What do you think?
Rate this book
Northwoods #2
The Clue in the Trees: An Enchantment Lake Mystery
Francie returns to Enchantment Lake looking for answers, only to get dragged into a murder mystery she might not survive
Francie’s brother Theo has secrets—secrets Francie thinks she wants to know. But what if one of those secrets is that Theo is a murderer? To avoid considering that possibility, Francie plunges into her senior year at a small-town high school near Enchantment Lake in northern Minnesota. It’s a radical change from her private school in New York, but she hopes to keep an eye on her great aunts and maybe finally learn more about the mother she never knew. A small silver box seems to hold the answers, and she is determined to get her hands on it.
But when her long-lost brother turns up, so does a dead body, and once again Francie is drawn into a mystery. A long list of suspects, with Theo at the top, keeps her head spinning. When Francie herself becomes a suspect she starts to feel like she is walking on thin ice, but it isn’t until she is literally walking on thin ice that the pieces start to come together—and by then it may be too late.
In her previous adventure Enchantment Lake, Francie was thrown into northern Minnesota lake living: fishing, berry picking, lost kayaks and scary boat rides, poisoned hotdishes, exploding bulldozers, a forest fire . . . and murder. But if she thinks things have settled down, she’s in for a surprise. A new school with new friends (and a few enemies), a lead role in a play, an encounter with a giant muskie, archaeological twists, secret tunnels, thin ice, and a strangely sticky murder are all coming her way in The Clue in the Trees.
Francie’s brother Theo has secrets—secrets Francie thinks she wants to know. But what if one of those secrets is that Theo is a murderer? To avoid considering that possibility, Francie plunges into her senior year at a small-town high school near Enchantment Lake in northern Minnesota. It’s a radical change from her private school in New York, but she hopes to keep an eye on her great aunts and maybe finally learn more about the mother she never knew. A small silver box seems to hold the answers, and she is determined to get her hands on it.
But when her long-lost brother turns up, so does a dead body, and once again Francie is drawn into a mystery. A long list of suspects, with Theo at the top, keeps her head spinning. When Francie herself becomes a suspect she starts to feel like she is walking on thin ice, but it isn’t until she is literally walking on thin ice that the pieces start to come together—and by then it may be too late.
In her previous adventure Enchantment Lake, Francie was thrown into northern Minnesota lake living: fishing, berry picking, lost kayaks and scary boat rides, poisoned hotdishes, exploding bulldozers, a forest fire . . . and murder. But if she thinks things have settled down, she’s in for a surprise. A new school with new friends (and a few enemies), a lead role in a play, an encounter with a giant muskie, archaeological twists, secret tunnels, thin ice, and a strangely sticky murder are all coming her way in The Clue in the Trees.
192 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2017
4 people are currently reading
568 people want to read
About the author
Margi Preus
26 books192 followersMargi Preus is a children's writer. She is a 2011 Newbery Honor winner and won the Asian/Pacific American Award for Literature for Heart of a Samurai.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
September 14, 2020
The Clue in the Trees is the second book of the Enchantment Lake Mystery Series. In this adventure Francie is a suspect in the latest murder on the lake and so is her brother, Theo. Theo has some explaining to do, but Francie isn’t sure she’s ready to know the answers.
I enjoyed this one much more than the first in the series and I am really looking forward the the third book, The Silver Box.
I enjoyed this one much more than the first in the series and I am really looking forward the the third book, The Silver Box.
September 19, 2017
3.5/5 Stars! Review Originally Posted On: Taylor Fenner's Bookish World
The Clue in the Trees takes place in a small town in northern Minnesota, though which side of the state it doesn't specify (probably not the Wisconsin side in my opinion). If you're looking for a book that's a short, easy read that perfectly describes the atmosphere of the northern Midwest, this is definitely your series. But as for mystery? I'm not so sure.
We meet our heroine (or re-meet if you've read the first book.) when she wakes up in the middle of the night and finds her long-lost brother sitting in the living room of her apartment at 3 am. Two things immediately sprung to mind as I read this:
1. Someone let themselves into your apartment at 3 am and you don't question that? Especially when they tell you to follow them to a gift shop? At 3 am?!?
2. What 17-year-old has their own apartment?!?!
Anyway, it isn't long before a murder occurs. But even though Francie has been compared to Nancy Drew, she's not really what I'd think of when I think girl detective. Probably because she keeps telling everyone she has no interest in solving the murder and because she doesn't seem to have the curiosity needed for the type of character she's supposed to be. Don't you want to find out what happened?
Most of this book seems to steer away from the murder investigation, instead focusing on Francie's missing or possibly dead mother and a missing silver box. The author also off-shoots into things like crude oil pipelining, protesting the pipelining, a Greek play the school is putting on, and a bunch of stuff one could do in a small country town in northern Minnesota. Then the ending and the motive for the murder was just so ridiculous it was comical.
There wasn't just enough mystery for me. I thought this book would be more in the line of a teenage sleuth reminiscent of Mrs. Fletcher from Murder, She Wrote, or even something along the lines of Texas Gothic or Spirit and Dust by Rosemary Clement-Moore. I also didn't feel like the characters felt like modern teenagers. The phrases they used, like "skedaddle", sounding more like someone in the 1950s or 1960s would use, if even then and their use of things - whether social media or computers or cell phones seemed lacking.
What this book did remind me of was something one of the local authors in my north-central Wisconsin area would write, something that might get sold in a local store for a 'flavor of the area' type thing. And if I didn't know this book was set in Minnesota I would have been more apt to believe it was more likely set in Yooper-land (Northern Michigan).
Despite all that, I can't exactly say how I feel about this book. I neither loved it nor disliked it. It did move fast, which is always good, but I just feel sort of indifferent about the book as a whole. It was made to sound like a YA novel, but I believe it is much better suited for a Middle-Grade audience.
The Clue in the Trees takes place in a small town in northern Minnesota, though which side of the state it doesn't specify (probably not the Wisconsin side in my opinion). If you're looking for a book that's a short, easy read that perfectly describes the atmosphere of the northern Midwest, this is definitely your series. But as for mystery? I'm not so sure.
We meet our heroine (or re-meet if you've read the first book.) when she wakes up in the middle of the night and finds her long-lost brother sitting in the living room of her apartment at 3 am. Two things immediately sprung to mind as I read this:
1. Someone let themselves into your apartment at 3 am and you don't question that? Especially when they tell you to follow them to a gift shop? At 3 am?!?
2. What 17-year-old has their own apartment?!?!
Anyway, it isn't long before a murder occurs. But even though Francie has been compared to Nancy Drew, she's not really what I'd think of when I think girl detective. Probably because she keeps telling everyone she has no interest in solving the murder and because she doesn't seem to have the curiosity needed for the type of character she's supposed to be. Don't you want to find out what happened?
Most of this book seems to steer away from the murder investigation, instead focusing on Francie's missing or possibly dead mother and a missing silver box. The author also off-shoots into things like crude oil pipelining, protesting the pipelining, a Greek play the school is putting on, and a bunch of stuff one could do in a small country town in northern Minnesota. Then the ending and the motive for the murder was just so ridiculous it was comical.
There wasn't just enough mystery for me. I thought this book would be more in the line of a teenage sleuth reminiscent of Mrs. Fletcher from Murder, She Wrote, or even something along the lines of Texas Gothic or Spirit and Dust by Rosemary Clement-Moore. I also didn't feel like the characters felt like modern teenagers. The phrases they used, like "skedaddle", sounding more like someone in the 1950s or 1960s would use, if even then and their use of things - whether social media or computers or cell phones seemed lacking.
What this book did remind me of was something one of the local authors in my north-central Wisconsin area would write, something that might get sold in a local store for a 'flavor of the area' type thing. And if I didn't know this book was set in Minnesota I would have been more apt to believe it was more likely set in Yooper-land (Northern Michigan).
Despite all that, I can't exactly say how I feel about this book. I neither loved it nor disliked it. It did move fast, which is always good, but I just feel sort of indifferent about the book as a whole. It was made to sound like a YA novel, but I believe it is much better suited for a Middle-Grade audience.
August 10, 2017
ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This was a cute story. The targeted audience is mainly children and young teens, but I really enjoyed it. I think there were a lot of opportunities to make this a more thorough story, but in general, I think it suits its intended audience well.
I have not read the first book in this series, but little references are made. It's a pretty good 'standalone' book, but it sets up nicely at the end for a sequel.
Francie seemed a little young compared to the age she's supposed to be, but understandably so, as this is written for a younger audience.
I would have loved this book when I was younger. I loved the entire Nancy Drew series and The Boxcar Children series. This is a more modern mystery, obviously, but I like that it's a series of mysteries. I would definitely buy this series for my kids to read. It's funny, a little scary at times and it's relatable to the age group it's targeted at.
This was a cute story. The targeted audience is mainly children and young teens, but I really enjoyed it. I think there were a lot of opportunities to make this a more thorough story, but in general, I think it suits its intended audience well.
I have not read the first book in this series, but little references are made. It's a pretty good 'standalone' book, but it sets up nicely at the end for a sequel.
Francie seemed a little young compared to the age she's supposed to be, but understandably so, as this is written for a younger audience.
I would have loved this book when I was younger. I loved the entire Nancy Drew series and The Boxcar Children series. This is a more modern mystery, obviously, but I like that it's a series of mysteries. I would definitely buy this series for my kids to read. It's funny, a little scary at times and it's relatable to the age group it's targeted at.
September 12, 2017
Very strong 3.5 stars.
This was a fun read, an excellent cozy mystery for teens. While the writing does seem a bit simplistic at times for it to be considered YA, the themes and age of the characters make it a bit too old to be considered middle grade (although I’m sure some middle schoolers would enjoy this too, I know I would have!).
The plot combines so many interesting topics–dinosaur and mastodon bones, maple syrup heists, pipeline protests–shrouded in the typical small-rural-town-mystery air, and garnished with the continuing narrative of Francie trying to figure out who she is and who her family is. While these plot points are sort of predictable, the mystery itself was intriguing and the characters were fun–it made for a fun fluffy-mystery read, where you could get invested in the story without intense amount of brain-power or stamina to sit through constant suspense. I also liked the parallels between Francie’s “quest” and the play they were putting on at school (Antigone). Again, another trite trope, but it worked well and never seemed to overly-harp on The Message.
I had not read the first book in the series, and this installment does ping off of many plot points (presumably) introduced in book one. However, I didn’t feel particularly lost with these points, as they followed a basic progression, and they were woven into the plot quite well.
While I don’t think I’ll be checking out any other books in the series, I did enjoy this as a cozy read, and would definitely recommend it for the middle-grade-transitioning-to-YA crowd.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with a free copy to review!
(Cross posted on my blog.)
This was a fun read, an excellent cozy mystery for teens. While the writing does seem a bit simplistic at times for it to be considered YA, the themes and age of the characters make it a bit too old to be considered middle grade (although I’m sure some middle schoolers would enjoy this too, I know I would have!).
The plot combines so many interesting topics–dinosaur and mastodon bones, maple syrup heists, pipeline protests–shrouded in the typical small-rural-town-mystery air, and garnished with the continuing narrative of Francie trying to figure out who she is and who her family is. While these plot points are sort of predictable, the mystery itself was intriguing and the characters were fun–it made for a fun fluffy-mystery read, where you could get invested in the story without intense amount of brain-power or stamina to sit through constant suspense. I also liked the parallels between Francie’s “quest” and the play they were putting on at school (Antigone). Again, another trite trope, but it worked well and never seemed to overly-harp on The Message.
I had not read the first book in the series, and this installment does ping off of many plot points (presumably) introduced in book one. However, I didn’t feel particularly lost with these points, as they followed a basic progression, and they were woven into the plot quite well.
While I don’t think I’ll be checking out any other books in the series, I did enjoy this as a cozy read, and would definitely recommend it for the middle-grade-transitioning-to-YA crowd.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with a free copy to review!
(Cross posted on my blog.)
June 5, 2022
Francie Frye, the sometime child star of a TV show about a girl detective, has transferred to a small-town high school in norther Minnesota for her senior year after helping solve a murder mystery on the remote lake where her two great-aunts live. She brings with her a reputation for meddling in local mysteries, which is the last thing she needs when she's just trying to fit in at a new school, earn good grades and try out for the school play. But before the school year even gets started, her long-absent older brother Theo turns up and drags her into a mysterious, cloak-and-dagger chase scene involving a figure actually wearing a trench coat and fedora.
To make things even more mysterious, the lead arecheologist in a mastodon bone dig at the lake turns up dead – and Francie has reason to suspect Theo of the murder. The more she digs, trying to prove his innocence, the worse it looks for Theo. Pretty soon the sheriff suspects him, and Francie, too. Meanwhile, Miss "I'm Not a Girl Detective But I Played One On TV" also can't resist digging, or rather, diving, for a silver box that she saw at a neighbor's house last summer, and that triggers one of her few early memories of her vanished mother. For some reason, somebody is willing to go to great lengths to keep her from finding it. But Francie is willing to go to great depths – even beneath the ice of a frozen lake. If that doesn't kill her, maybe the murderer will, as her search for answers to one mystery leads her dangerously close to the solution of the other.
This book plays with one's expectations in a fun way. You expect the sheriff, and everyone else, to tell Francie to steer clear of the mystery. What you don't expect is for the sheriff, her grandfather, her aunts and a teacher at the school to encourage her (more or less) in her inevitable investigation. Despite her protests of "I'm just here to live a normal life," they all know she's the one who's going to figure it all out. And a lot of people care about her – a couple of them, maybe, in a romantic way – which subtly influences you to care, too. So her danger makes your breath catch, and her need to know more about her mom is a feeling you share. Finally, the setting comes with its own colorful history and its own set of environmental, cultural and political concerns, which may interest you as well; the book concludes with an author's note that provides a sketch of these real-world components.
This is the second book in the "Enchantment Lake Mystery" trilogy, which hits me as if it was set in a thinly disguised version of the area where I live in northern Minnesota. The other installments in it are Enchantment Lake and The Silver Box. Margi Preus is also the author of the Newbery Honor book Heart of a Samurai as well as the young adult novels Shadow on the Mountain, West of the Moon, The Bamboo Sword, Village of Scoundrels, The Littlest Voyageur and, coming in September 2022, Windswept. Her children's picture books include the recent (May 2022) release Lily Leads the Way, and her nonfiction titles include Celebritrees: Historic and Famous Trees of the World.
To make things even more mysterious, the lead arecheologist in a mastodon bone dig at the lake turns up dead – and Francie has reason to suspect Theo of the murder. The more she digs, trying to prove his innocence, the worse it looks for Theo. Pretty soon the sheriff suspects him, and Francie, too. Meanwhile, Miss "I'm Not a Girl Detective But I Played One On TV" also can't resist digging, or rather, diving, for a silver box that she saw at a neighbor's house last summer, and that triggers one of her few early memories of her vanished mother. For some reason, somebody is willing to go to great lengths to keep her from finding it. But Francie is willing to go to great depths – even beneath the ice of a frozen lake. If that doesn't kill her, maybe the murderer will, as her search for answers to one mystery leads her dangerously close to the solution of the other.
This book plays with one's expectations in a fun way. You expect the sheriff, and everyone else, to tell Francie to steer clear of the mystery. What you don't expect is for the sheriff, her grandfather, her aunts and a teacher at the school to encourage her (more or less) in her inevitable investigation. Despite her protests of "I'm just here to live a normal life," they all know she's the one who's going to figure it all out. And a lot of people care about her – a couple of them, maybe, in a romantic way – which subtly influences you to care, too. So her danger makes your breath catch, and her need to know more about her mom is a feeling you share. Finally, the setting comes with its own colorful history and its own set of environmental, cultural and political concerns, which may interest you as well; the book concludes with an author's note that provides a sketch of these real-world components.
This is the second book in the "Enchantment Lake Mystery" trilogy, which hits me as if it was set in a thinly disguised version of the area where I live in northern Minnesota. The other installments in it are Enchantment Lake and The Silver Box. Margi Preus is also the author of the Newbery Honor book Heart of a Samurai as well as the young adult novels Shadow on the Mountain, West of the Moon, The Bamboo Sword, Village of Scoundrels, The Littlest Voyageur and, coming in September 2022, Windswept. Her children's picture books include the recent (May 2022) release Lily Leads the Way, and her nonfiction titles include Celebritrees: Historic and Famous Trees of the World.
September 18, 2017
A Middle Grade Cozy Action/Mystery
This book would work perfectly well as an adult cozy - fun setting, quirky characters, engaging heroine, tidy murder, some sleuthing, and a fine ending with a few coincidences to smooth over the bumps. For adults you'd add some more heroine backstory and maybe a love interest, a broken heart or career, and maybe a few more "adult" twists, but with that you'd have a fine cocoa and quilt fun read.
The appeal, here, is that the plot has been tweaked to add middle grade appeal. Our heroine is in high school, her pals are fellow students, she's a new kid out of water. She's a little snarky and a little angsty, but not excessively so. She is, for want of a better term, relatable for a younger reader. There are some light humor bits, and a few touches of school-daze drama, but that just helps to establish the character and set the right mood. No standard bullies or mean girls or other complications. As I say, cozy.
But here's one of the nicest parts. This book is very well written. Preus is an accomplished pro, (I admired her "Bamboo Sword"), and she has written a smart and sharp book for the younger crowd. The pacing is fast and offers a solid combination of action and reflection. Our heroine, Francie, is smart and observant and the sidekicks she picks up as the new girl have distinct personalities and their own varied appeal. Francie's two Aunts, who are sort of old-lady comic relief, perform their comic relief duties well, adding a bit of vinegar and tartness when the plot and pacing requires. Francie's mysterious brother Theo keeps things stirred up. The scenes are set well, and both the small town of Walpurgis, and Enchantment Lake, are all well drawn and convincing. Descriptions are crisp and effective. Dialogue is sharp and on point. There are nice little observations and throwaway lines that add a bit of flavor and heft to the tale.
Preus doesn't go in for irony and she doesn't mock the genre. This is classic earnest amateur sleuthing with just a touch of wry, and that's not all that easy to find in middle grade and early YA books. There's more I'd-tell-you-everything-but-I-don't-have time-right-now suspense and mystery building than I like, but that's just something I think you have to go with in these sorts of books. There's also an over-arching mystery about Francie's missing Mom that's a bit coy and moves through the series at a snail's pace, but one suspects that will get picked up in later books. And since the individual mysteries in each book get resolved completely, having a background mystery that's just hinted at is an honorable way to keep the series going.
So, I thought this was a well rounded and appealing teen mystery with a good feel, some nice touches, a satisfying amount of action, and a reasonably fair mystery. That's a pretty good find.
(Please note that I received a free advance ecopy of this book without a review requirement, or any influence regarding review content should I choose to post a review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)
This book would work perfectly well as an adult cozy - fun setting, quirky characters, engaging heroine, tidy murder, some sleuthing, and a fine ending with a few coincidences to smooth over the bumps. For adults you'd add some more heroine backstory and maybe a love interest, a broken heart or career, and maybe a few more "adult" twists, but with that you'd have a fine cocoa and quilt fun read.
The appeal, here, is that the plot has been tweaked to add middle grade appeal. Our heroine is in high school, her pals are fellow students, she's a new kid out of water. She's a little snarky and a little angsty, but not excessively so. She is, for want of a better term, relatable for a younger reader. There are some light humor bits, and a few touches of school-daze drama, but that just helps to establish the character and set the right mood. No standard bullies or mean girls or other complications. As I say, cozy.
But here's one of the nicest parts. This book is very well written. Preus is an accomplished pro, (I admired her "Bamboo Sword"), and she has written a smart and sharp book for the younger crowd. The pacing is fast and offers a solid combination of action and reflection. Our heroine, Francie, is smart and observant and the sidekicks she picks up as the new girl have distinct personalities and their own varied appeal. Francie's two Aunts, who are sort of old-lady comic relief, perform their comic relief duties well, adding a bit of vinegar and tartness when the plot and pacing requires. Francie's mysterious brother Theo keeps things stirred up. The scenes are set well, and both the small town of Walpurgis, and Enchantment Lake, are all well drawn and convincing. Descriptions are crisp and effective. Dialogue is sharp and on point. There are nice little observations and throwaway lines that add a bit of flavor and heft to the tale.
Preus doesn't go in for irony and she doesn't mock the genre. This is classic earnest amateur sleuthing with just a touch of wry, and that's not all that easy to find in middle grade and early YA books. There's more I'd-tell-you-everything-but-I-don't-have time-right-now suspense and mystery building than I like, but that's just something I think you have to go with in these sorts of books. There's also an over-arching mystery about Francie's missing Mom that's a bit coy and moves through the series at a snail's pace, but one suspects that will get picked up in later books. And since the individual mysteries in each book get resolved completely, having a background mystery that's just hinted at is an honorable way to keep the series going.
So, I thought this was a well rounded and appealing teen mystery with a good feel, some nice touches, a satisfying amount of action, and a reasonably fair mystery. That's a pretty good find.
(Please note that I received a free advance ecopy of this book without a review requirement, or any influence regarding review content should I choose to post a review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)
November 16, 2017
The Clue in the Trees by Margi Preus is the second in the Enchantment Lake series. Francie Frye from the first novel, Enchantment Lake, has decided to remain with her aunts in Minnesota for her senior year at the local high school.
On the night before her first day of school, France is awakened by the noise of her long-lost brother Theo sneaking into the house. While she is happy to see him, Francie can’t help but be suspicious of his sudden reappearance. First, he immediately involves her in a three-a.m. break-in during which they are chased by a mysterious figure in a trench coat. A few days later, he becomes a primary suspect in a murder. Desperate to protect her brother, Francie vows to stay away from the investigation, but decides she must solve the mystery once and for all when she herself becomes a suspect.
It is clear to that The Clue in the Trees is very much a middle book. The plot advances just enough from the previous book to hold reader interest into the next book, but not enough so as to give too much of the next book away.
As with Enchantment Lake, Preus does an excellent job of setting the scene. The descriptions of places and characters will make the reader feel as if they know the setting and people. Dialogue is believable, and Preus’ characterization of Francie carries over well from the previous book. Even though she attempts every effort to avoid getting involved in the the latest murder mystery, she can’t help but be dragged along with the intrigue. Francie’s aunts, who provided a welcome whimsical factor in Enchantment Lake, appear again in The Clue in the Trees. Unfortunately, their role has been greatly reduced, and I found myself missing their presence.
Enchantment Lake and The Clue in the Trees bring up frequent comparisons to Nancy Drew or the Hardy Boys, and in fact, fans of those books will likely enjoy The Clue in the Trees.
Other books readers might want to explore after reading The Clue in the Trees include Bone Gap by Laura Ruby or Being Henry David by Cal Armistead. Both books contain quirky characters that are somewhat reminiscent of Francie’s aunts, and both involved mysteries that double as journeys of self discovery. Being Henry David is heavier in tone than either of the Enchantment Lake books but is still recommended for readers who enjoy the mystery genre.
The Clue in the Trees is an excellent book for middle-school aged readers looking for a bit of adventure and imagination. While readers may be tempted to give up due to the slower plot movement, I encourage them to remain. Unfortunately with any series, there is always that book which is used to advance the plot but also has to hold back in order to set up the next book. The Clue in the Trees is that book, and I anticipate that the next in the series will harken back to the same feeling of suspense and quick moving past that was found in Enchantment Lake.
Note: I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
On the night before her first day of school, France is awakened by the noise of her long-lost brother Theo sneaking into the house. While she is happy to see him, Francie can’t help but be suspicious of his sudden reappearance. First, he immediately involves her in a three-a.m. break-in during which they are chased by a mysterious figure in a trench coat. A few days later, he becomes a primary suspect in a murder. Desperate to protect her brother, Francie vows to stay away from the investigation, but decides she must solve the mystery once and for all when she herself becomes a suspect.
It is clear to that The Clue in the Trees is very much a middle book. The plot advances just enough from the previous book to hold reader interest into the next book, but not enough so as to give too much of the next book away.
As with Enchantment Lake, Preus does an excellent job of setting the scene. The descriptions of places and characters will make the reader feel as if they know the setting and people. Dialogue is believable, and Preus’ characterization of Francie carries over well from the previous book. Even though she attempts every effort to avoid getting involved in the the latest murder mystery, she can’t help but be dragged along with the intrigue. Francie’s aunts, who provided a welcome whimsical factor in Enchantment Lake, appear again in The Clue in the Trees. Unfortunately, their role has been greatly reduced, and I found myself missing their presence.
Enchantment Lake and The Clue in the Trees bring up frequent comparisons to Nancy Drew or the Hardy Boys, and in fact, fans of those books will likely enjoy The Clue in the Trees.
Other books readers might want to explore after reading The Clue in the Trees include Bone Gap by Laura Ruby or Being Henry David by Cal Armistead. Both books contain quirky characters that are somewhat reminiscent of Francie’s aunts, and both involved mysteries that double as journeys of self discovery. Being Henry David is heavier in tone than either of the Enchantment Lake books but is still recommended for readers who enjoy the mystery genre.
The Clue in the Trees is an excellent book for middle-school aged readers looking for a bit of adventure and imagination. While readers may be tempted to give up due to the slower plot movement, I encourage them to remain. Unfortunately with any series, there is always that book which is used to advance the plot but also has to hold back in order to set up the next book. The Clue in the Trees is that book, and I anticipate that the next in the series will harken back to the same feeling of suspense and quick moving past that was found in Enchantment Lake.
Note: I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
October 23, 2017
Previously posted on The Young Girl Who Loved Books
This was a sweet and adorable story. This was something that I read in a fairly quick manner over the course of a week off and on while waiting for class. While this is a book that is really for middle grade to young teens, but I enjoyed it quite a bit. It doesn't seem to have a groundbreaking moral to it or taking away, but still, it is a great modern mystery.
The Clue in the Trees is the second book in the Northwoods Series, but it can it can be read as a stand-alone. There are some references that you may miss but for the most part, you can read this by itself. I felt like the end was really a cliffhanger that set up for the sequel. I can't wait for the third book to come out.
The book follows a little girl named Francie, who in my opinion was pretty immature for the character she is supposed to be. I feel this could be a really good modern mystery series similar to the Boxcar Children Series.
In terms of plot, this one has some many interesting topics. Things that I haven't read about previously. Things from mysteries in small towns, pipeline protests, long-lost brothers, maple syrup heists. The points are intriguing they are quite predictable which is expected for a general middle-grade novel.
I wouldn't say for older kids or teens this would be scary but for the intended audience, it might be scared by some parts of this book. This is a clean book, that you can enjoy with your children or have them read independently without fear.
Disclaimer: This ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest and unbiased review. All thoughts are my own.
This was a sweet and adorable story. This was something that I read in a fairly quick manner over the course of a week off and on while waiting for class. While this is a book that is really for middle grade to young teens, but I enjoyed it quite a bit. It doesn't seem to have a groundbreaking moral to it or taking away, but still, it is a great modern mystery.
The Clue in the Trees is the second book in the Northwoods Series, but it can it can be read as a stand-alone. There are some references that you may miss but for the most part, you can read this by itself. I felt like the end was really a cliffhanger that set up for the sequel. I can't wait for the third book to come out.
The book follows a little girl named Francie, who in my opinion was pretty immature for the character she is supposed to be. I feel this could be a really good modern mystery series similar to the Boxcar Children Series.
In terms of plot, this one has some many interesting topics. Things that I haven't read about previously. Things from mysteries in small towns, pipeline protests, long-lost brothers, maple syrup heists. The points are intriguing they are quite predictable which is expected for a general middle-grade novel.
I wouldn't say for older kids or teens this would be scary but for the intended audience, it might be scared by some parts of this book. This is a clean book, that you can enjoy with your children or have them read independently without fear.
Disclaimer: This ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest and unbiased review. All thoughts are my own.
September 12, 2017
I’ve found a new favourite tween/young adult series.
The Clue in the Trees, the second book in the Enchantment Lake Mystery Series, is a fun, light murder mystery reminding me of a modern Nancy Drew.
Set near Enchantment Lake, Northern Minnesota it follows Francie as she starts a new school, dances around the mysterious death of her mother and struggles to keep out of a murder case in which her brother is the main suspect.
The characters in the book are charming. Once upon a time, Theo, Francie’s secretive and perplexing older brother would have been my book crush.
The book works well as a standalone novel. Perfect for Middle-Grade readers to early Young Adult. With just enough gothic, darkness to make the murder mystery page turning. It also has a good dose of the humour a pre/early-teen likes.
There are some wonderful descriptions of Minnesota leaving you enchanted by the archaeological digs, eerie lakes, and a hope if you visited, you too would find giant dinosaur teeth lying around (or hidden in a gift shop).
What do I like most about this book? Other than the cover? I’m a massive fan of fiction laced with real life issues helping young people form an opinion on a subject. This book touches on the environment, crime and capitalism. Giving it depth you don’t usually find a young adult book. The author takes time to explain these in a summary illustrating what makes these relevant to modern society.
If you, or your child, grew up reading the Goth Girl Series by Chris Riddell then this is a perfect follow on. It contains the same gothic mystery feel those books did, but, aimed at an early young adult, rather than middle grade, it is further developed.
The Clue in the Trees, the second book in the Enchantment Lake Mystery Series, is a fun, light murder mystery reminding me of a modern Nancy Drew.
Set near Enchantment Lake, Northern Minnesota it follows Francie as she starts a new school, dances around the mysterious death of her mother and struggles to keep out of a murder case in which her brother is the main suspect.
The characters in the book are charming. Once upon a time, Theo, Francie’s secretive and perplexing older brother would have been my book crush.
The book works well as a standalone novel. Perfect for Middle-Grade readers to early Young Adult. With just enough gothic, darkness to make the murder mystery page turning. It also has a good dose of the humour a pre/early-teen likes.
There are some wonderful descriptions of Minnesota leaving you enchanted by the archaeological digs, eerie lakes, and a hope if you visited, you too would find giant dinosaur teeth lying around (or hidden in a gift shop).
What do I like most about this book? Other than the cover? I’m a massive fan of fiction laced with real life issues helping young people form an opinion on a subject. This book touches on the environment, crime and capitalism. Giving it depth you don’t usually find a young adult book. The author takes time to explain these in a summary illustrating what makes these relevant to modern society.
If you, or your child, grew up reading the Goth Girl Series by Chris Riddell then this is a perfect follow on. It contains the same gothic mystery feel those books did, but, aimed at an early young adult, rather than middle grade, it is further developed.
October 12, 2020
This second installment of Enchantment Lake has Francie trying to stay as far away from a murder as possible. Not only is she being told to stay away, but her brother is a suspect and she isn't sure she wants to know all his secrets. Though she tries to stay away, she stumbles on to clues, anyway. Her new friends are eager to help her solve a mystery she doesn't want any part of.
I read this book aloud to by 8 and 11 year old. They were much more interested in it than I was. This second book had scenes I wasn't sure what their purpose was. Francie, a senior in high school, is in a relationship with a college boy but they only have two conversations and she seems very uninterested, which leads me to wonder what the point of his character was. My kids didn't mind any of that and were drawn into whether or not Francie would find her mom's old silver box.
4/5 stars, thanks to my kids - This is a cute, fun story. In the end, much of what happens to the MC was by accident, including finding the murderer. There were few markers of a true mystery, even though there was an investigation. Whether it's worth the read will depend (for me) on what happens with the third book. My children, on the other hand, loved it, and are ready to start re-reading it in their own time.
*I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I read this book aloud to by 8 and 11 year old. They were much more interested in it than I was. This second book had scenes I wasn't sure what their purpose was. Francie, a senior in high school, is in a relationship with a college boy but they only have two conversations and she seems very uninterested, which leads me to wonder what the point of his character was. My kids didn't mind any of that and were drawn into whether or not Francie would find her mom's old silver box.
4/5 stars, thanks to my kids - This is a cute, fun story. In the end, much of what happens to the MC was by accident, including finding the murderer. There were few markers of a true mystery, even though there was an investigation. Whether it's worth the read will depend (for me) on what happens with the third book. My children, on the other hand, loved it, and are ready to start re-reading it in their own time.
*I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
January 29, 2018
Preus, Margi Clue in the Trees (Enchantment Lake #2), 200 pages. University of Minnesota Press, 2017. $17. Language: G (1 swear); Mature Content: G; Violence: PG (murder, other mild violence).
Francie, 17, has already made a name for herself by solving a murder mystery for her aunts. Now she is back at school and during a trip to a local archaeological dig, she finds herself face to face with another murder. Everyone seems to think the Francia is the one to solve it - but what if it leads straight to her brother Theo? Francie knows she shouldn’t ignore it, even if Theo is the murderer, but her heart is torn.
While several people make a point of calling Francie their own Nancy Drew, it comes off as the author trying to convince the reader that Francie really is a good as Nancy - but she’s not. The cover would lead you to believe that Francie is some fringe element loner, but she doesn’t really feel like that, either. If Francie were younger, I might recommend this for elementary, but at 17, she doesn’t work as a high school heroine.
NO. Cindy, Library Teacher
https://kissthebook.blogspot.com/2018...
Francie, 17, has already made a name for herself by solving a murder mystery for her aunts. Now she is back at school and during a trip to a local archaeological dig, she finds herself face to face with another murder. Everyone seems to think the Francia is the one to solve it - but what if it leads straight to her brother Theo? Francie knows she shouldn’t ignore it, even if Theo is the murderer, but her heart is torn.
While several people make a point of calling Francie their own Nancy Drew, it comes off as the author trying to convince the reader that Francie really is a good as Nancy - but she’s not. The cover would lead you to believe that Francie is some fringe element loner, but she doesn’t really feel like that, either. If Francie were younger, I might recommend this for elementary, but at 17, she doesn’t work as a high school heroine.
NO. Cindy, Library Teacher
https://kissthebook.blogspot.com/2018...
October 5, 2020
Reading this book took me back to the days when I used to binge read Nancy Drew novels (a fact that would probably irritate Francie). I loved reading more about the small town of Walpurgis and getting to know Raven, Jay, and Francie’s brother, Theo.
The main focus of the story is solving a murder– one that Francie worries her brother has committed– but it touches on several other current social and environmental issues, such as the pipeline projects and their impact on the environment and indigenous people as well as poaching and smuggling, in an organic, non-intrusive way.
I really enjoyed the goofy characters and snappy dialogue in ENCHANTMENT LAKE, and A CLUE IN THE TREES delivered on this as well. Raven has a way of cutting straight to the heart of an issue, something that helps Francie focus and keeps her honest. We still get glimpses of Francie’s great aunts and a bit of their shenanigans, but a lot of the interaction comes from Francie, Raven, and Jay.
I enjoyed reading this book and following along to uncover the truth about who committed the murder. In some places, Francie’s search for information about her mom overshadows the mystery, but I didn’t mind that too much, as I’m pretty invested in the series at this point, so I’m hoping that’s a thread that will continue to unravel in the third book, THE SILVER BOX (which I’ll be reviewing soon, too).
I recommend starting with ENCHANTMENT LAKE. This is a separate mystery story, so you could follow the plot of this one just fine if you read it first, but I think it’s worth getting that introduction to Francie’s family and the town of Walpurgis. Otherwise you might feel overwhelmed with the number of character names mentioned in this one that are references to characters in the first book.
Note: I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
The main focus of the story is solving a murder– one that Francie worries her brother has committed– but it touches on several other current social and environmental issues, such as the pipeline projects and their impact on the environment and indigenous people as well as poaching and smuggling, in an organic, non-intrusive way.
I really enjoyed the goofy characters and snappy dialogue in ENCHANTMENT LAKE, and A CLUE IN THE TREES delivered on this as well. Raven has a way of cutting straight to the heart of an issue, something that helps Francie focus and keeps her honest. We still get glimpses of Francie’s great aunts and a bit of their shenanigans, but a lot of the interaction comes from Francie, Raven, and Jay.
I enjoyed reading this book and following along to uncover the truth about who committed the murder. In some places, Francie’s search for information about her mom overshadows the mystery, but I didn’t mind that too much, as I’m pretty invested in the series at this point, so I’m hoping that’s a thread that will continue to unravel in the third book, THE SILVER BOX (which I’ll be reviewing soon, too).
I recommend starting with ENCHANTMENT LAKE. This is a separate mystery story, so you could follow the plot of this one just fine if you read it first, but I think it’s worth getting that introduction to Francie’s family and the town of Walpurgis. Otherwise you might feel overwhelmed with the number of character names mentioned in this one that are references to characters in the first book.
Note: I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
July 30, 2017
This is book two in the Northwoods series. I was not aware of that when I started reading and to be honest, I was just fine without reading the first. I am sure I missed details from not reading the first, but the author gave plenty of character information that I was just fine starting with book two. Francie meets what I have to assume are her new friends and partners in investigation for future books in this book so they were new to even those who read book one. The mystery was solved in this book as was the mystery in books one, however, there is an ongoing mystery related to Francie, Theo (her brother, and their mom. That mystery was as intriguing as the main mystery in the book if not more so. I really enjoyed this book and am looking forward to reading more from this series for new mysteries and to learn more about what Theo and Francie can learn about their mother. This book was listed as "children's fiction" and rightly so, but I am not going to lie, as an adult, I really enjoyed reading this book. I give this a 3.5, but rounded to 4.
August 25, 2017
This book follows Francie, an aspiring teen actress and reluctant detective, as she tries, unsuccessfully to avoid solving a murder that takes place at an archaeological dig site. Her brother has just come back into the picture, and his weird behavior makes her think he might have had something to do with it. It is a fun mystery story, with plenty of details about the picturesque setting of the Minnesota northwoods. I don't think it was written quite as well as Margi Preus' other titles, but I do think the intended audience will enjoy reading it. While I thought the characters and story itself could be more developed, I appreciated that it was a shorter read. Besides getting a better sense of the northwoods, this book works in details about Native Americans, pipelines and the environmental impact, mastodons, and more. My favorite characters are probably the quirky aunts. This is the second in the series, and I did think it helped to have the read the first book, but probably not necessary.
I received an advance copy from Netgalley.
I received an advance copy from Netgalley.
September 13, 2017
The Clue in the Trees
An Enchantment Lake Mystery
by Margi Preus
University of Minnesota Press
Univ Of Minnesota Press
Middle Grade
Pub Date 19 Sep 2017
I am reviewing The Clue in the Trees throwing University of Minnesota Press and Netgalley:
Francine's brother Theo is hiding secrets, secrets she thinks she wants to know, but what if they are secrets she really doesn't want to know? Instead of considering the possibility of her brother being a murderer so she jumps into her Senior Year at a small town high school near Enchantment Lake in Northern Minnesota a far different experience than the private school she attended in New York.
But it's hard to deny the fact that wherever her brother shows up so do dead bodies. When they find Doctor Digby dead only hours after last seeing him alive that morning. But soon Francine finds herself a suspect.
She had hoped things would have settled down by now, but that was far from the case.
I give The Clue In The Trees five out of five stars!
Happy Reading!
September 28, 2020
Now that I've read 3 books in this series (I hesitate to say I've read all the books in this series, because only the author knows if this is it or not) - I decided to go back and review them. I think it's important to know you could read any one of these books as a stand-alone, although they're absolutely lovely as a set. That said, I feel they'd make an excellent gift for a young reader in your life - though I enjoyed them as well. I feel like Francie is a modern day version of Nancy Drew and I can't wait to hand this series over to the young readers in my life. I'm sure they'll love them!
Press writes a whimsical story with a whimsical plot - perfect for middle-grade readers and beyond! The remote location drew me to the story and kept me interested. I didn't feel there were any dull points and each book was a smooth read. Such a fun and quirky mystery that would be entertaining for any reader - and I couldn't leave this 5 star review without mentioning the cover that pulled me in at first glance!
I can't wait to read more books by this delightful Minnesota author!
Press writes a whimsical story with a whimsical plot - perfect for middle-grade readers and beyond! The remote location drew me to the story and kept me interested. I didn't feel there were any dull points and each book was a smooth read. Such a fun and quirky mystery that would be entertaining for any reader - and I couldn't leave this 5 star review without mentioning the cover that pulled me in at first glance!
I can't wait to read more books by this delightful Minnesota author!
September 23, 2017
If you haven’t already be sure to check out my review for the first book here https://criticuncriticalbookwormblog....
Right from the first page this book jumps into the action and we get to meet a charcter I reeeally was looking forward to meeting! Francie’s brother Theo! Then there is soon another mystery or two for Francie to solve, or so everyone assumes it’s up to her to solve.
“Francie, caught off guard,stared back,thinking,Nancy Drew? Are you kidding me?
Francie now lives in town and goes to school there and meets a couple of new interesting friends that might just have some of there own unique detective skills. Of course the Aunt’s are still in the picture. The story wouldn’t be the same without their quirkyness.
There is so many interesting topics in this story! Dinosaur bones,pipeline protests, a mysterious heist,bootlegging and more! All on Enchantment Lake! It’s fast moving and a fun read! I read it in one sitting. I don’t totally agree that this is Middle Grade, I think it is definitely mature enough for YA and I think anyone at any age would love this if they are looking for a fun little mystery.
I love Margi Preus writing and enjoyed this series so much so far, I look forward to a third book and reading Margi’s others books!
Blog Review and Giveaway: https://criticuncriticalbookwormblog....
Right from the first page this book jumps into the action and we get to meet a charcter I reeeally was looking forward to meeting! Francie’s brother Theo! Then there is soon another mystery or two for Francie to solve, or so everyone assumes it’s up to her to solve.
“Francie, caught off guard,stared back,thinking,Nancy Drew? Are you kidding me?
Francie now lives in town and goes to school there and meets a couple of new interesting friends that might just have some of there own unique detective skills. Of course the Aunt’s are still in the picture. The story wouldn’t be the same without their quirkyness.
There is so many interesting topics in this story! Dinosaur bones,pipeline protests, a mysterious heist,bootlegging and more! All on Enchantment Lake! It’s fast moving and a fun read! I read it in one sitting. I don’t totally agree that this is Middle Grade, I think it is definitely mature enough for YA and I think anyone at any age would love this if they are looking for a fun little mystery.
I love Margi Preus writing and enjoyed this series so much so far, I look forward to a third book and reading Margi’s others books!
Blog Review and Giveaway: https://criticuncriticalbookwormblog....
October 20, 2020
The Clue in the Trees brings back old characters we love. We're also introduced to Francie's brother Theo. A murder mystery with Francie front and center in the spotlight, and other mysteries surrounding her brother are the main driving forces in this second installment. You can read this on its own, but reading book one first will give you a better feel for the characters and how they interact. Although this is written for teens, adults can easily enjoy this series. Recommend for teen mystery lovers and adults who enjoy cozy mysteries.
January 8, 2018
Meh...this may have been better if I had read book 1. However, the characters didn’t feel real to me, nor did they feel of this century. Their language and lack of technology made the teens seem as if they were from the 1950s. I just wasn’t sure of the target audience YA, middle-grade, or elementary.
March 5, 2021
3.5
I liked this one more than the first but I feel like this would have done better as a middle grade series instead of YA. The covers, the writing and the way the kids act at times feel more 7th or 8th graders. Maybe 9th grade if I’m stretching it but not seniors or high school graduates.
I will be finishing the last one soon so I’ll wrap up the trilogy then.
I liked this one more than the first but I feel like this would have done better as a middle grade series instead of YA. The covers, the writing and the way the kids act at times feel more 7th or 8th graders. Maybe 9th grade if I’m stretching it but not seniors or high school graduates.
I will be finishing the last one soon so I’ll wrap up the trilogy then.
August 5, 2017
Definitely more of a middle grade than YA book. I also felt that I missed on any real character development not having read the first book. An okay read, but I think it needs to be read in order.
Full disclosure - I received a copy of the book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review
Full disclosure - I received a copy of the book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review
October 3, 2017
This book is the second book in the enchantment lake mystery series. Even though this book is the second, it can be read as a standalone. This was a fast-paced, cozy mystery book. I enjoyed this book it was fun and quick and with interesting characters and murder!What more could you want?
January 31, 2018
Received this from a Goodreads Giveaway. A light, entertaining mystery - now I want to go to Minnesota! An enjoyable read.
December 6, 2024
These books are good. The mystery keeps unraveling!
September 29, 2017
Received access to an e-ARC of the clue in the trees by Margi Preus courtesy of University of Minnesota Press and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The book featured a Native/Indigenous secondary character named Raven, which was very cool. The story, however unintentionally, exoticized Raven which was not very cool. References to her coffee and cream skin and exotic eyes were not welcome. References to the racism Raven faces living in Enchantment Lake was appreciated, even if I didn't get the sense the main character really got any of Raven's struggles.
Honestly, outside of what was happening with her brother, I didn't get the sense Francie got or cared to get anything anybody was going through. The character was wildly myopic in a way that somehow totally lacked introspection--and the story rewards that introspection! She doesn't want to get involved in the murder--why on Earth would she?--so she signs up for a play to avoid it and wins the lead role! (This was such a minor subplot that it could have been left out entirely without any change to the story.) She's an alleged outcast but a whole group of people dress up as her at Halloween.
She nominally wants no part of the murder yet people keep asking about it! She's a suspect in the murder yet doesn't really suffer any consequences for this. She's initially judgmental of Raven because the annoying racist students make a crack about Raven being arrested when they first meet. This just after Francie internal monologuing how she wished she belonged to some group and yet hopes the freshman don't talk to her either. And let's not even get into the back flips she does to protect her brother despite the fact he's a complete cypher who lies to her. And she lies, too! Constantly.
Let's not even get into her weird parental situation. The resolution about her mother was weird at best. I don't know if that's meant to set up a bigger story arc, but it was just bizarre, totally out of keeping with the rest of the story. Her relationship with her aunts is likewise oddly ephemeral. None of Francie's relationships have any weight to them. Not her so-called friendships with Raven and Jay, who don't actually feel like characters but cardboard cutouts; not her relationship with Ned (was it Ned?) off at college; not her brother-sister bond with Theo; not even her incessant need to know who and what her mother was. None of these relationships felt compelling.
Full disclosure: When I requested this book, I did not realize it was a continuation of an existing series. I would have passed had I known, because every reference to previous goings-on in this story far exceeded the actual events of this story. I recognize this is harsh, but I was expecting a read that was at least fun and I got something that was tonally uneven at best.
From the beginning of the story, I wasn't sure what I was going to get. I got a dozen paranormal clues tossed at me that turned out to be red herrings. Then there was a school subplot that was equally wasted. There were smatterings of rivalry? A touch of Francie suffering the life of an outcast, and then she was cast in a play because she's just THAT GOOD. There's a murder but it's not very interesting. There are apparently loads of suspects but we only meet a few and none of them are really convincing or memorable. There's no tension to speak of. Even when endangered there was no sense that the characters might actually be harmed. Even when Francie is a SUSPECT, there's no tension. Even when she thinks her brother might be a murderer, most of the conflict is Francie's refusal to outright ask him about that night! And the topic of their missing/deceased mother, which is belabored to death, is only tense because Theo keeps avoiding the topic with cryptic, ultimately ridiculous one-liners and they keep getting interrupted. Pointless.
The events of this book are YA lite, but the writing is unquestionably middle grade, and I find myself unable to reconcile the two, because the final results are just bland. It isn't suspenseful. The mystery, for me, is trite. The relationships are shallow. The characters are one-dimensional. The setting isn't even very compelling because Halloween manages to sneak up on us somehow! If this were an adult cozy mystery, this story might pass muster, but as what is effectively a lower-YA novel billed as MG, it just doesn't make the grade for me.
2.5 stars, rounding up because I sort of like the cover art.
The book featured a Native/Indigenous secondary character named Raven, which was very cool. The story, however unintentionally, exoticized Raven which was not very cool. References to her coffee and cream skin and exotic eyes were not welcome. References to the racism Raven faces living in Enchantment Lake was appreciated, even if I didn't get the sense the main character really got any of Raven's struggles.
Honestly, outside of what was happening with her brother, I didn't get the sense Francie got or cared to get anything anybody was going through. The character was wildly myopic in a way that somehow totally lacked introspection--and the story rewards that introspection! She doesn't want to get involved in the murder--why on Earth would she?--so she signs up for a play to avoid it and wins the lead role! (This was such a minor subplot that it could have been left out entirely without any change to the story.) She's an alleged outcast but a whole group of people dress up as her at Halloween.
She nominally wants no part of the murder yet people keep asking about it! She's a suspect in the murder yet doesn't really suffer any consequences for this. She's initially judgmental of Raven because the annoying racist students make a crack about Raven being arrested when they first meet. This just after Francie internal monologuing how she wished she belonged to some group and yet hopes the freshman don't talk to her either. And let's not even get into the back flips she does to protect her brother despite the fact he's a complete cypher who lies to her. And she lies, too! Constantly.
Let's not even get into her weird parental situation. The resolution about her mother was weird at best. I don't know if that's meant to set up a bigger story arc, but it was just bizarre, totally out of keeping with the rest of the story. Her relationship with her aunts is likewise oddly ephemeral. None of Francie's relationships have any weight to them. Not her so-called friendships with Raven and Jay, who don't actually feel like characters but cardboard cutouts; not her relationship with Ned (was it Ned?) off at college; not her brother-sister bond with Theo; not even her incessant need to know who and what her mother was. None of these relationships felt compelling.
Full disclosure: When I requested this book, I did not realize it was a continuation of an existing series. I would have passed had I known, because every reference to previous goings-on in this story far exceeded the actual events of this story. I recognize this is harsh, but I was expecting a read that was at least fun and I got something that was tonally uneven at best.
From the beginning of the story, I wasn't sure what I was going to get. I got a dozen paranormal clues tossed at me that turned out to be red herrings. Then there was a school subplot that was equally wasted. There were smatterings of rivalry? A touch of Francie suffering the life of an outcast, and then she was cast in a play because she's just THAT GOOD. There's a murder but it's not very interesting. There are apparently loads of suspects but we only meet a few and none of them are really convincing or memorable. There's no tension to speak of. Even when endangered there was no sense that the characters might actually be harmed. Even when Francie is a SUSPECT, there's no tension. Even when she thinks her brother might be a murderer, most of the conflict is Francie's refusal to outright ask him about that night! And the topic of their missing/deceased mother, which is belabored to death, is only tense because Theo keeps avoiding the topic with cryptic, ultimately ridiculous one-liners and they keep getting interrupted. Pointless.
The events of this book are YA lite, but the writing is unquestionably middle grade, and I find myself unable to reconcile the two, because the final results are just bland. It isn't suspenseful. The mystery, for me, is trite. The relationships are shallow. The characters are one-dimensional. The setting isn't even very compelling because Halloween manages to sneak up on us somehow! If this were an adult cozy mystery, this story might pass muster, but as what is effectively a lower-YA novel billed as MG, it just doesn't make the grade for me.
2.5 stars, rounding up because I sort of like the cover art.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 8, 2017
** I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own**
This was a fun mystery book with a cozy feel. It is actually the second book in a series, but I found it enjoyable without having read the first. It kept me on the edge of my seat without being scary, and although the main character is in her senior year at high school I thought it had a middle grade feel.
This was a fun mystery book with a cozy feel. It is actually the second book in a series, but I found it enjoyable without having read the first. It kept me on the edge of my seat without being scary, and although the main character is in her senior year at high school I thought it had a middle grade feel.
December 12, 2017
Francie Frye returns to the backwoods sleuthing when a famous archaeologist is found dead in his tent. With the sudden reappearance of her brother Theo, who tends to pop in and out of her life, his mysterious actions, and secrets, she starts thinking of him as potential suspect. This is the second book in a Northwoods Mysteries Series by Margi Preus. Her first book in the series is "Enchantment Lake." I love it that Margi Preus sets these mysteries in the Northwoods of Minnesota. There are plenty of places to hide, and a wealth of history up here, from bootlegging to bogs. I also like how she weaves other stories into this one. Francie is an actress. She auditions for the school play, Antigone, and gets the lead. Preus draws parallels with the classic play to Francie's life. Preus is an excellent writer. Her books have great pacing, action, adventure, and characters you care about and root for. I'm looking forward to the next installment in this series!
December 1, 2018
Loved it
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews