I stumbled upon this book completely by accident while browsing the selection of used books at a local store. I'd never heard of the author before, but I was in the market for something different and this sounded promising. Thankfully, I wasn't disappointed.
The premise here is that author Matt Hardison has released a runaway bestselling novel, the plot of which is based on a story he and his best friend Tommy overheard from his eccentric Aunt when they were children. This story, now recreated in Matt's novel, involved a carnival spook called "The Shadowstealer", a malevolent creature that comes to life when its story is told and gains power the more people believe in it. Matt thought the story was just an urban legend, and only realizes his error when it is too late. The story was real, and now that his book is a runaway success, people far and wide have learned to fear The Shadowstealer, releasing the horrific creature upon the world and giving it terrifying power.
A big part of what makes Let There Be Dark work is that its antagonist draws upon the elements of a good urban legend, creeping through the pages like a good campfire tale. It comes to life when its story is told; its power is based upon people believing in it; it follows its unsuspecting victim by hiding in their own shadow, its presence announced only by a tingle at the back of the neck. Then, finally, it can't take hold of its victim until they look at it. It's the kind of tale we may have heard as kids at summer camp, huddled around a flickering campfire, casting suspicious glances at our own shadow in spite of ourselves.
The novel starts off fairly tame, building up its cast of characters and their various quirks before things really begin to escalate. The Georgia setting and the characters who reside there can seem a bit off-putting, even heavy-handed perhaps, to someone who isn't familiar with it. Having family in Georgia myself I didn't find it too distracting, though opinions on the matter are likely to vary. The villain itself takes its time establishing itself, but once it finally gains strength the stops are pulled, and the novel escalates into a bloody flurry of possession and misuse of power tools.
Despite the villain's seemingly hokey carnival spook origins, the story behind The Shadowstealer itself actually had a surprising amount of depth that I frankly hadn't expected. By the end of the novel, the reader is given not only a better understanding of what this creature is, but why it came to be, and ultimately what it wants. When it comes to horror the inclusion of such information isn't always a good thing -- sometimes understanding something makes us less afraid of it -- but in this case I thought the extra story made this particular creature more interesting than it would have been otherwise.
So, if you're ever browsing used books looking for something good like I was and you are lucky enough to come across a copy of Let There Be Dark, give it a chance. I was pleasantly surprised, and if you like a good spooky story that isn't afraid to use a weed eater in unintended way, I'm sure you will be too.