A tighter editorial hand might have reduced some of the occasionally excruciating - not to say scatological - detail of Shaanxi village life in the 1960s. But any failings are more than made up for by the sympathetic and convincing depiction of how the cultural revolution played out at village level. To say this is not a common theme of contemporary Chinese fiction would be putting it mildly (I rather suspect a lesser known writer than Jia would have had great difficulty getting this published). Well worth a read, for those with a certain degree of patience.