Very mixed feelings. But I'll start with a bit of context - I like football a lot, I enjoy watching matches (more on TV than at the venue), but I'm very bad at "reading" tactics. What does it mean? I understand tactics (4-3-3, 4-4-2, ...), I understand the positions & roles they play - but all of that in theory, on a scrap of paper (or in Football Manager) - all that theory doesn't correspond to me to what happens on the field. OK, I see the most obvious facts:
- target man deployed in the penalty area
- wingers dashing close to the line
- defenders in line trying to set up an offside trap
etc.
But I don't see more intricate patterns, especially in the midfield - for me, it's actually
hard even to track an individual player's movement (and tactical thinking behind that) - I am intuitively more focused on a more holistic overview of what's happening.
So, as a person missing the connection between the tactical theory & chaos on the pitch, I tried to solve my problem with this book. But ... it didn't work out well. "Zonal ..." is like a sentimental journey across football, starting somewhere in the late 80s until the modern day (early 2020s) - that focuses on the most important matches, key players, and the impact of individual coaches on the grandest teams. This is all quite interesting & pleasant, as I do remember 90% of what is described, but ... there's just (by far) too little tactical depth in that. I openly admit to being far from proficient & still - I don't think I've learned anything ...
I'm struggling to understand who is this book for?
- someone new to football (to learn the tactical basics) - no, because if someone had never seen these players, doesn't remember these matches, it will be a boring chronicle of alien names ...
- someone like me (40+ yo) who has always been an avid fan of football - maybe, but only if what you're looking for is some sentimental journey
I was disappointed, I expected much more.