Beginning in 1968 and continuing into the 1970s, a predator stalked California and New York, torturing, raping and murdering young girls and women. But who was the monster behind these tragedies?
Eventually, a suspect emerged, but he didn’t look like a monster. Indeed, Rodney Alcala was a handsome, charming photographer who’d once studied film at New York University under director Roman Polanski. With his wit and easy self-confidence and humor, he’d even been selected as the “winner” on the popular television show “The Dating Game.” But his real game was much more sinister.
In 2010, Alcala was convicted of murdering five women in California during the 1970s; then in 2013, as he waited on Death Row, he confessed to the murder of two more in New York. Yet, that might not be the end of the nightmare he caused. At his arrest, police found his “portfolio” with thousands of nude and erotic photographs of women and boys, who may also be among his victims.
In “THE KILLING GAME,” bestselling true crime author and radio show host, Alan R. Warren reveals the shocking details of Alcala’s brutal crimes, as well as the trials and appeals that stretched on for decades and may still not be over.
ALAN R. WARREN is the Host of the Popular True Crime History Radio show 'House of Mystery' Heard in the NBC news talk radio network on KCAA 106.5 F.M. Los Angeles/Riverside/Palm Springs http://www.houseofmysteryradio.com/
Al Warren has his Doctorate in Religious Studies (DD), Masters Degree ( MM) in Music from the University of Washington in Seattle, Bachelor of Arts (BA ) Criminology from the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, B.C. Canada and Recording & Sound Engineering Diploma from the Juno Award Winning Bullfrog Studios in Vancouver B.C. Canada. He got his start on Digital Radio for the Z Talk Radio Network and still produces several shows for them.
Al Started Writing for Articles in True Case Files Magazine and is still a Contributor and Serial Killer magazine. Since then he has completed 12 true crime books for two different publishers ( RJ Parker/Vronksy Publishing in Toronto, Canada & WildBlue Press in America)
His bestsellers include 'Above Suspicion' The True Story of Colonel Russell Williams, 'Blood Thirst' the true story of the Vampire Killer of Canada, 'Deadly Betrayal' the true story of Jennifer Pan , 'Last Man Standing' the true story of Jack McCullough, the man that was put away for the oldest unsolved murder case in America, and has since then been released as he did not do the crime. You can read more about him on his website.
A Special Note from the author... "On Tuesday, April 2, this past Autism Awareness Day 2019, I decided to let my fans of both radio and writing that I myself am autistic. The struggle for me to speak the words that I could only read has taken many years of work and practice in order to fool broadcasters into hiring me for radio. Even then I kept is secret as I worked to allow the writer in my mind to be able to get those words on paper. I dedicate all of my public works to any others out there struggling with the same challenge that I have, as well as any obstacles you might have in accomplishing your dreams." - Alan R Warren
The Killing Game: The True Story Of Rodney Alcala SECOND EDITION
This Second Edition of the book is a good true crime read, even if you haven't read the original. I enjoyed this Second Edition of Warren’s book on Rodney Alcala. The killer has since died on July 24, 2021 in prison. There remains much mystery around his total number of victims, with all of the pictures recovered of people he photographed. It is unknown how many are still living and how many are potential victims. Hopefully law enforcement will continue to investigate this.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I had never heard of Rodney Alcala until I saw the blurb for this book on NetGalley. Being a fan of true crime stories, I was immediately interested in digging into the mind and background of someone who could commit such horrible and heart-breaking crimes, and in the midst of it all, appear on a TV game show looking for a date! I was also, as always when I read true crime, expecting to learn about the victims and their families, not just as casualties or names on a page, but as real people with hopes, dreams, and their own histories that caused fate to place them in the path of a disturbed individual. I still hope to read that book someday, but this wasn't it.
The Killing Game reads like a poorly constructed school report. It is as dry as a bone, and there is very little background information about Alcala himself or his victims to make them seem anything more than just statistics. I felt like I could have gotten all of this information myself just by doing a Google search. It's hard to imagine that a true crime story could be boring, and I even hesitate to write this, as it dishonors the victims, but I couldn't wait to get through the book. The final section on Alcala's last trial was perhaps the most interesting, ironically, since most of that was simply direct verbiage from the trial, and not even the author's words.
I'm always sorry to rate a NetGalley book so low, as I'm honored to be given the chance to read and review these stories. However, I can't give this one more than 1 star. Many thanks to NetGalley and WildBlue Press for the opportunity to read in exchange for my honest review.
In 1980, serial killer Rodney Alcala was convicted of the kidnapping, sexual assualt, and murder of 13-year-old Robin Simcoe. He is known today as the game show killer, not because his crimes had anything to do with game shows, but because in the middle of a 10 year crime spree, he appeared on (and won) The Dating Game. Luckily for the contestant who won a date with him, she was more astute at judging character than the young girls that Alcala usually preyed upon. In fact, she declined the date because she found him "creepy." She was very, very right.
The story may be interesting (albeit horrifying), but unfortunately, The Killing Game adds little or no insight into Alcala or his crimes. The writing style is terse and might, with a fair amount of editing, make an adequate podcast (maybe), but it does not translate to the page well. There are a couple lengthy asides that sound like they came straight from Wikipedia articles; in addition, there are lengthy awkward hard-to-follow descriptions of crime scenes that would be better served by simply telling us the killer arranged his victims' bodies in lewd or sexual positions. The emphasis Warren gives to exactly how the bodies were positioned makes this an extremely uncomfortable read, as if the author is himself or anticipates an audience that might be titillated by this type of information. (The horrific excerpt from his next book that appears at the back of this one seems to confirm this. It describes a brutal rape/murder in very exact detail. The writing in the excerpt is unedited and genuinely atrociously bad.)
I picked this up on a whim from the new book shelf at the public library, because I had recently heard of Alcala and wondered how he had managed to commit so many crimes and get away with them for so long (AND appear on a dating show AND win). This book didn't provide much insight. I am 100 percent sure there are better books out there on the subject than this badly written, inadequately researched mediocrity. I highly recommend reading anything else.
In September of 1968, Rodney Alcala, a 22 year-old Mexican-American, abducted and raped Talia Shapiro. She was saved by the LAPD, but Rodney escaped. He was captured three years later, but because the Shapiro family had moved to Mexico, the court was forced to accept a plea agreement of molestation. A prison shrink determined that Rodney was just fine and he was released after 34 months in the clink. In 1975, he abducted a 13 year-old girl, was caught, and spent another 2 and a half years in jail. While on parole, he was allowed to travel to my state, New York, and guess what, another one bites the dust. Ellen Hover’s skeletal remains turned up on the Rockefeller estate, here in Westchester County. While again on parole, Rod appeared on the Dating Game and won. His date was creeped out by him and refused her prize. Warren describes numerous murders in graphic, anatomical detail. In the meantime, Alcala worked at a photo studio and used it as a guise to lure teenage girls to pose for pictures, sometimes nude. In February of 1980, Alcala went on trial for the kidnapping and murder of 12 year-old Robin Samsoe. The next stop would be San Quentin and a supposed visit to the gas chamber. I flashed back to Susan Hayward in I Want to Live, as she is led into the void. Hollywood fabricated the circumstances of Barbara Graham’s innocence. She was a hooker in real life, not an innocent deer caught in the headlights. Caryl Chessman was also gassed in California for rape. As for Alcala, the California appeals process kept him alive for years, and resulted in two retrials. Florida would have fried his ass, as they to Ted Bundy in 1989. Alcala was finally defeated by the wonderful world of modern science in the form of DNA. He represented himself at trial, and, like Bundy, had a fool for a client. Killing Game is only about 120 unnumbered pages, and Alcala deserves a longer, Ann Rule style treatment with a more extensive history. My top five serial killers: 1.Ted Bundy. 2 .Richard Kuklinski(Ice Man) 3.(tie) Alcala. 3. Edmund Kemper. 5. H.H. Holmes. P.S. Manson was a chicken**** who had others do his dirty work, including young women.
Starting in 1968 and continuing into the 1970s, Rodney Alcala stalked young women in California and New York, raping, strangling, and killing many. He was able to hide in plain sight, due to his charming nature and big personality. He was even a winning contestant on the popular television show "The Dating Game" during this time. After many years of trials and pain, Alcala was finally convicted of five murders in 2010. Currently, police are still asking for the public's help in identifying the girls and women in his photograph collection, hoping that they are found or their murders are brought to justice. Today, Alcala remains in California State Prison, Corcoran.
While I found this case to be an interesting read, there was something that was not connecting between the material and the author. There was not any new or additional information that people familiar with this case would not have known before. If you have seen a television special, or even read through the Wikipedia article on Rodney Alcala, you have read everything in this book. I would have liked to read more about the mind of Alcala or the voices of the victims but these were not included. I also found the writing style to be disconnected from the subject material. If you are writing about horrendous crimes, you probably should lay off of the exclamation points and the conversational tone. It was a good book if you have never heard about Alcala but for those of us that have, it was just a rehashing of old information.
Thanks to NetGalley and WildBlue Press for the ARC.
This is a well-written and well-researched story about California serial killer Rodney Alcala. His story is told in sufficient detail that one cannot doubt his guilt. Alcala was tried three times for the kidnapping, rape and murder of 12-year-old Robin Samsoe, receiving the death penalty after each conviction. During the third trial, charges were added for four additional murders, thanks to the availability of DNA identification.
Alcala was subsequently tried and convicted of two additional murders in New York where he received a sentence of 25 years to life. New York does not have a death penalty. In fact, a death penalty in California is an empty victory as they warehouse their death row inmates and never carry out an execution of the death penalty.
3.5 - To the point, albeit, repetitive. I think I might have heard of Rodney Alcala in passing but realizing he’d made it onto The Dating Game in the middle of his crime spree was what got me to pick up the book. My heart goes out to his victims and their families. Unimaginable.
Alan R. Warren once again proves why he is one of today’s most compelling true crime authors with The Killing Game. In this meticulously researched account, Warren pulls back the mask on Rodney Alcala, a man whose charm and outward success hid one of the most sadistic serial killers in modern history.
The story begins in the late 1960s, as young women and girls in California and New York fell prey to a mysterious predator. For years, the crimes remained unsolved, with few realizing that the “handsome” and “talented” photographer—who had even won an appearance on The Dating Game—was in fact the monster behind the horrors. Warren expertly guides the reader through Alcala’s double life, from his time studying film under Roman Polanski to his decades-long trail of terror, manipulation, and legal wrangling.
What makes this book stand out is Warren’s ability to combine detailed investigative research with a narrative that is both chilling and engaging. The shocking discovery of Alcala’s portfolio—thousands of photographs of women and boys, many still unidentified—underscores the possibility that the true scope of his crimes has yet to be fully known. Warren doesn’t sensationalize but instead lays out the facts in a way that highlights the sheer audacity of Alcala’s deception and the failures that allowed him to continue his killing spree for so long.
The Killing Game is not just the story of a serial killer, but a reminder of the fragility of trust and the dangers that can lurk behind even the most disarming smiles. It’s a gripping, disturbing, and unforgettable book that will haunt readers long after they’ve turned the final page.
Rodney Alcala, born in 1943 in San Antonio, Texas, is believed to have raped and murdered around 130 people. Alcala committed his first known crime (rape of an 8 year old girl) in 1968, at the age of 25 while a student at UCLA. Due to the unavailability of the witness (she had moved back to Mexico with her family), Alcala was given a sentance of only 1 year to life, and released on parole after 34 months.
That was just the beginning of the horrific crimes of torture, rape, and murder that Alcala would commit during his lifetime.
I am giving the book 3 stars out of 5, as I neither really liked, nor really disliked it.
While I usually enjoy a true crime story, I found that this book while being extremely detailed and obviously well researched, lacked the human element -- both in the telling of the background story of the killer himself, and also in the telling of the story of the victims. I felt like I was reading some legal document, which was spelling out the facts of the case to a judge, rather than a novel.
I am a huge True Crime fan who listens to many Podcasts and read many books on the subject. The Killing Game is a in-depth and fascinating look into one of the most disturbing and mysterious Killers is United States history. Not only does it dive deep into the life of Rodney Alcala it goes into detail about the victims and gives them a voice that always is appreciated in my book. It helps give the subject matter more levity and helps break up some of the more serious crimes and topics that are discussed. I hope more people read and discover this story to help police find his other victims and the thousands of people in the pictures he took. Overall this is a great read that you must check out if you love true crime.
This book is a WOW! I had never heard of this serial killer before. I thought that this book was a great over view of the killings and the serial killer. However, I wish that there was more information on the victims and of the background of the serial killer himself. I felt that this was a great start for the subject and I just wish that there was more information. I devoured this book in one sitting! I can't believe that a serial killer was on the Dating Game show. WOW! I learned something new.
i love the way the chapters of this book were organized to the names of victims. Made it easier to keep up with dates and events, plus I felt it made the book more about the people who had the horrendous misfortune of meeting Rodney Alcala. Could tell I was really enjoying reading this book because of how irritated I got whenever I was interrupted.
Interesting book about this serial killer. some seriously disturbing atrocities from him for sure. I can't imagine what the victims and families must have gone through. anyone else ever heard of him?
This is a great read. It's gory, but written in a professional way so the reader gets the point. I plan to read more true crime by this author. This is why I love Kindle so much.
It was an OK true-crime story that broke down his murders and many trials/re-trials but never really delved into the psychology of what drove him to do these horrendous deeds.
Rodney Alcala aka the dating game killer was finally tried in 2010 for the murders of 5 young women. While searching his belongings, the police found hundreds of nude pictures of women and young boys. They theorize that there must be more deaths and then Alcala admits to only 2 more. I watched the show that dating game that he was on and was taken aback by his looks and charm yet I knew what he had done. When I requested this book, I was hoping it would give the reader some background on Alcala and I was not disappointed.The writer included all pertinent information without going overboard on things not so much of interest. I learned things that I was not aware of and Feel that the author has done an amazing job researching everything for his book. I highly recommend this one to anyone who enjoys true crime,
Thank you to netgalley as well as the author/publisher for allowing me to read this book in exchange for my honest review.