A grumpy old carpenter has just begun carving a Jesse tree in a peacefully empty church—when he is interrupted by an inquisitive young boy who wants to know the stories behind the symbols. Day after day, the young boy returns to hear the newest installment. The stories start at the very beginning with creation, move through moments like the miraculous birth and near-sacrifice of Isaac, and end with the escape of Mary, Joseph and Jesus to Egypt.
Things I loved:
1) The beautiful writing. Here are just a few examples:
"On the far side of the sea, the children of Israel lay panting on the shore. Behind them the smooth and silent sea sighed; ahead of them stretched the empty desert, humming with heat."
"Like a crumpled rainbow the coat was laid at old Jacob's feet."
"An earthquake took hold of the roots of the mountain and shook it until the boulders bounced by and stones skittered downhill in landslides...But the earthquake was not God speaking.
"Mary laid her hands on her cousin's stomach. (Her own baby's movements were still too tiny to be felt.) It was like a magnet turning north. It was like a weathercock turning to the wind. It was like the oceans being tugged to and fro by the moon. The child in Elizabeth's womb, sensing the closeness of Mary's baby, turned in his watery world and reached out a hand. This other child was why he would struggle into the light of day. Here was his reason to live."
2) The way the stories built on each other and the connections were made so clear. Sometimes I lose sight of the big picture of God's amazing plan. This book helped me see that again.
Things I didn't love:
1) The illustrations. Not my favorite style...the faces in particular were a bit weird for me.
2) Added details. All retellings of Bible stories struggle with this, of course. It isn't wrong to use our imaginations to help the stories seem more real. But for children in particular, it's so important to stay clear on what exactly the Bible said (what we know is truth) and what we are filling in on our own.
3) Dubious theological statements. For example:
"Who knows why God forgave Jacob—the trickster, the cheat—except that God forgives most things." [not sure what that is supposed to mean, exactly...]
"Joseph, who had given orders for the silver cup to be planted among their belongings, looked on with grim satisfaction. His brother were as afraid now as Joseph had been twenty years before when, wrists tied, he had stumbled into slaver behind the merchant camel train." [is it just me, or does it sound like Joseph wanted a moment of revenge??]
"Mary was a good girl. Everyone said so. In fact, people probably never spoke about her at all,because gossips are only interested in people's faults and mistakes, and Mary did nothing wrong."
"Joseph lay in his bed staring at the ceiling. He would marry Mary: a woman more perfect than even he had realized." [previous statement and this one sound so much like the Catholic teaching that Mary was sinless...don't know if that is what the author was referring to or not]
My conclusion: In my opinion, the pros outweigh the cons. This book is going on my to-buy list. I can foresee it sparking great conversations with my children someday, as a beautiful reminder of God's redemptive plan through Christ.
In the words of the old man and the boy...
"'It's like you said once,' Mr. Butterfield recalled. 'Jesus was like the sheep who died in place of Isaac. He was like that offering on Elijah's altar. He was God's ultimate rescue plan!'
'He was like David slaying the big bad giant!'
'He was the way back to the Paradise Garden!'
'He's the Once-upon-a-time and The End!'"