What do you think?
Rate this book
The Forgotten Secret
Can she unlock the mysteries of the past?
A country at war
It’s the summer of 1919 and Ellen O’Brien has her whole life ahead of her. Young, in love and leaving home for her first job, the future seems full of shining possibility. But war is brewing and before long, Ellen and everyone around her are swept up by it. As Ireland is torn apart by the turmoil, Ellen finds herself facing the ultimate test of love and loyalty.
A long-buried secret
A hundred years later and Clare Farrell has inherited a dilapidated old farmhouse in County Meath. Seizing the chance to escape her unhappy marriage she strikes out on her own for the first time, hoping the old building might also provide clues to her family’s shadowy history. As she sets out to put the place – and herself – back to rights, she stumbles across a long-forgotten hiding place, with a clue to a secret that has lain buried for decades.
For fans of Kate Morton and Gill Paul comes an unforgettable novel about two women fighting for independence.
Readers love Kathleen McGurl
‘Another fabulous dual timeline story’
‘Haunting’
‘Had me gripped from the start’
‘I literally could not turn the pages fast enough’
‘Captivating’
333 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 1, 2019
1664 people are currently reading
1543 people want to read
About the author
Kathleen McGurl
26 books482 followersKathleen McGurl lives in Bournemouth with her husband and cat. She has two grown-up sons who have now left home. She always wanted to write, and for many years was waiting until she had the time. Eventually she came to the bitter realisation that no one would pay her for a year off work to write a book, so she sat down and started to write one anyway. Since then she has sold dozens of short stories to women's magazines and written three books for writers. These days she is concentrating on longer fiction and has published several dual timeline novels with CarinaUK and HQ. She works full time in the IT industry and when she's not writing, she's often out running, slowly.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 216 reviews
March 11, 2019
An Absorbine tale that exquisitely weaves together present and past!
Kathleen McGurl has skillfully threaded together an intriguing story that truly captivated me. This book introduced me to a lot of Irish history that I had not previously known. I love when a book educates me about something and how appropriate for me to learn more about Ireland in the month of March. Although I’ve been told st. Patrick’s Day is more of a holiday in the US then in Ireland? Or maybe that Cinco de Mayo? Yes I know they don’t celebrate that in Ireland... all my aimless rambling is to say I really love the historical part of this book, it seemed very well researched and was extremely educational to me.
This book jumps between 1919 and present day. Claire has recently extricated herself from a toxic marriage, it’s the perfect time to inherit an old family farm house. While doing some refurbishing Claire happens across a clue a key to her past. Ellen in 1919 is a upstairs maid in a small Irish town during the resistance. Two strong courageous independent women facing very unique struggles. The way these two stories were woven together was very clever, it made for a highly addictive and enjoyable read.
There really is nothing better than a well constructed tale that both entertains and educates you! Recommend!
*** A big thanks to HQ Digital for my copy ***
Kathleen McGurl has skillfully threaded together an intriguing story that truly captivated me. This book introduced me to a lot of Irish history that I had not previously known. I love when a book educates me about something and how appropriate for me to learn more about Ireland in the month of March. Although I’ve been told st. Patrick’s Day is more of a holiday in the US then in Ireland? Or maybe that Cinco de Mayo? Yes I know they don’t celebrate that in Ireland... all my aimless rambling is to say I really love the historical part of this book, it seemed very well researched and was extremely educational to me.
This book jumps between 1919 and present day. Claire has recently extricated herself from a toxic marriage, it’s the perfect time to inherit an old family farm house. While doing some refurbishing Claire happens across a clue a key to her past. Ellen in 1919 is a upstairs maid in a small Irish town during the resistance. Two strong courageous independent women facing very unique struggles. The way these two stories were woven together was very clever, it made for a highly addictive and enjoyable read.
There really is nothing better than a well constructed tale that both entertains and educates you! Recommend!
*** A big thanks to HQ Digital for my copy ***
March 13, 2019
5☆ Unputdownable, Mesmerising and Stunning read, that Stole My Heart.
WOW! I can't begin to find the right words to describe just how much I adored this beautifully compelling and poignant read.
Two very different women connected by different eras.
So brave and strong.
Standing up for what they believe in.
I don't want to give anything away.
But what I will say is, I enjoyed Clare's story.
After 25years of being belittled by her husband, she decides to take a stand and run away to Ireland, to live in her Uncles House that was left to her when he passed away.
Clare grows in confidence and strength, makes friends, and it's such a joy to see.
But Ellen's story BLEW ME AWAY!
I have always been fascinated with history, I can't say I remember dates etc... but I enjoy the stories.
So for me Ellen's story shone through and lit up the pages.
She tells of a story of the Irish Rebellion, falling in love, finding herself in turmoil, the trials and tribulations of war, family, heartache, loss and Love.
Her story had me deeply enthralled, and I shouldn't say This as i did enjoy Clare's story but I found myself eagerly turning the pages just to get another instalment.
The paced flowed between timelines seamlessly, as the story is told by Clare and Ellen in alternating chapters.
The plot was uplifting, mesmerising, thought provoking, heart warming and enthralling.
It's a story about love, heartbreak, danger, history, new beginnings, starting over, family, friendships, strength and heartache.
The Characters are strong, relatable, and both loveable, kick ass women that melted my heart.
The Forgotten Secret is an absolutely mesmerising and stunning read, that stole my heart.
It had me hooked from the first few pages, it was Unputdownable.
Would I recommend reading this Gorgeous Book..... without a doubt.... 100% YES!!
Thank you to Rachel Random Resources for this copy which I reviewed honestly and voluntarily.
My Review is also on my Blog Website:-
https://dashfan81.blogspot.com/2019/0...
WOW! I can't begin to find the right words to describe just how much I adored this beautifully compelling and poignant read.
Two very different women connected by different eras.
So brave and strong.
Standing up for what they believe in.
I don't want to give anything away.
But what I will say is, I enjoyed Clare's story.
After 25years of being belittled by her husband, she decides to take a stand and run away to Ireland, to live in her Uncles House that was left to her when he passed away.
Clare grows in confidence and strength, makes friends, and it's such a joy to see.
But Ellen's story BLEW ME AWAY!
I have always been fascinated with history, I can't say I remember dates etc... but I enjoy the stories.
So for me Ellen's story shone through and lit up the pages.
She tells of a story of the Irish Rebellion, falling in love, finding herself in turmoil, the trials and tribulations of war, family, heartache, loss and Love.
Her story had me deeply enthralled, and I shouldn't say This as i did enjoy Clare's story but I found myself eagerly turning the pages just to get another instalment.
The paced flowed between timelines seamlessly, as the story is told by Clare and Ellen in alternating chapters.
The plot was uplifting, mesmerising, thought provoking, heart warming and enthralling.
It's a story about love, heartbreak, danger, history, new beginnings, starting over, family, friendships, strength and heartache.
The Characters are strong, relatable, and both loveable, kick ass women that melted my heart.
The Forgotten Secret is an absolutely mesmerising and stunning read, that stole my heart.
It had me hooked from the first few pages, it was Unputdownable.
Would I recommend reading this Gorgeous Book..... without a doubt.... 100% YES!!
Thank you to Rachel Random Resources for this copy which I reviewed honestly and voluntarily.
My Review is also on my Blog Website:-
https://dashfan81.blogspot.com/2019/0...
April 3, 2019
Engrossing, character driven, dual time line story about finding yourself, family secrets and lost love.
Clare Farrell is a wife and mother of two grown sons. Her marriage has gone stale; her husband is selfish and takes her for granted. For years she's put up with everything being for his convenience. The unexpected inheritance of a house in Ireland gives Clare a chance to get away and reassess her life. Against her husband's objections, and with the support of her sons, she packs her bags and goes to stay at her new property, where a chance discovery reveals a family secret and a forgotten love story.
Normally with dual time line stories, it's the past that fascinates me. Not this time. Clare's story in the present is just as interesting and compelling as Ellen's in the past. What really stands out is the realistic characters. They are so well written that you feel you know these people. Right from the first page I drawn into the story and really cared about Clare's happiness. This story is slower to develop than many of this type, but it's so beautifully written that I didn't mind.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for a copy of this book.
Clare Farrell is a wife and mother of two grown sons. Her marriage has gone stale; her husband is selfish and takes her for granted. For years she's put up with everything being for his convenience. The unexpected inheritance of a house in Ireland gives Clare a chance to get away and reassess her life. Against her husband's objections, and with the support of her sons, she packs her bags and goes to stay at her new property, where a chance discovery reveals a family secret and a forgotten love story.
Normally with dual time line stories, it's the past that fascinates me. Not this time. Clare's story in the present is just as interesting and compelling as Ellen's in the past. What really stands out is the realistic characters. They are so well written that you feel you know these people. Right from the first page I drawn into the story and really cared about Clare's happiness. This story is slower to develop than many of this type, but it's so beautifully written that I didn't mind.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for a copy of this book.
August 22, 2021
Ellen O’Brien has started working as a maid for Madame Emily Carlton at her grand house and her father’s happy she’s bringing in a wage. The future looks promising for Ellen, James Gallagher has returned home to Clonamurty Farm and the young couple are in love. But, Ireland’s on the brink of war, and there's lots of hushed and secret talk about Irish Independence. The Black and Tans are prowling the area, people are in hiding, others have been arrested and had their property damaged.
Clare Farrell has inherited an old rundown farm house called Clonamurty, and it’s in County Meath, Ireland. Her extremely controlling husband of twenty five years Paul, he plans to quickly sell the farm and invest the money. He’s that full of himself, Paul hasn’t noticed Clare’s unhappy and she knows this is her chance to leave him. Her sons Matt and Jon support their mother, they want her to be happy and financially independent. Paul doesn’t take Clare leaving well, she doesn’t care and she’s excited to start her new life in Ireland. The house and out buildings need to be thoroughly cleaned out and refurbished. Clare finds a birth certificate and a communion medal hidden in an old arm chair and she wants to solve the hundred year old mystery.
The Forgotten Secret has a dual timeline, a century apart, the story is about Irish history, secrets, family, starting over and lost love. I really liked the characters of Ellen and Clare, two strong women, and both had to overcome adversity and controlling men.
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley, my favorite book by Kathleen McGurl and five stars from me.
Clare Farrell has inherited an old rundown farm house called Clonamurty, and it’s in County Meath, Ireland. Her extremely controlling husband of twenty five years Paul, he plans to quickly sell the farm and invest the money. He’s that full of himself, Paul hasn’t noticed Clare’s unhappy and she knows this is her chance to leave him. Her sons Matt and Jon support their mother, they want her to be happy and financially independent. Paul doesn’t take Clare leaving well, she doesn’t care and she’s excited to start her new life in Ireland. The house and out buildings need to be thoroughly cleaned out and refurbished. Clare finds a birth certificate and a communion medal hidden in an old arm chair and she wants to solve the hundred year old mystery.
The Forgotten Secret has a dual timeline, a century apart, the story is about Irish history, secrets, family, starting over and lost love. I really liked the characters of Ellen and Clare, two strong women, and both had to overcome adversity and controlling men.
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley, my favorite book by Kathleen McGurl and five stars from me.
March 13, 2019
I have so many good thoughts about this book. Firstly lets talk history and politics. I grew up in 70's England and remember the Troubles as they were then but as with most British history lessons in schools they tend not to focus on things that don't go well so I don't recall learning about the history of how the Troubles came about. There's an analogy in here about relationships that gave me more insight then any school lesson. Now if only the next book I read will explain the Brexit Backstop! The other bit if history is around the Magdalene Laundry scandal. Again something that I saw briefly in the newspapers but explained so much better in this book. So I loved it to start with just for that.
For me, if a book covers two time frames I tend to find one better than the other but here I really enjoyed both stories. Characters from both eras are drawn so vividly and each story would stand alone as an enjoyable read. As a reader you can't help but wonder how things will turn out as you read and start imagining potential endings as you go along. I was trying to work out how the two stories would join up at the end and I found the way it was done so sweet and a bit different from the usual 'they were related all along' cliche.
It was all just so delightful. I loved Clare's journey. I found I had a few things in common with her and funnily enough my step-mum was re-upholstering an antique chair as I was reading about Clare doing it so in my head now Clare's chair looks like the family one! I'm a little bit in love with Ryan the book shop owning silver fox. I could quite do with a Ryan myself.
Ellen's story back in 1919 is dramatic and filled with sadness and you can't help rooting for some good to happen to her and again the time period is so richly described.
I could go on and on. It's just such a wonderful book and easily the best book I've read so far this year. I'm looking forward to reading the authors other books.
For me, if a book covers two time frames I tend to find one better than the other but here I really enjoyed both stories. Characters from both eras are drawn so vividly and each story would stand alone as an enjoyable read. As a reader you can't help but wonder how things will turn out as you read and start imagining potential endings as you go along. I was trying to work out how the two stories would join up at the end and I found the way it was done so sweet and a bit different from the usual 'they were related all along' cliche.
It was all just so delightful. I loved Clare's journey. I found I had a few things in common with her and funnily enough my step-mum was re-upholstering an antique chair as I was reading about Clare doing it so in my head now Clare's chair looks like the family one! I'm a little bit in love with Ryan the book shop owning silver fox. I could quite do with a Ryan myself.
Ellen's story back in 1919 is dramatic and filled with sadness and you can't help rooting for some good to happen to her and again the time period is so richly described.
I could go on and on. It's just such a wonderful book and easily the best book I've read so far this year. I'm looking forward to reading the authors other books.
February 15, 2023
This was thoroughly engaging from beginning to end & I really learned so much from this amazing story. I love how it starts: " If you were educated in Ireland you'll probably know all this already,in which case feel free to skip this section. Everyone else - please read on. I hope this will provide some context for the novel. I'll try to keep it as short as possible! " I'm Irish but wasn't raised in Ireland (My Dad was born in County Claire, Ireland and we were raised Irish💚) so I read on to learn about how Ireland fought to be free from Britain. As promised, she kept it short! I never knew this before and so glad that I know it now 😃
This is a duel time line story. It alternates beautifully between Ellen O'Brian in1919 and Clare Farrell in 2016. It's setting is Ireland 🍀.
Ellen is 19 years old and has a hard life. Her Mother passed away from the flu when she was little,her Father is a nice enough man but they aren't close. She has a childhood sweetheart named Jimmy. They eventually fall in love but with the war brewing, Jimmy now a Volunteer,Ellen working for a woman who is secretly involved in the war and Ellen carry information in empty milk jugs from Mrs. Carlton to the Volunteers & back ,then soon finds out that she's pregnant is a lot to go through all of a sudden! Exciting! " As Ireland is torn apart by the turmoil,Ellen finds herself facing the ultimate test of love and loyalty." She is also hiding a secret which ties her to Clare in 2016. Ummm. Wondering what the secret is, read & find out!
Clare Farrell has inherited a delapidated farm house from her uncle in Ireland. She has two grown sons and is escaping an emotionally abusive marriage. She decides to fix up the farm house 🏡 and leave England to live in Ireland. She's very interested in learning everything she can about her family history. One day she accidentally finds a birth certificate and a First Communion Medallion leading to the past. Thus, the mystery of The Forgotten Secret begins!!
This is a wonderful, interesting and enjoyable read. It's full of beauty, mystery,intrigue and history! I enjoy Historical Fiction and books about Ireland and this is the perfect blend of everything! Read and unlock the mystery of The Forgotten Secret and go back in time and get lost in this book... you'll be glad that you did! 😃 This is my first book by Kathleen McGurl and not my last! She has really researched this story and her writing style draws you in from page one!! Highly recommend! Enjoy & Happy Reading 😁📚🍀✨💫
This is a duel time line story. It alternates beautifully between Ellen O'Brian in1919 and Clare Farrell in 2016. It's setting is Ireland 🍀.
Ellen is 19 years old and has a hard life. Her Mother passed away from the flu when she was little,her Father is a nice enough man but they aren't close. She has a childhood sweetheart named Jimmy. They eventually fall in love but with the war brewing, Jimmy now a Volunteer,Ellen working for a woman who is secretly involved in the war and Ellen carry information in empty milk jugs from Mrs. Carlton to the Volunteers & back ,then soon finds out that she's pregnant is a lot to go through all of a sudden! Exciting! " As Ireland is torn apart by the turmoil,Ellen finds herself facing the ultimate test of love and loyalty." She is also hiding a secret which ties her to Clare in 2016. Ummm. Wondering what the secret is, read & find out!
Clare Farrell has inherited a delapidated farm house from her uncle in Ireland. She has two grown sons and is escaping an emotionally abusive marriage. She decides to fix up the farm house 🏡 and leave England to live in Ireland. She's very interested in learning everything she can about her family history. One day she accidentally finds a birth certificate and a First Communion Medallion leading to the past. Thus, the mystery of The Forgotten Secret begins!!
This is a wonderful, interesting and enjoyable read. It's full of beauty, mystery,intrigue and history! I enjoy Historical Fiction and books about Ireland and this is the perfect blend of everything! Read and unlock the mystery of The Forgotten Secret and go back in time and get lost in this book... you'll be glad that you did! 😃 This is my first book by Kathleen McGurl and not my last! She has really researched this story and her writing style draws you in from page one!! Highly recommend! Enjoy & Happy Reading 😁📚🍀✨💫
March 18, 2019
A century apart, this dual timeline story tells of two very different women, living in Ireland, and the secret from the past that links them. The insight into Ireland in 1919, the abuse of power by those seeking to annihilate those striving to free the country from the rule of England and the turmoil, devastation and destruction which ensued is brought vividly to life.
One of the people caught up in these turbulent times is Ellen O'Brien and it something she hid that is discovered a century later by Clare Farrell. Forty-nine year old Clare has inherited a property in Ireland and the money necessary to help her escape from her unhappy marriage. Encouraged to make the most of the opportunity by her two sons, she moves into the house she has happy memories of visiting with her Mum as a child. As she makes new friends and starts to regain her self confidence and self reliance, Clare seeks to discover just why the artefacts were hidden and the history of the people named in them.
It is a heartwarming story from both eras and the ending is a brilliant culmination, bringing the threads of the story from both timelines together in a conclusion that certainly left me smiling. Whilst life and experiences for both women are very different, both are prepared to stand up for what they believe in and it feels like you watch them grow and develop their own strengths through their experiences as their stories progress.
The detective work to discover more about the artefacts that Clare discovered is the key link to these women and I found it an intriguing read, a story of struggles, decisions, secrets and love a century apart. I have absolutely no hesitation in highly recommending this fascinating story which I found to be a real page turner and fascinating read, especially as my maternal grandparents were around the same age as Ellen, both born and living in Ireland during the same era!
I requested and was gifted a copy of this book via NetGalley and this is my honest review after choosing to read it.
One of the people caught up in these turbulent times is Ellen O'Brien and it something she hid that is discovered a century later by Clare Farrell. Forty-nine year old Clare has inherited a property in Ireland and the money necessary to help her escape from her unhappy marriage. Encouraged to make the most of the opportunity by her two sons, she moves into the house she has happy memories of visiting with her Mum as a child. As she makes new friends and starts to regain her self confidence and self reliance, Clare seeks to discover just why the artefacts were hidden and the history of the people named in them.
It is a heartwarming story from both eras and the ending is a brilliant culmination, bringing the threads of the story from both timelines together in a conclusion that certainly left me smiling. Whilst life and experiences for both women are very different, both are prepared to stand up for what they believe in and it feels like you watch them grow and develop their own strengths through their experiences as their stories progress.
The detective work to discover more about the artefacts that Clare discovered is the key link to these women and I found it an intriguing read, a story of struggles, decisions, secrets and love a century apart. I have absolutely no hesitation in highly recommending this fascinating story which I found to be a real page turner and fascinating read, especially as my maternal grandparents were around the same age as Ellen, both born and living in Ireland during the same era!
I requested and was gifted a copy of this book via NetGalley and this is my honest review after choosing to read it.
March 6, 2019
My Rating: 4.5 Stars
Clare Farrell has inherited an old farmhouse in County Meath, Ireland. The timing couldn't be more perfect because she had been looking for a way to end a very unhappy marriage. She takes control and leaves her husband for Ireland and is determined to make a go of it. As she starts to reupholster a chair, she finds something that looks like it might be the key to discovering her past.
The timeline shifts in this story to July 1919 with Ellen O'Brien, young, idealistic and in love. She leaves home for a job that ends up involving her in the war currently taking place. The man she is in love with is involved in the turmoil that is destroying Ireland. What ensues then changes her life and that of others irrevocably.
What Clare finds has been buried to decades and she might just find a long-lost relative. Meanwhile, her sons offer great moral support. All the while, her past with her husband is never far from her mind, especially as he is not quite ready to let their marriage go.
The Forgotten Secret seamlessly shifts between past and secret. The past is rather exciting, albeit tragic with regard to Ireland struggling for independence from Britain. Also, what Ellen experienced for a time there in Ireland, at what was referred to as The Magdalene Laundries, was nothing less than tragic. Sadly, what happened there, also referred to as asylums was based on real history. With regard to Clare, we have a woman needing to reestablish herself, and even entertaining new friends and a possible love interest.
This was an enjoyable story in essence, although quite sad at times. Not only was I able to read it in one sitting, Most times when history is mixed in with a dual timeline like this it can be rather interesting, as this book proved. I am definitely looking forward to much more from Kathleen McGurl.
Many thanks to HQ Digital and to NetGalley for this ARC to review in exchange for my honest opinion.
Clare Farrell has inherited an old farmhouse in County Meath, Ireland. The timing couldn't be more perfect because she had been looking for a way to end a very unhappy marriage. She takes control and leaves her husband for Ireland and is determined to make a go of it. As she starts to reupholster a chair, she finds something that looks like it might be the key to discovering her past.
The timeline shifts in this story to July 1919 with Ellen O'Brien, young, idealistic and in love. She leaves home for a job that ends up involving her in the war currently taking place. The man she is in love with is involved in the turmoil that is destroying Ireland. What ensues then changes her life and that of others irrevocably.
What Clare finds has been buried to decades and she might just find a long-lost relative. Meanwhile, her sons offer great moral support. All the while, her past with her husband is never far from her mind, especially as he is not quite ready to let their marriage go.
The Forgotten Secret seamlessly shifts between past and secret. The past is rather exciting, albeit tragic with regard to Ireland struggling for independence from Britain. Also, what Ellen experienced for a time there in Ireland, at what was referred to as The Magdalene Laundries, was nothing less than tragic. Sadly, what happened there, also referred to as asylums was based on real history. With regard to Clare, we have a woman needing to reestablish herself, and even entertaining new friends and a possible love interest.
This was an enjoyable story in essence, although quite sad at times. Not only was I able to read it in one sitting, Most times when history is mixed in with a dual timeline like this it can be rather interesting, as this book proved. I am definitely looking forward to much more from Kathleen McGurl.
Many thanks to HQ Digital and to NetGalley for this ARC to review in exchange for my honest opinion.
January 25, 2019
This was a pleasant, dual timeline read. In the present day, Clare is left property in Ireland and leaves her manipulative husband behind in Britain to start afresh. Items she discovers in the house prompt her to research the history of the house and people connected with it. Her investigations lead to the early 1900's, and housemaid Ellen's story unfolds as she finds herself caught up in the fight for independence from Britain.
Past and present combined nicely to offer a quick read, but I didn't particularly connect with either character. Ellen's story got better as it went on, but Clare's was rather clichéd, and I found it a little unbelievable that she would have got out from such a controlling relationship so quickly. I'm sure I would have have enjoyed the book more had her part of the story been better developed. There is lots of history concerning Ireland's fight for Independence contained in the plot, which appears well researched and I would recommend it for, as I'm sure it would interest many.
*I received a copy of the book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
Past and present combined nicely to offer a quick read, but I didn't particularly connect with either character. Ellen's story got better as it went on, but Clare's was rather clichéd, and I found it a little unbelievable that she would have got out from such a controlling relationship so quickly. I'm sure I would have have enjoyed the book more had her part of the story been better developed. There is lots of history concerning Ireland's fight for Independence contained in the plot, which appears well researched and I would recommend it for, as I'm sure it would interest many.
*I received a copy of the book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
February 21, 2019
I love this author's writing and this book is no exception. I know very little of the history of Ireland and this book provided quite an insight into it.
The book is a dual timeline story and although I enjoyed both timelines (which are linked together) I did enjoy the modern one slightly more. I thought the characters well rounded, and I felt I got to know them very quickly.
I liked how the author has drawn in quite current news stories into the book, for example the recent stories surrounding the Magdalene laundries.
All in all, a well written and enjoyable book.
The book is a dual timeline story and although I enjoyed both timelines (which are linked together) I did enjoy the modern one slightly more. I thought the characters well rounded, and I felt I got to know them very quickly.
I liked how the author has drawn in quite current news stories into the book, for example the recent stories surrounding the Magdalene laundries.
All in all, a well written and enjoyable book.
June 12, 2021
Excelentă carte!! Pentru cei cărora le place stilul scriitoarei Kate Morton (preferata mea), povești de familie, secrete din trecut, locuri frumoase și misterioase, grădini abundente cu fel și fel de plante și clădiri vechi care ascund secrete, aceasta e alegerea! Mie îmi place foarte mult acest stil de scriere, care îmbină foarte bine evenimente istorice și relatări, cercetări din trecut, cu o poveste de ficțiune, încât mă bucur enorm că am descoperit-o pe această autoare și abia aștept să îi citesc toate cărțile!
April 3, 2019
The Forgotten Secret by Kathleen McGurl. HQ Digital, 2019.
This book links two stories set in a farmhouse in County Meath, Ireland. In 2016, Clare considers leaving her critical, overbearing, unscrupulous husband of twenty-five years. In 1919, young Ellen and her Jimmy become involved in the old Irish Republican Army (IRA). Clare, having inherited the house once owned by Jimmy’s parents, finds personal records in an old chair she is reupholstering. Readers will be sympathetic to both women as their stories unfold in alternating chapters. The Irish history skilfully woven through Ellen’s story contributed to the book’s appeal.
This book’s cover compares it to those of Kate Morton, but is about half the length. I enjoyed reading it more than I have enjoyed Morton’s books.
Disclosure: I received a review copy of The Forgotten Secret via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
This book links two stories set in a farmhouse in County Meath, Ireland. In 2016, Clare considers leaving her critical, overbearing, unscrupulous husband of twenty-five years. In 1919, young Ellen and her Jimmy become involved in the old Irish Republican Army (IRA). Clare, having inherited the house once owned by Jimmy’s parents, finds personal records in an old chair she is reupholstering. Readers will be sympathetic to both women as their stories unfold in alternating chapters. The Irish history skilfully woven through Ellen’s story contributed to the book’s appeal.
This book’s cover compares it to those of Kate Morton, but is about half the length. I enjoyed reading it more than I have enjoyed Morton’s books.
Disclosure: I received a review copy of The Forgotten Secret via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
March 23, 2019
All reviews can be found at sarahsvignettes.wordpress.com
I can’t believe I am only just reading Kathleen McGurl’s stories!! I am sure I say this every time I review a book by an author whose books I haven't read before, but I can’t!
The Forgotten Secret has everything I love in a story: contemporary and historical fiction, a mystery, characters I can easily connect with, well researched, beautifully told.
The story is told as a dual time frame, set between 1919-1920 and the present day. In the historical thread, Kathleen McGurl pulls us into Ellen O'Brien's life and the War of Irish Independence. I warmed to Ellen instantly and the love she has for her childhood sweetheart is beautiful. Ellen’s story was not easy to read at times and there were instances where I wanted to jump into the page to hug her.
In present day Ireland, we accompany Clare Farrell on her journey to independence from her broken marriage. Having inherited a run-down farmhouse from her uncle, she seizes the chance to leave her husband, Paul, and start a new life. Gosh, I hated Paul. Even after a week, he still hasn’t redeemed himself. Well done to Kathleen McGurl for a writing a character who provoked this emotion in me! I did however really like Clare and was championing her on to really make a new life for herself.
I do love it when a house throws up a mystery to be solved and the farmhouse in this story is no exception. I will say no more for the risk of spoiling the story so you will have to read The Forgotten Secret to find out more.
I love how Kathleen McGurl intertwines both women’s stories, answering questions raised in one era in the other, tying it all up nicely at the end.
I do love reading the acknowledgements at the end of a book. Often, the author will give us an insight into where the idea for the story came from. The seed for The Forgotten Secret was a small nugget of conversation which became this great story.
*I received a review copy from the publisher via Netgalley in return for this honest review.
I can’t believe I am only just reading Kathleen McGurl’s stories!! I am sure I say this every time I review a book by an author whose books I haven't read before, but I can’t!
The Forgotten Secret has everything I love in a story: contemporary and historical fiction, a mystery, characters I can easily connect with, well researched, beautifully told.
The story is told as a dual time frame, set between 1919-1920 and the present day. In the historical thread, Kathleen McGurl pulls us into Ellen O'Brien's life and the War of Irish Independence. I warmed to Ellen instantly and the love she has for her childhood sweetheart is beautiful. Ellen’s story was not easy to read at times and there were instances where I wanted to jump into the page to hug her.
In present day Ireland, we accompany Clare Farrell on her journey to independence from her broken marriage. Having inherited a run-down farmhouse from her uncle, she seizes the chance to leave her husband, Paul, and start a new life. Gosh, I hated Paul. Even after a week, he still hasn’t redeemed himself. Well done to Kathleen McGurl for a writing a character who provoked this emotion in me! I did however really like Clare and was championing her on to really make a new life for herself.
I do love it when a house throws up a mystery to be solved and the farmhouse in this story is no exception. I will say no more for the risk of spoiling the story so you will have to read The Forgotten Secret to find out more.
I love how Kathleen McGurl intertwines both women’s stories, answering questions raised in one era in the other, tying it all up nicely at the end.
I do love reading the acknowledgements at the end of a book. Often, the author will give us an insight into where the idea for the story came from. The seed for The Forgotten Secret was a small nugget of conversation which became this great story.
*I received a review copy from the publisher via Netgalley in return for this honest review.
March 10, 2019
I must say I seem to be enjoying the historical fiction genre at the moment and this one is told in a dual timeline. I found it so easy to lose myself in 1919 and 2016, and when the main character in 2016 has a very similar surname as me, well that’s me done. I have to read it!!
In 1919 with Ellen, with the excitement of her new job as an upstairs maid in a small Irish town, in the height of the resistance against the British, it reminded me of Downton Abbey (which I love). In 2016, Clare Farrell has inherited a dilapidated farmhouse in Ireland and once the probate has been settled she finds a way to leave her controlling husband and with the support of her sons moves to Ireland. But how are they both connected?
The writing by Ms McGurl was so easy to lose myself into, and I found it all very believable. The only thing I found to be too easy was Clare initially leaving Paul if he was as controlling as we are shown how could she up and leave so easily? However, in The Forgotten Secret, it works. The writing is seamless as we alternate between past and present and McGurl has created two extremely strong, fascinating and courageous women.
You can see how much research has gone into The Forgotten Secret and before you start the book, McGurl explains the background which was interesting to read. This helped me as I know very little of the history in Ireland at this time. This is a page turner but of one where you want to savour the pages and the characters do not let you rest until their story has been told, no matter how painful for them at times.
April 15, 2019
3.5* Full review at:
http://greatreadsandtealeaves.blogspo...
This was an engaging read set during two different time periods and centred around a farmhouse in Ireland. In the past there is Ellen and her experiences of life and love during the Irish Uprising of 1919 and the war of independence. In modern day there is 50 year old Clare embarking on a fresh start after leaving her critical and overbearing husband. The link, apart from the farmhouse, is personal documents discovered in a old armchair being reupholstered by Clare and she embarks to find their rightful owner.
Apart from solving the above mystery, the stories are separate with the only common theme centring around two women trying to get by. Both tales are easy to follow which can often be difficult in dual narratives. There are quite a few twists in both storylines - some realistic others, not so much. I felt that the historical story held more appeal with the history of the IRA deftly woven throughout Ellen’s story.
I like the mystery Clare embarked on and how the author used the artifacts to link the narrative from the past. Ellen’s story is interspersed with rich historical detail of Ireland’s struggle for independence with solid experiences and is a rather sad tale. Clare’s story itself was not as strong. Whilst I appreciated having her older in age and questioning life’s meaning, it all played out a little too conveniently with her actions to leave a bad marriage after so many years.
‘There’s something funny about being at my stage of life. OK, spare the jokes about the big change, but being 49 and having the big five-oh looming on the horizon does make you reevaluate who you are, what your life is like, and whether you’ve achieved your life’s dreams or not. Ever since my last birthday I’d been doing a lot of navel gazing. What had I done with my life?’
Overall, the story moved along at a good pace and I recommend this book to anyone who likes stories set in Ireland, with a strong focus on Irish independence.
‘The forgotten secret, buried in the depths of that old chair, now revealed and resolved.’
This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher and provided through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The quoted material may have changed in the final release.
http://greatreadsandtealeaves.blogspo...
This was an engaging read set during two different time periods and centred around a farmhouse in Ireland. In the past there is Ellen and her experiences of life and love during the Irish Uprising of 1919 and the war of independence. In modern day there is 50 year old Clare embarking on a fresh start after leaving her critical and overbearing husband. The link, apart from the farmhouse, is personal documents discovered in a old armchair being reupholstered by Clare and she embarks to find their rightful owner.
Apart from solving the above mystery, the stories are separate with the only common theme centring around two women trying to get by. Both tales are easy to follow which can often be difficult in dual narratives. There are quite a few twists in both storylines - some realistic others, not so much. I felt that the historical story held more appeal with the history of the IRA deftly woven throughout Ellen’s story.
I like the mystery Clare embarked on and how the author used the artifacts to link the narrative from the past. Ellen’s story is interspersed with rich historical detail of Ireland’s struggle for independence with solid experiences and is a rather sad tale. Clare’s story itself was not as strong. Whilst I appreciated having her older in age and questioning life’s meaning, it all played out a little too conveniently with her actions to leave a bad marriage after so many years.
‘There’s something funny about being at my stage of life. OK, spare the jokes about the big change, but being 49 and having the big five-oh looming on the horizon does make you reevaluate who you are, what your life is like, and whether you’ve achieved your life’s dreams or not. Ever since my last birthday I’d been doing a lot of navel gazing. What had I done with my life?’
Overall, the story moved along at a good pace and I recommend this book to anyone who likes stories set in Ireland, with a strong focus on Irish independence.
‘The forgotten secret, buried in the depths of that old chair, now revealed and resolved.’
This review is based on a complimentary copy from the publisher and provided through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The quoted material may have changed in the final release.
March 19, 2019
*I voluntarily reviewed this book from Netgalley
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET by Kathleen McGurl is an absorbing, dual-timeline story that packs an emotional punch which I was not expecting.
In 1919, Ellen O'Brien has gotten a job up at the big house and the boy who claims her heart returns home from school where they can finally be together. Life is hard work but she is happy. But things are about to change drastically for Ellen and she will experience hardships and heartbreaks like no other. Will she have the strength to keep on living against the odds?
In the present day, Clare Farrell has inherited her uncle's farm in Ireland and her controlling husband is determined to sell it regardless of her feelings. But this farm may just be the perfect place to escape to - a place where Clare can leave her sham of a marriage and find herself again. But life is never quite straight-forward and when she finds an old heirloom hidden in a chair, will uncovering the past help Clare face her future?
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET by Kathleen McGurl is excellently written and Ireland's harsh and raw past is well-depicted without being too graphic. I had a very emotional reaction to this book, especially Ellen's story, because I'm Irish and this is my history, my ancestor's history, and I felt anger and sadness at times but I also felt pride and hope too. For Ellen is a character that echoes in our history - a proud, strong, Irish woman who suffers abominably but continues to forge a new life against the odds, a woman who never gives up. Clare's story is equally important and I enjoyed watching her character find her inner strength too.
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET by Kathleen McGurl is a compelling and gripping story that will hook you from the very first page and I highly recommend it.
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET by Kathleen McGurl is an absorbing, dual-timeline story that packs an emotional punch which I was not expecting.
In 1919, Ellen O'Brien has gotten a job up at the big house and the boy who claims her heart returns home from school where they can finally be together. Life is hard work but she is happy. But things are about to change drastically for Ellen and she will experience hardships and heartbreaks like no other. Will she have the strength to keep on living against the odds?
In the present day, Clare Farrell has inherited her uncle's farm in Ireland and her controlling husband is determined to sell it regardless of her feelings. But this farm may just be the perfect place to escape to - a place where Clare can leave her sham of a marriage and find herself again. But life is never quite straight-forward and when she finds an old heirloom hidden in a chair, will uncovering the past help Clare face her future?
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET by Kathleen McGurl is excellently written and Ireland's harsh and raw past is well-depicted without being too graphic. I had a very emotional reaction to this book, especially Ellen's story, because I'm Irish and this is my history, my ancestor's history, and I felt anger and sadness at times but I also felt pride and hope too. For Ellen is a character that echoes in our history - a proud, strong, Irish woman who suffers abominably but continues to forge a new life against the odds, a woman who never gives up. Clare's story is equally important and I enjoyed watching her character find her inner strength too.
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET by Kathleen McGurl is a compelling and gripping story that will hook you from the very first page and I highly recommend it.
May 20, 2019
The Forgotten Secret by Kathleen McGurl stole my Sunday afternoon, and I'm perfectly fine with that! For hours I was lost in the gripping lives of both of these women, and I can't help but admire this author's lovely storytelling skills.
First Line:
"We rounded a corner, turned off the narrow country lane and onto a gravel track, drove past a little copse of birch trees and there it was.".
My Thoughts on The Forgotten Secret by Kathleen McGurl
I snapped this book up because of the 1919 setting during the Irish War of Independence, and that storyline was brilliant. As you might expect, it spilled over with tension and tragedy, and made me feel all the emotions.
Ellen becomes entangled in the War for Irish freedom, though at times her thoughts were conflicted about what she believed in. Her journey and her storyline was the one I literally couldn't put down.
However the 2016 storyline was just as captivating. Clare has inherited a dilapidated house in Ireland from her uncle, and seizes the opportunity to make an escape from her emotionally abusive husband. Watching Clare learn to become dependent was a joy.
I LOVED how the storylines linked together, and thought they weaved together skilfully and wonderfully.
Highly recommended.
First Line:
"We rounded a corner, turned off the narrow country lane and onto a gravel track, drove past a little copse of birch trees and there it was.".
My Thoughts on The Forgotten Secret by Kathleen McGurl
I snapped this book up because of the 1919 setting during the Irish War of Independence, and that storyline was brilliant. As you might expect, it spilled over with tension and tragedy, and made me feel all the emotions.
Ellen becomes entangled in the War for Irish freedom, though at times her thoughts were conflicted about what she believed in. Her journey and her storyline was the one I literally couldn't put down.
However the 2016 storyline was just as captivating. Clare has inherited a dilapidated house in Ireland from her uncle, and seizes the opportunity to make an escape from her emotionally abusive husband. Watching Clare learn to become dependent was a joy.
I LOVED how the storylines linked together, and thought they weaved together skilfully and wonderfully.
Highly recommended.
March 18, 2019
This novel is delightful, fascinating and engrossing demanding complete attention from the reader.
Two women, two time periods, two stories.
Ellen, a young girl in 1919 working as a maid in a larger country house. Set in County Meath in the midst of a growing war between the Irish and the English, Ellen is almost coerced into choosing a side despite being unsure of her feelings. Swept up by love and loyalty, Ellen finds herself becoming involved and doing things she never dreamed of.
A hundred years later and Clare has inherited a run-down farmhouse in County Meath belonging to her uncle. Leaving her husband in England to start a new life, Clare's story is that of new beginnings but also of embracing your family history and discovering who your really are.
I found the historical aspect of this novel beautifully and sensitively written and fascinating from the perspective of someone who knows very little about this time. As a child of the 80s I grew up hearing snippets about 'the troubles' in Ireland but at that age you never realise that it's one biased perspective. Ms McGurl writes about this in a way that sheds light on what things were like for the Irish people and their beliefs that led to those circumstances. Such a touching and emotive subject in itself.
The character development in the novel is superb. In 1919 Ellen is faced with difficult choices to make in order to prove love and loyalty but remains a strong character throughout. In 2016 Clare finds her strength by leaving her husband and finding out about her family. Both women's stories leave you feeling so connected to them and are inspiring to follow as the develop throughout the book.
HIghly recommended!
Two women, two time periods, two stories.
Ellen, a young girl in 1919 working as a maid in a larger country house. Set in County Meath in the midst of a growing war between the Irish and the English, Ellen is almost coerced into choosing a side despite being unsure of her feelings. Swept up by love and loyalty, Ellen finds herself becoming involved and doing things she never dreamed of.
A hundred years later and Clare has inherited a run-down farmhouse in County Meath belonging to her uncle. Leaving her husband in England to start a new life, Clare's story is that of new beginnings but also of embracing your family history and discovering who your really are.
I found the historical aspect of this novel beautifully and sensitively written and fascinating from the perspective of someone who knows very little about this time. As a child of the 80s I grew up hearing snippets about 'the troubles' in Ireland but at that age you never realise that it's one biased perspective. Ms McGurl writes about this in a way that sheds light on what things were like for the Irish people and their beliefs that led to those circumstances. Such a touching and emotive subject in itself.
The character development in the novel is superb. In 1919 Ellen is faced with difficult choices to make in order to prove love and loyalty but remains a strong character throughout. In 2016 Clare finds her strength by leaving her husband and finding out about her family. Both women's stories leave you feeling so connected to them and are inspiring to follow as the develop throughout the book.
HIghly recommended!
July 4, 2019
Wow, this story literally grabbed a hold of me and sucked me in. I was gripped and sitting on the edge of my seat with ever chapter, right to the very end.
It didn't take me long to be drawn into the stories of both Ellen back in 1919 and that of Clare in present day 2016, I was captivated right from the first few chapters. I loved how the story went back and forth from 1919 to 2016 which was done so seamlessly.
It was highly captivating, dramatic and emotional read in places, I literally could not turn the pages fast enough, with wanting to find out what happens next and as to how it would all end.
I thought the story was brilliantly well written and the characters are all so very well portrayed and believable. I truly felt for Ellen, everything she had to deal with as a young woman and the effects it all had on her future.
I enjoyed this book so much that I just didn't want it to end. I also learnt a lot from it, as in the historical side of things, as I knew nothing of the troubles/politics that took place in Ireland back in 1919. So was very insightful.
As always, I'm very much looking forward to Kathleen's next book.
It didn't take me long to be drawn into the stories of both Ellen back in 1919 and that of Clare in present day 2016, I was captivated right from the first few chapters. I loved how the story went back and forth from 1919 to 2016 which was done so seamlessly.
It was highly captivating, dramatic and emotional read in places, I literally could not turn the pages fast enough, with wanting to find out what happens next and as to how it would all end.
I thought the story was brilliantly well written and the characters are all so very well portrayed and believable. I truly felt for Ellen, everything she had to deal with as a young woman and the effects it all had on her future.
I enjoyed this book so much that I just didn't want it to end. I also learnt a lot from it, as in the historical side of things, as I knew nothing of the troubles/politics that took place in Ireland back in 1919. So was very insightful.
As always, I'm very much looking forward to Kathleen's next book.
January 21, 2019
This book centres around two different woman from two different eras.
Clare is living in our modern age and is about to turn 50 and living London , she inherits her uncle Padraigs farmstead in Ireland. When she first visits a seed is sown and she imagines a new life in Ireland away from her increasingly controlling husband.
Ellen lives in Ireland around 1919..She is 18 and has just started her first job as an upstairs maid in a big house. Her childhood friend has returned from school and they discover first love.
Irish history is woven throughout this book and as I live Ireland I found this very interesting.
The two woman’s lives are very different but nevertheless full of events which shape them into the people they become.
This story reminded me of how lucky I am to live in the present age. Our ancestors did not have the freedom or choices we have today.
Many thanks to netgalley and the publishers for my chance to read this memorable book.
Clare is living in our modern age and is about to turn 50 and living London , she inherits her uncle Padraigs farmstead in Ireland. When she first visits a seed is sown and she imagines a new life in Ireland away from her increasingly controlling husband.
Ellen lives in Ireland around 1919..She is 18 and has just started her first job as an upstairs maid in a big house. Her childhood friend has returned from school and they discover first love.
Irish history is woven throughout this book and as I live Ireland I found this very interesting.
The two woman’s lives are very different but nevertheless full of events which shape them into the people they become.
This story reminded me of how lucky I am to live in the present age. Our ancestors did not have the freedom or choices we have today.
Many thanks to netgalley and the publishers for my chance to read this memorable book.
March 13, 2019
The Forgotten Secret
By Kathleen McGurl
4 stars
Reviewed on behalf of 3 Degrees of Fiction Book Blog
The Forgotten Secret was really enjoyable read which had me intrigued the whole way through. I really like historical fiction and this book was a great example. It is also the first book that I have read by this author and I really enjoyed her detailed writing style. I loved the dual timeline to the story and at first I wondered if I would be lost and confused but I wasn’t at all, her writing was just seamless. The author did an amazing job with keeping everything really easy to read. There were times when I felt like I was watching a period drama not reading a story and this is what I love about historical fiction. The story was so easy to lose myself in and I did that many times. I loved the characters and found them to be both likeable and believable.
I absolutely recommend this story to lovers of historical fiction and also maybe to people who are looking for something different to read. The authors’ writing was excellent and I would absolutely love to read more from her again in the future.
By Kathleen McGurl
4 stars
Reviewed on behalf of 3 Degrees of Fiction Book Blog
The Forgotten Secret was really enjoyable read which had me intrigued the whole way through. I really like historical fiction and this book was a great example. It is also the first book that I have read by this author and I really enjoyed her detailed writing style. I loved the dual timeline to the story and at first I wondered if I would be lost and confused but I wasn’t at all, her writing was just seamless. The author did an amazing job with keeping everything really easy to read. There were times when I felt like I was watching a period drama not reading a story and this is what I love about historical fiction. The story was so easy to lose myself in and I did that many times. I loved the characters and found them to be both likeable and believable.
I absolutely recommend this story to lovers of historical fiction and also maybe to people who are looking for something different to read. The authors’ writing was excellent and I would absolutely love to read more from her again in the future.
July 7, 2019
Turbulent times and heroic deeds marry with sad times and happy endings
Set in the fight for Irish Independence the book also reflects a woman's personal fight for independence from a dominating husband both connected by a secret find. Well written and worth reading.
Set in the fight for Irish Independence the book also reflects a woman's personal fight for independence from a dominating husband both connected by a secret find. Well written and worth reading.
March 7, 2020
I loved this book. Genealogy, history, and Ireland - what’s not to love? I haven’t read fiction for ages so this was a surprise.
July 12, 2019
A brilliant dual timeline story set in Ireland
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, a dual timeline set in Ireland in the early 20th century during the warring in Ireland and in the present day.
The author has researched the years of the wars, and written a lot about these hard times, so a great history lesson for the reader.
It was a real page turner for me, and I was disappointed when it ended.
This is a book I would highly recommend.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, a dual timeline set in Ireland in the early 20th century during the warring in Ireland and in the present day.
The author has researched the years of the wars, and written a lot about these hard times, so a great history lesson for the reader.
It was a real page turner for me, and I was disappointed when it ended.
This is a book I would highly recommend.
January 26, 2020
Very engaging story; kept my interest til the end.
April 2, 2019
As usual Kathleen McGurl as written a page-turner. Both the historical and modern plots keep you engaged and wanting to know what happens next. The characters are charming and believable and the in-depth history is seamlessly wrapped up with their lives. Fabulous.
January 14, 2020
This was a bitter sweet story that I couldn't put down, It was a great read.
February 28, 2019
“You can research ancestry all you like, but how people actually felt and what they thought is lost in the mists of time.”
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET is the first book I've read by Kathleen McGurl and it won't be my last. It is difficult to place this in just one genre as it has so many facets to it. It's a touch of women's fiction, a touch of mystery and a wonderfully historical!
I must say I LOVE dual timeline stories as it brings to life two stories into one. And this one is no different. Centreing around two different women from two different eras, it's beautiful, poignant and a little sad.
The story begins with Mary-Ellen O'Brien in 1919, at the height of the Irish war for independence. I know little of its history and to be honest it doesn't really interest me but it makes a fitting backdrop for Ellen's story. At 18 she has just begun her first job as an upstairs maid at Carlton House, known locally as "the big house". She works for Madame Carlton who is both friendly an sympathetic, and Ellen soon discovers she's an important figure in the fight for Ireland's independence. Ellen's childhood friend Jimmy Gallagher has also just returned from boarding school and together he and Ellen discover first love.
Amidst the sweet joyful moments of first love, however, is the war for Ireland's independence, and sadly for her, Jimmy has chosen to fight for the cause which lay close to his heart. Closer, it seems, than Ellen does. As I don't condone war in any shape or form I fail to see how the bloodshed of innocent people could bring peace and resolution to anyone. However, Jimmy feels fiercely about Ireland's independence and signs up to become a "volunteer". The only saving grace is that Madame Carlton is also a volunteer and often keeps Ellen updated, passing notes secretly between the two.
But just when life seems to as sweet as ever, unforeseen circumstances hit sending Ellen off to the Merciful Sisters in Dublin. Though I know little of Ireland's history, I do know a little of the notorious Magdalene Laundries of the early to mid-20th century. Set up for "fallen women" the Magdalene laundries also took in girls who misbehaved or were homeless. Many had illegitimate children there, and often the children either died mysteriously and were buried in the grounds or secretly adopted unbeknownst to the mothers. Conditions were harsh and almost unlivable. How anyone could send their child there is beyond me!
Fast forward 90 years we meet Clare in 2016, married to a manipulative controlling husband for 25 years and with two beautiful grown sons. Clare finds herself with a newfound independence when she inherits a dilapidated cottage farmstead from an uncle in Ireland. With this and the money also bequeathed to her, Clare suddenly decides to leave her husband Paul when she had shown no "backbone" to stand up to him before. How she suddenly did after 25 years of conditioning under his manipulation and control, I've no idea. However, despite this I still found myself rooting for her and her independence.
So Clare packs up her belongings and her car, which Paul ironically thinks of as his, books her ferry crossing and leaves. Despite telling Paul of her intentions for days and weeks leading up to it, he still didn't believe she would. He belittled her and told her she wouldn't survive five minutes without him. Upon returning home from work, Paul discovered she had indeed left him and proceeded to call and text her repeatedly with demands of where was his dinner and how was he supposed to get to work without a car? I found Paul's tirade tiresome and wanted to slap him. Although there were times I wanted to slap Clare as well.
Aside from those little nuances, Clare settled into her dilapidated cottage and set to making it a home. She makes two friends immediately - Janice, who runs the cafe, and Ryan, who runs the bookshop across from the cafe. Clare has an immense love of books but Paul dismissed her interest and threw out her beloved novels to make way for his car magazines. At last now she can pick up her love of books again with no one to stop her. She can also eat what she likes, often devouring slices of Janice's to-die-for cakes which Paul wouldn't allow her to, insinuating she was letting herself go. Such put-downs had my blood boiling!
As soon as Clare moves into Clonamurty Farm and begins to pull it apart, throwing out junk and setting aside pieces she could re-purpose. One such chair, which had seen better days, Clare found a hole in the bottom of - large enough to put her hand in. As she did so, her hand encircled something and she withdrew it, revealing an old birth certificate for a James O'Brien folded over a First Communion medallion with the date 1910 and the name Jimmy Gallagher engraved on the back. Who were these people? And what did the birth certificate have to do with the medallion? Were these things someone's forgotten secret?
The discovery of these items inspired Clare to delve into the history of her new home to find out who lived at Clonamurty Farm before her family did.
I must admit, Ellen's story was by far the most poignant and the one that enthralled me the most. Her character just touched your heart. I felt myself seeing the world - or Ireland - through her eyes and the harsh realities that faced a young woman on her own amidst a time of war. As Clare unravels a few secrets and learns a little more about her new home we see Ellen's story unfold in parallel to the present day.
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET is a clever page turner that will transport you back in time to 1920s Ireland alongside the present day story. Each chapter tells the tale of both women in dual timelines that will take your breath away. I am a sucker for historical fiction so of course the historical aspect is always going to appeal to me more. But having said that, I did enjoy both stories which lead to an incredibly touching end.
BUT...I felt there were still a few things that were left unsaid that should have been explored more. Throughout the book as Clare talks about her grandmother (which I was confused at times when she referred to her being her grandmother and her great-grandmother), we are lead to believe from Ellen's story alongside Clare's who Granny Irish was. But it seemed not. However, the story doesn't actually tell you of Granny Irish's identity, just a vague reference to a woman in one of Ryan's history books which we are then lead to assume. The other point that grated with me was throughout all of Clare's research into the history of Clonamurty Farm and who lived there before her family, there is no reference at all as to how it started out as the Gallagher's farm and ended up being the Kennedy's. What happened in between? Wasn't that the whole point of Clare's research?
For all the stories that were in THE FORGOTTEN SECRET, despite the sorrow and heartache that be-felled Ellen she went on to have her happy ever after in the end, though we only hear it third hand in the end. But the saddest part is the reunion that never was. What Clare and Ryan achieved in the end was beautiful and bittersweet.
“You can research ancestry all you like, but how people actually felt and what they thought is lost in the mists of time.” This has to be one of my favourite quotes from the book. So beautiful and so insightful. I also loved Ryan's analogy of Ireland's war of independence in parallel to divorce.
I would like to thank #KathleenMcGurl, #NetGalley and #HQDigital for an ARC of #TheForgottenSecret in exchange for an honest review.
This review appears on my blog at https://stinathebookaholic.blogspot.com/.
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET is the first book I've read by Kathleen McGurl and it won't be my last. It is difficult to place this in just one genre as it has so many facets to it. It's a touch of women's fiction, a touch of mystery and a wonderfully historical!
I must say I LOVE dual timeline stories as it brings to life two stories into one. And this one is no different. Centreing around two different women from two different eras, it's beautiful, poignant and a little sad.
The story begins with Mary-Ellen O'Brien in 1919, at the height of the Irish war for independence. I know little of its history and to be honest it doesn't really interest me but it makes a fitting backdrop for Ellen's story. At 18 she has just begun her first job as an upstairs maid at Carlton House, known locally as "the big house". She works for Madame Carlton who is both friendly an sympathetic, and Ellen soon discovers she's an important figure in the fight for Ireland's independence. Ellen's childhood friend Jimmy Gallagher has also just returned from boarding school and together he and Ellen discover first love.
Amidst the sweet joyful moments of first love, however, is the war for Ireland's independence, and sadly for her, Jimmy has chosen to fight for the cause which lay close to his heart. Closer, it seems, than Ellen does. As I don't condone war in any shape or form I fail to see how the bloodshed of innocent people could bring peace and resolution to anyone. However, Jimmy feels fiercely about Ireland's independence and signs up to become a "volunteer". The only saving grace is that Madame Carlton is also a volunteer and often keeps Ellen updated, passing notes secretly between the two.
But just when life seems to as sweet as ever, unforeseen circumstances hit sending Ellen off to the Merciful Sisters in Dublin. Though I know little of Ireland's history, I do know a little of the notorious Magdalene Laundries of the early to mid-20th century. Set up for "fallen women" the Magdalene laundries also took in girls who misbehaved or were homeless. Many had illegitimate children there, and often the children either died mysteriously and were buried in the grounds or secretly adopted unbeknownst to the mothers. Conditions were harsh and almost unlivable. How anyone could send their child there is beyond me!
Fast forward 90 years we meet Clare in 2016, married to a manipulative controlling husband for 25 years and with two beautiful grown sons. Clare finds herself with a newfound independence when she inherits a dilapidated cottage farmstead from an uncle in Ireland. With this and the money also bequeathed to her, Clare suddenly decides to leave her husband Paul when she had shown no "backbone" to stand up to him before. How she suddenly did after 25 years of conditioning under his manipulation and control, I've no idea. However, despite this I still found myself rooting for her and her independence.
So Clare packs up her belongings and her car, which Paul ironically thinks of as his, books her ferry crossing and leaves. Despite telling Paul of her intentions for days and weeks leading up to it, he still didn't believe she would. He belittled her and told her she wouldn't survive five minutes without him. Upon returning home from work, Paul discovered she had indeed left him and proceeded to call and text her repeatedly with demands of where was his dinner and how was he supposed to get to work without a car? I found Paul's tirade tiresome and wanted to slap him. Although there were times I wanted to slap Clare as well.
Aside from those little nuances, Clare settled into her dilapidated cottage and set to making it a home. She makes two friends immediately - Janice, who runs the cafe, and Ryan, who runs the bookshop across from the cafe. Clare has an immense love of books but Paul dismissed her interest and threw out her beloved novels to make way for his car magazines. At last now she can pick up her love of books again with no one to stop her. She can also eat what she likes, often devouring slices of Janice's to-die-for cakes which Paul wouldn't allow her to, insinuating she was letting herself go. Such put-downs had my blood boiling!
As soon as Clare moves into Clonamurty Farm and begins to pull it apart, throwing out junk and setting aside pieces she could re-purpose. One such chair, which had seen better days, Clare found a hole in the bottom of - large enough to put her hand in. As she did so, her hand encircled something and she withdrew it, revealing an old birth certificate for a James O'Brien folded over a First Communion medallion with the date 1910 and the name Jimmy Gallagher engraved on the back. Who were these people? And what did the birth certificate have to do with the medallion? Were these things someone's forgotten secret?
The discovery of these items inspired Clare to delve into the history of her new home to find out who lived at Clonamurty Farm before her family did.
I must admit, Ellen's story was by far the most poignant and the one that enthralled me the most. Her character just touched your heart. I felt myself seeing the world - or Ireland - through her eyes and the harsh realities that faced a young woman on her own amidst a time of war. As Clare unravels a few secrets and learns a little more about her new home we see Ellen's story unfold in parallel to the present day.
THE FORGOTTEN SECRET is a clever page turner that will transport you back in time to 1920s Ireland alongside the present day story. Each chapter tells the tale of both women in dual timelines that will take your breath away. I am a sucker for historical fiction so of course the historical aspect is always going to appeal to me more. But having said that, I did enjoy both stories which lead to an incredibly touching end.
BUT...I felt there were still a few things that were left unsaid that should have been explored more. Throughout the book as Clare talks about her grandmother (which I was confused at times when she referred to her being her grandmother and her great-grandmother), we are lead to believe from Ellen's story alongside Clare's who Granny Irish was. But it seemed not. However, the story doesn't actually tell you of Granny Irish's identity, just a vague reference to a woman in one of Ryan's history books which we are then lead to assume. The other point that grated with me was throughout all of Clare's research into the history of Clonamurty Farm and who lived there before her family, there is no reference at all as to how it started out as the Gallagher's farm and ended up being the Kennedy's. What happened in between? Wasn't that the whole point of Clare's research?
For all the stories that were in THE FORGOTTEN SECRET, despite the sorrow and heartache that be-felled Ellen she went on to have her happy ever after in the end, though we only hear it third hand in the end. But the saddest part is the reunion that never was. What Clare and Ryan achieved in the end was beautiful and bittersweet.
“You can research ancestry all you like, but how people actually felt and what they thought is lost in the mists of time.” This has to be one of my favourite quotes from the book. So beautiful and so insightful. I also loved Ryan's analogy of Ireland's war of independence in parallel to divorce.
I would like to thank #KathleenMcGurl, #NetGalley and #HQDigital for an ARC of #TheForgottenSecret in exchange for an honest review.
This review appears on my blog at https://stinathebookaholic.blogspot.com/.
March 24, 2019
Set over two timelines, 2016 and 1919, this absorbing story takes a look back at troubled times in Ireland , alongside a woman taking control of her own life after many years of being controlled by her husband, and finding her own feet again at the age of 50.
In the present timeline, we follow Claire who has been left a Farm in Ireland by an Uncle, which is in dire need of renovation and the thought of that gives her goosebumps! Not so her husband, Paul, who is used to getting his own way and just wants her to sell it so he can invest the money in something else. Over the years she'd given up going against his wishes for the sake of her two sons, but now they're grown up and doing their own thing she gets the courage to do what SHE wants for a change and makes the big decision to leave her husband and set out on a new journey in Ireland.
And back in 1919, we follow the story of Ellen who is a young girl living with her Dad with not much money, but sets out on her life journey with a new job and a new romance that is put to the test early on as Jimmy is determined to join the cause to fight for Irish independence. Ellen's new boss is also involved with setting up clandestine meetings and Ellen finds herself passing on messages and doing all she can to avoid being detected by those out to thwart all those plotting against the English.
The two timelines worked so well with each other - we had the historical look back at some very troubling times and got to see how it affected the people living and working in Ireland at the time, and that is set against the backdrop of Claire who is looking to make her own way in life and explore the things she finds on the farm that had been hidden away for many years and to look back at the family history she didn't hear about. Some of the revelations are pretty shocking but dealt with in sympathetic ways but left you as a reader feel quite emotional about what went on, and how things were so different back then.
In the present timeline, we follow Claire who has been left a Farm in Ireland by an Uncle, which is in dire need of renovation and the thought of that gives her goosebumps! Not so her husband, Paul, who is used to getting his own way and just wants her to sell it so he can invest the money in something else. Over the years she'd given up going against his wishes for the sake of her two sons, but now they're grown up and doing their own thing she gets the courage to do what SHE wants for a change and makes the big decision to leave her husband and set out on a new journey in Ireland.
And back in 1919, we follow the story of Ellen who is a young girl living with her Dad with not much money, but sets out on her life journey with a new job and a new romance that is put to the test early on as Jimmy is determined to join the cause to fight for Irish independence. Ellen's new boss is also involved with setting up clandestine meetings and Ellen finds herself passing on messages and doing all she can to avoid being detected by those out to thwart all those plotting against the English.
The two timelines worked so well with each other - we had the historical look back at some very troubling times and got to see how it affected the people living and working in Ireland at the time, and that is set against the backdrop of Claire who is looking to make her own way in life and explore the things she finds on the farm that had been hidden away for many years and to look back at the family history she didn't hear about. Some of the revelations are pretty shocking but dealt with in sympathetic ways but left you as a reader feel quite emotional about what went on, and how things were so different back then.
December 30, 2019
Great plot and character development.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 216 reviews