I am on a mission to acquaint myself with all of Kadir Nelson's artworks. Mandela, the picture biography, has the striking, moving artwork that Kadir Nelson is known for. I found the text, which Nelson also wrote, not nearly as moving. Resistance leaders are often 'saintified' after their death, and this book seemed to me to do the same thing. Young readers are not presented with the paradoxes of Nelson's Mandela's life. Instead this seems more of an illustrated timeline of his life on Earth.
There are two shocking teachable discussion points on the very first page. Nelson Mandela was the only child in his tribe chosen for school. What? Why? Explain more, please. Discussing that shocking inequity of resources would be a good way for children to feel the injustice of apartheid. Can young people imagine what it would be like to see their friend go off to school while they and everyone else stays home?
Then, on Nelson Mandela's first day of school, his white teacher refused to use his given Xhosa tribal name, Rolihlahla. What? Can you imagine being Mandela's mother and a teacher refused to use the name you lovingly bestowed on your child? It's outrageous that Mandela is known to the world by an apartheid-given name, not his own name. I never knew that. Since the text doesn't provide answers, those discussion points could be great inquiry questions.
Two issues the picture book glosses over are Nelson Mandela becoming divorced from Winnie post-prison, and his armed struggle. If anyone had the right to armed struggle, didn't Mandela? The American Revolution for liberty is depicted as an armed struggle in picture books, why doesn't Mandela get the same truth? Why can't Kadir Nelson can't show that truth? Also, the book makes it seems as if Nelson and Winnie lived happily ever after. They didn't. Isn't that yet another cost to Nelson Mandela and his family that apartheid contributed to? A broken family? Shouldn't it be discussed?
One visual I thought the book missed was a full-length artwork of the moment Mandela got out of prison. I remember that moment. I gasped. I didn't know much about his struggle then, but the regalness of Mandela's bearing told any human being watching Mandela's story as a leader would only get bigger.
I wish the text carried more emotion with it. For Mandela to forgive his jailers, his white countrymen, and lead all people is an example of humanitarianism that the world bowed to at his death. How many other people could do what he did? Live through 27.5 years of imprisonment? Then turn around and lead without bitterness? What an example! I am not sure children will feel in their bones the incredible nature of this from the text. That's where I find the book could be improved. Every child in the world would benefit from feeling the extraordinary character in Nelson Mandela in their bones.