It is hard to believe that the original Queer Eye for the Straight Guy sashayed onto our TV screens more than 15 years ago. With the Fab Five supremely confident in their inner diva-sanctioned mission to unlock the ‘queerness’ within everyone, the unabashedly confident and flamboyant show (well, for straight people anyway) ended up as a cultural phenomenon.
It’s astonishing to read in this book that “the word ‘queer’ was considered way too risqué for a TV show title in the 2000s”, but the producers pushed ahead anyway. The rest is herstory, as they say.
When I first heard about the Netflix reboot, my first reaction was: WTF? Queer Eye then was definitely dependent upon a certain cultural milieu for its effectiveness and social relevance.
Now, in the age of Trump, and the growing debate about gender identity, and the conflation of gay rights with other minority causes, not to mention the vexed issue of the gay community propping up ‘straight’ institutions such as marriage by buying into the white picket-fence dream … did we really need a revival of such a frivolous thing as a ‘gay makeover’ show?
Even though the new incarnation is called ‘Queer Eye’, it nevertheless seems much less gay and camp than its predecessor. The unabashed gayness of the original has been replaced with a non-threatening mantra of inclusivity and kumbaya singalong. The agenda of the Netflix revival seems to be that one can be gay, but not be or act queer, so as not to frighten the horses or women and children.
Or does it? I have just begun to watch season two, and the new show has managed to creep into my heart in a very insidious and unexpected manner. Not a single episode goes by without bringing a tear to the eye (maybe showing emotion is a gay trait, after all. Perhaps it is only acceptable for straight blokes to cry at Game of Thrones.)
The episode when our bohemian boys redo a church hall and reunite a mother with her son, as well as shepherd his ultimate acceptance within a straitlaced religious community, had me crying openly.
Why? I think that, as with the original, the new show has a definite socio-political agenda, especially in the shadow of Trump, and the resurgence of right-wing extremism as a global phenomenon, not to mention intolerance, prejudice, ethnic subjugation, and a plethora of other ills and misconceptions that has sparked every war and conflict since time immemorial.
The new Queer Eye has a much broader agenda, sending our boys into parts of the US we didn’t even know existed (there really is a town called Gay?) And not to mention the show’s first encounter with the fairer sex. The new millennial Fab Five, if we can call them that, are a much more diverse and nuanced bunch, coming across as ‘real’ people, with baggage and back stories.
The focus really wasn’t on the guys themselves in the original, which did have the unfortunate side-effect of painting them as caricatures. The super-gays-fly-in-and-do-a-magical-makeover-before-you-can-even-blink recipe of the original was never deviated from in any meaningful sense.
The new Queer Eye, on the other hand, insists on everyone taking a liberal snort of fairy dust. There is no getting away from the ‘gayness’ of the hosts themselves. Paradoxically, however, this very openness tends to push the ‘gay agenda’ to the back burner … while very much informing every aspect of the show itself. It is a curious dichotomy, and yet it works incredibly well.
So I was equally curious when I stumbled across this lavish book. Not only do we learn something of the back stories of each of the guys, but this section is then followed by a detailed overview of each of their areas of expertise, from grooming to culture (which is more psychological integration in the PC reiteration of the show) and those old gay standbys, cooking and interior design.
The end result is a wonderfully eclectic reading experience that not only gives great insight into the show itself, but helps round out the Fab Five as fully-fledged people in their own right. Who just happen to be gay. And who extend us the following invitation:
We officially give you permission to go out and ‘queer eye’ the world. It starts with you – now put your best foot forward!