I love debut works, especially suspense/thrillers, as I am always interested to see if an author can pull off taking a rather tired topic, and making it fresh and new. For me, this book fell somewhere in between the two. While there were some good moments in the book, way too much is given away just by reading the back of the book, and unfortunately, without a complete suspension of reality, much of the book is unbelievable, at best.
The book begins with Anna, who has always been taught that her mamma’s strict rules are the only path to follow, on her eighteenth birthday, defying her mother for the first time in her life and going to nearby amusement park, Astroland, with her boyfriend, Will. As she has never been allowed to visit Florida’s most popular amusement park, she doesn't understand why everything about it seems familiar. Then, coincidentally (eye roll), on that same day, a creepy, mysterious man hands her a letter addressing her by a different name. This series of events makes Anna suspicious of her past, and thus begins her quest to find out the truth.
Meanwhile, in London, Rosie has grown up in the shadow of the abducted sister she barely remembers, and her family has been severely fractured by years of unsuccessful searching. On the fifteenth anniversary of her sister’s disappearance, the family funds dedicated to the search are running out, so teenage Rosie attempts to uncover the truth herself.
{SLIGHT SPOILER ALERT} The story is told in alternating POV -Anna and Rosie. Anna's chapters are the more intriguing of the two - Rosie's are pure fluff. The biggest issue for me was that in the age of the internet, much of the plot did not make sense. For example, at Astroland, Anna has a recollection of being there before, and the name, Emily. She tells her boyfriend that she thinks she may have been abducted as a child, and her boyfriend's first reaction is to go to the internet and pull up a random article about manufactured memories - say what?? How about doing an internet search with key words, "Emily, Astroland, missing girl." Boom - mystery solved. Especially as so much of Rosie's story focused on the media circus that had continued for fifteen years, so it wasn't as if there was a big secret as to what happened to Emily. And I won't even get started on Rosie's search and her interactions with the internet conspiracy theorists - again, if you can suspend all common sense, then it might make sense to you, but for me, it was a no-go.
There were a few subplots involving a cult-like church, which I found interesting, but there again, the Pastor Paul - Mamma relationship was bizarre and generally inexplicable. There were also some references to some pretty twisted child abuse, which while they were not overly graphic, they were still disturbing.
Overall, this was a super short book that I read in one sitting, and I liked Barber's crisp writing style. For me, it just missed the mark in regard to the believability factor . As this is her debut novel though, I am interested to see how Barber grows as a writer and would definitely be open to reading more of her works in the future. 3 stars.