I want to talk more about the book itself and how it was put together rather than the stories in it, if you're getting this hardcover omnibi collection then you already know what kinda story you're getting [this is more a collectors piece than a curious buy]. We're just hitting that good ol' school wide rumble that we were expecting back when volume 1 came out.
The art on the covers is beautiful, as always, and I'm quite happy that they kept the same style of and coloration as the regular trade paperbacks [it makes the comics feel unified, like they go together, and it will look that much nicer on your shelves]. I especially love the bright yellow-orange they used [I'm a sucker for yellow]. If I have any complaint about the cover is that its artwork cropped from other volumes. I recognize the back cover as the top half of the fifth trade paperback, and I know I've seen the front art somewhere else but I can't remember where from. I'm just personally not the biggest fan of cropping art to make new covers from it, like you have a great artist working on these comics, I'm sure he could have made something just as amazing as his other covers for the deluxe edition [it's not a huge deal I'm just saying].
I was a little confused as to how this book was so thick, compared to the 3 volumes that make it up. I was hella excited to see that almost an entire trade paperback worth of pages was dedicated to cover composition, coloration techniques, variants, scripts, and panel layouts. I love seeing how a comic book is brought to its final look, I love the process. The last thing that I'm very happy with is the size of the pages, I'm not saying the regular comic book size isn't good, but there's just something about larger pages that makes me feel like I get to experience the art better, I can see all the tiny details clearer, it's a preferable size for me and my janky glasses wearing face.
My only issue with publishers making large, hardcover [even though I prefer hardcover books], omnibus issues of a series is that so many pages bound together [not matter how well done] is very heavy on the spine, and will [sooner rather than later] start breaking apart due to weight [not overuse but just from the weight of the book itself]. That makes it harder to read the comic cause every time you open it or turn the page you can hear the spine slowly coming undone, creaking, coming loose, wiggling in your hands. It makes me think that these aren't even meant to read just to look nice on the shelf, at that point it's just a collectible and you can't enjoy your comic from it.
I love comics, I love hardcovers cause they tend to last longer, I love having more pages to read cause that means I get more story and am not as sad or as impatiently waiting for the rest. But when they're this big and this heavy I feel like I can't enjoy the book without being worried that I'll mess it up by just opening it. I would prefer a sort of boxed set scenario, a nice sleek outer box with exclusive hardcover versions inside to replace these deluxe editions that they keep putting out. And I don't want it to happen every so often but at the end of a series, when we have all the books. Admittedly, having so many individual hardcover comics might be a bit much, in that case I feel like we can bind them up by two's; volume 1 and volume 2 together as one hardcover and so on, if we end on an odd number of books that last book is gunna be a bit thicker [what can ya do at that point]. I mean sure you could make the final volume its own individual hardcover and then make the rest of the book bonus features; like an extended art gallery for the series, but I would rather have a bonus book just for that, for the scripts and the page layout, color tests, developing the covers, I feel the process deserves to be seen so people know just how much work goes into every single comic out there, not just the ones they like to read.
Too long didn't read? The book is amazingly sized and great if you want to just binge a huge chunk of the story all at once. But if you, like me, want to laze around and enjoy the story be careful, the deluxe omnibi spines are under a large weight strain due to the amount of pages and even the slightest of reading will loosen the spine and affect the connectivity of the pages.