Okay, I have to admit. I like the idea. I like going back to see what happened with Bluestar before Firepaw came in. I also have to admit something else. I didn't like this book.
Bluestar was just annoying. Her decisions made no sense. I didn't get her at all. Oakheart was, eh, dumb. I totally think Crookedpaw was nicer. Side note: I loved Crookedpaw's character. I absolutely love his loyalty. He is overly friendly at gatherings, but in battle, he's fiercely loyal to his clan, which I appreciate.
Okay, back on track. Yes, Sunfall/star was actually pretty good. Pinestar was, uh, okay. Kinda stupid, but okay. Thistleclaw was actually pretty cool, even if he was evil. Thrushpelt.... oh, Thrushpelt, I pity you :) He reminds me of Peeta, a little bit. Big softie. Very down to earth. Unfortunately for him, his Katniss (Kat-niss?) didn't like him back. Oh well, I think he probably got over her. Actually, wait, no, I don't think he did -_- wow. Never mind. Anyway.... who am I forgetting? Oh, yeah, Snowfur. Poor her. I don't know. She was kind of annoying, and I don't get what she saw in Thistleclaw (hey, me and Bluefur agree on something!).
Apart from the characters, this book was absolute crap (some of the characters were crap too, or else it might have gotten 3 stars). The plot was pointless. It's because of these books that I've come to hate prophesies in books with a vengeance. Goosebutt, or whatever his name was (Gooseflower? No. Goosepelt? No. Goosejerk? Yes, that's more like it), was perhaps the most annoying character ever. Worst pick for medicine cat, I admit. Wait, I'm going on about the characters. Never mind. Alright, the plot. Too many prophesies in the Warriors books. I know they're supposed to be important, but I just hate them. The story in this book felt like it was just being dragged out. Some scenes felt important to the plot, but (as is typical with these books) there were just SO many pointless scenes that drove me insane. I really have no sympathy for Bluefur, despite all she went through. I don't know. Maybe it was because she actually wasn't that nice at times, and way too ambitious. I like an unambitious lead, but she was the opposite.
Okay, I'll conclude this. Basically, I hated this book. It was the worst, probably, of the Special Editions, at least the ones I've read, and I don't have any particular sympathy for Bluestar after reading it. I thought maybe we'd get to see why she had doubts about the loyalty of her own clan, but no, we didn't. I thought we'd get a better story. But it was pretty bad.
The only part I liked was the little epilogue, with Spottedleaf and Bluestar, and Rusty, and the whole 'get Graypaw to track him' thing. By the way, why in later books are apprentices not even really allowed out alone, but in this one they're being sent on missions next to Twoleg-place, or whatever they called it?
All in all, just awful -_-
(Also, Bluefur and Oakheart had a damn one night stand. Really!)