prostitutes frequent and men relieve themselves. She informs the city watch and they inform the Marshall who starts an investigation.
In a city where gangs fight for control of the streets; where life is cheap and corruption is rife, the Marshall Justy Flanagan faces an uphill struggle. We see Justy fighting to uncover the killer before a lynch mob takes to the street. Kerry and Justy find themselves combining forces to solve the murder
This book will appeal to fans of Peaky Blinders. Also readers of C.J. Samson.
June 26, 2019
Takes you back in time
I am a huge fan of this genre of historical fiction so when the time came to read this book I was so excited as from first impression it sounded great and I was not disappointed at all! You can tell such thought and certainly research has gone into the story to ensure that the reader is truly transported back in time and I can say I was - I felt part of all the drama and mystery!
It is well written and gives an insight into historical societal issues that in fact we are still seeing today therefore makes you think and reflect while reading - something which I love from a book.
I overall found it to be so fascinating and well thought out and from reading this book I will be looking to read more from this author.
I am a huge fan of this genre of historical fiction so when the time came to read this book I was so excited as from first impression it sounded great and I was not disappointed at all! You can tell such thought and certainly research has gone into the story to ensure that the reader is truly transported back in time and I can say I was - I felt part of all the drama and mystery!
It is well written and gives an insight into historical societal issues that in fact we are still seeing today therefore makes you think and reflect while reading - something which I love from a book.
I overall found it to be so fascinating and well thought out and from reading this book I will be looking to read more from this author.
November 18, 2019
I'm happy to keep on with this really enjoyable historical procedural series as long as more get written. Big thumbs up to the audio.
June 15, 2020
I would have liked more closure with all aspects of the story at the end.
April 28, 2024
This book had an interesting setting because it was set in 19th century New York. It’s all about the justice system of the time, conspiracies, murder, and all the different gangs fighting for control after the recent war in france. Slavery was also still common in this time, though much more frowned upon than it once was. The book was very well researched in the language, laws, and happenings of the timeframe which made it an authentic and realistic read. It was also really interesting with the French revolutionary wars having happened around the time it was set to see the way that this shaped a lot of the events and characters that returned fairly recently from fighting. Hirsch spun a lifelike setting with accurate locations, and scenes, a dramatic plot line, and a detailed murder mystery conspiracy studded with some pretty dark themes that all tie together to sell a gripping story with many almost as many twists and turns as the streets it takes place in. Good book!
Read
August 2, 2019An excellent read! The content of Hudson's Kill is grotesquely descriptive and perhaps not for the faint of heart, but for lovers of mystery and intrigue it promises a fascinating well researched read. The history appears, well-studied, accurate and uncensored, a rare trait of much historical fiction. The language used throughout sections of speech is often appropriate to the time period and the book even includes a useful glossary at the back to help readers with some of the more obscure terms.
Paddy Hirsch presents a strikingly honest portrayal of New York in the early 19th Century discussing themes such as race, religion, gang warfare, poverty, organised crime, infant mortality, human trafficking, murder, rudimentary forensic science, early policing, civil unrest and warfare.
A young girl has been killed, her body discovered by Kerry O'Toole who although neutral herself has links to both of the major crime gangs in New York, as well as to the early policing network. It is through the investigations into this murder that we as readers are introduced to the powder keg of a political situation that is at the very heart of New York itself.
The descriptive writing in this novel is outstanding, at times I felt like I could see and smell the surroundings in which the characters were placed, particularly those of the market area.
One aspect of the novel that I particularly enjoyed was the debate over morality. 'Hudson's Kill' appears to be a tale of good and evil, but not in the traditional sense. The complex collection of characters are so well written that they represent the very best and very worst of humanity. Acts of atrocities are committed by those too naive to know better whilst the brotherhood of criminals commit acts of integrity and kindness. The question of whether or not bad deeds can be done for the best of reasons is frequently raised throughout the novel and the complex nature of morality is certainly presented as something to think about.
This is the first book of Paddy Hirsch's that I have read but I will certainly be reading his first novel and eagerly awaiting any more of his books in the future. I admire the work that has obviously led to the historical accuracy of this novel, something which I as a historian and Literature graduate often find disappointingly lacking in much historical fiction. The atmosphere felt realistic and the majority of characters behaved in a believable fashion for the era.
The tone of 'Hudson's Kill', as the title and blood spattered cover suggests, is dark and it certainly delivers the serious yet entertaining and absorbing read that I was hoping for. I would definitely recommend this book to lovers of historical fiction and mystery thrillers.
Paddy Hirsch presents a strikingly honest portrayal of New York in the early 19th Century discussing themes such as race, religion, gang warfare, poverty, organised crime, infant mortality, human trafficking, murder, rudimentary forensic science, early policing, civil unrest and warfare.
A young girl has been killed, her body discovered by Kerry O'Toole who although neutral herself has links to both of the major crime gangs in New York, as well as to the early policing network. It is through the investigations into this murder that we as readers are introduced to the powder keg of a political situation that is at the very heart of New York itself.
The descriptive writing in this novel is outstanding, at times I felt like I could see and smell the surroundings in which the characters were placed, particularly those of the market area.
One aspect of the novel that I particularly enjoyed was the debate over morality. 'Hudson's Kill' appears to be a tale of good and evil, but not in the traditional sense. The complex collection of characters are so well written that they represent the very best and very worst of humanity. Acts of atrocities are committed by those too naive to know better whilst the brotherhood of criminals commit acts of integrity and kindness. The question of whether or not bad deeds can be done for the best of reasons is frequently raised throughout the novel and the complex nature of morality is certainly presented as something to think about.
This is the first book of Paddy Hirsch's that I have read but I will certainly be reading his first novel and eagerly awaiting any more of his books in the future. I admire the work that has obviously led to the historical accuracy of this novel, something which I as a historian and Literature graduate often find disappointingly lacking in much historical fiction. The atmosphere felt realistic and the majority of characters behaved in a believable fashion for the era.
The tone of 'Hudson's Kill', as the title and blood spattered cover suggests, is dark and it certainly delivers the serious yet entertaining and absorbing read that I was hoping for. I would definitely recommend this book to lovers of historical fiction and mystery thrillers.
July 2, 2019
I received a free copy from Readers First in exchange for an honest review.
I was a fan from the previous book so i had some preconceptions going in that were more than met. If anything i found this to be even more enjoyble than the first book, perhaps as it has less of the backstories than the first one did so it can concentrate more on the action at hand. That doesn't mean to say any new readers are coming into this blind, there is some brief backstory for most of the main characters - and if you enjoy this book then you can find out more of the history with the first book.
The main action of this book centres around the mysterious Jericho, a walled compound within New York, created by a Mohammedan Immigrant and sneakily expanded upon right under the noses of the city officials. No one knows what goes on inside the walls or just how big the compound actually is.
Our protagonist Justy (a marshall of the city) starts off investigating the death of a young woman who had her stomach slit wide open, this inevitably leads him inside Jericho where girls seem to go but never come back. Something more mysterious is afoot - what is the charismatic preacher who leads the compound really up to? Girls are promised a better life if they join, but it may not be what it appears.
Our other main character Kerry O'Toole, who found the dying girl in an alley, goes undercover to break into Jericho to see if she can uncover what is going on, but things don't quite go to plan.
There is a wealth of action to enjoy, and quite a lot of language from the era, so much there are several pages of glossary at the back which i found myself having to refer to a few times when i couldn't work out a word. I didn't notice quite as much of this in the first book.
I was a fan from the previous book so i had some preconceptions going in that were more than met. If anything i found this to be even more enjoyble than the first book, perhaps as it has less of the backstories than the first one did so it can concentrate more on the action at hand. That doesn't mean to say any new readers are coming into this blind, there is some brief backstory for most of the main characters - and if you enjoy this book then you can find out more of the history with the first book.
The main action of this book centres around the mysterious Jericho, a walled compound within New York, created by a Mohammedan Immigrant and sneakily expanded upon right under the noses of the city officials. No one knows what goes on inside the walls or just how big the compound actually is.
Our protagonist Justy (a marshall of the city) starts off investigating the death of a young woman who had her stomach slit wide open, this inevitably leads him inside Jericho where girls seem to go but never come back. Something more mysterious is afoot - what is the charismatic preacher who leads the compound really up to? Girls are promised a better life if they join, but it may not be what it appears.
Our other main character Kerry O'Toole, who found the dying girl in an alley, goes undercover to break into Jericho to see if she can uncover what is going on, but things don't quite go to plan.
There is a wealth of action to enjoy, and quite a lot of language from the era, so much there are several pages of glossary at the back which i found myself having to refer to a few times when i couldn't work out a word. I didn't notice quite as much of this in the first book.
July 7, 2019
Hudson’s Kill is a historical thriller, set in the early 1800’s.
Full of political intrigue, racial tension, conspiracy and violence, the author recreates the dark and gritty underbelly of New York. As the population continues to grow and the city is forced to expand, a deadly battle for land is inevitable. Gangs fight for supremacy whilst the poor fight to survive.
Hudson’s Kill was a great read. Although I’m not usually a fan of a lot of historical fiction, this was a definite exception. The book is well written and clearly well researched and the writing is so atmospheric and realistic that you can almost see, smell and hear the city as the story unfolds. The story itself is intriguing and continues to build, keeping you guessing as to who the murderer is.
In keeping with the time, the author uses a lot of unfamiliar language and terms, and although there is a glossary included, this did distract from the story in places, as I felt I was constantly having to check the meaning of things. I can completely understand why this was included, and for the most part it was a great addition to the story, but it did leave me frustrated at times.
All in all this was a great read, full of interesting characters, wonderful world building and a well constructed plot line. I didn’t realise this was the second book featuring these characters so I’ll definitely be looking out for book one.
4 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you to Readers First and the publishers (Corvus and Atlantic Books) for my copy. All opinions are my own and provided willingly.
Full of political intrigue, racial tension, conspiracy and violence, the author recreates the dark and gritty underbelly of New York. As the population continues to grow and the city is forced to expand, a deadly battle for land is inevitable. Gangs fight for supremacy whilst the poor fight to survive.
Hudson’s Kill was a great read. Although I’m not usually a fan of a lot of historical fiction, this was a definite exception. The book is well written and clearly well researched and the writing is so atmospheric and realistic that you can almost see, smell and hear the city as the story unfolds. The story itself is intriguing and continues to build, keeping you guessing as to who the murderer is.
In keeping with the time, the author uses a lot of unfamiliar language and terms, and although there is a glossary included, this did distract from the story in places, as I felt I was constantly having to check the meaning of things. I can completely understand why this was included, and for the most part it was a great addition to the story, but it did leave me frustrated at times.
All in all this was a great read, full of interesting characters, wonderful world building and a well constructed plot line. I didn’t realise this was the second book featuring these characters so I’ll definitely be looking out for book one.
4 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you to Readers First and the publishers (Corvus and Atlantic Books) for my copy. All opinions are my own and provided willingly.
December 19, 2019
I had great hopes for this book -- a thriller set in 19th century New York City. But it turned out to be MUCH more your ordinary crime-mystery-thriller, and much less about NYC's history.
This is the second novel in a series by Paddy Hirsch, who is also a journalist and the editor for one of NPR's economics podcasts, The Indicator. Set in 1803, when NYC was still a small town geographically limited to the Wall Street area, Marshall (that's a title, not a first name) Justy Flanagan finds himself investigating the murder of a young girl. The plot gets increasingly complicated as the novel progresses -- involving rival gangs, turf wars, prostitution, escaped slaves, land grabs, and corrupt politicians. And Flanagan discovers that even those you trust most can turn out to be working for the other side.
If you're a lover of thrillers, you will probably enjoy this. There's plenty of action and quite a bit of violence. But if, like me, you're interesting in learning more about NYC's origins, this won't be very satisfying. Most of the historical reality came from Hirsch's habit of relying on outdated language, which I assume is authentic to this time period. But there's so much of it that he included an 8-page glossary at the book's end which I did not discover until mid-way through the book. So I had to struggle to piece together what people were actually saying to one another and what was happening in the plot. Most annoying!
As a result, I'm unlikely to pick up another book in this series. But I WILL continue listening to The Indicator.
This is the second novel in a series by Paddy Hirsch, who is also a journalist and the editor for one of NPR's economics podcasts, The Indicator. Set in 1803, when NYC was still a small town geographically limited to the Wall Street area, Marshall (that's a title, not a first name) Justy Flanagan finds himself investigating the murder of a young girl. The plot gets increasingly complicated as the novel progresses -- involving rival gangs, turf wars, prostitution, escaped slaves, land grabs, and corrupt politicians. And Flanagan discovers that even those you trust most can turn out to be working for the other side.
If you're a lover of thrillers, you will probably enjoy this. There's plenty of action and quite a bit of violence. But if, like me, you're interesting in learning more about NYC's origins, this won't be very satisfying. Most of the historical reality came from Hirsch's habit of relying on outdated language, which I assume is authentic to this time period. But there's so much of it that he included an 8-page glossary at the book's end which I did not discover until mid-way through the book. So I had to struggle to piece together what people were actually saying to one another and what was happening in the plot. Most annoying!
As a result, I'm unlikely to pick up another book in this series. But I WILL continue listening to The Indicator.
December 24, 2020
Hudson’s Kill is set in New York in 1803. New York was a dangerous and socially stratified place full of corruption, immigration scandals, horrific living conditions, rampant Irish and Black warring gangs, slavery (white and black) and some people trying to do things properly.
Justy Flanagan is a Marshal in the city which has a police system under the whip of politicians’ exploitive land manipulators. A young woman is found murdered in an alley, no culprits in sight or imagination. He and a woman named Kelly O’Toole attempt to solve the girl’s murder under the direst conditions.
Hirsch uses the vernacular of the day, some Irish, some old English, some German, some who knows? You need a glossary. And the author provides it, at the end of the book (seven pages!) It would have helped at the beginning.
I found it by accident and did not use it preferring to fight my way through the language maze. You can do it, it's educational and enlightening but you might prefer to peek occasionally.
I liked the book and the writing. The history is somewhat thin but there is so much going on it doesn’t matter.
Slavery is still a problem (although mostly hidden) in our society so the book has resonance.
Found out later it is the second in a trilogy. I probably won’t read the others simply because there is far too much to read but I liked this book!
I huge been to New York often and know Manhattan fairly well but I didn’t know ‘Broadway’ was once ‘Broad Way” for obvious reasons.
January 13, 2020
Hudson’s Kill- A historical thriller adventure!
Thanks Readers First & Atlantic for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Synopsis;
New York, 1803. The expanding city is rife with tension, and violence simmers on every street as black and Irish gangs fight for control. When a young girl is found brutally murdered, Marshal Justy Flanagan must find the killer before a mob takes the law into their own hands.
Kerry O'Toole, Justy's friend and ally, decides to pursue her own inquiries into the girl's murder. When they each find their way into a shadowy community on the fringes of the city, Justy and Kerry encounter a treacherous web of political conspiracy and criminal enterprise. As events dangerously escalate, they must fight to save not only the city, but also themselves...
Thoughts: The best story I’ve read in a while! Main Character Justy a city marshal tries to find out who killed a young black women and left her in the ally to die. This book has romance, violence, tension, action, friendship and more! It gives you a real picture into what New York was like back then. It’s hard to believe black people were slaves and were treated so badly. There’s so many different gangs in this book too. It’s so interesting. If you like historical fiction and thrillers/ crime stories you’ll love this!
Thanks Readers First & Atlantic for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Synopsis;
New York, 1803. The expanding city is rife with tension, and violence simmers on every street as black and Irish gangs fight for control. When a young girl is found brutally murdered, Marshal Justy Flanagan must find the killer before a mob takes the law into their own hands.
Kerry O'Toole, Justy's friend and ally, decides to pursue her own inquiries into the girl's murder. When they each find their way into a shadowy community on the fringes of the city, Justy and Kerry encounter a treacherous web of political conspiracy and criminal enterprise. As events dangerously escalate, they must fight to save not only the city, but also themselves...
Thoughts: The best story I’ve read in a while! Main Character Justy a city marshal tries to find out who killed a young black women and left her in the ally to die. This book has romance, violence, tension, action, friendship and more! It gives you a real picture into what New York was like back then. It’s hard to believe black people were slaves and were treated so badly. There’s so many different gangs in this book too. It’s so interesting. If you like historical fiction and thrillers/ crime stories you’ll love this!
September 22, 2019
Fantastic atmospherics and a good mystery make this a very good read. Kerry O'Toole, now a school teacher, finds the body of a young black girl in the mud. It's 1803 New York City- a gritty dark and difficult time for anyone, much less someone like Kerry. She luckily can call on Justy Flanagan, now a Marshal, to figure out what happened. It's not actually surprising that no one was looking for this girl- they might have been but times- and communications- were different then. What is surprising is that she appears to have been extremely well cared for and not the type to fall prey to whoever brutally murdered her. Hirsch has written an excellent thriller filled with conspiracies, politics, gangs, and crimes in a way we often see in novels set in the present but seldom do for this period. No spoilers but you will get a good education. Some of the vernacular used in the dialogue might be unfamiliar but there is a glossary of sorts at the end. Thanks to edelweiss for the ARC. This is the second in a series; I missed the first but did not feel that diminished my enjoyment of this in the least. An excellent choice for historical thriller/mystery fans.
July 4, 2019
As a historical thriller set in New York in the 1800s I wasn't sure what I was expecting especially as I hadn't read the first novel with these characters but Paddy Hirsch sets an exceptional scene. I could picture every scene clearly and I could hear the characters American and Irish drawls clear as day in my head while I was reading. I will say one thing - I found the lingo difficult in places as I often had to refer to the translation listings in the back of the book to tell me what some of the words meant!
The narrative flows really well, switching between Justice (Justy) and Kerry smoothly and allowing the reader to follow the storyline with ease. I really enjoyed these characters and I will definitely be getting the first novel from this author so that I can catch up however I don't feel I needed to read it to understand what was happening in Hudson's Kill.
Overall I would recommend this novel to those who read novels such as CJ Sansom & SJ Parris and enjoy the historical aspect to those novels.
The narrative flows really well, switching between Justice (Justy) and Kerry smoothly and allowing the reader to follow the storyline with ease. I really enjoyed these characters and I will definitely be getting the first novel from this author so that I can catch up however I don't feel I needed to read it to understand what was happening in Hudson's Kill.
Overall I would recommend this novel to those who read novels such as CJ Sansom & SJ Parris and enjoy the historical aspect to those novels.
July 4, 2019
Set at the turn of the 19th century, in New York; this is a mystery, crime thriller read which begins with the gruesome discovery of a young girl’s body.
This is the second book in the series, and despite not having read the first, I had a great time reading this; I loved being transported in time, to a growing city full of issues and angst. It’s really well researched and executed. I’ll definitely be getting book one soon.
A myriad of contrasting and engaging characters; a deeply immersive setting and a central mystery that hooks you right in. I loved the atmosphere of the streets and the dangers and politics at play. There’s a great lead character in Marshall Justy Flanagan ~ a fascinating protagonist to follow, as well as the young Kerry O’Toole. Both morally focussed on finding out the truth amid a dangerous city rife with criminal and social tension ~ it certainly is a challenging and tough environment to live and work in. The story builds in pace to a great climax.
A really happy reader! Recommended for those who like historical crime thrillers.
This is the second book in the series, and despite not having read the first, I had a great time reading this; I loved being transported in time, to a growing city full of issues and angst. It’s really well researched and executed. I’ll definitely be getting book one soon.
A myriad of contrasting and engaging characters; a deeply immersive setting and a central mystery that hooks you right in. I loved the atmosphere of the streets and the dangers and politics at play. There’s a great lead character in Marshall Justy Flanagan ~ a fascinating protagonist to follow, as well as the young Kerry O’Toole. Both morally focussed on finding out the truth amid a dangerous city rife with criminal and social tension ~ it certainly is a challenging and tough environment to live and work in. The story builds in pace to a great climax.
A really happy reader! Recommended for those who like historical crime thrillers.
July 5, 2019
I am not usually a fan of historical thrillers but Paddy Hirsch has got a winning formula for an entertaining novel. This, his second book in the series is better than the first.
It’s set in New York in 1803 where the hero Justy Flanagan is a Marshal (an early policeman). The rapidly growing city has immigrants coming in from all over setting up enclaves and Black and Irish gangs fighting violently for control of limited space.
Justy’s friend Kerry O’Toole discovers a dying girl and she vows to find out who she was and who did the murder and why!
This is a well written well researched book with nicely crafted characters that carries the reader along at a good pace. I enjoyed both books and can recommend this to anyone who enjoys a good thriller
I was given this book in return for an honest review
It’s set in New York in 1803 where the hero Justy Flanagan is a Marshal (an early policeman). The rapidly growing city has immigrants coming in from all over setting up enclaves and Black and Irish gangs fighting violently for control of limited space.
Justy’s friend Kerry O’Toole discovers a dying girl and she vows to find out who she was and who did the murder and why!
This is a well written well researched book with nicely crafted characters that carries the reader along at a good pace. I enjoyed both books and can recommend this to anyone who enjoys a good thriller
I was given this book in return for an honest review
July 10, 2019
I’m not one for historical fiction however the setting of this in New York in the early nineteenth century is quite fascinating as it really makes you think about how this incredible city came to be. The variety of nationalities and the turf wars really set the scene well for a murder mystery as the complex splits and integrations between the groups provide a realistic challenge of collecting evidence, witnesses and knowing just who to trust. This is really well written and places the reader in the centre of the action, the characters are beautifully flawed and the language is easy enough to follow although my one gripe is that the glossary would have been better placed at the front of the book as it was little use to me once I’d read it through and discovered it at the back! Overall though this makes an unusual story and I’d recommend giving it a go.
July 21, 2019
If you have seen Gangs of New York then you know the period this novel is set. This book is completely immersive, Hirsch has done an incredible amount of research, to the language used, the the style of buildings. I often felt myself drawn into the period, even dreaming about the city in my sleep, his descriptions become so vivid. Hudson's Kill has pretty much got a bit of everything for everyone. It's a thriller, it's a murder mystery, it's a political and corruption rollercoaster, it's full of action, it has heroes , villains and enough in every page to keep you turning. All this and written in a way that is very easy and absorbing. Hirsch is a master and it is very hard to believe this is only his second novel. Hudson's Kill deserves to be celebrated and loved, a rare book that will delight so many and deserves to be read. 4/5
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews