I liked this book, even if it just made my wanderlust and claustrophobia from being stuck at home that much worse. There are tons of interesting stories and tidbits I picked up, like the pioneering parkitecture of Mary Colter at the Grand Canyon or the mysterious"Old Man" of Crater Lake. And of course, like any American outdoorsy book, it is peppered with plenty of John Muir and Teddy Roosevelt quotes. Some of the stories are quite funny too, especially the bears at Katmai.
But I didn't love the book. Some parks got interesting stories (whether historical, ecological, or Knighton's personal), but many parks received short shrift. Acadia is mentioned for its claim as the "first sunrise of the year", but otherwise nothing. Olympic is only discussed in relation to a story about needing a cell phone, which turns into a longer piece on cell service and connectedness throughout the parks. Interesting, but I still wanted to hear about Olympic itself. With 56 parks to go through in one year and one book, it's understandable that there just isn't enough time/ room to go into every park in detail. But disappointing nonetheless.
Overall, the humor and writing style had more misses than hits for me, filled with pat jokes and bad lines (like "America's parks really do shine from sea to sea"). After every section, I can almost hear him saying "Now back to you, Tom!", like the TV reporter he is. Knighton is definitely not the next Bill Bryson. His writing at times feels heavily influencing by blogging and on-air TV personalities, in that carefully calculated confessional style that makes you think they're being open and honest about their lives, but feels like another mask. It's the "trying to appeal and seem relatable to the largest audience possible" that makes him feel a little fake and, honestly, boring. Travel books like this one that are centered around the person traveling, rather than the destination, needs a narrator who isn't afraid to be unlikable, foolish, and neurotic at times. It makes for better stories. Otherwise, it feels like watching your friend's vacation photos and hearing their anecdotes, fun for a bit, but not riveting.