In Drums of War, Drums of Development, Glassman offers an interpretation of industrialization in East and Southeast Asia that foregrounds Pacific ruling class geopolitical economic manoeuvring during the Vietnam War, challenging interpretations that ignore the effects of military violence.
Most of the accounts of East Asian development that aren't pabulum come from a sort of centre-left Keynesian or 'neo-Weberian' place, which is broadly accepting of capitalism but highly critical of neoliberalism - Robert Wade on Taiwan, Alice Amsden on Korea, Chalmers Johnson on Japan, Ha-Joon Chang more generally, etc. But there's quite little in the way of Marxist accounts, except to a degree on the PRC (do you know how many books Verso has published on Japan, the world's second or third largest economy for all the time Verso has been around? Two). This is from the Historical Materialism series, which also had a very interesting recent book on State Capitalism in East Asia. While that gets a little too bogged down for me in trying to justify Tony Cliff Thought, this is much more of a frontal account, taking on the "Neo-Weberians" directly and taking a long historical and geographical view. It's highly convincing in its central thesis on the immense importance of the Vietnam War and the US Military Industrial Complex in East Asian capitalist development, and it's even rather good on why this 'worked' in some countries and not others (Thailand, the Phillipines, which lacked 'disciplining of finance' and land reform...here the argument is remarkably similar to books the author probably abhors, like 'How Asia Works' by Joe Studwell). It's sketchier but I suspect accurate too on how much this all involved taking it all out on the working class in each country.
So it's good, helped by tart, often ironic writing, and it shows Marxism can after all be useful in understanding what happened here (important for Marxism that it can be, imo!!), but all that said it's hilarious that this devotes a couple of pages to South Korea locking up most of its major capitalists and nationalising all its banks - mainly to argue it wasn't that important - but devotes 200 pages or so to Gramsci, American elite formation, Lee Kuan Yew's belief in race science, and the precise nature of the presents given to each other by American and Asian leaders at summits in the 1960s.
Impressive and expansive work, centring the (US) military industrial complex's role in the development of ESEA states, particularly in the context of the Viet Nam War Geo-political economic approach should take violence and warfare to be integral aspects of capitalist class relations, rather than external factors Although the omission of Indonesia and Malaysia was notable, if accounted for by the author, the book's broad span convincingly breaks down and critiques Neo-Weberian analysis and explanation of ESEA development that exclude geographical-historical specificities and path-dependence in favour of common denominators such as nodal planning agencies and EOI industrial policies
Japan's postwar recovery and industrial transformation, along with the construction of a Japanese developmental state were in crucial ways the products of collaboration between US and Japanese elites The importance of offshore procurement (OSP) illustrates the deep fusion of economic and military interests within the process of Pacific ruling class formation OSP has a a significance that goes the quantitative volume of capital it pumps into the economy, OSP provides a direct subsidy and protected market opportunity to specific industrial firms, thus contributing in tangible ways to the very processes of learning, development of engineering skills, and technological upgrading that concern developmental states. Thus, the enormous windfalls to Korean firms from Cold War OSP need to be factored among the crucial conditions for the success of both Korean chaebol and the developmental state
Leans and expands on a range of rich literature, for example Bruce Cumings' (1981,1990) work framing the Korean War as one concerning the colonial legacies left by Japanese occupation and by the Koreans who struggled against or collaborated with it. In contrast to the blunt, typical narrative of a large-scale confrontation between major powers - USA and the Soviet Union In addition Cumings drawing out the very different colonial experiences South Korea and Taiwan had under Japan, and different popular reaction to such experiences were factors that conditioned later political environments
Other key themes discussed included: Specificities like Singapore inheriting a first-class naval facility from the British Royal Naval at Sembawang upon the latter's departure that enabled them to be used for the maintenance and repair of military vessels, in contrast to the US stripping infrastructure and floating docks from Subic Bay in the Philippines when it pulled out in the 90s US interactions with ESEA leaders were tinged with orientalism as they largely produced and reproduced understandings of a static essentialised Asian otherness that was internally consistent and resistant to change, in contrast to the dynamic realities on the ground
Pretty good overall begins with a somewhat interesting if perhaps not strictly necessary excavation of Gramsci and geopolitical economy. I don’t know I find the debates over the “transnational” or “international” or “multinational” character of capital not especially exciting and for which variety of paradigms could get the job done in explaining the facts. Gets into, again, a not exactly dry but certainly excessively granular reading of the diplomatic history of the Brown memorandum which authorized Korean troops to enter the Vietnam War in exchange for tech transfer and contracts. Here we finally get to the interesting portion where the role of the Korean War and Vietnam War in fueling Japanese and Korean development respectively come in via OSP. Unfortunately after here the depth of the arguments he makes declines right at the point where I would’ve really appreciated a fully fleshed out argument. I picked this up mainly as a study in the role US imperialism played in shaping different developmental outcomes in Asia and while that’s there it’s not as developed as certain other things which were a bit less marginal for me though not necessarily irrelevant (like certain elite gift giving rituals). Still if you have the time I think it still chock full of interesting charts and citations and is generally agreeable.
Though it seems this book was at first made to respond specifically to the type of people who say “You want to see how communism vs. capitalism play out, just look at North vs. South Korea” it is so much more. Everything from the theoretical chapters constructing the authors view of “geo-political economy” to the specific details of negotiations between the US and its numerous Asian allies in the Cold War is insightful. The book lays out and convincingly argues a case that is best summarized by the understanding that the supposed “East Asian Economic Miracle” was tied, in a perverse way, to the “East Asian Massacres” just some years before.
If I could boil down how this book affected me, I would say it greatly reaffirmed war and catastrophic violence as in the absolute core of capitalism’s being. I mean this in that it is both a tool of discipline, and also a foundation upon which capital accumulation and what we call “development” can take place. This was certainly the case with south Korea.
With one last comment about south Korea, I would respond to the comment in the first sentence by saying “Fine. If you want to follow the capitalist south Korean road, you must first subject your population to conditions of borderline slavery, and then you must help kill some ~3 million Vietnamese, as that is how they became the country they are today.”
While the book gets quite meticulous in places where it might not have need to, and quickly glosses over some places where it should've gone further into, Jim Glassman's "Drums of War, Drums of Development" is still a compelling tome dissecting the oft-hidden geopolitical and economic circumstances behind the mythos of the "East Asian Miracle". If it has a central point to make, it would be that violence is not something peripheral but inherent to capitalism, that the trajectories of these countries cannot be caricatured to the "free market" or dispassionate state directives, but the result of a multifaceted and multitudinous class war. The colonial dynamic was modified into a similar exploitative, extractive national dynamic post-independence. In an era where Southeast Asia is once again being hyped up by liberal economists as the rising star, and technocrats the world over turn to South Korea for near-mystical guidance, it is important to peel back the aura and recognize the real motives behind that rhetoric.