We Belong to the Land: The Story of a Palestinian Israeli Who Lives for Peace and Reconciliation

by Elias; Mary E. Jensen Chacour

WE BELONG TO THE LAND, THE STORY OF A PALESTINIAN ISRAELI WHO LIVES FOR PEACE AND RECONCILIATION, ELIAS CHACOUR, MARY JENSEN.

Genres: Nonfiction, History, Middle East, Memoir, Religion, Biography, Israel

212 pages, Hardcover

First published October 1, 1990

Reviews

[Lucasparry2002 · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a must read for Christians who are interested un understanding the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.

Most of the dialogue we hear from the US media and even within the Christian church is a one-sided story. I believe it is vital to understand the whole story so that we can work together for a solution of peace, which will help in easing conflict and tension all around the world.

Begin here... then read "Blood Brothers" by the same author. Your understanding will never be the same again.

[Evan Hays · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is always the first book that I recommend (and constantly loan out) to anyone who asks me about the Middle East. For those of you who do not know, Abuna is a Melkite Priest (now an Archbishop) in Galilee. He is an Israeli citizen, but he is an Arab. He was expelled from his home at the Nakba, along with his family. His life has been devoted to bringing reconciliation between Israelis and Palestinians, which is an overwhelming task for anyone, let alone a person which neither side would claim fully as their own because he is neither Jewish nor Muslim.

I had the amazing opportunity to meet him in the spring of 2005 during my semester in Cairo, and it was a major blessing to meet him and learn from him. Yes, I do not agree with all of his theology, but I can't say that I would necessarily believe anything different from his particular Palestinian form of liberation theology if I had grown up the way he had. His life has been a serious challenge to me because I believe he has faithfully lived out the gospel in so many ways despite how it easy it would have been for him to resort to hate or despair.

The best part of this book is the way that he uses his life story to talk about the conflict rather than using political rhetoric. My favorite part is when he locks his parishioners in the church until they reconcile, and then they have Easter a week early!

Read this book if you want to learn about what the Middle East conflict is really all about!

[Linda · Rating 3 out of 5]

A pro-Palestnian point of veiw wrtten about a Christian-Palestinian Priest, Elias Chacour, in Galilee. Sort of a back-patting book about all the great things he did for his parish and how brave he was in every circumstance. Yet, there is a lot of unknown history of Paleistine here and I, at least, needed to read it. With the situation in the Middle East continuing for decades, I need to have a broader understanding of what is going on. I have seen Israel as the "right"side in the issue, only to discover the sources of much of the great anger against both Israel and the US concerning the land.

[Jennifer · Rating 5 out of 5]

“We Palestinians and Jews live in what the world calls the Holy Land, but what makes the land holy? Is it the stones or trees? Is it the churches? The shrines? The paths on which the patriarchs and our Lord Jesus Christ walked? Or is the land sanctified by what we do to make God present?”

“Mobile Western people have difficulty comprehending the significance of the land for Palestinians. We belong to the land. We identify with the land, which has been treasured, cultivated, and nurtured by countless generations of ancestors. As a child I joined my family and moving large rocks from the fields. We lay with our backs on the ground and our feet on the rock, and pushed, pushed, all together. Little by little, ‘slow by slow,’ the rock was moved to the side of the field. Perspiration rolled off our bodies, and blood often streamed from our feet, soaking into the ground. It took months to clear the stones from just a small field. The land is so holy, so sacred, to us because we have given it our sweat and blood. It rewards us with wonderful, immense crops. Father could collect up to three tons of dry figs from his fields. Palestinians are at one with their land, and part of them dies when they must be separated from it.”

“Remember, your roots in Galilee go back long before the two-thousand-year-old trees. Your Palestinian ancestors planted these trees, and loved the land. It is from this land you have been removed and into this land you will someday return. From this land God took human form. In this land Jesus of Nazareth gave his word for the redemption of the world. Perhaps you will have something to do with your blood to redeem Jews and Palestinians and to create an environment of negotiation, love, and tolerance.”

“My dear friends, we love you and regret that you hold these those machine guns to threaten, scare, and kill. When you face all olive saplings with machine guns, you have no hope for life. You are scared and you scare others. See these Palestinian youngsters who are all carrying an olive sapling, the tree of peace that promises to endure for centuries! The children are relaxed while you were very tense with machine guns. We shall never give up, but we shall never carry weapons to plant in olive tree and obtain our human rights to home and freedom.”

[Aberdeen · Rating 4 out of 5]

I'm hesitant to rate this or even record that I read it because the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is so complicated and there are real people on both sides. It's even more tricky theologically for Christians, who have Arab Christian brothers and sisters and yet also are related to the Jews somehow (that's a whole can of worms itself). The history of how the Church has treated Jews is horrific, and I want to be a part of the recent change in Christian attitudes toward the Jews (see Nostra Aetate). And yet we must listen to our Palestinian family, too, the first Christians. This is a good glimpse into one Palestinian community (I'd like to see what he thinks about things today, if anything has changed, one way or the other)—and, more importantly, a glimpse into the life an incredibly faithful, loving, Christ-like man of God.

[Richard R., Martin · Rating 5 out of 5]

I highly recommend this book. It is excellent. The author, Elias Chacour, is the former Melkite archbishop of Galilee and a Palestinian. His is the story we do not often hear in the West -- the story of how the Palestinians who are citizens of Israel are treated as second class citizens in their own country; how they experience such great discrimination that makes U.S. discrimination today seem minor. It is also the story of a courageous priest who would stand up to his bishop when he felt that his bishop was not living up to Christ's call in serving his flock. It is a great story of strength, courage and faith in the face of many difficulties and challenges, and it is a call for all of us to confront evil and violence with love, mercy and forgiveness.

[Patty · Rating 4 out of 5]

Elias Chacour is the Archbishop of Galilee of the Melkite Greek Catholic Church. This is the second book of his that I have read. I found this book to cover much of the same ground that his first book, Blood Brothers talks about. That did not detract from this book, but readers should be aware of this fact.

This book will expose the reader to a point of view that we rarely hear about in the United States. Chacour considers himself to be a descendant of Jesus' disciples. His message is that the Israelis and the Palestinians need to live on the same land, in peace.

I wish that I could believe that his desire will ever come true.

[Riley Potter · Rating 5 out of 5]

such a good book!!! I whole heartedly recommend to anyone and everyone who. Written over 30 years ago, it’s a testament to the power of faith and perseverance in the quest for peace and reconciliation in Palestine. Abuna Charcour’s commitment to nonviolence and love for all people is made manifest as he works to bridge chasms between people in his homeland, inviting people of all faiths and from all around the world to join in the work God is doing through him.

[Claudia · Rating 5 out of 5]

What a beautiful story of one man’s refusal to hate, even in the face of horror. “Abuna Elias” fights for justice, but he refuses to use the weapons of his enemies. I am inspired by his relentless hope.

[Shelley Alongi · Rating 3 out of 5]

It seems as if he wanted to live with his neighbors but he always seem to present them in a bad light so I’m not sure why this book that laminated for a little bit of peace prize or what he did. He may be sincere and maybe he wants to point out that he was forced to leave his home he always puts them in a bad light I think. But it was a good read.

[Trevor Leyden · Rating 3 out of 5]

I read this book for my english class and I wasn’t very interested. I would read because I had to and not because I wanted too. Then as I got into the later chapters it started to catch my attention, I started to get more into the book because of what was going on and what Elias believed in. I soon found myself reading 10 pages every night because I wanted to and sometimes I didn't want to stop. I can see why this book was put up 7 times for a Nobel Peace Prize. Elias Chacour describes his life how he grew up in a religious family and what he liked to do as a child such as go on walks with Jesus. When he grew older he tried to make peace with the Israelis and Palestinians. Elias tells us about how he was a priest in Gallie and how it was a struggle to build schools, and libraries. I like this book because it tells you stuff you may have never heard of in regular life. It shows you how much the people are need help and how Elias is doing the right thing trying to get Israelis and Palestinians to make peace because they need to make peace. If the Israelis and Palestinians make peace then the people that live there will be safer because there will be less war. With that being said I think more people need to follow Elias and do what he tried to do for years. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who wants to learn more about the Israelis and Palestinians. This will help your knowledge and will make you excited to see what is next.

[Jeston Mason · Rating 4 out of 5]

I’m happy that I was able to devote the attention to this book that it warrants. I was assigned it with my friends in undergrad, but was not disciplined enough to sit with it and read it.

Chacour is a beautiful example of a creative rebel, seeking nonviolent avenues to end his own experience of oppression, occupation, and division. I’m so inspired by his action in the face of terrifying obstacles.

I am also incredibly impressed with the honesty that he has about himself. He does not minimize his accomplishments in the way that I would be tempted to. In the same way, he does not hold back his frustrations and negative thoughts about people or circumstances he is in.

He writes in a way that is entirely void of shame. And it reminds me that my own experience as a human with my various accomplishments and misgivings is not a story that I should share lightly. Rather, I should share it boldly, because the bold proclamation of my life connects others to me. It allows others to find affirmation of their experience.

But that requires me to trust that I am indeed like other humans. I must believe that I am relatable to others, that they can connect to my experience and, in some way, see a reflection of their own.

Thanks for reading my review that is directly related to the book that I read: We Belong to the Land.

[Blair · Rating 4 out of 5]

Recommended reading to hear a perspective from an Arab Christian from Palestine, who was displaced from his home as a child by Israelis. I found the writing itself to be confusing sometimes as he moved back and forth between different time periods in his life; and sometimes it was too slow. HOWEVER it is still an inspiring read about the Israel/Palestine conflict.

[Diana Kullman · Rating 5 out of 5]

I read Blood Brothers several years ago and saw this one mentioned during these horrific times in Israel and Gaza. Educational and sad and hopeful... The author's father was a refugee in 1997 with his small children.

[Daniel · Rating 4 out of 5]

What an amazing story! Elias Chacour is an inspiration to all of us a prophet in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict

[Kolby Pinkston · Rating 5 out of 5]

In the top 3 books I read for my M.Div.

[John Newbauer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Excellent book

An excellent read. Very interesting and even exciting at times. A story of persecution and triumph, faith and vision. Very personal and yet prophetic.

[Teresa · Rating 5 out of 5]

A local, Christian Palestinian's point of view of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. Worth reading.

[Ivey · Rating 4 out of 5]

I feel like Abuna Elias is the type of Christian that Jesus said people should be

[Rocio · Rating 5 out of 5]

Very good and enlightening. Loved his perspective, knowledge and giving life.

[Julier · Rating 4 out of 5]

Elias Chacour, a Palestinian - Arab-Israeli Melkite Christian priest in the West Bank presented years of personal experiences in an evolving timeline of the conflict between the Palestinian Arabs and the Israeli Jews. I marked lots of things in the book but unfortunately don't have the book now. Chacour met world leaders, including a Pope.

It is still worth reading today, 34 years after publication. Elias Chacour presented personal experiences to illustrate an evolving timeline of the conflict between the Palestinian Arabs and the Israeli Jews from the perspective of a Palestinian - Arab-Israeli Melkite Christian priest in the West Bank.

The Israel/Palestine conflict has existed since before I was born. Much has happened since this book was published in 1990,

"Palestinian-Arab-Christian-Israeli".
Friends lent me an autographed copy of this book almost a year ago.

 the Israelis completed their withdrawal from the Gaza Strip and Jericho in May 1994
In September 1995, Rabin, Arafat, and Peres signed a peace agreement providing for the expansion of Palestinian self-rule in the West Bank and for democratic elections to determine the leadership of the Palestinian Authority. The rest is history and the present.

[Simcha · Rating 4 out of 5]

Elias Chacour is a Palestinian, Arab, Israeli Christian priest. This autobiography covers key highlights in his youth, and time in priestly service in a small village. He covers various interactions he has had with Israeli bureaucracy and the police, bureaucracy and corruption in the church, and his various methods of non-violent peacekeeping.

I hate to say this, but I did feel that he came across as a humblebrag in the way he handled difficult situations, it is kind of suspicious to me that he never really shares an anecdote where he comes across as the bad guy. Of course, several years later we learn that he was accused of sexually assaulting one of his employees, who was later fired. I don't know if there was merit to her accusation or not, though I do tend to believe women who have more to lose in this power dynamic.

Still, I think people are complicated and a bad person (if he is one) can still have a right philosophy and approach to life. In the book and in interviews, he is consistent about his 2 beliefs: God does not kill, and God is love. I appreciated his non-violent approach to resisting occupation and feel that I can empathize more than I did before.

[Brian · Rating 5 out of 5]

What an inspiration this man was and still could be! I am only sad to see a man who was so supple, flexible and effective now allow himself to become hardened and stiff. If only he could retrace his own steps. Never say it can't be done. Look at the Dalai Lama. Abuna Elias Chacour was much more effective and damaging to the hardheads of the bad side of Zionism. (Yes there is a good side, there is good and bad in everything). Was very moved by some of the truths and basic pieces of common sense emitted by the mouth of this man. My own words inspired by this book would be:
"Humans are a beautiful and a terrible thing."

Brian Ross

[Erin · Rating 4 out of 5]

In February I walked into a church, and my life has not been the same since. Many of you have asked me (or yourselves) what I am doing with these "religious nuts", and I am here to tell you that I am radicalizing my understanding of the world. There are many things happening that I can't put words to yet, a shift in some stodgy, dusty old thinking that's no longer serving me. I am opening myself up to new ideas about religion and the religious. How exciting! Wish me luck (and good books) on the journey.

[Kirsten · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is an incredibly moving and inspiring book about an amazing man who, despite obstacles, strives for peace in a troubled area. He loves his oppressors as much as his own people and will stop at nothing to create educational opportunities for the children of his village. I recommend this to anyone interested in learning more about the Israel/Palestine conflict through the eyes of a Palestinian Christian Arab Israeli.

[Mary · Rating 5 out of 5]

So touching and emotional. You think you know all about the history of Israel and Palestine, but this book really opens it all up for you. I think everyone should read this and take a leaf out of Elias Chacour's book. We sure would have alot less wars going on. It is really heartbreaking to read all about the unjust way Palestinians are treated.

[Wesley · Rating 3 out of 5]

Wasn't as good as Blood Brothers, but still very powerful. I was able to visit Chacour's school in the Galilee region. He spoke to our group of 27 students. Irregardless of your agreement with his political-religious messages, he is profoundly a man of peace; when he spoke to us you could feel the love and gentleness that he writes about so astonishingly well in his books. He is no pretender.

[Emily · Rating 4 out of 5]

I am very grateful for this book. It was really my first exposure to what life is like as a Palestinian in Israel. It exposed a lot of misconceptions I had. It was not terribly well written, but kept me interested and was overall a very good meditation on forgiveness. This man seems to live the gospel out.

[Cheryl · Rating 3 out of 5]

In some ways too sweet, a Pollyanna view of life, yet if more people believed this way, the world would be a much better place. A good intro to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, especially for Christian westerners, as it is not too graphic or frightening, and speaks in a religious format they will be familiar with, yet still shows the problems and ideological impasse all sides face.

[Kim · Rating 4 out of 5]

I loved this book. It speaks in a voice that is so often ignored in the dialogue about Israel and Palestine. I learned so much and found myself driven to caring so deeply about the people in it. I would definitely recommend it to anyone with a base knowledge of the conflict.