Before I review the book, I should state for the record that I am a 55 year-old Dolphins fan from the northeast who had the great fortune of attending 4-6 Dolphins road games and a home game every year from 1987 to 1995 (and every playoff game in that span), including attending practices and even shooting minicamp practices for the team in 1990 as I had befriended their video director. That said, I met Shula many times and he was a great influence on my eventual career in sports. I am also a collector, so I only bought the book to add to my collection of dozens of books about the Dolphins. So I know things...
With that in mind, this was the worst sports book I've ever read with many factual errors. For just one example, in recapping the 1990 playoff loss in Buffalo - a game I watched from the sideline with the team photographer - Ribowsky refers to the weather as "blustery," a word meaning windy, when in fact the game was played in a lake-effect blizzard. Further, in his recap of that game, Ribowsky claims that Dan Marino threw touchdown passes to "spare halfbacks Roy Foster and Tony Martin," but neither was a halfback. Ever. Foster was a starting offensive lineman (left guard) who famously caught that TD on a tackle-eligible play and proceeded to dance in the snow after that catch while Martin was the team's third-string wide receiver. Errors like that are all over this book.
He also took Fins owner Joe Robbie to task - sometimes justifiably so, other times stupidly. For example, he mocks Robbie's construction of a new stadium in the 80s, calling it a "vanity stadium." Fact is, Robbie set the standard for modern stadiums both in private funding through PSLs and in having many suites with restaurant areas. Most stadiums and arenas built today follow the model Robbie introduced decades ago. Robbie should be in the Hall of Fame for charting the league's - and pro sports' - future.
What's more, the book's introduction begins with no less than three references to Donald Trump - all extremely, and often unfairly, negative. I didn't choose to read this book to read about the author's personal politics. Then in the first paragraph of Chapter 1, another negative and nasty Trump reference. The book was released in 2018 and clearly the author has a really bad case of Trump Derangement Syndrome.
Ribowsky ties in politics throughout, negatively referencing Republican presidents without ever mentioning Democrat presidents LBJ and Jimmy Carter and their failed terms. If Riboswky refuses to be fair to both parties, don't mention either. What really made me shake my head was his references to Nixon and Vietnam when failing to mention LBJ with regard to Nam since LBJ put us there and had us fighting with one hand tied behind our backs - I've read enough books to know. But again, in this sports book, I'd rather not have read any of the author's political opinions.
Equally annoying is Ribowsky's penchant for using big words where they're not necessary - "jejune" appeared not once, but twice. As a post-grad degree recipient who's been teaching at university for 12 years now, I find this kind of writing as obnoxious as it is unnecessary. I think he simply selected random words while writing in Microsoft Word, right clicked, and looked in the thesaurus for words he thought would impress readers.
So skip this book. It's trash. And I learned nothing new by reading this book - everything here has been written in other books. Larry Csonka has a new book release upcoming that will surely be a helluva lot better than this crappy tome.