I don't like it when I have practically nothing good to say about my experience with a book because I probably come across very harshly. I wouldn't say this was a bad book by any means, but I definitely didn't have a good experience for a variety of reasons. In short, I thought the setting and world of the story has a basic good setup and I was interested to see more of it, learn more about it, and meet more of the people living in it. Unfortunately, my pov for the series is Darius: an amnesiac man-child who is supposedly a warrior but gets sick at the sight of blood and kind of loses every time he gets in a fight.
I feel confident enough to say that if you aren't feeling the Darius character, you probably won't have a good time in this book. As long as you don't let the GoT/Total Recall callout in the summary oversell your expectations, then you might enjoy this.
I'm not a fan of taglines and summaries that compare a book to specific other works. Too often, the comparisons don't do the title in question any favors and it only leads to disappointment. That was also the case for me with this book and the Game of Thrones/Total Recall comparisons. I have both read and watched GoT, Bourne Identity, and Total Recall/We Can Remember it for You Wholesale. I never had anything even resembling a GoT vibe from this story. I did start off with a Bourne Identity feel that moved toward a Total Recall impression, but unfortunately it only made me think about why I liked those other books/movies and wasn't enjoying this story. The simple answer was: I didn't like Darius at all.
I was never really sold on why he was overly suspicious about so many things in the first half of the book. Sure it was possible, but it's not my job to come up with explanations. Ideally, the book should lay some foundation to explain it. I never felt that it did. It seemed a bit more like the book was trying too hard to be the Bourne Identity and add suspense. I left the first few chapters feeling mildly apathetic, but curious to see where things were going.
My apathy started falling into active dislike as Darius mostly just came across as very childish and mildly idiotic. He constantly seemed full of himself and, despite having no memories and maybe being more amenable to new information, he continued to overestimate himself and his abilities despite repeated failures. Oh, and he's a warrior that feels sick at the sight of blood...a trait that did less to make him a unique character and more to just make him annoying to me. Then there was even a painkiller problem with Darius and a traveling companion. I found the idea not just distasteful for a character I'm supposed to like to be so weak as to rely on painkillers, but honestly pathetic considering they are supposed to be warriors. It just further reinforced my impression of Darius in particular as being a whiny little child with no mettle.
The overall setup is pretty good from a world-building standpoint. Very basic, but still interesting. Two opposed factions, each of which has warriors that wield a supernatural power. There are a variety of minor gripes I had with the writing itself though. There were some very unfortunate turns of phrase that honestly made me laugh, but not at times when I should have been.
...he prepared to land a blow on his slippery foe.
...Darius braced for another assault, ready to counter this time, but her rage remained caged.
There were also a variety of descriptors like "dingy dungeon" and "pale paste" along with generic phrases like "in the blink of an eye" and "dropped like a sack of potatoes." I was also confused when a character used the expression "he dropped the ball" in the figurative sense, because there are never any sports mentioned to explain where that vernacular could have come from.
These were things that were obstacles to my immersion in the story and unfortunately they happened often during what were supposed to be action scenes.
Overall, this story really had the feel of a Young Adult book to me. All of the characters bordered on being idiots. There were no indications of anyone having much in the way of tactical smarts or experience. At one point some people decide to go forward with a plan that involves: being directly insubordinate, going drastically against basic odds, relying entirely on the enemy giving his weapon to someone else even though there is no indication of that ever happening before...and if it doesn't go according to plan they're all doomed. To me, this is textbook idiot plot material where the plot only moves forward because every character is lacking common sense.
I think even Darius aside, there were too many obstacles for me to get into this story. Maybe if the summary info compared it to some YA stories I would have come in with a different measuring stick and things would have been received differently, but if that was the case then odds are I might not have picked it up in the first place.