The story: Robert Burnside's closet is like an earth-bound black hole: matter goes into it, and comes out changed into something completely different…plus, it's alive! So Rob does what any normal kid would do--he burgles, burps, and bungles his way through one disaster after another until the only thing left to do is completely humiliate himself by reciting poetry onstage. Is Wonkenstein the monster of doom, or could there be an upside?
June Cleaver's ratings: Language PG; Nudity G; Sexual Content G; Violence G; substance abuse G; GLBT content G; adult themes G; overall rating G.
Liz's comments: Give this one to any kid who likes Diary of a Wimpy Kid or the Origami Yoda series. Skye has a funny narrative style and even draws his own cartoon pictures! (Not sure the book will get him the absolution he seeks from former teachers, but if not, he can cry all the way to the bank.) Oh yeah--is it dumb? Totally. But let's face it…that's what this particular audience is looking for, and Skye delivers.
Annotation with spoilers: We meet Robert Columbo Burnside in Chapter 1 and are introduced to his closet: a convenient way of keeping his room clean that doesn't involve actual cleaning. His dad bought a strangely heavy door at a garage sale--one with a strange gold handle with a stamped-on face that happens to change expressions occasionally, and hung it in Rob's room. Clearly this is no normal closet.
His dad sells lame toys, and his mom spends most of her time sleeping on the couch. Rob has an annoying older sister (some funny cartoons about her) and a bothersome little brother named Tuffin. Rob has just completed one of his clean-ups by stuffing everything into the closet when he notices the door is stuck. For days, he can't get it open--but when he eventually hears a knock on the other side, the door mysteriously swings free to reveal Wonkenstein: a three-foot-high combination of Willy Wonka and Frankenstein (both of which books had been covered with goo from a science experiment gone bad, and allowed to stew until ithe result came to life…kind of like the Big Bang in that respect).
After dealing with the problem of believing that Wonkenstein can even exist, Rob has to figure out what to do with him. In a moment of carelessness, he lets his friend Jack watch the little guy. The next thing he knows, Jack has dressed Wonkenstein in his sister's dance recital costume and jewelry, and the creature has run away to take refuge in their mean neighbor's house. The rescue involves breaking and entering, and eventually the mean neighbor's son, Ogre, gets busted for stealing Jack's sister's property, which got left behind during the rescue (Ogre gets caught showing it off at school). To make things worse, Rob's parents catch him coming in from really late at night after the rescue, and they ground him forever. Next, Wonkenstein lets off a terrible belch when JaNae, the cute girl down the street, is around, and she thinks it's Rob being totally socially unacceptable.
Rob and Wonkenstein realize the only way they can get everyone in the same place to listen to Rob's explanations is to participate in the school-wide poetry reading event. Even though he knows it's social suicide, he and Wonk write a poem about all the "Misunderstandings" in his life and Rob recites it--and wins first place! JaNae decides he's less lame than she thought and decides to like him again; he and Jack confess to Mr. Pang about the break-in and make things right with Ogre and the cops, and before you know, Wonkenstein realizes his work here is done…so it's back into closet and on to his next adventure. Rob is sad for a few days, until there's another knock on the closet door, and out comes…the Potterwookiee. On to book 2!