Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Young Drew Morgan has an enviable position. Handpicked by Bishop Laud, next to the king the most powerful man in England, it is his assignment to infiltrate Puritan villages, turn over "traitors" to the church and crown, and discover the secret identity of the notorious pamphleteer Justin.

But when Drew falls in love with a Puritan curate's daughter, his personal fortunes begin to falter as his spiritual yearnings take root. After unwittingly betraying what he knows to be right, the stage is set for his conversion.

At last Drew sails to the New World colony of Massachusetts and sets out to win the forgiveness of those whom he has wronged--especially the woman he loves. Only as Bishop Laud reaches his long arm across the ocean in one final threat can Drew prove his true mettle and affections.

Trace this unforgettable adventure of one of America's first families of faith, the beginnings of a vibrant spiritual heritage that will span generations.

510 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1994

50 people are currently reading
754 people want to read

About the author

Jack Cavanaugh

36 books154 followers
Jack Cavanaugh is an award-winning, full-time freelance author with twenty-five published novels to his credit. His nine-volume American Family Portrait series spans the history of a nation from 1630 to the present and is still in print nearly fifteen years following its release.

A student of the novel for more than a quarter of a century, Jack takes his craft seriously, continuing to study and teach at Christian writers conferences. He is the former pastor of three churches in San Diego County and draws upon his theological background for the spiritual elements of his plots and characters.

His novels have been translated into a dozen foreign languages, largely because of the universal scope of his topics. Jack has not only written about American history, but about South Africa, banned English Bibles, German Christians in the days of Hitler and Communism, revivals in America, and angelic warfare.

Jack’s current writing schedule includes motion picture screenplays and e-book serial fiction with Internet distribution. His novel Death Watch has been optioned to be made into a motion picture by Out Cold Entertainment, Inc.

Jack has three grown children and lives with his wife in Southern California.

AWARDS

• Silver Medallion Award (1995), Christian Booksellers Association
• Christy Award (2002, 2003), Excellence in Christian Fiction
• Silver Angel Award (2002), Excellence in Media
• Gold Medal, Best Historical (2001), ForeWord Magazine
• Best Historical Novel (1994), San Diego Literary Society
• Best Novel (1995, 1996, 2005), San Diego Christian Writers Guild

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
370 (42%)
4 stars
307 (35%)
3 stars
141 (16%)
2 stars
28 (3%)
1 star
15 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews
Profile Image for Jamie.
102 reviews
February 24, 2011
This was a book that taught me more about church history, some of the corruption in the 1600s, how the King James version of the Bible came to be commissioned and the history and life of that time period in general. The fictional part of it combines covert spying missions, romance, great sacrifice, martyrdom, relocation to a New World, and overcoming evil.
Profile Image for Melissa.
869 reviews91 followers
December 22, 2008
They were ordinary people, but their story is anything but ordinary. They disagreed with the Church of England fled to the new land called America. They were called Puritans.

Drew Morgan seizes the opportunity to work for the high-up Bishop, longing for adventure and romance. That's exactly what he gets....

"I loved this book--it's one of my favorites in the series, and one of my favorite novels! It's just so emotional and deep and exciting...It also has romance (maybe too much), adventure, and Christian values. I was brought to tears, and I laughed...all of The American Family Portrait series is good, but this is one of my favorites, as I've said. The characters in all of his books are so real!

Yes, there were some rather violent moments, almost gruesome, but it just brought me more concern and appreciation for the characters and all they went through.

I read it first when I was 14 or 15, and I'm looking forward to reading it again in future years!" (Earlier review)
Profile Image for Eva-Joy.
511 reviews45 followers
August 19, 2019
Very good book overall, but it infuriates me that nobody tried to remove Jenny from that abusive situation once she was married to Elliot. Not until she sent that Bible verse but she shouldn't have HAD to - Drew and Nell and Cooper should have banded together and gotten her far away from Elliot at the first sign of mental and physical abuse.

UGH.
Profile Image for Jill Crosby.
871 reviews64 followers
November 28, 2025
I wanted a book about Thanksgiving, so I pulled this one out of my stash and dove. What could be more Thanksgiving-y than a book about the Puritans, right?
Unfortunately, the author spent the first 400+ pages getting the main characters them on the boat to get them over to the New World; the bulk of the book discusses how the MC has a change of heart after working for a Church of England VIP seeking out puritan writers and preachers from the general population in order to punish and murder them.
Very easy narration—-I’m guessing 6th/7th grade level, and lots of definitions of things like women’s stomachers, wool processing, and pamphlet-making. Impressed at the author’s confidence in killing off beloved characters, and at his commitment to describe a love scene honestly without the introduction of smut.
There are EIGHT more books in this series, so I guess I need to buckle up
Profile Image for Paulin.
30 reviews
July 2, 2010
My 6th book installment for June 2010

This book reminded me so much about sacrifices, and not just any kind of sacrifice, but the kind that matters for eternity. Dying for your faith, dying for your conviction, dying for the One true God who can circumvent what could have happened and yet chose to allow suffering not because He is not in control but precisely because He is. He would allow others to suffer for the sake of the people around them so that they may be enlightened in knowing the God of salvation, the God who is faithful and true, the God who is sovereign.

We are standing here today, because we stood on the shoulders of the great people who suffered before us, who forged the road ahead of us, whose sacrifice preceded us so that we might have a better future, a brighter tomorrow, and a bigger and grander dream for the next generations where we would lay the foundation today.

Better is a life lived in hopes, dreams, plans, sacrifice laid down before Jesus, than live a life of accolades, affluence, and wealth in the influence of the wicked.

My successes are the gifts of others to me. My failures are my gift to others. But even my failures are not a total waste for I find in them the gift of friendship and humility. – Erwin Raphael McManus, Lead Pastor of Mosaic Church in LA, CA

Quoting the quotable quotes here:

"If our question is what are we going to do, then we are asking the wrong question because this is a question of hopelessness by helpless people. It’s the question of a people looking to themselves for answers, and the people who look only to themselves for answers to life’s problems are drawing from a shallow well.

What question should we be asking instead is “What would God have us to?” Are we do filled with pride to think that something strange and unusual is happening to us? That we are the only people who have faced a crisis like this? That God is so shortsighted He has failed to supply us with sufficient guidance with His Word?

God knows our needs. He will provide a way. In the meantime, we must live by faith in God’s Word. Faith does not wear a long face. Faith does not fret. Faith will not waste a beautiful day like today with concern for tomorrow. “This is the day which the Lord hath made: Let us rejoice and be glad in it!”

I dream of a future. I dream of a place where people can speak without fear of being killed for expressing themselves. I dream of a country where honesty is the national heritage, where people spend more time amassing friends than they do amassing wealth. I dream of a community where God is King and where all the townspeople are committed to loving and serving God and one another. There is no need for a watchman, no jail, no court. They’re not needed because everyone is just as much concerned about others as they are about themselves. And everyone lives in freedom… freedom from hate, freedom from fear and freedom to love and be loved.

Dying for a dream is not a vain thing. The sacrifice we make – whether that sacrifice comes through living or dying – will be the foundation of a new community. A community that will be a blessing to our children and our children’s children for ages to come.

In comparison to the depth of life lived by the humble people who has only enough, the glitter, the lights, the jewels, the accolades and the wealth of the affluent were but empty vessels.

“When the heart is right, it matters not which way the head lieth” – Christopher Matthews from the Puritans

There is poor comfort in sitting down in any place that you cannot say, “This place is appointed me of God.” Can you say that God spied out this place for you, and there has settled you above all hindrances? Did you find that God made room for you either by lawful descent, or purchase, or gift, or other warrantable right? Why then, this Is the place God has appointed for you,. Here He has made room for you."
Profile Image for Gracee .
181 reviews
May 17, 2009
I have to admit I'm a sucker for a series. Especially a GOOD series. Especially a good Christian series. Don't be misled, this isn't to say there isn't any sex. Think of the 1950's movies where there was enough of an innuendo that you get the idea...It just proves you don't need throbbing and heaving to make a good story.

This particular installment had a simple twist of murder and scandal. But it was still entertaining. The "hero" -- who starts out as a real creep, has an epiphany that is slow and doesn't come without a dead body or two..

I am eager to read the second in the series!
Profile Image for Elaine.
2,258 reviews2 followers
November 20, 2009
Bishop Laud’s crusade is to "prosecute to death" those he considers traitors to England. He hires Drew to act as his minion in this. Drew meets untold people in his "profession,"many of whom befriend him and many of whom he betrays. He is shaken by this since he's really come to like some of them. They feed him, and trust him, and love him and he in turn, turns them in. They then become branded - physically - on the face - both cheeks.

Betrayal. Heroism. Trust. Sick Entertainment. Persecution. Prosecution. Murder. Control. Execution. Done in the name of religion.
Profile Image for Katie.
705 reviews7 followers
March 19, 2009
Very interesting book. Great plot line and very detailed historical fiction. Cavanaugh obviously did a LOT of research before writing this book, and it shows. Surprisingly the majority of this book takes place in England, and gives a lot of insight into what exactly caused the Puritans to leave and become Separatists (and the reasons we have laws agains "cruel and unusual punishment"). Would definitely recommend if you like historical fiction
1 review
May 15, 2009
This was a great way to get a good feel for the conditions that lead the Puritans to come to America. The story was very interesting, and the character development was excellent, pulling me into their lives and identifying with them. Cavanaugh pretends to add suspense, but provides so many clues to foreshadow the mysteries that it is not difficult to figure them out well in advance. Nevertheless, it is still a page-turner!
Profile Image for Jeff Danhauer.
145 reviews
March 10, 2018
Excellent read. Very enjoyable. A garage sale find - I happened upon the first book in the series. Enjoyed this one so much I hopped on eBay and found the 2nd book - the Colonists. Looking forward to its arrival.
16 reviews1 follower
February 26, 2014
I love how he intertwined the fiction with the real history. He's a great story teller. He kept me turning the pages.
Profile Image for April Warner.
48 reviews7 followers
May 16, 2015
I thought, even though I enjoy stuff like this, that even I would end up bored with it but decided to give it a try. I was pleasantly surprised and have already started the next book in the series. Jack Cavanaugh, good work.

You start off liking Drew and even identifying with him. Then you become very disappointed in him. You end up being his fan again in the end and even kind of admiring him. Of course some things work out well for him but not without his fair share of bad so it's not that fairy tale storyline. Good thing too because those times were anything but even though so many have succeeded in doing just that.

If you like historical fiction, I recommend this. I believe it would also satisfy romance fans and religious buffs. Just remember. It is historical FICTION. If your the type that wants complete accuracy at every turn, your in the wrong genre.

Happy Reading!
Profile Image for Lynne Tagawa.
Author 10 books221 followers
June 16, 2018
This is great historical fiction. It opens a series of books on American history--imagine a James Michener drawn out into a series and written by a Christian!

Most of the action in this story takes place in England, where we are viscerally acquainted with the motives for those who left with John Winthrop in 1630 for Massachusetts. Some of the characters are real, some fictional, and I think it's done well. The author even makes the Archbishop--the bad guy--seem human.

There are some violent scenes and so forth that make this story definitely PG or above.
Profile Image for Ed.
412 reviews24 followers
July 16, 2021
A very exciting history of Christianity starting with the persecution of Christians in England and the Puritans being forced out of England to escape to freedom in the new colonies in America. It covers the history of Drew Morgan and his actions eventually causing him to accept Christ as his Savior. This book was not dull, but enjoyable to read about the persecutions of English people in England and America.
6 reviews1 follower
December 29, 2010
One of my all-time favorites series! A wonderful, historical, Christian saga.
Profile Image for SBF.
75 reviews
April 25, 2020
I wanted to like this book. It's a pretty good story, but the writing is weak. The author overuses words like "yelled" and "shouted". Does everything need to be said at full volume? I did like that the story didn't shy away from things that people do in reality: without any graphic description, it is obvious that men visit prostitutes, there are murders committed, one character correctly points out that at that time, it was legal to hit one's spouse, etc. Christian fiction is sometimes a little too sanitized, and protagonists need to make mistakes. However, the prose is perfectly safe to read whether you are a teenager or a grandmother. Outside of the protagonist (Drew), the bishop, and the two love interests and their father, most characters were one-dimensional. The villains are cartoonishly evil. Historical accuracy was fine from what I know about the time period, though I felt like I was reading through a modern veneer of what happened rather than being there with people of the time. The way characters spoke was a little too twentieth-century at times, though the author is nowhere near the historical inaccuracy of some Christian fiction writers I've read (or secular fiction; this is a problem across many genres). I thought it took too long for the story to get to the New World: I would have liked to have spent more time in the colony. I suppose that is for the next books in the series. I think ultimately this book suffers from my having read other series documenting a family's journey through American history (eg. the Sackett series by Louis L'Amour). It's hard to beat my love for those stories. For readers that aren't fussy about writing style, enjoy books in a series, and are interested in early American history, this series would be a good choice.
Profile Image for Kristi.
227 reviews4 followers
November 11, 2019
This has got to be the worst Jack Cavanaugh book I've read yet!
The plot was the basic plot to everyone of his other books but that's not what gives it the one star. This book is hardly 'Christian' at all let alone historically accurate! The Puritans did not behave as he portrays them (especially single women entertaining a single man). The main character is so involved in his lust over two women at the same time (but in his mind that's justifiably diff then his previous lust for prostitutes because we all know desiring one that does it for money is bad and desiring one that doesn't do it for money is OK) The authors justification of loving one woman, yet physically loving another woman and everyone being OK with it makes me think this guy's got some serious polygamy fantasies! Why would anyone think that's 'love'??
I understand portraying the wickedness of the time but this was overboard. The fact that the main character the whole time is in this female obsession, the Puritans are portrayed as everyday people (not strict as they were known for), the plot was drawn out and seriously overused, the many innuendos, sexual references, this book isn't even staying in my house. It even portrays the Puritans as accepting Roger Williams but historically the Puritans banned him! I wish there was more time put into really understanding the Puritans of the time and less time fulfilling sexual fantasies.
I definitely wouldn't let my teenager read it.
I've read several Jack Cavanaugh books before and found them to be entertaining but this, like I said, was the very worst and I highly DON'T recommend it!
Profile Image for Shauna.
51 reviews4 followers
August 4, 2018
History alive on the page

I have been researching my family tree for years and have traced my father's side to the first settlers, a devout family that was persecuted by English law, one John Rogers a martyr for his faithful work in helping William Tyndale write and print the bible in English. He was burned at the stake in 1555 , the very first Maryyr of Bloody Mary Tudor. It was his great grandsons, and great grandsons, the Stone brothers who left England. This band of brothers, carried their spiritual heri to light. My grandfather carried on their faith, from those generations, he was a minister in a long line of ministers dating to the start of our beloved country.

This was well researched book, and the history and fiction were woven together beautifully.
1 review
January 22, 2022
Through the thrilling adventures of a lad, by the name of Drew Morgan, Jack Cavanaugh expresses the virtues of love, friendship, forgiveness, hate, and spirituality. This book follows, Drew Morgan around 17th century England and later the New World as Drew has two major conversions of himself and what he believes and stands for. Cavanaugh creates an environment for all those who enjoy either history, fiction, or religious works and creates a story that will hold your attention for the entire time. This is also, the first book in nine following books that follow this genre mixing path Cavanaugh uses, in the series, An American Family Portrait. This is a must read!
Profile Image for Paige Wilson.
12 reviews
November 2, 2017
Oh. My. Word. If u dnt feel like having your heart tugged, then dnt read this book. This book starts off slow to get you attach to the characters then it TAKES OFF. You read how Drew helps expose the Christian Puritans to Bishop Laud so they can be persecuted and sometimes even beheaded ! Drew finally finds God and his whole life becomes a plot twist! Amazing, inspiring story!!!
Matthew 10:28 ~And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.
This is the first book to the series “American Portraits” by Jack Cavanaugh.
2 reviews
January 28, 2023
Excellent Book. Very Inspirational.

I love historical fiction. I also love Bible based stories. Books that promote wholesome family values. I love that the plots are so intriguing, and there's never an opportunity for boredom. I read these books several years ago, and now I'm having Kindle read to me while I do other things. I highly recommend Jack Cavanaugh and specifically The American Family Portrait Series.
Profile Image for Andrea.
169 reviews1 follower
September 11, 2018
The mix of fact and fiction was very good. I Goggled Bishop Laud early on and it made the story even more real. Cavanaugh does a supreme job of putting together a story that is entertaining and also teaching history.
Profile Image for Amanda Geaney.
536 reviews339 followers
May 21, 2019
The bits of history were the only thing that propelled me to finish. Between the more tension-filled scenes, the story seemed flat.
60 reviews2 followers
August 27, 2020
It has been a number of years since I read, but i do recall liking it. If it's the book I think it is there is a very clever (to me) part of it.
Profile Image for Allen Goforth.
2 reviews
Read
August 6, 2021
Very good book. I read it while I was living in the Philippines, found it at a used book store in Manila.
148 reviews
May 31, 2022
Love this series. I purchased it due to its re readability.
Profile Image for Pamela King.
2 reviews
December 30, 2022
My favorite books .

I loved this book. I read it years ago and decided to read the whole series again. My husband is also reading this series now.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 72 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.