ARC provided by the publisher, Sourcebooks Fire, in exchange for an honest review.
"To the other residence of Cadence, California, Marley was nothing but an event. A flower to drop outside Mr. Bricket's front door. An extra thank-you to give to God once a year. A lesson. To me, she was everything."
In the quiet town of Cadence, California, Olivia Stanton and her eight other friends run wild. Known as the kids of Albany Lane, they can be found following Marley around on their bikes at all hours of the day, stirring up trouble and are never, ever apart. They lived for the summertime, and for the huge scavenger hunt Marley always organized - The Adventure. Until Marley is killed by an accidental shooting, and everything changes.
Flash forward five years - The kids of Albany Lane have disbanded, and Olivia is still trying to hold it together. She thinks she's doing just fine carrying the weight of Marley around on her shoulders, until the five year memorial, when Nick Cline walks in - one of the Albany Lane kids, Olivia's former best friend, and the boy who accidentally pulled the trigger on Marley. And when Olivia discovers one final scavenger hunt that Marley orchestrated before she died, the Albany Lane kids are finally all together again. But as the kids try to solve Marley's puzzle, they find more questions than answers, and may have to rethink everything they thought they knew about what happened five years ago.
"We were kids, but we weren't young anymore. If we wanted to build a new world for ourselves atop the wreckage of our past, we could do it. Couldn't we?"
I ended up giving this book 3.5 stars. The synopsis immediately grabbed my attention - a scavenger hunt intertwined with a murder mystery vibe? Sign me up! It's like a summer camp mystery book without the camp part, and I am a sucker for those kinds of books. While those vibes were still there, the book ended up being different than what I was expecting, and definitely tackled some pretty tough topics along the way.
The story is told from Olivia's point of view. When Marley was killed, she was one of the youngest of the 9, and always seemed to be tagging along on Marley's heels. She was always viewed as Aidy's annoying little sister who always seemed to be messing up or getting underfoot. When Marley was shot, Olivia and Nick were the only two in the room. Determined to not mess it up, Olivia tries to be more and more like Marley as she carries her memory around on her shoulders - so much so that she forgets herself along the way.
I liked Olivia as a main character. Her grief is so raw and open and on the surface, no matter how much she tries to keep it buried. She is not perfect, or even a very likable character, but she's so real and relatable. I love watching her throughout the storyline, and seeing how she was different in the flashbacks from five years before. And I loved watching her discover who she is again while she reunites with her friends, and allows herself to finally come out from the burden of seeing Marley's last moments.
"After Marley died, she showed me how pliable the truth could be. How it molded itself to serve the situation at hand. My family, my classmates, even the people paid to help me cope - they all tried to trick me into thinking her death didn't affect me because it happened before I'd worn a bra or gotten my period...As these truths bent, so did I, until I was nothing more than a contortionist, squeezing myself into the box of a life Marley left behind."
I also loved watching Olivia reconnect with her sister, Aidy. Aidy had been Marley's best friend, and it's obvious the two girls grieved differently and separately over the past five years. As the group comes together again, so do the two sisters. Olivia begins to realize Aidy would do anything to protect her, and Aidy learns that Olivia needs her more than she may realize.
This book probably deserved more stars than I gave it, but I ended up knocking off a star mainly because I couldn't fully get into it for about half of the book. I'm not sure if it was the writing style or the pacing, but I felt a little disconnected until about 50%. Don't let my 3.5 turn you off, though - it really picked up at that point and I ended up really liking the storyline and the beautiful way it was told.
More than anything, this book was about grief. Everyone grieves differently, and through each of these kid's eyes we got to see that first-hand. Watching Olivia struggle with her own grief, and the shock of seeing Nick again, was so eye-opening and well-done. I felt like Morrissey found a little bit of my soul and put it to paper, using Olivia to do it. Grief is such a touchy topic, because it's different for everybody. But it can also bring people back together again, just like it did in this book. And while there was certainly a lot of grief throughout this story, there was also a lot of love and friendship, which are just as powerful. Those two things can span time and space, and can even surmount death. And if we let them, they can begin to help us heal.
"'I get what you mean about the room with no exit,' he said. 'You and me, we're stuck inside July 11 forever. But I really do have to believe there's a way for us to get out. And I think we're finding it.'"
When The Light Went Out released on June 4, 2019.
*All quotations taken from an ARC and are subject to change upon publication.