I've read a few Hercule Poirot stories, and while he's great, mysteries aren't too much my thing. I don't usually read a lot in a row because the formulaic plots of "meet characters, murder happens, interview characters one at a time, find flaws, twist, solve the crime" isn't something I stay too interested in one after the other.
This book contains And Then There Were None, Crooked House and Endless Night, and I was drawn in by each of them much quicker than I expected, and they all feel so different from each other!
My experience of And Then There Were None was preceded by the movie, which I did like, but this original story was very good. Watching the characters get weeded off one by one is eerie and satisfying in a suspenseful sense. The conclusion was unexpected but totally worked, although it is very sad. The fact that the murderer was able to predict all the characteristics of the people around him, all the way up to the final girl killing herself (thus completely confusing the police), was fascinating but heavy. Definitely worthy of its acclaim for how it was written and it sat with me.
Crooked House was a bit more typical of a setup, with the early murder followed by the investigation and multiple questionings and "it could be this person, but it COULD be this person", etc. But I think Agatha must do a good job of making the characters feel compelling, because even if they felt at all clichéd, I still found myself really interested halfway through. I did NOT call the murderer in this but I was expecting it to be Sophia and I was glad it wasn't after all. This felt simple but well done and I was glad to be surprised.
Endless Night had a slow opening; it felt like there was too much ominous foreshadowing and hinting before they actually got to things HAPPENING. It's all kind of told as a memory and it takes so long for anything bad to occur.. but once again, I got to a point where I just didn't want to put it down. My main guess that Greta was involved was correct, but when I got to those ending chapters where the full story was revealed... I was flabbergasted! I kept thinking they could not have pulled that over on me when I have been reading the narrator's story the entire time! And I am so fascinated by that conclusion that now I have to go back and reread the whole thing with this knowledge in mind. It's had me thinking about perspectives and twisting things to our own advantage and it's a fascinating look at how you can paint a story so believably one way by omitting info when the full truth s actually completely the opposite. I think this will sit with me quite a while.
I conclude that Agatha Christie has a way of telling stories that sneak up on you, her characters are decently compelling, and her twists are genuinely surprising. Finishing this book has put me in a mystery bingeing mood, and that never happens, so thanks Agatha as I go read some modern mysteries and relax with some classic Hitchcock!