Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Two couples. One love potion. And a whole lot of mayhem.

Henry Stoepel, Earl of Saalfeld has loved Lady May Cottrell since they were children. He’s proposed three times. She hasn’t said no, but she hasn’t said yes. He decides to give it one more try at his friend’s Christmas ball, knowing this time he might get the answer he dreads.

Mr. Everett Hawley and Lady Lucy Radnor have been engaged for several months. The banns have been read, but her parents invent flimsy excuses postponing the wedding date. Everett is determined to force her parents to fulfill the marriage contract at the Christmas ball.

When a little faerie magic gets mixed with mistletoe, both couples are plunged into mischief and mayhem. Will either get a happily ever after?


Mistletoe Mayhem begins where P.S. I Love You, Twickenham Time Travel Romance Book 1, ended.

166 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 30, 2018

166 people are currently reading
104 people want to read

About the author

Jo Noelle

47 books335 followers
This mother/daughter writing team writes “Sweet, Swoony Ever-Afters.”

Sweet Historical Western under the name Gemma Stuart

Sweet Victorian & Regency Time Travel under the pen name Jo Noelle, who a USA TODAY bestselling author

Sweet Contemporary under the name Evee Tuttle.

They write stories about the places they’ve lived, the places they’ve visited around the world, and the places still on their bucket lists.

Follow us on Amazon, Goodreads, and Bookbub to get notices for all our new releases!

Join our Facebook Groups and chat with us and other readers who love sweet and clean romance.

• Cowboys and Angels and The Matchmaker’s Ball

• Loving Sweet Historical Romance

• Sweet Kisses Readers’ Group

• Sweet and Sassy Books Facebook Page

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
71 (41%)
4 stars
55 (32%)
3 stars
30 (17%)
2 stars
15 (8%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
Profile Image for Elsbeth.
838 reviews
March 7, 2019
Long-distance relationships are not easy. But what about long-time relationships... May has to choose between two loves of her life: Henry in the 19th Century or being a nurse in the 21st.
Lucy has to choose between doing what her parents want or what her heart wants.
Time for a little fae magic...
Which results in a lot of mayhem.
And two marriages.
Wonderful read, with a lot of familiar characters from P.S. I Love You. So nice to see how Cora is doing in the 19th Century.
I'm looking forward to reading Jo Noelle's next book in this series!
203 reviews
May 21, 2023
2.5 stars. This book was a disappointment! There was very little time travel and the plot, while imitating "A Mid-Summer's Night Dream" was actually quite silly - not funny or humorous, just dumb. I'm not really sure what compelled me to even finish it.

Also, reader be ware - this book is published under another title as well, "Midwinter Mayhem".

Another thing to be aware of is that this is the second book and the first is needed to even begin to comprehend the plot. May reviews I read after reading this book stated that they were totally lost and wished someone had told them it wasn't a stand-alone book.

I do enjoy time travel, and I did enjoy the first book of this series, so I'll probably give the third book a chance.
Profile Image for Lisa Swinton.
Author 27 books197 followers
November 22, 2018
I love the Twickenham series and this holiday tale didn't disappoint!

The mayhem is real. A mixed up love potion, what a brilliant idea to add into this charming tale.

Loved the characters, their journeys to HEA, and the setting.

Lots of emotion and good clean writing.

Bring on the next one, please!
2,574 reviews46 followers
October 16, 2019
I've enjoyed the Twickenham series even though I don't usually read a lot of paranormal stuff. I liked this story and there was indeed some mayhem for a bit. It was imperative that there be two couples for this plot line but I have a difficult time with remembering names under the best of circumstances. So having two sets of main characters left me confused sometimes. Not the fault of the book mind you. When the mayhem started my head was really swirling trying to keep straight which two belonged together. Probably doesn't help that I haven't read the books in order so when a reoccurring character comes up (besides Nellie) I don't always recognize who it is. But if you set aside my quirks I think the story was entertaining. I kind of wonder a little about Nellie. Is it possible she knew from the start what mayhem would happen under the mistletoe and used her magic to bring it about knowing that it would resolve in the end but entertain her a bit in the meantime? Maybe. Maybe not. I don't know.

Sex: some kissing
Language: no
Violence: a bit
32 reviews3 followers
February 23, 2019
Oops! Sorry, this one really comes right after the first book in the series. I had forgotten that as I was reviewing the rest of the series. This has two couples that are meant to be together, but are having trouble accomplishing that. Between meddling relatives and a crazy love potion gone array, it will entertain and satisfy at the same time. Enjoy the Christmas themed segment and continue on with the series, it’s fun and rewarding!
Profile Image for Khadejah R..
174 reviews2 followers
March 7, 2019
Reminiscent of A Midsummer Night’s Dream

Mayhem occurs when Aunt Nellie’s unreservedly spreads her matchmaking magic. I was pleased to learn more about May, Lucy, Henry, and Everett. They made up much of P.S. I Love You and was happy to read more of their stories.

It could have become a convoluted mess writing a two love stories with a love square thrown in. A very entertaining read.

I thoroughly enjoyed the ladies growth and decisions.
Profile Image for Melissa.
16 reviews1 follower
August 6, 2019
I've enjoyed the Twickenham Time Travel series so far, but felt that this entry, Mistletoe Mayhem, was jusn't quite as good as the previous books. The story felt chaotic and rushed, rahter like it was trying to be a 30-minute sitcom a la "I Love Lucy." Additionally, I felt at least one of the characters acted entirely different than what we've seen in prior books in the series, which was also jarring. Still, though, it is an enjoyable and quick read with a satisfying resolution to the story.

1,097 reviews2 followers
November 30, 2018
Clean romance
This is the last Twickenham Time Travel book and the author mentions her first book in this series. I thought I might prefer reading the first book before the last book because of that. I enjoyed this book as much as I did the first. I think you may laugh about the couples in this book
118 reviews1 follower
September 26, 2023
Whatever the title I enjoyed the book. I actually read MIDWINTER MAYHEM but the cover is the same on both books so I trust this us the right book. The authors do a good job with the time travel but I like the fact that the main focus was on the two love couples in the book. Some fun twists I the middle makes for an fun read.
Profile Image for Debra Miller.
246 reviews
February 18, 2019
It was chaotic and fun!

I enjoyed the fact there is two love stories. At times it was quite crazy and the of fun and heartbreak all at once. The best part was the ending, it gives you all the good feelings a romance should.
Profile Image for Kyra.
367 reviews26 followers
March 21, 2019
Funny but not as sweet as the first book

Think of this as a time traveling Midsummer Nights Dream. The fey can cause trouble when they get involved, but they usually help with the solution.
Profile Image for Veray.
1,338 reviews
July 28, 2019
Another good one

This story was crazy mixed up and very entertaining. A love potion goes wrong and the couples whoes story this is, ended up in quite a mess. I had many theories as to how it would end but none where correct. So cute!
Profile Image for Melanie Mason.
Author 17 books39 followers
September 30, 2021
A delightful romp

I enjoyed the story. It was fun to see the different viewpoints of the different characters, and how they all work together. There were a lot of errors in the book that were a bit distracting. But other than that it was a great story.
358 reviews
Read
November 28, 2021
Not what I was expecting

It was different than the first book. I am happy she made the right decision. It was touch and go for a while. I enjoyed it. I had to put the book down when Henry proposed to Lucy.
Profile Image for Phylis Collins.
2,858 reviews8 followers
March 21, 2023
May and Henry

Henry and May
This story was deep, emotional, with twists and turns, and secret, with laugh out loud moments and a little magic. That keeps you glued to the pages of this fascinating story. All this within a love story. A must read.
Profile Image for Sharon.
2,771 reviews7 followers
February 2, 2019
Tremendous Mayhem! Loved it!

Everett and Lady Lucy - engaged but her dad kept postponing hoping she gets a man with a title.

Henry/Earl Saafeld and May - she's a "traveler"

I enjoyed reading this captivating double romantic story that is fantastically written with unforgettable characters. Mistletoe Mayhem with Mayhem being the operative word is the perfect title. Both their stories have a wonderful HEA.
Profile Image for Donna Weaver.
Author 89 books459 followers
March 24, 2019
I loved this book. It was fun to see some characters from PS I Love You. And Aunt Nellie. She's hilarious. Two happily ever afters for the price of one.
Profile Image for Deanna.
1,084 reviews19 followers
September 3, 2019
Mayhem. That just about sums up this story of love and time travel.

Another great book in this series, and they never disappoint.

Enjoy
1,839 reviews12 followers
August 8, 2020
This is a fun & funny short story. A different time travel romance when a love potion is consumed by 2 couples. Makes like a little mayhem for a while. Very enjoyable.
Profile Image for Kathy Danheim.
252 reviews7 followers
April 1, 2021
A little Magic 🪄

Funny, romance, humor and a little magic equals disaster. Will the two couples ever get together? A wonderful read. You will enjoy it.
Profile Image for Fanica Rarinca.
Author 5 books5 followers
October 23, 2021
Interesting

This is an interesting book. I liked the magical mistake gust happened. It was impredictibile and full of suspense as well.
Profile Image for Paulette Marshall.
Author 46 books222 followers
November 3, 2021
Good

This story was a clean story where love prevails through all. There is a mishap that threatens to change the ending but love prevails.
Profile Image for Jacque.
33 reviews1 follower
November 22, 2020
I'm always impressed when I read another Twickenham Time Travel Romance. I keep thinking, "There is just no way I can continue being entertained but the stories". BOY I AM WRONG. The author always manages to throw in some twist that I would not have thought about. Jo Noelle didn't disappoint in her story of the time travels of another lady. Love that she incorporated conflict within the main character. It wasn't just a cut and dry decision she had to make. Great job!
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.