A thoroughly enjoyable slice of american Civil War melodrama. Ruth Appleby has likable characters, an engaging plot and descriptive setting, from the wild Yorkshire moors to the heart of a burgeoning New York. My only quibble was that the author occasionally stepped outside the fiction to tell the reader little historical factoids, like, 'white dresses weren't the fashion until several decades later,' in the middle of one character's wedding or, 'of course, this battle would be lost by the rebels in 1964.' It's an odd move in such an immersive story. Plus, protagonist Ruth should really have ended up marrying the lovely Professor Priestly instead of rich banker Joss Barnet because a) university professors are better than bankers and b) Joss spent half the novel being a terrible cock to Ruth and using her just for sex. Plus Priestly only ever got to confess his love for Ruth to his mother whilst on his death bed and it was TOO SAD and I can't actually take how melodramatic this novel is. It's wonderful.