What do you think?
Rate this book
The Keeper Chronicles #1
A Threat of Shadows
#SPBFO Semifinalist
2nd Edition
Alaric betrayed everything he believed to save Evangeline — and failed.
His last chance to save the woman he loves lies in an ancient Wellstone, a repository of power, buried and lost long ago.
Luck—or something more troubling—leads him to a small group searching for the same stone.
A disgruntled dwarf,
a bumbling wizard,
and an elf with an unsettling amount of power.
If he can gain their trust, they might help him find the cure.
But the Wellstone holds more than he knows, and a terrible evil he’d thought defeated is stirring again, searching for the stone.
Can the companions survive a traitor, a dragon, and their own pasts to reach the stone before time runs out?
This new 2nd edition includes maps and illustrations.
A Threat of Shadows is the brilliant introduction to the magical world of The Keeper Chronicles, a new epic fantasy series by JA Andrews. Fans of Patrick Rothfuss, David Eddings, and Terry Pratchett will love this unputdownable tale.
Dive into this enchanting fantasy novel with real emotional depth. Grab your copy of A Threat of Shadows and begin this epic series today!
2nd Edition
Alaric betrayed everything he believed to save Evangeline — and failed.
His last chance to save the woman he loves lies in an ancient Wellstone, a repository of power, buried and lost long ago.
Luck—or something more troubling—leads him to a small group searching for the same stone.
A disgruntled dwarf,
a bumbling wizard,
and an elf with an unsettling amount of power.
If he can gain their trust, they might help him find the cure.
But the Wellstone holds more than he knows, and a terrible evil he’d thought defeated is stirring again, searching for the stone.
Can the companions survive a traitor, a dragon, and their own pasts to reach the stone before time runs out?
This new 2nd edition includes maps and illustrations.
A Threat of Shadows is the brilliant introduction to the magical world of The Keeper Chronicles, a new epic fantasy series by JA Andrews. Fans of Patrick Rothfuss, David Eddings, and Terry Pratchett will love this unputdownable tale.
Dive into this enchanting fantasy novel with real emotional depth. Grab your copy of A Threat of Shadows and begin this epic series today!
460 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 30, 2016
1022 people are currently reading
2958 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 298 reviews
January 4, 2017
A Threat of Shadows (The Keeper Chronicles #1) by J.A. Andrews follows 'A Keeper's Tale: The Story of Tomkin and the Dragon' but could be read as a stand alone. Alaric is a Keeper, but is putting this on hold while he tries to find the antidote for his wife who has poison in her system. This is his tale as he tries to find the answer he needs. He meets all kinds of creatures and beings and is in all kinds of encounters along the way. Dragons, elves, dwarves, sorcerers, and more. There's action, adventure, lots of humor, battles, and sadness. The wonderful plot,great dialogue, the great characters, and witty humor make this a fun and exciting book. Truly loved it.
January 4, 2021
This book is a beautiful treasure trove of hope and redemption. Alaric is on a quest to save his wife and along the way stumbles upon a group of unlikely heroes. They soon find themselves on an adventure to save not only his wife but the world. Heartwarming and witty, its message of love and friendship left me feeling so satisfied. I look forward to the next book.
March 23, 2024
Fantastic! Great characters, group of misfits, quests! What will you do for love. I think I have found a new autobuy author! Such a great debut
July 1, 2021
I haven't finished reading it. I'm 70% through and switching to another book. I might get back to it someday...
I really wanted to like A Threat of Shadows, giving it another chance, and another one, and then another one, but unfortunately it didn't work for me. It's classic fantasy with a modern touch, so it's right up my alley. That's why I gave it many chances, but unfortunately to no avail
The book has potential, and the author's skills at writing are pretty good, the problem was all the other things. Almost all the characters felt quite flat and didn't flash, maybe except for the MC whose character is better drawn than the rest.
The plot was very thin and not cohesive enough (though there were a few nice twists), and the pacing is very slow.
Halfway through I was asking myself "wait, what has happened so far?" my answer was - not much.... it seemed like after the first half, things started moving, but still not by much.
In the 90's it was very acceptable to write a slow opening, and sometimes even almost half a book but then - fireworks! That's why I wanted to get at least to the 50% mark hoping things would improve .afterward
The author definitely has potential, and I'm convinced that the more she'd write, the better author she'd become, so I'll keep my eyes on her career.
Actually, a better editor could have helped the author a lot in polishing her story. It would require some serious revisions, but I'm sure AToS could have been much better.
Choosing Tim Gerard Reynolds for doing the narration is a great choice!
It seems like quite a lot of people are very fond of AToS, so give it a shot if it's right up your alley.
3.25-3.5/5
Disclaimer- I know the author and like her very much! She's super cool, witty, and has a great sense of humor (you definitely should follow her) :)
My acquaintance with Janice didn't influence my review whatsoever. All my reviews are honest and judged by the same standards.
I really wanted to like A Threat of Shadows, giving it another chance, and another one, and then another one, but unfortunately it didn't work for me. It's classic fantasy with a modern touch, so it's right up my alley. That's why I gave it many chances, but unfortunately to no avail
The book has potential, and the author's skills at writing are pretty good, the problem was all the other things. Almost all the characters felt quite flat and didn't flash, maybe except for the MC whose character is better drawn than the rest.
The plot was very thin and not cohesive enough (though there were a few nice twists), and the pacing is very slow.
Halfway through I was asking myself "wait, what has happened so far?" my answer was - not much.... it seemed like after the first half, things started moving, but still not by much.
In the 90's it was very acceptable to write a slow opening, and sometimes even almost half a book but then - fireworks! That's why I wanted to get at least to the 50% mark hoping things would improve .afterward
The author definitely has potential, and I'm convinced that the more she'd write, the better author she'd become, so I'll keep my eyes on her career.
Actually, a better editor could have helped the author a lot in polishing her story. It would require some serious revisions, but I'm sure AToS could have been much better.
Choosing Tim Gerard Reynolds for doing the narration is a great choice!
It seems like quite a lot of people are very fond of AToS, so give it a shot if it's right up your alley.
3.25-3.5/5
Disclaimer- I know the author and like her very much! She's super cool, witty, and has a great sense of humor (you definitely should follow her) :)
My acquaintance with Janice didn't influence my review whatsoever. All my reviews are honest and judged by the same standards.
June 5, 2022
This was even better the second time. I love this book so much! Alaric is on a mission to save his dying wife. He soon joins a gang of misfits (including a grumpy dwarf, a cheerful elf, a fearless milkmaid and an optomistic blacksmith) and finds himself on a quest to not only save his wife, but to save the world.
There is a wholesome goodness about this book. It has messages of love and friendship and forgiveness. It's a quick, clean and easy enough story that is appropriate for young readers. But it also has a deepness, with thought-provoking messages, that is satisfying for adults. Reading it is like wrapping myself in a cozy blanket. It will forever be a favorite.
There is a wholesome goodness about this book. It has messages of love and friendship and forgiveness. It's a quick, clean and easy enough story that is appropriate for young readers. But it also has a deepness, with thought-provoking messages, that is satisfying for adults. Reading it is like wrapping myself in a cozy blanket. It will forever be a favorite.
April 23, 2023
I really enjoyed this one! It reminds me in tone of the Riyria books, as the series is rather "clean" too, as in no sex scenes or very graphic violence.
But it's not fluff, instead does have quite some character development! The main protagonists is flawed, as he did bad things trying to save someone. I liked getting to know the whole crew better and better, and see them go from what feels a bit stereotypical at the start to fleshed out individuals!
And having read farther in the series, I can say the author gets better and the characters gain more and more depth throughout the whole arc of the series.
I'd highly recommend this, especial for anyone who's looking for something that isn't grimdark, has more of a classic feeling to it, yet has a more modern take and doesn't why away from painful topics.
(PS, if you like audible - 46 hours of the amazing Tim Gerard Reynolds for just one credit, as the whole series is published as one there! *Coughs* Do yourself a favour and go get it...)
But it's not fluff, instead does have quite some character development! The main protagonists is flawed, as he did bad things trying to save someone. I liked getting to know the whole crew better and better, and see them go from what feels a bit stereotypical at the start to fleshed out individuals!
And having read farther in the series, I can say the author gets better and the characters gain more and more depth throughout the whole arc of the series.
I'd highly recommend this, especial for anyone who's looking for something that isn't grimdark, has more of a classic feeling to it, yet has a more modern take and doesn't why away from painful topics.
(PS, if you like audible - 46 hours of the amazing Tim Gerard Reynolds for just one credit, as the whole series is published as one there! *Coughs* Do yourself a favour and go get it...)
June 21, 2018
A Threat of Shadows, is about a Keeper named Alaric who is on a desperate search for a cure to save his wife from dying. Alaric has forsaken his role as a Keeper and does some nasty things all to save her. He is ashamed of himself, yet resilient towards his purpose whatever the cost.
Alaric tracks down a lead to an old Keeper who lived a hundred years ago that might have the cure. His journey to find a Wellstone, a literal record of memories, takes him on a harrowing journey filled with cunning and deceit. Before he knows it, he discovers the very fate of the world depends upon his actions.
The Characters
The story for A Threat of Shadows revolves around the Keeper, Alaric, a boy named Brandson, a dwarf named Douglon, an elf named Ayda, Brandson’s girlfriend Milly, and an old wizard named Wizendorfurderfor (Gustav).
These characters are so wonderful and so intricately woven. Andrews has carefully crafted each with a wealth of history, motivation, and personality. The story follows Alaric exclusively, so we get inside his head and know more about him than anyone else. You’ll fall in love with Alaric’s character as you cheer him on in his quest. You’ll rejoice at his successes and empathize with his failures.
The supporting characters are witty and fun. As you’re reading, keep an eye on character progression, especially the elf and the dwarf. You won’t be sorry!
The Plot
As I already mentioned, the plot in A Threat of Shadows is centered around Alaric’s need to save his wife, but it goes far deeper than that. It’s not long before the heroes find out someone is trying to raise an all-powerful evil nefarious bad guy. If he rises, the world as they know it will end. I can’t reveal more without spoiling it, but trust me, the circumstances surrounding this are brilliantly written.
My favorite part? The twists! I love a good twist. If a book doesn’t surprise me, I don’t get engaged. A Threat of Shadows delivers time and time again.
Additional Thoughts
This is generally the section where I share a few things that didn’t work for me. Yea. I can’t do that here. I loved A Threat of Shadows that much. Seriously. I haven’t liked a book this much in awhile. I’ve been reading Brandon Sanderson’s Mistborn for three months. I read a chapter and put it down and forget about it for awhile. But…I could not put down A Threat of Shadows. There you go Ms. Andrews. You’re better than Mistborn. LOVED IT.
Alaric tracks down a lead to an old Keeper who lived a hundred years ago that might have the cure. His journey to find a Wellstone, a literal record of memories, takes him on a harrowing journey filled with cunning and deceit. Before he knows it, he discovers the very fate of the world depends upon his actions.
The Characters
The story for A Threat of Shadows revolves around the Keeper, Alaric, a boy named Brandson, a dwarf named Douglon, an elf named Ayda, Brandson’s girlfriend Milly, and an old wizard named Wizendorfurderfor (Gustav).
These characters are so wonderful and so intricately woven. Andrews has carefully crafted each with a wealth of history, motivation, and personality. The story follows Alaric exclusively, so we get inside his head and know more about him than anyone else. You’ll fall in love with Alaric’s character as you cheer him on in his quest. You’ll rejoice at his successes and empathize with his failures.
The supporting characters are witty and fun. As you’re reading, keep an eye on character progression, especially the elf and the dwarf. You won’t be sorry!
The Plot
As I already mentioned, the plot in A Threat of Shadows is centered around Alaric’s need to save his wife, but it goes far deeper than that. It’s not long before the heroes find out someone is trying to raise an all-powerful evil nefarious bad guy. If he rises, the world as they know it will end. I can’t reveal more without spoiling it, but trust me, the circumstances surrounding this are brilliantly written.
My favorite part? The twists! I love a good twist. If a book doesn’t surprise me, I don’t get engaged. A Threat of Shadows delivers time and time again.
Additional Thoughts
This is generally the section where I share a few things that didn’t work for me. Yea. I can’t do that here. I loved A Threat of Shadows that much. Seriously. I haven’t liked a book this much in awhile. I’ve been reading Brandon Sanderson’s Mistborn for three months. I read a chapter and put it down and forget about it for awhile. But…I could not put down A Threat of Shadows. There you go Ms. Andrews. You’re better than Mistborn. LOVED IT.
August 22, 2016
This was kinda a mixed-bag...
At first, it was a straightforward lone guy on a quest to Save The Damsel... except, by the end, it totally wasn't.
Then it had the stereotypical elf, dwarf, wizard, and 'farmerboy kid' meet guy in a tavern to go on a quest... except it was new and different, and not stereotypical... at least not in a stereotypical way. The wizard was a sort of Fizban/Arctavius goofball, the farmboy was a blacksmith, the elf was... strange and glittery (not in a twinkle-pire way... uh, i don't think...), and they also picked up a milkmaid. And the only guy in the whole 'party' who was even a fighter was the dwarf with his axe. The blacksmith was okay with knives. So it wasn't a battle with... fights in it. Much.
I kinda felt smart when I Figured Stuff Out. Um... but then wondered if it was actually obvious, and the characters were just dense. :/ But the plot kept going in unexpected, anti-stereotypical ways. The only problem, really, was... I didn't feel that close to any of the characters. I really wanted to, but... I dunno.
The main character is driven by his deep love for his wife, driven to do dark things he deeply regrets... and while I read about it, I didn't really feel it.
Worth a shot as a different kind of story, with some unexpected (and possibly some expected) twists.
(Grammar cop says good writing & editing, except the author used one word wrong, twice. Grammar cop is a doof and can't remember what the word was.)
At first, it was a straightforward lone guy on a quest to Save The Damsel... except, by the end, it totally wasn't.
Then it had the stereotypical elf, dwarf, wizard, and 'farmerboy kid' meet guy in a tavern to go on a quest... except it was new and different, and not stereotypical... at least not in a stereotypical way. The wizard was a sort of Fizban/Arctavius goofball, the farmboy was a blacksmith, the elf was... strange and glittery (not in a twinkle-pire way... uh, i don't think...), and they also picked up a milkmaid. And the only guy in the whole 'party' who was even a fighter was the dwarf with his axe. The blacksmith was okay with knives. So it wasn't a battle with... fights in it. Much.
I kinda felt smart when I Figured Stuff Out. Um... but then wondered if it was actually obvious, and the characters were just dense. :/ But the plot kept going in unexpected, anti-stereotypical ways. The only problem, really, was... I didn't feel that close to any of the characters. I really wanted to, but... I dunno.
The main character is driven by his deep love for his wife, driven to do dark things he deeply regrets... and while I read about it, I didn't really feel it.
Worth a shot as a different kind of story, with some unexpected (and possibly some expected) twists.
(Grammar cop says good writing & editing, except the author used one word wrong, twice. Grammar cop is a doof and can't remember what the word was.)
September 8, 2018
“Let the past inform your choices today, but don’t let it rule them.”
Whip-smart, well-paced, deeply satirical and dappled with just enough dark and light to keep the reader riveted. Weaving drama, excitement, grit, raw emotions and mystery through a quest journey, unlikely and disparate companions, with a huge difference between them, they each bring together unique perspective and unite in a desperate front. Emotional clashes, ethics and morals are always questioned. I really loved this book!
THE BLACK HORN.
“We might not be enough, But we have to try.”
This short story based in the same world is so captivating and poignant, an excellent perspective of how hope, belief and endurance can motivate a person.
I am voluntarily giving a review of an advance copy I received from the author.
Whip-smart, well-paced, deeply satirical and dappled with just enough dark and light to keep the reader riveted. Weaving drama, excitement, grit, raw emotions and mystery through a quest journey, unlikely and disparate companions, with a huge difference between them, they each bring together unique perspective and unite in a desperate front. Emotional clashes, ethics and morals are always questioned. I really loved this book!
THE BLACK HORN.
“We might not be enough, But we have to try.”
This short story based in the same world is so captivating and poignant, an excellent perspective of how hope, belief and endurance can motivate a person.
I am voluntarily giving a review of an advance copy I received from the author.
June 25, 2019
This isn't a bad book. It's just weak.
The story idea is interesting enough. It just needs to be fleshed out a lot more.
The setting feels more like a stage with a few properties thrown on it than a real world. Apart from a map and a few place-names, there isn't much to it.
The plot is thin, the crises and resolutions are too pat and convenient to be believable. At no time is there any real sense of danger. Even in the final showdown with the villain, I never felt like he was truly a threat.
And the characters are too flat to be interesting. I'm pretty sure I didn't sympathize with anyone I was supposed to sympathize with. You could have interchanged any of them with anyone else (bad guys included) and it wouldn't have made that much difference.
The potential is there for a great story. But it needs more.
The story idea is interesting enough. It just needs to be fleshed out a lot more.
The setting feels more like a stage with a few properties thrown on it than a real world. Apart from a map and a few place-names, there isn't much to it.
The plot is thin, the crises and resolutions are too pat and convenient to be believable. At no time is there any real sense of danger. Even in the final showdown with the villain, I never felt like he was truly a threat.
And the characters are too flat to be interesting. I'm pretty sure I didn't sympathize with anyone I was supposed to sympathize with. You could have interchanged any of them with anyone else (bad guys included) and it wouldn't have made that much difference.
The potential is there for a great story. But it needs more.
April 5, 2017
The book starts with Alaric, a Keeper who has embarked on a mission to save his wife Evangeline. In doing so, one day he meets with an unusual group on their own mission and he joins them. Together they start an adventure of magic, mystery and deception. I liked all the characters, especially Ayda the elf. I really liked the plot and the book keep me turning to the next page to read what would happen next. I liked the ending that didnt leave me disappointed. I sincerely recommend this book to anyone who likes fantasies.
August 29, 2024
3.5⭐️ solid, classic epic fantasy. Very comfortable setting and i could see each book getting better!
September 10, 2018
Stop what you're doing and dive into this magnificent piece!! JA Andrews is going to rock your socks off! From her beautiful voice, her cast of lovable characters, phenomenal world building, the magic . . . . and the secrets!!!!!!!!!!!!! JA was constantly unraveling layers upon layers of secrets--jaw-dropping, heart-stopping, can't-stop-reading secrets!! The plot kept thickening as I found myself completely enthralled with this world, unable to come up for air! It was such a masterfully told fantasy worthy of all the greats like Brandon Sanderson, Richard Knaak, Patrick Rothfuss, Michael J. Sullivan and more!!
And to top it all off she included beautiful character sketches and a magnificent short story called The Black Horn. And let me tell you . . . The Black Horn was SUCH an amazing short! The characters, the world building . . . bahhh!! It grips you from the first page, takes you on a wild ride, and then drops you, leaving you begging for more! I cannot even describe how excited I am to see what happens!!!
It's authors like JA Andrews that are CRUSHING the indie stigma!!!!
And to top it all off she included beautiful character sketches and a magnificent short story called The Black Horn. And let me tell you . . . The Black Horn was SUCH an amazing short! The characters, the world building . . . bahhh!! It grips you from the first page, takes you on a wild ride, and then drops you, leaving you begging for more! I cannot even describe how excited I am to see what happens!!!
It's authors like JA Andrews that are CRUSHING the indie stigma!!!!
November 4, 2017
One of the best epic fantasy books I've ever read, this adventure will hold you spellbound and keep you up late in night, because you have to know what happens! The blend of magic, mystery, life-threatening encounters and the loyal friendships combine with a blend of wit and romance make this an enjoyable fantasy read for young and old alike. I love the message in the book and the blend between light and darkness. The hero is noblebright and I look forward to reading more by this author.
December 15, 2018
A Threat of Shadows by JA Andrews is a book that aches with hope and redemption wrapped in a classic fantasy setting. I’m not sure if I can find words that describe this novel better than classic fun. As I was reading it I was often put in mind of Dragonlance and other classic fantasy from the 80s.
There is a lot to enjoy in this novel from Andrews, especially if you are a fan of classic, hopeful fantasy. The main character, Alaric, is a take on the classic brooding hero archetype. But whereas that archetype is typically a strong, dark, handsome warrior, in A Threat of Shadows the brooding hero is a scholar. It’s a twist on the classic trope that puts things into a different perspective and adds the hint of freshness. It certainly isn’t an entirely unique take, but it isn’t trying to be. It’s a fun take on a classic hero, and Andrews seasons it with a tragic backstory that, while being deeply emotional, doesn’t cross the line into melodrama. This is a story that is about the character of Alaric. While there are epic and important events that he participates in, the novel itself is his story from the inciting incident to the denouement. I tend to really enjoy character stories, and this aspect of Andrews’ novel connected with me. I should also mention that there are some cool character portraits scattered throughout the book that I enjoyed.
No novel is without weaknesses, however. For me, one of the largest is that while Alaric is incredibly well drawn, the side characters largely fell flat for me. I didn’t feel like I entirely understood their motivations. I also would have liked to have seen more depth to the setting. There are some interesting tidbits we receive throughout the story, but the world felt a little vanilla in the end. Perhaps the biggest issue, for me, was that I felt the story overall lacked some tension and suspense. This was not because the writing was lacking in any way nor due to a lack of dramatic scenes but rather because I was able to predict any twists or reveals before they happened. I’m not quite sure if this was down to the foreshadowing being a little too blunt or some other reason. It did lessen the dramatic tension for me, however.
I thoroughly enjoyed A Threat of Shadows and if you’re looking for a hopeful fantasy in a classic vein you should give it a read. While I hope for more depth in future books, the themes of hope and identity and redemption in this one really scratch that itch for something less dark. 4/5 stars.
5 – I loved this, couldn’t put it down, move it to the top of your TBR pile
4 – I really enjoyed this, add it to the TBR pile
3 – It was ok, depending on your preferences it may be worth your time
2 – I didn’t like this book, it has significant flaws and I can’t recommend it
1 – I loathe this book with a most loathsome loathing
There is a lot to enjoy in this novel from Andrews, especially if you are a fan of classic, hopeful fantasy. The main character, Alaric, is a take on the classic brooding hero archetype. But whereas that archetype is typically a strong, dark, handsome warrior, in A Threat of Shadows the brooding hero is a scholar. It’s a twist on the classic trope that puts things into a different perspective and adds the hint of freshness. It certainly isn’t an entirely unique take, but it isn’t trying to be. It’s a fun take on a classic hero, and Andrews seasons it with a tragic backstory that, while being deeply emotional, doesn’t cross the line into melodrama. This is a story that is about the character of Alaric. While there are epic and important events that he participates in, the novel itself is his story from the inciting incident to the denouement. I tend to really enjoy character stories, and this aspect of Andrews’ novel connected with me. I should also mention that there are some cool character portraits scattered throughout the book that I enjoyed.
No novel is without weaknesses, however. For me, one of the largest is that while Alaric is incredibly well drawn, the side characters largely fell flat for me. I didn’t feel like I entirely understood their motivations. I also would have liked to have seen more depth to the setting. There are some interesting tidbits we receive throughout the story, but the world felt a little vanilla in the end. Perhaps the biggest issue, for me, was that I felt the story overall lacked some tension and suspense. This was not because the writing was lacking in any way nor due to a lack of dramatic scenes but rather because I was able to predict any twists or reveals before they happened. I’m not quite sure if this was down to the foreshadowing being a little too blunt or some other reason. It did lessen the dramatic tension for me, however.
I thoroughly enjoyed A Threat of Shadows and if you’re looking for a hopeful fantasy in a classic vein you should give it a read. While I hope for more depth in future books, the themes of hope and identity and redemption in this one really scratch that itch for something less dark. 4/5 stars.
5 – I loved this, couldn’t put it down, move it to the top of your TBR pile
4 – I really enjoyed this, add it to the TBR pile
3 – It was ok, depending on your preferences it may be worth your time
2 – I didn’t like this book, it has significant flaws and I can’t recommend it
1 – I loathe this book with a most loathsome loathing
January 14, 2023
I am reading the omnibus edition The Keeper Chronicles but for tracking purposes I will rate each individual book separately.
Book 1 showed an interesting world and magic that has potential to be stage for some amazing stories. However, while entertaining, the story at this first volume was a bit weak and repetitive. The characters could have been fleshed out a bit more.
The ending was very cliche and I saw it coming from early in the book.
Having said all that, I still enjoyed it. It was quick, easy and entertaining even with all my cons.
I will probably continue the series as I already own the next two books.
Book 1 showed an interesting world and magic that has potential to be stage for some amazing stories. However, while entertaining, the story at this first volume was a bit weak and repetitive. The characters could have been fleshed out a bit more.
The ending was very cliche and I saw it coming from early in the book.
Having said all that, I still enjoyed it. It was quick, easy and entertaining even with all my cons.
I will probably continue the series as I already own the next two books.
July 2, 2016
An adventure tale wisely told that I caught myself thinking about often when I was away from it. Andrews writes with a lot of heart and great understanding. In the end this is a book about wrestling--with evil wizards, yes, but also with oneself and with death--and she carries the reader along on that quest to overcome all three in a very honest and satisfying way.
Read
December 15, 2017I have an author interview up on the podcast The Nerd Book Review !
August 30, 2021
I loved this book, it had a bit of a sleeping beauty feel to it as Alaric is trying to rescue his wife from the poison she's been infected with, and has done some questionable things along the way, but all in the name of love. This fantasy book has elves, dwarves, a dragon and more, and a storyline that draws you in and keeps you guessing! Looking forward to the next book already!
Read
October 28, 2025Read about 1/3 of this story and decided to put it aside. In a bit of a reading slump so I want to pick this up again when that has passed as what I did read was entertaining.
February 1, 2021
JA Andrews has my heart with her covers alone, but I absolutely love to sink into her stories! Her noblebright fantasy roots always steal my heart, and this first book was no exception. Tension kept me reading but not so stressed I couldn't focus, and I really jived with her writing style. 5 stars, of course!
Read
April 25, 2019This was a really fun read, rather reminiscent of old-fashioned D&D fantasy, featuring a group of adventurers that include a scholar, a dwarf, an elf, a blacksmith, a good-hearted milkmaid and a ditzy wizard. Keeper Alaric is on a quest to find the antidote to the poison that is killing his beloved Evangeline, and to find the antidote he's done terrible things...but a chance at redemption comes when his quest gets mixed up in a much bigger quest to defeat one of those pesky Dark Lords that won't stay dead.
If you're looking for something groundbreakingly original or lyrically written, then this is probably not the book for you, but the star of this story was definitely the plot. There are a ton of revelations that Andrews makes at key moments, and I really enjoyed wondering how the author was going to surprise me next. All the plot twists are well foreshadowed in advance, so you might guess one or two, but when they do come they feel super satisfying. Finally, while the message of the book isn't subtle, it's resonant and beautiful.
I also loved "The Black Horn", an ambiguous and bittersweet short story that is included at the end.
I have the rest of this trilogy and am looking forward to reading it soon!
If you're looking for something groundbreakingly original or lyrically written, then this is probably not the book for you, but the star of this story was definitely the plot. There are a ton of revelations that Andrews makes at key moments, and I really enjoyed wondering how the author was going to surprise me next. All the plot twists are well foreshadowed in advance, so you might guess one or two, but when they do come they feel super satisfying. Finally, while the message of the book isn't subtle, it's resonant and beautiful.
I also loved "The Black Horn", an ambiguous and bittersweet short story that is included at the end.
I have the rest of this trilogy and am looking forward to reading it soon!
April 27, 2022
A wonderful epic fantasy tale that will win over any fan of Tolkien with its ragtag team of heroes and world-saving storyline. The beginning is leisurely and methodical as Ms. Andrews deftly weaves a rich tapestry that combines both past and present. I felt connected to the protagonist Alaric right away and truly felt for his plight, because like many sympathetic heroes and villains alike, his faults and flaws arose from simply loving too much.
While I am not the target audience for this book, as I tend to skew toward fast-paced contemporary reads, the writing quality is masterful, the plot is superb, and I also really appreciated the fact that the story tied up nicely in the end, while still leaving plenty of room for the subsequent sequels (which I hear are even better!).
Bravo, J.A. Andrews!
While I am not the target audience for this book, as I tend to skew toward fast-paced contemporary reads, the writing quality is masterful, the plot is superb, and I also really appreciated the fact that the story tied up nicely in the end, while still leaving plenty of room for the subsequent sequels (which I hear are even better!).
Bravo, J.A. Andrews!
January 7, 2018
I really enjoyed this read. The story follow Keeper Alaric. A very conflicted character who bears great burdens and even deeper sorrows. Following his journey, the tale depicts the journey of a group of unexpected heroes who will stop at nothing for treasure and the salvation of their world. While they face their challenges, they must also face themselves and in turn come to grips with who they really are and what their place is in their world. This story is gripping and weaves a beautiful tale of love, friendship, and adventure. I gave it 4 stars because it took me some time to truly get into the tale as it has a slow beginning for me. Nevertheless, it’s a great story that I would highly recommend to all epic fantasy lovers. If you love Tolkien, you’ll love Andrews.
April 10, 2024
It was a bit like a canned dnd adventure. Not all that exciting, and I didn’t really care enough about the characters for their codes to make an emotional impact for me.
April 10, 2021
I was first introduced to J.A. Andrews when I read Dragon's Reach as a judge for SPFBO. I thoroughly enjoyed that book, and always had plans to dive into The Keeper Chronicles at some point. Well, that point has come. And I wasn't disappointed.
A Threat of Shadows follows the story of Alaric, desperate to find a cure for his wife, Evangeline, who has been bitten by a poisonous snake. Alaric is a Keeper, part of a group who are tasked with preserving the land's histories, and who use magic to do so. From the outset, I identified with his quest. His strong love for his wife is endearing, and Alaric has stopped at nothing to do everything he can for her. The story picks up with Alaric having already done things he regrets, and he has stepped away from his role as Keeper to the queen. He stood at her right hand, involved in the running of the kingdom, and the various political intrigues that naturally come with his role.
But now, it's been a year since he was at court. In the course of the first few chapters, Alaric joins a group of treasure seekers. Yet only he knows the treasure they seek; a stone, with memories hidden. And one of those memories is the antidote to the poison coursing through his wife. Among this group is a young man, an elf with strong magical powers, a dwarf, and a curious wizard. Andrews does interpersonal relationships between characters quite well, and this was one of the best parts of this book, too. The elf in particular was fascinating, funny, and an intriguing character. She is the last of her kind, and for unknown reasons has joined this band of treasure seekers. There is a hint of mystery to her, and the reader is drawn into her story.
The worldbuilding is quite good, although I wish it had been a bit more solid. Andrews' strong point is characters, so the worldbuilding seems to take a back seat at times. There are, however, terrifying beasts and even a dragon (yay!) that make the world more fascinating. At one point Alaric finds himself back at court, and the politics are well done.
The magic system was pretty typical, but I didn't mind. The magic users are drained of strength, as is often the case in fantasy settings, and are viewed with a healthy dose of fear and suspicion by the commonfolk. What I did find refreshing was the ability for users to keep their memories in unique Wellstones, therefore prolonging the histories of the world. I quite liked it.
All in all, A Threat of Shadows is well done, well written, and strong on characters. I plan on continuing this series in the future. 4/5 stars, and fans of epic fantasy with well-developed characters are sure to enjoy it.
*This review originally published on Booknest.eu*
A Threat of Shadows follows the story of Alaric, desperate to find a cure for his wife, Evangeline, who has been bitten by a poisonous snake. Alaric is a Keeper, part of a group who are tasked with preserving the land's histories, and who use magic to do so. From the outset, I identified with his quest. His strong love for his wife is endearing, and Alaric has stopped at nothing to do everything he can for her. The story picks up with Alaric having already done things he regrets, and he has stepped away from his role as Keeper to the queen. He stood at her right hand, involved in the running of the kingdom, and the various political intrigues that naturally come with his role.
But now, it's been a year since he was at court. In the course of the first few chapters, Alaric joins a group of treasure seekers. Yet only he knows the treasure they seek; a stone, with memories hidden. And one of those memories is the antidote to the poison coursing through his wife. Among this group is a young man, an elf with strong magical powers, a dwarf, and a curious wizard. Andrews does interpersonal relationships between characters quite well, and this was one of the best parts of this book, too. The elf in particular was fascinating, funny, and an intriguing character. She is the last of her kind, and for unknown reasons has joined this band of treasure seekers. There is a hint of mystery to her, and the reader is drawn into her story.
The worldbuilding is quite good, although I wish it had been a bit more solid. Andrews' strong point is characters, so the worldbuilding seems to take a back seat at times. There are, however, terrifying beasts and even a dragon (yay!) that make the world more fascinating. At one point Alaric finds himself back at court, and the politics are well done.
The magic system was pretty typical, but I didn't mind. The magic users are drained of strength, as is often the case in fantasy settings, and are viewed with a healthy dose of fear and suspicion by the commonfolk. What I did find refreshing was the ability for users to keep their memories in unique Wellstones, therefore prolonging the histories of the world. I quite liked it.
All in all, A Threat of Shadows is well done, well written, and strong on characters. I plan on continuing this series in the future. 4/5 stars, and fans of epic fantasy with well-developed characters are sure to enjoy it.
*This review originally published on Booknest.eu*
August 4, 2022
I had read this before not too long after it had come out, and it was one of the first indie fantasy books I can remember reading.
At the time, I was surprised it was indie such was its quality. In my mind it stood alongside the traditionally published books I'd usually read. Of course now I know that's just the case - there is no difference in quality when you come across talented indie fantasy writers, and JA Andrews is definitely one of them.
Re-reading A Threat Of Shadows is like disappearing under a weighted blanket with headphones playing your favourite band while drinking a delicious warm drink (the blanket would have to be quite big so you don't spill it, obv.) It's cozy, comfortable, and it's like returning to a place you know extremely well with great company.
I don't mean this as a backhanded compliment; it's a high one. There is peril, there is threat, there is heartache and world-changing stakes, but it's also a throwback to the classic epics like the Belgariad. You know everything will mostly work out for our heroes, but it might not end in the way you expect.
I enjoyed Alaric the first time round, and found him a well-rounded and slightly broken character who I admired as he wasn't a mighty wizard, strong warrior or capable rogue. He has many of these traits, and a little magic of course, but his ability being his mind always tickled me. This time, I found him more compelling. He's a man haunted by the mistakes he's made while trying to save the person he loves, but he's also a person searching for connection with others, and a yearning for reminders of who he used to be, and acceptance from others and himself of what he is *now* It's a wonderful character study, and Alaric stands out in a likeable cast.
The ending really hit hard with me this time, too. The dawning realisation Alaric finally comes to terms with is superbly done, and the moment is treated and painted with heartbreaking care. Of course, there's always a twist in the tale, and the way everything is pulled together is magnificent.
But I don't know why anyone should be surprised, JA Andrews really is a master, and this book is a Keeper.
At the time, I was surprised it was indie such was its quality. In my mind it stood alongside the traditionally published books I'd usually read. Of course now I know that's just the case - there is no difference in quality when you come across talented indie fantasy writers, and JA Andrews is definitely one of them.
Re-reading A Threat Of Shadows is like disappearing under a weighted blanket with headphones playing your favourite band while drinking a delicious warm drink (the blanket would have to be quite big so you don't spill it, obv.) It's cozy, comfortable, and it's like returning to a place you know extremely well with great company.
I don't mean this as a backhanded compliment; it's a high one. There is peril, there is threat, there is heartache and world-changing stakes, but it's also a throwback to the classic epics like the Belgariad. You know everything will mostly work out for our heroes, but it might not end in the way you expect.
I enjoyed Alaric the first time round, and found him a well-rounded and slightly broken character who I admired as he wasn't a mighty wizard, strong warrior or capable rogue. He has many of these traits, and a little magic of course, but his ability being his mind always tickled me. This time, I found him more compelling. He's a man haunted by the mistakes he's made while trying to save the person he loves, but he's also a person searching for connection with others, and a yearning for reminders of who he used to be, and acceptance from others and himself of what he is *now* It's a wonderful character study, and Alaric stands out in a likeable cast.
The ending really hit hard with me this time, too. The dawning realisation Alaric finally comes to terms with is superbly done, and the moment is treated and painted with heartbreaking care. Of course, there's always a twist in the tale, and the way everything is pulled together is magnificent.
But I don't know why anyone should be surprised, JA Andrews really is a master, and this book is a Keeper.
September 7, 2016
A delightful fantasy read.
Epic fantasy at its best.
Vibrant characters, great world building and a page-turner of a story.
The Keeper, the elf, the bumbling magic weaver, a blacksmith and a milkmaid. A rather eclectic group to journey with on their adventures, but all the more enjoyable for it. A journey that is not solely physical, it's also a journey of the mind and heart.
The effortless way in which ideas, the characters and their actions are woven seamlessly into a compelling story that make this such a joy to read. A skill usually unnoticed, except in its absence.
Now, I have to wait patiently for the next book in the series to continue the adventure, but I will certainly be pouncing on it as soon as it appears!
*Note: I received an ebook copy to read in return for my honest review. Which you now have. Read it, it's a terrific book!*
Epic fantasy at its best.
Vibrant characters, great world building and a page-turner of a story.
The Keeper, the elf, the bumbling magic weaver, a blacksmith and a milkmaid. A rather eclectic group to journey with on their adventures, but all the more enjoyable for it. A journey that is not solely physical, it's also a journey of the mind and heart.
The effortless way in which ideas, the characters and their actions are woven seamlessly into a compelling story that make this such a joy to read. A skill usually unnoticed, except in its absence.
Now, I have to wait patiently for the next book in the series to continue the adventure, but I will certainly be pouncing on it as soon as it appears!
*Note: I received an ebook copy to read in return for my honest review. Which you now have. Read it, it's a terrific book!*
September 21, 2018
A Threat of Shadows by J.A. Andrews is the first book of The Keeper Chronicles. We follow Alaric on his journey to find a cure for his dying wife.
I just love J.A.'s writing style. She lured me in with the first sentence and kept my attention throughout the book. I fell in love with the characters. They were believable to the point of making sure I had tissues on hand. This is a wonderful love story? Maybe...but definitely a story of determination and love so strong that you have to ask yourself, "How far would I go for a loved one?" Truly an amazing tale. I can't wait for the next book!
I just love J.A.'s writing style. She lured me in with the first sentence and kept my attention throughout the book. I fell in love with the characters. They were believable to the point of making sure I had tissues on hand. This is a wonderful love story? Maybe...but definitely a story of determination and love so strong that you have to ask yourself, "How far would I go for a loved one?" Truly an amazing tale. I can't wait for the next book!
December 12, 2020
J. A. Andrew’s ‘Threat of Shadows’ harks back to the fantasy stories of old. It is kind of like the old Forgotten Realms type books or Terry Brooks.
The story revolves around a ‘Keeper’ (an order of clerics who store memories, histories and stories) called Alaric who has abandoned his role in order to search for a cure for his wife, who was accidently poisoned by a group of villagers in an earlier incident.
He returns to his old life to find knowledge on how to cure her whilst she is kept in stasis to slow the spread of the poison.
On his journey, he meets a dwarf, an elf, a human and a bumbling wizard in his tavern and is drawn into a quest to stop the return of an evil that has lain dormant for seven years.
This was one of those books that I picked up without knowing anything about it and was pleasantly surprised. It’s a light-hearted read, with mostly well-rounded characters, a fast-paced plot, a decent magic system and some decent world building.
Alaric the Keeper is a strong lead character that has done some questionable things to save his wife and is haunted by his past.
Ayda the Elf is a typical elf, although she does hold some secrets of her own and she does grow in throughout the story.
Then there are the other supporting characters, Gustav the Wizard, Douglan the Dwarf and Brandson & Mille.
Whilst the main characters are well rounded, I did wonder about the supporting characters. Douglan is the typical complaining dwarf, and in all honesty, I could not determine what the role of Brandson & Millie was in the story as they are barely utilised in most of the book.
In terms of the plot, it didn’t really hold many surprises and was quite functionable. Although one plot device that I didn’t like was the frequent reference to the main antagonist as an ‘idiot’. I didn’t think this worked. As throughout the narrative, the idiot of an antagonist stays one or two steps ahead of the main characters, so he cannot be that much of an idiot.
However, I don’t hold this against the book, and it didn’t spoil my enjoyment. There are some good ideas in the book, like the well stone. A magical stone that stores memories. And the characters deal the problems that they face in an original way. Not necessarily restoring to the usual hack and slash of some fantasy books
Threat of Shadows is part of a trilogy and I will read the next ones out of interest to see how the book develops.
The story revolves around a ‘Keeper’ (an order of clerics who store memories, histories and stories) called Alaric who has abandoned his role in order to search for a cure for his wife, who was accidently poisoned by a group of villagers in an earlier incident.
He returns to his old life to find knowledge on how to cure her whilst she is kept in stasis to slow the spread of the poison.
On his journey, he meets a dwarf, an elf, a human and a bumbling wizard in his tavern and is drawn into a quest to stop the return of an evil that has lain dormant for seven years.
This was one of those books that I picked up without knowing anything about it and was pleasantly surprised. It’s a light-hearted read, with mostly well-rounded characters, a fast-paced plot, a decent magic system and some decent world building.
Alaric the Keeper is a strong lead character that has done some questionable things to save his wife and is haunted by his past.
Ayda the Elf is a typical elf, although she does hold some secrets of her own and she does grow in throughout the story.
Then there are the other supporting characters, Gustav the Wizard, Douglan the Dwarf and Brandson & Mille.
Whilst the main characters are well rounded, I did wonder about the supporting characters. Douglan is the typical complaining dwarf, and in all honesty, I could not determine what the role of Brandson & Millie was in the story as they are barely utilised in most of the book.
In terms of the plot, it didn’t really hold many surprises and was quite functionable. Although one plot device that I didn’t like was the frequent reference to the main antagonist as an ‘idiot’. I didn’t think this worked. As throughout the narrative, the idiot of an antagonist stays one or two steps ahead of the main characters, so he cannot be that much of an idiot.
However, I don’t hold this against the book, and it didn’t spoil my enjoyment. There are some good ideas in the book, like the well stone. A magical stone that stores memories. And the characters deal the problems that they face in an original way. Not necessarily restoring to the usual hack and slash of some fantasy books
Threat of Shadows is part of a trilogy and I will read the next ones out of interest to see how the book develops.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 298 reviews