What do you think?
Rate this book
Şimdi ve Sonsuza Dek
"Ne geçmişti ne de gelecek; önceden gerçekleşmiş olan her şey artık günün birinde olacak her şeye dönüşmüştü. Zoe sonsuz hissediyordu, her zaman var olmuş, her zaman parıl parıl parlamış gibi hem genç hem de çok yaşlı hissediyordu. Güzel hissediyordu."
"Çekici, duygusal ve şaşırtıcı."
-Corey Ann Haydu-
"Akıcı ve duygu dolu."
-Publishers Weekly-
"Dokunaklı ve şaşırtıcı… mükemmel bir yaz kitabı."
-RT Book Reviews-
"Yetişkinliğin eşiğindeki okurlar arasında yankı uyandıracak, akıcı ve güzel bir kitap."
-Kirkus Reviews-
"Mizah, duygu ve biraz da sihirle anlatılmış, arkadaşlığın gücüne ve ikinci şansların olasılığına dair güzel bir kitap."
-Jennifer E. Smith-
"Çekici, duygusal ve şaşırtıcı."
-Corey Ann Haydu-
"Akıcı ve duygu dolu."
-Publishers Weekly-
"Dokunaklı ve şaşırtıcı… mükemmel bir yaz kitabı."
-RT Book Reviews-
"Yetişkinliğin eşiğindeki okurlar arasında yankı uyandıracak, akıcı ve güzel bir kitap."
-Kirkus Reviews-
"Mizah, duygu ve biraz da sihirle anlatılmış, arkadaşlığın gücüne ve ikinci şansların olasılığına dair güzel bir kitap."
-Jennifer E. Smith-
344 pages, Paperback
First published June 2, 2015
83 people are currently reading
8047 people want to read
About the author
Lexa Hillyer
7 books547 followersHello! I'm the author of the YA fantasy duology Spindle Fire & Winter Glass, YA speculative contemporary Proof of Forever, and the upcoming YA contemporary Frozen Beauty. I also wrote the poetry collection Acquainted with the Cold, which won the 2012 Foreword Book of the Year Award. I'm one of the founders, and President of Publishing, at creative development company Glasstown Entertainment. I live in Carroll Gardens with my husband, daughter, and a very skinny orange tree. Follow me on instagram @ProofOfLex and twitter @Lexa_Hillyer !
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 345 reviews
March 9, 2015
2.5 stars
(Source: I received a digital copy of this book for free on a read-to-review basis. Thanks to HarperCollins and Edelweiss.)
“Our camp years are forever behind us. I get that. But I know, deep down, that you guys have to be sad about that too. That it meant something to you, just like it did to me.”
This was a contemporary time-travel/ do-over story, with an unexpected ending.
The characters in this were all okay, but I didn’t really love any of them. They all came across as quite immature and even selfish in places, and they did irritate me at times.
“So… you’re suggesting we hang around in the past for five days and then… take a bunch of glam shots in the photo booth and hope it works like a time machine in the other direction?”
The storyline in this involved the four girls accidentally going back in time and re-doing their summer at camp when they were 15. They tried to recreate what they had done previously in order to take the same photo as they took at the end of that summer, hoping that that would trigger their return back to the present.
“The photo from two summers ago?” Joy asks.
“The photo from this summer,” Luce says slowly.
“Right.” Tali nods. “It’s totally erased. Gone. Like it never happened.”
This was all very well and good, but it was a bit of an odd one that the girls were trying to do exactly what they had done before, but to see things in a new light. Bit odd. Anyway, I can’t really say that I found this all that interesting really, I lost interest quite early on, and the most excitement I got from this book was when one girl thought that she might not want to return to her present life.
“It’s blank because it hasn’t happened yet,” Zoe says.
“Wha are you suggesting?” Tali frowns.
Zoe shrugs. “I don’t know… maybe we have to, like, take it again.”
There was some romance, but I wasn’t all that big of a fan really. The problem was that I knew that the girls were all about to go back to the future, and leave their holiday romances behind, which was a bit of a dampener really.
“This sounds crazy,” he whispers. “But do you believe in love at first sight?”
The ending to this did have a little surprise in store, and I hadn’t guessed it for a moment. It was a bit of a weird ending though, and reminded me a bit of the last 2 episodes of Dawson’s Creek (anybody else watched that?).
5 out of 10
(Source: I received a digital copy of this book for free on a read-to-review basis. Thanks to HarperCollins and Edelweiss.)
“Our camp years are forever behind us. I get that. But I know, deep down, that you guys have to be sad about that too. That it meant something to you, just like it did to me.”
This was a contemporary time-travel/ do-over story, with an unexpected ending.
The characters in this were all okay, but I didn’t really love any of them. They all came across as quite immature and even selfish in places, and they did irritate me at times.
“So… you’re suggesting we hang around in the past for five days and then… take a bunch of glam shots in the photo booth and hope it works like a time machine in the other direction?”
The storyline in this involved the four girls accidentally going back in time and re-doing their summer at camp when they were 15. They tried to recreate what they had done previously in order to take the same photo as they took at the end of that summer, hoping that that would trigger their return back to the present.
“The photo from two summers ago?” Joy asks.
“The photo from this summer,” Luce says slowly.
“Right.” Tali nods. “It’s totally erased. Gone. Like it never happened.”
This was all very well and good, but it was a bit of an odd one that the girls were trying to do exactly what they had done before, but to see things in a new light. Bit odd. Anyway, I can’t really say that I found this all that interesting really, I lost interest quite early on, and the most excitement I got from this book was when one girl thought that she might not want to return to her present life.
“It’s blank because it hasn’t happened yet,” Zoe says.
“Wha are you suggesting?” Tali frowns.
Zoe shrugs. “I don’t know… maybe we have to, like, take it again.”
There was some romance, but I wasn’t all that big of a fan really. The problem was that I knew that the girls were all about to go back to the future, and leave their holiday romances behind, which was a bit of a dampener really.
“This sounds crazy,” he whispers. “But do you believe in love at first sight?”
The ending to this did have a little surprise in store, and I hadn’t guessed it for a moment. It was a bit of a weird ending though, and reminded me a bit of the last 2 episodes of Dawson’s Creek (anybody else watched that?).
5 out of 10
June 18, 2015
“Each friend represents a world in us, a world possibly not born until they arrive, and it is only by this meeting that a new world is born.”
---- Anaïs Nin, a French-born novelist, passionate eroticist and short story writer
Lexa Hillyer, an American author, pens her debut novel, Proof of Forever that traces the moving tale of four girlfriends and their camp days but two years down the line, they grew apart and are given a chance to go back to their camp days and do it all over again.
Synopsis:
Before: It was the perfect summer of first kisses, skinny-dipping, and bonfires by the lake. Joy, Tali, Luce, and Zoe knew their final summer at Camp Okahatchee would come to an end, but they swore they’d stay friends.
After: Now, two years later, their bond has faded along with those memories.
Then: That is, until the fateful flash of a photo booth camera transports the four of them back in time, to the summer they were fifteen—the summer everything changed.
Now: The girls must recreate the past in order to return to the present. As they live through their second-chance summer, the mystery behind their lost friendship unravels, and a dark secret threatens to tear the girls apart all over again.
Always: Summers end. But this one will change them forever.
Zoe, Joy, Luce and Tali were once the best of best friends who spent their last summer before graduation at Camp Okahatchee, where they had incredible fun and made lots of promises. But two years later, they all drifted apart in their own worlds, and so floated so far away from each other that they hardly ever talked to each other. One fine day, Joy, the girl who disappeared from the group two years back, manages to plan a reunion at Camp Okahatchee and her plan of bringing all together becomes successful when the rest of the girl agrees to go on summer camp one more time. But a photo booth changes their lives forever, when they are transported back in the time when they were seventeen and were camping out like nobody's business, and if they have to come back to their present, they have to re-create that special day, which sounds bit difficult given the fact that they were not that close anymore.
From Hillyer's bio, I read that her poetry collection, Acquainted with the Cold, has won the 2012 Foreword Book of the Year Award's Gold Prize for Poetry, and that proves that why her writing style is so lyrical, beautiful and her prose is like a soft music playing in loops whose melody sways the readers with it's flow. The evocative narrative tone sets the mood of the readers right into the moment, and when I'm saying moment, I mean to say, summer. Hillyer have vividly recreated the beauty, the flair and the feel of the summer with her choice of eloquent words. Although the book falls in the YA genre and so most people might take it as another of cheesy teenage drama story, but surprisingly, the quality of this novel is so rich that it feels like reading a literary fiction.
The author have unraveled the mystery behind the girls' animosity and the reason behind their drifting apart from each other by peeling one layer after another which peaked my interest and kept me engaged with anticipation, until the very end, which I felt a bit rushed and was not completely structured to wow the readers with the beauty, and at times too, especially midway through the book, the secrets that the girls harbor became very predictable and anybody can easily guess it away.
The plot is layered with fun, humor and emotions which are depicted with enough depth to make the readers feel the joy and the pain with equal vigor. The emotions vary with the story when it is summer, then the author lets us have fun with the charm and glitter of the weather and the fun lurking in the air and the smell of friendship and warmth, but when they re-visit that summer, then the author takes us on a emotional over-ride with the girl's path to self-discovery, embracing truth and finding one another.
The characters are very realistic and each appears to be a stark contrast from one another. Zoe with her nerdy demeanor will simply make the readers adore her, Tali is a bit of a bitch when it comes to men and money and well she annoyed me with her attitude in the begining of the book, Luce is the perfect exemplary figure among these four girls, but there's a lot of mystery behind that one, and finally, Joy, the only sane person in the group who doesn't like to speak off her mind a lot, and the mystery behind her disappearance from the girls' lives play a huge role in this story. Told from the POV of the four girls, lets the readers see past through the fears, inhibitions, flaws, feelings of the four protagonists.
Overall, this is a story where four girls re-discover themselves as well as their bond of friendships that is so deeply moving that in the end, even though it is bit rushed, is bound to bring a tear to the eyes of the readers. This is a captivating yet funny story of love and friendships that perfectly captures that salty taste of summer through this story.
Verdict: Here comes your perfect summer read!! Grab a copy now.
Courtesy: Thanks to the author, Lexa Hillyer's publishers from Harper Collins for giving me an opportunity to read and review this book.
---- Anaïs Nin, a French-born novelist, passionate eroticist and short story writer
Lexa Hillyer, an American author, pens her debut novel, Proof of Forever that traces the moving tale of four girlfriends and their camp days but two years down the line, they grew apart and are given a chance to go back to their camp days and do it all over again.
Synopsis:
Before: It was the perfect summer of first kisses, skinny-dipping, and bonfires by the lake. Joy, Tali, Luce, and Zoe knew their final summer at Camp Okahatchee would come to an end, but they swore they’d stay friends.
After: Now, two years later, their bond has faded along with those memories.
Then: That is, until the fateful flash of a photo booth camera transports the four of them back in time, to the summer they were fifteen—the summer everything changed.
Now: The girls must recreate the past in order to return to the present. As they live through their second-chance summer, the mystery behind their lost friendship unravels, and a dark secret threatens to tear the girls apart all over again.
Always: Summers end. But this one will change them forever.
Zoe, Joy, Luce and Tali were once the best of best friends who spent their last summer before graduation at Camp Okahatchee, where they had incredible fun and made lots of promises. But two years later, they all drifted apart in their own worlds, and so floated so far away from each other that they hardly ever talked to each other. One fine day, Joy, the girl who disappeared from the group two years back, manages to plan a reunion at Camp Okahatchee and her plan of bringing all together becomes successful when the rest of the girl agrees to go on summer camp one more time. But a photo booth changes their lives forever, when they are transported back in the time when they were seventeen and were camping out like nobody's business, and if they have to come back to their present, they have to re-create that special day, which sounds bit difficult given the fact that they were not that close anymore.
From Hillyer's bio, I read that her poetry collection, Acquainted with the Cold, has won the 2012 Foreword Book of the Year Award's Gold Prize for Poetry, and that proves that why her writing style is so lyrical, beautiful and her prose is like a soft music playing in loops whose melody sways the readers with it's flow. The evocative narrative tone sets the mood of the readers right into the moment, and when I'm saying moment, I mean to say, summer. Hillyer have vividly recreated the beauty, the flair and the feel of the summer with her choice of eloquent words. Although the book falls in the YA genre and so most people might take it as another of cheesy teenage drama story, but surprisingly, the quality of this novel is so rich that it feels like reading a literary fiction.
The author have unraveled the mystery behind the girls' animosity and the reason behind their drifting apart from each other by peeling one layer after another which peaked my interest and kept me engaged with anticipation, until the very end, which I felt a bit rushed and was not completely structured to wow the readers with the beauty, and at times too, especially midway through the book, the secrets that the girls harbor became very predictable and anybody can easily guess it away.
The plot is layered with fun, humor and emotions which are depicted with enough depth to make the readers feel the joy and the pain with equal vigor. The emotions vary with the story when it is summer, then the author lets us have fun with the charm and glitter of the weather and the fun lurking in the air and the smell of friendship and warmth, but when they re-visit that summer, then the author takes us on a emotional over-ride with the girl's path to self-discovery, embracing truth and finding one another.
The characters are very realistic and each appears to be a stark contrast from one another. Zoe with her nerdy demeanor will simply make the readers adore her, Tali is a bit of a bitch when it comes to men and money and well she annoyed me with her attitude in the begining of the book, Luce is the perfect exemplary figure among these four girls, but there's a lot of mystery behind that one, and finally, Joy, the only sane person in the group who doesn't like to speak off her mind a lot, and the mystery behind her disappearance from the girls' lives play a huge role in this story. Told from the POV of the four girls, lets the readers see past through the fears, inhibitions, flaws, feelings of the four protagonists.
Overall, this is a story where four girls re-discover themselves as well as their bond of friendships that is so deeply moving that in the end, even though it is bit rushed, is bound to bring a tear to the eyes of the readers. This is a captivating yet funny story of love and friendships that perfectly captures that salty taste of summer through this story.
Verdict: Here comes your perfect summer read!! Grab a copy now.
Courtesy: Thanks to the author, Lexa Hillyer's publishers from Harper Collins for giving me an opportunity to read and review this book.
September 12, 2025
THIS WAS PERFECT AND BITTERSWEET. It took a little while to get into the narrative, as it's told in what I like to call 'fan fiction tense' (third person, present) but when I got other that I fell in love with the characters and the story. Maddie and I were talking about this for hours after finishing it. For a story about four girls accidentally going back in time it was so realistic. Also, beautiful writing style. I could go on about this story forever. Just read it!
January 3, 2016
I received a free copy via Edelweiss
First Impressions: A little disappointed but a good summer read and a pretty unique premise. I think I would have liked it a lot more had it been more friendship focused but a lot of it was romance centric and insta-love which was a big turn off for me.
Review: Four girls, Zoe, Tali, Joy and Luce, were once best friends. One summer, everything changed. At their Camp reunion years later, the four girls meet up again, brought together by Joy, the one who left. A photo booth and a camera flash and the four girls are transported back that summer when they were fifteen and they have a chance to figure out where it all went wrong.
I was rather looking forward to Proof of Forever, and whilst I really enjoyed aspects of it and flew through, it's safe to say I'm a tad disappointed. The blurb makes it seem very friendship orientated, and whilst some of it is, I felt it was bogged down with romance, and that romance was rushed considering it was something like five days they were there and they fell in love in that time. That's really my only qualm with Proof of Forever and I quite enjoyed the characters, particularly Luce. There's quite a bit of diversity within the cast, too. We have an African-American, a Filipino,
The ending was quite sad, if not a little rushed and I enjoyed the message about friendship, but I do wish that it was more focused on that.
Overall, an enjoyable contemporary summer read, but a lot more focus on romance that I would have liked.
First Impressions: A little disappointed but a good summer read and a pretty unique premise. I think I would have liked it a lot more had it been more friendship focused but a lot of it was romance centric and insta-love which was a big turn off for me.
Review: Four girls, Zoe, Tali, Joy and Luce, were once best friends. One summer, everything changed. At their Camp reunion years later, the four girls meet up again, brought together by Joy, the one who left. A photo booth and a camera flash and the four girls are transported back that summer when they were fifteen and they have a chance to figure out where it all went wrong.
I was rather looking forward to Proof of Forever, and whilst I really enjoyed aspects of it and flew through, it's safe to say I'm a tad disappointed. The blurb makes it seem very friendship orientated, and whilst some of it is, I felt it was bogged down with romance, and that romance was rushed considering it was something like five days they were there and they fell in love in that time. That's really my only qualm with Proof of Forever and I quite enjoyed the characters, particularly Luce. There's quite a bit of diversity within the cast, too. We have an African-American, a Filipino,
The ending was quite sad, if not a little rushed and I enjoyed the message about friendship, but I do wish that it was more focused on that.
Overall, an enjoyable contemporary summer read, but a lot more focus on romance that I would have liked.
June 17, 2016
The idea for this book was deliciously original: four estranged friends accidentally travel back in time, and get to make different choices and get into all sorts of trouble. But Lexa Hillyer could not pull it off. It was rushed, the writing was juvenile, and there were even a few grammatical errors. *shudders*. The end was a cheap rip-off of other, more moving plots, and failed to stir any of my emotions at all.
When Hillyer learns how to write, let me know, and I might give her a try again. But this book is certainly not worth reading.
When Hillyer learns how to write, let me know, and I might give her a try again. But this book is certainly not worth reading.
February 11, 2017
This and other reviews can be found on The Psychotic Nerd
MY THOUGHTS
This book focuses on a group of ex-friends: Joy, Tali, Luce, and Zoe. After Joy moved without explanation, the friends drifted apart. It's when the summer camp they used to attend has a reunion that the girls see eachother again and end up accidentally transporting 2 years into the part. To their last summer as friends. The girls have to recreate their past, and their last photo, in order to get back to the present. But how can they live in the past when their older now? And what if they change things?
I was actually surprised by this book. For some reason I thought they metaphorically transported in time, so I was expecting a full-on contemporary. I was pleasantly surprised by the time travel aspect. Yet, this book is still very realistic. I think a praise on the book "Sisterhood of the (Time) Traveling Pants" is an accurate way to describe this book. The friendship and the summertime feeling to this book reminded me of the Traveling Pants book, though there are definitely differences.
There is the fact that this book is very very slow-paced. It makes sense considering the plot, but most of the book is the friends doing their separate things. Not that it was dull or anything. It was interesting seeing the girls try to recreate their summer, and not really recreate it. I actually really did end up liking seeing their different stories. This book is mostly about friendship and second chances, so there is hope and lots of drama in this.
This book also follows each of the girls individually. It's in third person, but it's like we're seeing the POV from each girl. I'm not a big fan of third person and some might find the switches confusing, but I think this worked out for this book! I really can't see how we could've gotten the story in any other way. Now, I did have issues with the girls. They seemed much younger. In fact, it seemed like they completely took over their roles of being 15 again, which kind of bothered me. It's not a huge problem, but I kind of wish that they seemed more their age. Besides this, though, these characters did grow so much throughout this book, learning about things about themselves and their past.
As for romance, some of the girls have their romances in the book, but I don't think that's important. This book is, again, about friendship. Whether it's a past friendship or a current one.
IN CONCLUSION
Overall, this was a great book with magical realism. I had issues with the characters and pacing, at first, but I grew into liking this book. I think this is a great summer read abouts second chances and friendship! I recommend this to fans of contemporary friendship reads!
MY THOUGHTS
This book focuses on a group of ex-friends: Joy, Tali, Luce, and Zoe. After Joy moved without explanation, the friends drifted apart. It's when the summer camp they used to attend has a reunion that the girls see eachother again and end up accidentally transporting 2 years into the part. To their last summer as friends. The girls have to recreate their past, and their last photo, in order to get back to the present. But how can they live in the past when their older now? And what if they change things?
I was actually surprised by this book. For some reason I thought they metaphorically transported in time, so I was expecting a full-on contemporary. I was pleasantly surprised by the time travel aspect. Yet, this book is still very realistic. I think a praise on the book "Sisterhood of the (Time) Traveling Pants" is an accurate way to describe this book. The friendship and the summertime feeling to this book reminded me of the Traveling Pants book, though there are definitely differences.
There is the fact that this book is very very slow-paced. It makes sense considering the plot, but most of the book is the friends doing their separate things. Not that it was dull or anything. It was interesting seeing the girls try to recreate their summer, and not really recreate it. I actually really did end up liking seeing their different stories. This book is mostly about friendship and second chances, so there is hope and lots of drama in this.
This book also follows each of the girls individually. It's in third person, but it's like we're seeing the POV from each girl. I'm not a big fan of third person and some might find the switches confusing, but I think this worked out for this book! I really can't see how we could've gotten the story in any other way. Now, I did have issues with the girls. They seemed much younger. In fact, it seemed like they completely took over their roles of being 15 again, which kind of bothered me. It's not a huge problem, but I kind of wish that they seemed more their age. Besides this, though, these characters did grow so much throughout this book, learning about things about themselves and their past.
As for romance, some of the girls have their romances in the book, but I don't think that's important. This book is, again, about friendship. Whether it's a past friendship or a current one.
IN CONCLUSION
Overall, this was a great book with magical realism. I had issues with the characters and pacing, at first, but I grew into liking this book. I think this is a great summer read abouts second chances and friendship! I recommend this to fans of contemporary friendship reads!
December 30, 2015
If you’re looking for a story of the crazy ups and downs of friendship look no further. I read the summary of this book and instantly felt like this would be the perfect summer read.
Tali, Luce, Zoe and Joy were friends since their first days at Camp Okahatchee and when the last day arrived, they swore they would remain friends forever. But as it often happens, people slip away and time apart creates rifts and waves and the four girls end up anything but best friends.
Two years later, on the cusp of their high school graduations, they are all heading back to Camp Okahatchee for the reunion of a lifetime… one that will change their lives forever.
The story is told from four different points of view, which is in itself a feat. But honestly, it’s done really well. Each of the girls has a unique voice and Hillyer did an amazing job showing the character growth throughout.
The catalyst here is a photo booth that transports the girls back to their final year at Camp Okahatchee and in order to get back to the present time they ultimately think they have to recreate their last summer together. The premise itself was incredibly unique and I think what I loved best was the evolution of the friendships here. Don’t get me wrong, there’s some sweet romance here, and I definitely liked that, but I love that the focus here was on the girls figuring out their paths back to each other.
Of course you know from the get-go that something is wrong with one of them…. I mean it’s not really spelled out, but it’s also not hidden all that well, so I kind of had an idea of what was coming down the road, but I think knowing that the other girls weren’t aware of the real issue while I was reading, really puts in perspective that mentality that we sort of feel invincible when we’re that age, we never would expect what happens to happen.
This all leads to some bittersweet moments… not only for their friendships, but for the romances as well.
If you’re looking for a wonderfully and uniquely written coming of age story, one about second chances and friendship definitely give this one a try!
Thank you to the publisher for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Tali, Luce, Zoe and Joy were friends since their first days at Camp Okahatchee and when the last day arrived, they swore they would remain friends forever. But as it often happens, people slip away and time apart creates rifts and waves and the four girls end up anything but best friends.
Two years later, on the cusp of their high school graduations, they are all heading back to Camp Okahatchee for the reunion of a lifetime… one that will change their lives forever.
The story is told from four different points of view, which is in itself a feat. But honestly, it’s done really well. Each of the girls has a unique voice and Hillyer did an amazing job showing the character growth throughout.
The catalyst here is a photo booth that transports the girls back to their final year at Camp Okahatchee and in order to get back to the present time they ultimately think they have to recreate their last summer together. The premise itself was incredibly unique and I think what I loved best was the evolution of the friendships here. Don’t get me wrong, there’s some sweet romance here, and I definitely liked that, but I love that the focus here was on the girls figuring out their paths back to each other.
Of course you know from the get-go that something is wrong with one of them…. I mean it’s not really spelled out, but it’s also not hidden all that well, so I kind of had an idea of what was coming down the road, but I think knowing that the other girls weren’t aware of the real issue while I was reading, really puts in perspective that mentality that we sort of feel invincible when we’re that age, we never would expect what happens to happen.
This all leads to some bittersweet moments… not only for their friendships, but for the romances as well.
If you’re looking for a wonderfully and uniquely written coming of age story, one about second chances and friendship definitely give this one a try!
Thank you to the publisher for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
June 10, 2015
THE PROOF OF FOREVER is a beautifully written, moving, heartwarming and heartbreaking must-read story. It is the story of four girls, summer friends, who have grown apart in the two years since camp ended and who have been given the chance to go back in time to the final few days of their last summer together and do it all over. It is wistful. It is eye-opening. It’s sad and sweet. It’s the perfect summer read.
If Joy hadn’t asked, Zoe might never have gone to Camp OK’s reunion. Tali had her own reason for going: Blake. Luce’s mom, The Cruz, might have made her go. But without all four of them, they never would have entered that photo booth, gone back in time, and been forced to try and recreate the events that would bring them back to the present.
They never would have learned the truth. About themselves. About their lives. About each other. And they never would have been given the chance to become who they wanted to be, or should be, instead of who they were.
Lexa Hillyer penned an emotional and thoughtful story that at first glance appears to be simply one that is light and fun. She begins to add layers with each new revelation, each new secret uncovered. She takes readers on a heartfelt and sentimental journey with her characters. She draws them in with passages that are at times breathtaking, heart-wrenching, and achingly beautiful. She makes them think about might-have-beens and could-bes, what was lost and what was gained.
Told from each of the four characters’ perspectives, readers will get to know and connect with Joy, Zoe, Tali and Luce. They’ll discover their secrets. Their fears. Their truths. They’ll find out whether the trip back in time was helpful or harmful. And they’ll learn whether or not the girls were able to return to the present and if any of what happened was real.
THE PROOF OF FOREVER is bittersweet and nostalgic and wonderfully told. It’s about friendship and love and discovering oneself. It’s about perfection and imperfection, mistakes and forgiveness. It’s about second chances. It’s a story that is guaranteed to bring tears to every reader’s eyes. It’s a story that is infinitely re-readable.
Original GR comments:
Oh wow, this book. Completely unexpected. Talk about an emotional roller coaster. It was sweet and sad. The writing was gorgeous. I do not want to reveal any spoilers but I will just say that I sobbed.
Review TK. But this one is definitely getting my 6-star off-the-menu rating on the blog.
If Joy hadn’t asked, Zoe might never have gone to Camp OK’s reunion. Tali had her own reason for going: Blake. Luce’s mom, The Cruz, might have made her go. But without all four of them, they never would have entered that photo booth, gone back in time, and been forced to try and recreate the events that would bring them back to the present.
They never would have learned the truth. About themselves. About their lives. About each other. And they never would have been given the chance to become who they wanted to be, or should be, instead of who they were.
Lexa Hillyer penned an emotional and thoughtful story that at first glance appears to be simply one that is light and fun. She begins to add layers with each new revelation, each new secret uncovered. She takes readers on a heartfelt and sentimental journey with her characters. She draws them in with passages that are at times breathtaking, heart-wrenching, and achingly beautiful. She makes them think about might-have-beens and could-bes, what was lost and what was gained.
Told from each of the four characters’ perspectives, readers will get to know and connect with Joy, Zoe, Tali and Luce. They’ll discover their secrets. Their fears. Their truths. They’ll find out whether the trip back in time was helpful or harmful. And they’ll learn whether or not the girls were able to return to the present and if any of what happened was real.
THE PROOF OF FOREVER is bittersweet and nostalgic and wonderfully told. It’s about friendship and love and discovering oneself. It’s about perfection and imperfection, mistakes and forgiveness. It’s about second chances. It’s a story that is guaranteed to bring tears to every reader’s eyes. It’s a story that is infinitely re-readable.
Original GR comments:
Oh wow, this book. Completely unexpected. Talk about an emotional roller coaster. It was sweet and sad. The writing was gorgeous. I do not want to reveal any spoilers but I will just say that I sobbed.
Review TK. But this one is definitely getting my 6-star off-the-menu rating on the blog.
May 27, 2015
- Boring and bogged down by unnecessary details that did not help the story at all.
- Has a very typical teen voice which I didn't enjoy reading probably because I'm pretty much over it. Definitely more suited towards readers who enjoy that.
- A lot of telling and not enough showing.
- Expected friendship aspect to be more in-depth but it was all on a surface level and more focus was given to the romances.
I'm just so relieved to have finished this book *dances off to read something hopefully better*.
- Has a very typical teen voice which I didn't enjoy reading probably because I'm pretty much over it. Definitely more suited towards readers who enjoy that.
- A lot of telling and not enough showing.
- Expected friendship aspect to be more in-depth but it was all on a surface level and more focus was given to the romances.
I'm just so relieved to have finished this book *dances off to read something hopefully better*.
January 4, 2016
Proof Of Forever, on first glance, is Disney material. From the cover to the theme to the entire idea of being thrown back into time courtesy of a Photo Booth. Very idyllic. And that is the frame of mind I went with into this book. And I’m pleased to report, that this book was nothing like the cheese fest or the fluffy cotton candy I expected. It was honest and real and even though it wasn’t perfect, it’s going to be a book I’m going to remember for a long while.
This book is about time travel but it’s not your typical Sci-Fi. This book is also technically about four girls and their (mis)adventures, but it’s about so many more characters. Basically, Proof Of Forever is not your typical Contemporary so DO NOT judge it that way. The book follows four girls, Tali, Luce, Zoe and Joy. They used to be best friends and they’d sworn to remain best friends after their last summer at Camp Okahatchee. But as these things usually go, life got in the way, and they drifted apart, almost becoming strangers to each other. But two years later, when Joy suggests they all meet up at the reunion night of Camp OK, they grudgingly agree, only to be thrown back into time to two years ago, when they were fifteen; their last summer at the camp. There they realise that they have to do everything the way they’d done it before, so as not to alter their futures. But while their bodies might be fifteen years old, each of them have changed and grown. The book is all about how they deal with their growth and reconcile themselves with the people that they’ve grown into (or will grow into) and their attempts to go back to their time again.
The book was rather predictable where it came to plot—I was sure right away about certain things that would happen and I turned to to be right. This is the precise reason I found myself having a so-so opinion where it came to the story itself. Talking about each character is a little easier, because the end result was predictable (to me, at least), the way they went about their days at the camp weren’t. They were not all perfect human beings, and they did a lot of things that I didn’t quite agree with, but I suppose it did enhance the whole learning curve that the girls experienced.
I’ll also admit--the book is rather slow. It’s written as third person POV, in four different POVs, and while I’d like to say that each girl had a different, unique voice, that isn’t completely true. After a certain point, the characters started to blend into one for me, which sucks, and I had to physically make notes trying to remember who is who. It might be just me, but yeah. That happened.
Again, if you do choose to read the book, don’t do it for the story itself, meaning the time-travelling part. I found myself enjoying the symbolism behind each character and what they learnt and how they learnt it, and I think you might too. The writing too was not quite my type, but it was perfect for the mood of the book,and that was amazing. It doesn’t grab you, but it definitely lures you into continuing to read the book. All in all, as far as “coming-of-age” YA goes, Proof of Forever may be something you might want to try if you’re looking for a bitter sweet ending and a couple of cute summer romances!
I WAS PROVIDED A FREE ECOPY OF THIS BOOK IN EXCHANGE OF AN HONEST REVIEW. THIS DID NOT IN ANY WAY, HOWEVER, INFLUENCE THE CONTENT OF THIS REVIEW.
This book is about time travel but it’s not your typical Sci-Fi. This book is also technically about four girls and their (mis)adventures, but it’s about so many more characters. Basically, Proof Of Forever is not your typical Contemporary so DO NOT judge it that way. The book follows four girls, Tali, Luce, Zoe and Joy. They used to be best friends and they’d sworn to remain best friends after their last summer at Camp Okahatchee. But as these things usually go, life got in the way, and they drifted apart, almost becoming strangers to each other. But two years later, when Joy suggests they all meet up at the reunion night of Camp OK, they grudgingly agree, only to be thrown back into time to two years ago, when they were fifteen; their last summer at the camp. There they realise that they have to do everything the way they’d done it before, so as not to alter their futures. But while their bodies might be fifteen years old, each of them have changed and grown. The book is all about how they deal with their growth and reconcile themselves with the people that they’ve grown into (or will grow into) and their attempts to go back to their time again.
The book was rather predictable where it came to plot—I was sure right away about certain things that would happen and I turned to to be right. This is the precise reason I found myself having a so-so opinion where it came to the story itself. Talking about each character is a little easier, because the end result was predictable (to me, at least), the way they went about their days at the camp weren’t. They were not all perfect human beings, and they did a lot of things that I didn’t quite agree with, but I suppose it did enhance the whole learning curve that the girls experienced.
I’ll also admit--the book is rather slow. It’s written as third person POV, in four different POVs, and while I’d like to say that each girl had a different, unique voice, that isn’t completely true. After a certain point, the characters started to blend into one for me, which sucks, and I had to physically make notes trying to remember who is who. It might be just me, but yeah. That happened.
Again, if you do choose to read the book, don’t do it for the story itself, meaning the time-travelling part. I found myself enjoying the symbolism behind each character and what they learnt and how they learnt it, and I think you might too. The writing too was not quite my type, but it was perfect for the mood of the book,and that was amazing. It doesn’t grab you, but it definitely lures you into continuing to read the book. All in all, as far as “coming-of-age” YA goes, Proof of Forever may be something you might want to try if you’re looking for a bitter sweet ending and a couple of cute summer romances!
I WAS PROVIDED A FREE ECOPY OF THIS BOOK IN EXCHANGE OF AN HONEST REVIEW. THIS DID NOT IN ANY WAY, HOWEVER, INFLUENCE THE CONTENT OF THIS REVIEW.
May 27, 2015
3.5 stars!
Proof of Forever is a unique twist on your typical summer camp, second romance type of beach read. These just happen to be one of my very favorite types of books to read, so this was one I wasn’t going to miss. The uniqueness of this story took me a bit by surprise… but it was a good surprise, and one that kept me pretty interested.
Luce, Joy, Tali and Zoe were the best of friends up until a summer they spent in camp together. After that summer, the group of friends completely drifted after Joy walked away from the friendship without any explanation. The girls are all living their own lives, but Joy is still torn up about the loss of these friendships and decides to call together somewhat of a reunion with the girls. When they all pile into a photo booth to take a group shot, they are teleported back to that very summer when they were 15 years old and their friendships dissolved. Now that they’re back at that summer camp, each girl has the opportunity to relive that week that forever changed their lives. Each girl learns a lot during this second chance week, a lot of life lessons that will touch your heart. I wasn’t sure how this story was going to end, but I was satisfied with its bittersweet conclusion.
I have to admit the story was a bit slow at times, in the beginning particularly. And I had trouble liking some of the characters, especially Tali. But since I was able to relate to others, specifically Luce the most, I still really enjoyed the book and was invested in the story. The only real issue I had with this book, and it’s totally MY issue, not really the book’s, was trying to keep all of the characters straight. Having 4 MC’s, some with boyfriends and other characters that went along with them, it seemed like I needed to take notes in order to keep all of them straight. I have trouble with this a lot, so I’m sure it’s more of a “it’s not you, it’s me” type issue, but I wanted to mention it regardless, in case others have a problem with multiple POVs as well. I also was a bit disappointed at first when I saw it was all in third person. I wished it had been in first person POVs with each chapter being a different MC. But, honestly, I can see why it was written the way it was… and since it did end up working this way, I got over that pretty quickly.
When I went into this book, I honestly wasn’t prepared for the time travel part. I guess I missed that when I had first read the synopsis. My first thought was, “What is going on?”… then my immediate second thought was, “Oh, this could be cool.” I’m glad I stuck with it because I really ended up enjoying this. It had a typical contemporary feel, yet the added time travel factor, as well as some very valuable life lessons. Overall, I was pretty pleased with this book, and I really think others will enjoy it as well.
(Thanks to HarperCollins for the review copy!)
Find this review and others like it at Lost in Literature!
Proof of Forever is a unique twist on your typical summer camp, second romance type of beach read. These just happen to be one of my very favorite types of books to read, so this was one I wasn’t going to miss. The uniqueness of this story took me a bit by surprise… but it was a good surprise, and one that kept me pretty interested.
Luce, Joy, Tali and Zoe were the best of friends up until a summer they spent in camp together. After that summer, the group of friends completely drifted after Joy walked away from the friendship without any explanation. The girls are all living their own lives, but Joy is still torn up about the loss of these friendships and decides to call together somewhat of a reunion with the girls. When they all pile into a photo booth to take a group shot, they are teleported back to that very summer when they were 15 years old and their friendships dissolved. Now that they’re back at that summer camp, each girl has the opportunity to relive that week that forever changed their lives. Each girl learns a lot during this second chance week, a lot of life lessons that will touch your heart. I wasn’t sure how this story was going to end, but I was satisfied with its bittersweet conclusion.
I have to admit the story was a bit slow at times, in the beginning particularly. And I had trouble liking some of the characters, especially Tali. But since I was able to relate to others, specifically Luce the most, I still really enjoyed the book and was invested in the story. The only real issue I had with this book, and it’s totally MY issue, not really the book’s, was trying to keep all of the characters straight. Having 4 MC’s, some with boyfriends and other characters that went along with them, it seemed like I needed to take notes in order to keep all of them straight. I have trouble with this a lot, so I’m sure it’s more of a “it’s not you, it’s me” type issue, but I wanted to mention it regardless, in case others have a problem with multiple POVs as well. I also was a bit disappointed at first when I saw it was all in third person. I wished it had been in first person POVs with each chapter being a different MC. But, honestly, I can see why it was written the way it was… and since it did end up working this way, I got over that pretty quickly.
When I went into this book, I honestly wasn’t prepared for the time travel part. I guess I missed that when I had first read the synopsis. My first thought was, “What is going on?”… then my immediate second thought was, “Oh, this could be cool.” I’m glad I stuck with it because I really ended up enjoying this. It had a typical contemporary feel, yet the added time travel factor, as well as some very valuable life lessons. Overall, I was pretty pleased with this book, and I really think others will enjoy it as well.
(Thanks to HarperCollins for the review copy!)
Find this review and others like it at Lost in Literature!
June 13, 2015
Proof of Forever, Lexa Hillyer’s debut novel, seriously impressed me. It’s a beautifully written novel that perfectly captured the feeling of summer, lost friendships, and first love.
Proof of Forever is the story of four very different girls who happen to be former best friends. Zoe is a quirky nerd who loves everything Dr. Who. Tali is the pretty girl obsessed with money, popularity, and boys. Luce is the golden girl with the perfect boyfriend, perfect family, and perfect life, or so it seems. Then there is Joy, the one who disappeared from their lives two years ago but still manages to bring them all together for their camp reunion. The mix of characters allows for readers to find at least one they can relate to, if not all of them. Of course, each character also had their flaws that might annoy readers. Tali was by far the worst. I had issues with how shallow she was and how selfish. Joy was a bit closed off, Luce was a bit high strung, and Zoe was a bit oblivious but otherwise I liked them. And even Tali grew on me.
The story is extremely fun. These four former friends are sent back in time to their last summer at Camp Okahatchee. To get back to the present they have to recreate the summer but they quickly find out that it might be better for them as friends and individuals if they change some things about their past. The story might be very basic contemporary but there is also a sense of urgency to everything they do which helps speed the story along.
The synopsis mentions a dark secret about the girls but it’s not all that dark or secret to the reader. I was able to guess pretty early on exactly what was going on and what was probably going to happen. Nothing regarding this secret ever even came into the story until the end of the book. The ending was quite rushed and that was honestly my only issue with Proof of Forever.
A big plus about Proof of Forever were the types of relationships represented. Tali was kind of typical, going for the popular guy but there was someone else in her life that challenged everything she knew. Zoe is a bit clueless about relationships and sexuality but she learns a lot that one summer. Luce has the perfect relationship but there is a chance it’s holding her back. As for Joy, she meets someone new in the past that opens her up to love, something she never expected or hoped for.
Overall, Proof of Forever puts Lexa Hillyer on my radar. I can’t wait to see what she does next. It’ll have to be pretty dang awesome to top this one.
Proof of Forever is the story of four very different girls who happen to be former best friends. Zoe is a quirky nerd who loves everything Dr. Who. Tali is the pretty girl obsessed with money, popularity, and boys. Luce is the golden girl with the perfect boyfriend, perfect family, and perfect life, or so it seems. Then there is Joy, the one who disappeared from their lives two years ago but still manages to bring them all together for their camp reunion. The mix of characters allows for readers to find at least one they can relate to, if not all of them. Of course, each character also had their flaws that might annoy readers. Tali was by far the worst. I had issues with how shallow she was and how selfish. Joy was a bit closed off, Luce was a bit high strung, and Zoe was a bit oblivious but otherwise I liked them. And even Tali grew on me.
The story is extremely fun. These four former friends are sent back in time to their last summer at Camp Okahatchee. To get back to the present they have to recreate the summer but they quickly find out that it might be better for them as friends and individuals if they change some things about their past. The story might be very basic contemporary but there is also a sense of urgency to everything they do which helps speed the story along.
The synopsis mentions a dark secret about the girls but it’s not all that dark or secret to the reader. I was able to guess pretty early on exactly what was going on and what was probably going to happen. Nothing regarding this secret ever even came into the story until the end of the book. The ending was quite rushed and that was honestly my only issue with Proof of Forever.
A big plus about Proof of Forever were the types of relationships represented. Tali was kind of typical, going for the popular guy but there was someone else in her life that challenged everything she knew. Zoe is a bit clueless about relationships and sexuality but she learns a lot that one summer. Luce has the perfect relationship but there is a chance it’s holding her back. As for Joy, she meets someone new in the past that opens her up to love, something she never expected or hoped for.
Overall, Proof of Forever puts Lexa Hillyer on my radar. I can’t wait to see what she does next. It’ll have to be pretty dang awesome to top this one.
June 1, 2015
I received an ARC copy of this book from the publisher through Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review. For more reviews like this on, check out my blog, Divergent Gryffindor.
Actual rating: 3.5
When I first read the synopsis of this book, I really wanted to get my hands on it. The synopsis was vague to me, and that only piqued my interest more. However, when I started reading the book, I felt disappointed.
When I read about going back to the past through the photo booth, it reminded me of Disney movies, and I got giddy. However, after reading a bit more, I found that he first half of the book was really slow and dragging, and I would have given up on it had it not been a buddy read. I was also really taken aback that this book was in the third person point of view.
I thought that the story was weird. I knew what was going on, but I felt like I didn't really understand it. The story was kind of predictable too.
However, towards the second half of the book, things became more interesting, and I was able to get into the book again. I really liked how the four characters all got equal attention, not dwelling on a single character. The author was able to make the third person point of view work to the advantage of her plot, and I applaud her for that. I loved the four characters' journey towards finding themselves and finding their way towards each other.
I felt like the last few chapters were written in a rushed manner, but the story ended really well. I like how the book closed off in a kind of both positive and negative note, making it more or less realistic.
I think this book is not for everyone, but it's worth giving a shot.
Actual rating: 3.5
When I first read the synopsis of this book, I really wanted to get my hands on it. The synopsis was vague to me, and that only piqued my interest more. However, when I started reading the book, I felt disappointed.
When I read about going back to the past through the photo booth, it reminded me of Disney movies, and I got giddy. However, after reading a bit more, I found that he first half of the book was really slow and dragging, and I would have given up on it had it not been a buddy read. I was also really taken aback that this book was in the third person point of view.
I thought that the story was weird. I knew what was going on, but I felt like I didn't really understand it. The story was kind of predictable too.
However, towards the second half of the book, things became more interesting, and I was able to get into the book again. I really liked how the four characters all got equal attention, not dwelling on a single character. The author was able to make the third person point of view work to the advantage of her plot, and I applaud her for that. I loved the four characters' journey towards finding themselves and finding their way towards each other.
I felt like the last few chapters were written in a rushed manner, but the story ended really well. I like how the book closed off in a kind of both positive and negative note, making it more or less realistic.
I think this book is not for everyone, but it's worth giving a shot.
April 25, 2015
I received a copy of this teen novel from the publisher, opened it eagerly, and... almost gave up on it when I realized it was written in the present tense. Oh, my friends, how I hate reading extended narratives in the present tense. Hate hate hate. But I kept going, mostly because I love time-travel premises in all their shapes and forms, and I'm really glad I did. The present tense wasn't the last thing that annoyed me about the book, but it's okay, because this book has THE STUFF - that fierce, unfakeable spark of life that makes a book worth reading, no matter what. The stuff will propel me past any number of eye rolls. I predict I will still occasionally think of this book, with a smile, years from now. And when I was a teenager I would've loved it.
February 9, 2017
WOAHHHHHHHHH
JUST AWESOMNESSSSS
THE GIRLS WERE AWESOME!
REMINDED ME A LOT OF PLL
JUST READ
YOU WON'T REGRET IT
I KNOW I ONLY GAVE IT 4 STARS BUTTTTTTT ITS JUST NOT 5 STARS EVEN THOUGH IT WAS AWESOME!
JUST AWESOMNESSSSS
THE GIRLS WERE AWESOME!
REMINDED ME A LOT OF PLL
JUST READ
YOU WON'T REGRET IT
I KNOW I ONLY GAVE IT 4 STARS BUTTTTTTT ITS JUST NOT 5 STARS EVEN THOUGH IT WAS AWESOME!
March 13, 2015
Have you ever think of re-doing things over? having second chances? going back to the past and just try to be better for your future? coz, I honestly do.
This book is so good, beautiful, weird, fantastic, heart breaking and full of self discovery.
-- the rest of the review will be up soon!
This review is originally posted on my blog Home of a Book Lover
Have you ever think of having second chances? Have you ever think of going back to the past where you could just repeat everything you did and probably change the future? I’m asking because I do. Like every single day, I wish I could live in the past for a while.
I could say that this book is a great read. I had mixed emotions and the one that stays is the ending that made me cry. Reading this made me excited and frustrated at the same time because when I was reading the scene was getting to the climax then something will happen that you’ll get annoyed and sometimes I want to ask the author, why did you wrote that I was already excited (LOL). I had fun reading it. I liked how each and every one of the characters have their own side story. I like how each of them learned their mistakes and how they figured out their actions on how are they going to change their selves. I like how everyone just try to change the future but end up getting the opposite of what they wanted.
“Everyone always says it’s the little things in life that really matter”
Friendship that’s what they wanted to focus on here. Little things like friendship matters. I like how the wrote about the twists and turns from everyone’s life on this book. From Tali, to Luce to Zoe and to Joy. The four of them are best friends but two years passed Joy avoided the three of them for some unknown reason. Joy suddenly appeared and called them for a reunion but what happened is something extra ordinary. They all went back from two years ago, their day at the camp where every memories are good. Days passed and so many things happened and on their last day, is also the day they knew what really happened to Joy, or what was really the cause of her disappearance.
“It’s unfair, that you just have to accept things, take whatever you’re dealt and work with what you got. But you get to a point where at least you’re happy for the time you did have.”
The ending of the book broke me in to tears. Beautiful book. That is how I will describe the book in one word. It’s something that I will never forget because it makes me realize that second chances maybe a good thing or a bad one, but still I will take the risks though, going back one year or two years ago? Why not.
And what caught my eye first thing is the cover. I wasn’t expecting something that deep kind of story when I saw the book cover, all I know is that this will be a good book but I didn’t expect that it will be really good. I can’t wait for the hard copy of this book. I will definitely buy it and read it again. I fell in love with it so much.
I already suggested this book to some of my friends and tell them about the story and I even told them it made me cry and they smiled at me. So to the people reading this blog, I will also recommend this book to you. It is a must try!
Thank you Lexa! For giving me a chance to read your wonderful creation.
“You can’t just rely on your strength. You can’t win if you’re holding back”
This book is so good, beautiful, weird, fantastic, heart breaking and full of self discovery.
-- the rest of the review will be up soon!
This review is originally posted on my blog Home of a Book Lover
Have you ever think of having second chances? Have you ever think of going back to the past where you could just repeat everything you did and probably change the future? I’m asking because I do. Like every single day, I wish I could live in the past for a while.
I could say that this book is a great read. I had mixed emotions and the one that stays is the ending that made me cry. Reading this made me excited and frustrated at the same time because when I was reading the scene was getting to the climax then something will happen that you’ll get annoyed and sometimes I want to ask the author, why did you wrote that I was already excited (LOL). I had fun reading it. I liked how each and every one of the characters have their own side story. I like how each of them learned their mistakes and how they figured out their actions on how are they going to change their selves. I like how everyone just try to change the future but end up getting the opposite of what they wanted.
“Everyone always says it’s the little things in life that really matter”
Friendship that’s what they wanted to focus on here. Little things like friendship matters. I like how the wrote about the twists and turns from everyone’s life on this book. From Tali, to Luce to Zoe and to Joy. The four of them are best friends but two years passed Joy avoided the three of them for some unknown reason. Joy suddenly appeared and called them for a reunion but what happened is something extra ordinary. They all went back from two years ago, their day at the camp where every memories are good. Days passed and so many things happened and on their last day, is also the day they knew what really happened to Joy, or what was really the cause of her disappearance.
“It’s unfair, that you just have to accept things, take whatever you’re dealt and work with what you got. But you get to a point where at least you’re happy for the time you did have.”
The ending of the book broke me in to tears. Beautiful book. That is how I will describe the book in one word. It’s something that I will never forget because it makes me realize that second chances maybe a good thing or a bad one, but still I will take the risks though, going back one year or two years ago? Why not.
And what caught my eye first thing is the cover. I wasn’t expecting something that deep kind of story when I saw the book cover, all I know is that this will be a good book but I didn’t expect that it will be really good. I can’t wait for the hard copy of this book. I will definitely buy it and read it again. I fell in love with it so much.
I already suggested this book to some of my friends and tell them about the story and I even told them it made me cry and they smiled at me. So to the people reading this blog, I will also recommend this book to you. It is a must try!
Thank you Lexa! For giving me a chance to read your wonderful creation.
“You can’t just rely on your strength. You can’t win if you’re holding back”
March 7, 2019
This review also appears on Happy Indulgence.
It’s been a while since I’ve read a contemporary YA novel that I’ve actually enjoyed so Proof of Forever definitely came as a bit of a surprise. I didn’t really have high expectations for it because of my reading slump, and the fact that I came into possession of this book when another blogger didn’t want it. But I highly enjoyed the friendship story and thought it was the perfect summer book as Toronto starts to transition to fall.
Proof of Forever is a second chance friendship story about four girls who used to be best friends at a summer camp that they attended when they were younger. Now seniors in high school, they have drifted apart but a camp reunion gives them the opportunity to right their wrongs. When they’re mysteriously transported back into their fifteen-year-old bodies, they need to figure out a way to get back to their present lives. But along the way, they discover much more about themselves than they anticipated.
My favourite aspect of this book was the character development. The novel is told from the perspectives of each of the four girls and I enjoyed being about to get an in-depth look into their thought processes. Each character grew and developed throughout the book and they definitely were not the same girls at the end of the novel as they were at the start. I loved each of their stories separately and how they came to discover new things about themselves, but I also enjoyed reading about the bond between them and seeing it develop throughout the book. The character development was done in a really subtle manner and I loved that there wasn’t a major catalyst for their changes.
Each of the characters had depth and I liked how different they were from each other. It’s interesting how people who come from different backgrounds and have different personalities can come together and be there for each other. I liked all of the girls individually but together, I thought they were magic. Luce was probably my favourite character and I connected with her the most, probably because of how structured and organised her life was. She was definitely the quiet nerd of the group. But I also loved Joy, who turned out to be a completely different character to who I had envisioned her to be at the start of the novel. Tali and Zoe were also great characters and I loved the way that they were portrayed. Tali, at times, came across as quite self-centred but it was also nice to see her gentle and apologetic side.
There is romance in the novel but it doesn’t overshadow the main theme of friendship and I really appreciated that. The romances and relationships kept each girl’s individual story interesting to me but wasn’t the main focus of the book, which was refreshing to see. I also really liked all of the love interests and thought that their roles in the book were interesting and well thought out by the author.
Proof of Forever was a huge surprise to me and I really enjoyed it. The character development and exciting plot twists were the standout aspects of the novel for me and I really liked the way the story was weaved together.
It’s been a while since I’ve read a contemporary YA novel that I’ve actually enjoyed so Proof of Forever definitely came as a bit of a surprise. I didn’t really have high expectations for it because of my reading slump, and the fact that I came into possession of this book when another blogger didn’t want it. But I highly enjoyed the friendship story and thought it was the perfect summer book as Toronto starts to transition to fall.
Proof of Forever is a second chance friendship story about four girls who used to be best friends at a summer camp that they attended when they were younger. Now seniors in high school, they have drifted apart but a camp reunion gives them the opportunity to right their wrongs. When they’re mysteriously transported back into their fifteen-year-old bodies, they need to figure out a way to get back to their present lives. But along the way, they discover much more about themselves than they anticipated.
My favourite aspect of this book was the character development. The novel is told from the perspectives of each of the four girls and I enjoyed being about to get an in-depth look into their thought processes. Each character grew and developed throughout the book and they definitely were not the same girls at the end of the novel as they were at the start. I loved each of their stories separately and how they came to discover new things about themselves, but I also enjoyed reading about the bond between them and seeing it develop throughout the book. The character development was done in a really subtle manner and I loved that there wasn’t a major catalyst for their changes.
Each of the characters had depth and I liked how different they were from each other. It’s interesting how people who come from different backgrounds and have different personalities can come together and be there for each other. I liked all of the girls individually but together, I thought they were magic. Luce was probably my favourite character and I connected with her the most, probably because of how structured and organised her life was. She was definitely the quiet nerd of the group. But I also loved Joy, who turned out to be a completely different character to who I had envisioned her to be at the start of the novel. Tali and Zoe were also great characters and I loved the way that they were portrayed. Tali, at times, came across as quite self-centred but it was also nice to see her gentle and apologetic side.
There is romance in the novel but it doesn’t overshadow the main theme of friendship and I really appreciated that. The romances and relationships kept each girl’s individual story interesting to me but wasn’t the main focus of the book, which was refreshing to see. I also really liked all of the love interests and thought that their roles in the book were interesting and well thought out by the author.
Proof of Forever was a huge surprise to me and I really enjoyed it. The character development and exciting plot twists were the standout aspects of the novel for me and I really liked the way the story was weaved together.
June 10, 2015
After my last read, I really needed something to give me a boost again, and Proof of Forever easily did that for me. There have been so many amazing contemporary novels this year and it makes me wonder if this is the year of contemporary. Lexa hit it out of the park with Proof of Forever, and I didn’t want to put the book down once I picked it up, which rarely happens anymore even if I love a book.
This book contains everything I look for in debut novel. I know Lexa has done poetry in the past and won awards for it, so she obviously has amazing talent as a writer, but I will consider this her debut, as it is her first actual novel. That aside, I just can’t get over how beautifully written this book is. The concept of it is very intriguing and it really gives the reader something exciting to experience as they read the book.
With the concept of the book being as intriguing as it is, there are some moments while reading the book that I found to be slightly confusing, at least early on. I feel like it will take most readers a little time to fully catch on to how the story works but once you do, you are in for a truly incredible book.
The characters are also written extremely well, which make the flow of the story even better. Tali, Zoe, Joy and Luce all have very unique personalities, which can easily be picked up on once you get into the story. It’s interesting to see them return to the past and have to figure out who they really are, and to just watch them grow as characters. This is by far the main focus of the overall concept of the book, so like I mentioned above, once you pick up on how the book is written you are in for a treat.
I can recall several books in recent years that have attempted to pull something like this off, and while some of them were really good, I have to say that Proof of Forever is a shining example of how to execute these stories involving time travel, and light fantasy concepts. It’s still very much a contemporary book, but it was really interesting to see how Lexa tied in all of the other elements to make it such an exciting read.
This book is perfect for anyone that loves young adult. Aside from needing a little time to grasp the overall concept of the book, I couldn’t find anything else that had any negative impact on the book as a whole. It’s beautifully written with a compelling story and a group of characters that will easily pull you into their journey as they work to figure out who they are.
I highly recommend that you all pick this book up whenever you get an opportunity too. I still can’t get over how impressed I am with this book, and I am eagerly awaiting Lexa’s next title. She has proven that she is an extremely talented writer, so I can only hope that her future books will be even more amazing, and Proof of Forever sets a really high bar out of the gate.
This book contains everything I look for in debut novel. I know Lexa has done poetry in the past and won awards for it, so she obviously has amazing talent as a writer, but I will consider this her debut, as it is her first actual novel. That aside, I just can’t get over how beautifully written this book is. The concept of it is very intriguing and it really gives the reader something exciting to experience as they read the book.
With the concept of the book being as intriguing as it is, there are some moments while reading the book that I found to be slightly confusing, at least early on. I feel like it will take most readers a little time to fully catch on to how the story works but once you do, you are in for a truly incredible book.
The characters are also written extremely well, which make the flow of the story even better. Tali, Zoe, Joy and Luce all have very unique personalities, which can easily be picked up on once you get into the story. It’s interesting to see them return to the past and have to figure out who they really are, and to just watch them grow as characters. This is by far the main focus of the overall concept of the book, so like I mentioned above, once you pick up on how the book is written you are in for a treat.
I can recall several books in recent years that have attempted to pull something like this off, and while some of them were really good, I have to say that Proof of Forever is a shining example of how to execute these stories involving time travel, and light fantasy concepts. It’s still very much a contemporary book, but it was really interesting to see how Lexa tied in all of the other elements to make it such an exciting read.
This book is perfect for anyone that loves young adult. Aside from needing a little time to grasp the overall concept of the book, I couldn’t find anything else that had any negative impact on the book as a whole. It’s beautifully written with a compelling story and a group of characters that will easily pull you into their journey as they work to figure out who they are.
I highly recommend that you all pick this book up whenever you get an opportunity too. I still can’t get over how impressed I am with this book, and I am eagerly awaiting Lexa’s next title. She has proven that she is an extremely talented writer, so I can only hope that her future books will be even more amazing, and Proof of Forever sets a really high bar out of the gate.
Read
June 1, 2015The review was originally posted on Andi's ABCs
I was first interested in Proof of Forever because it reminded me of the Britney Spears movie Crossroads. I love a story about girls that are pulled apart, whether it is because they have grown apart or for other reason, that are all of sudden thrust back into each others lives. And although the book is very different from Crossroads, they did have some similarities and the same vibe.
Proof of Forever is the story of Joy, Tali, Luce, and Zoe, 4 girls that used to spend their summers at camp attached at the hip. But now they are virtual strangers as 2 years ago something pulled them apart. When the camp reunion happens though Joy is convinced they all need to come together and be together one last time. Not completely sold on the idea Tali, Luce and Zoe go along begrudgingly. But before they even know what happens a flash of a camera transports them back in time to the summer they were 15 and all had each other's back. Now with only each other to count on the 4 of them must figure out a way to fix what broke and get back to the future where they belong.
I guess the main part that I liked about Proof of Forever didn't end up being the friendships, but the growth of each individual girl. Joy, Tali, Luce and Zoe each had a lot of growing up to do and needed to look at their life before things got complicated. They needed to see what they were like before boys and popularity and the stress of perfection and anger got in the way of everything. It was a highlight to see them make the changes when forced to confront the past and what exactly tore them apart to begin with. It's a fact that we all change as we get older, but if given the chance to look back would we do things differently? I liked that idea as I watched the 4 of them struggle with it.
All in all Proof of Forever definitely wasn't Crossroads. It was something else. It was a different kind of story about friendship and growing up. And about how hard it is to stay true to what you feel and believe when other outside sources what you to behave differently.
I was first interested in Proof of Forever because it reminded me of the Britney Spears movie Crossroads. I love a story about girls that are pulled apart, whether it is because they have grown apart or for other reason, that are all of sudden thrust back into each others lives. And although the book is very different from Crossroads, they did have some similarities and the same vibe.
Proof of Forever is the story of Joy, Tali, Luce, and Zoe, 4 girls that used to spend their summers at camp attached at the hip. But now they are virtual strangers as 2 years ago something pulled them apart. When the camp reunion happens though Joy is convinced they all need to come together and be together one last time. Not completely sold on the idea Tali, Luce and Zoe go along begrudgingly. But before they even know what happens a flash of a camera transports them back in time to the summer they were 15 and all had each other's back. Now with only each other to count on the 4 of them must figure out a way to fix what broke and get back to the future where they belong.
I guess the main part that I liked about Proof of Forever didn't end up being the friendships, but the growth of each individual girl. Joy, Tali, Luce and Zoe each had a lot of growing up to do and needed to look at their life before things got complicated. They needed to see what they were like before boys and popularity and the stress of perfection and anger got in the way of everything. It was a highlight to see them make the changes when forced to confront the past and what exactly tore them apart to begin with. It's a fact that we all change as we get older, but if given the chance to look back would we do things differently? I liked that idea as I watched the 4 of them struggle with it.
All in all Proof of Forever definitely wasn't Crossroads. It was something else. It was a different kind of story about friendship and growing up. And about how hard it is to stay true to what you feel and believe when other outside sources what you to behave differently.
December 16, 2015
I received an eARC of this book from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review, and yes, heartbreakingly honest it shall be.
I was totally enraptured by this book even before reading it, because firstly, HAVE YOU SEEN THAT COVER? IT'S SO PRETTY. Secondly, this book is about time-travelling, but it's not sci-fi. Which makes it all the more cooler, because hello, contemporary plus time-travelling? Perfect summer read. (Not that it's summer here, PFFT.) Also, guys, this is the ultimate girls bestfriend book. Or bestfriendS in this scenario. Basically, this book is about four girls, Tali, Joy, Luce and Joy. They used to be best friends, until Joy unexpectedly abandoned them. Two years later, Joy comes back, asking for a reunion between the four of them.
For some reason, to recreate another photo strip, the flash from that photo booth sent them back in time, to the summer that changed everything.
Before you start reading this book, grab boxes of tissues, because I shall warn you beforehand that this book will make you cry. To be honest, the character I loved most was Joy. She was the quiet one, the one who's always there for everybody. And she was the one who left too. Honestly, from the start, I really really wanted to know the reason as to why she left, because nobody seemed to know. But right now? NO. Get this book away from me HAHAHA kidding. Joy had her faults but I feel like she's the only one who actually tried hard in this book. She wanted them to be together again. And when she finally found a guy for herself (because they all did, really), I was so overjoyed that I may have screamed HAHA.
Until now though, I am still amazed that this author mixed in TIME TRAVELLING with a normal summer bool, and that kind of book could either make it or break it. REALLY. But I love this book and I say, "Good job, Lexa Hillyer!"
July 14, 2015
Huh. So this was flawed, but, to my own surprise, I found it effective by the end.
The premise of going back in time . . . yeah, that's really hard to pull off in a realistic novel and the execution made me cringe at times. The characters' reactions to going back in time didn't feel realistic to me. It sort of felt like, "Let's just go with it!!" and, well. I don't know how to "fix" that. Because the point of the novel wasn't really the time travel. Still. It ended up feeling a bit too . . . random. And their conclusion on how to get back . . . I don't know. That felt too random as well.
I didn't quite connect with the characters or their motivations. I never felt like I quite got to understand the specific things they were struggling with. And I don't believe they grew and changed that much in the course of the book.
Still, by the end, I was satisfied with the read.
The premise of going back in time . . . yeah, that's really hard to pull off in a realistic novel and the execution made me cringe at times. The characters' reactions to going back in time didn't feel realistic to me. It sort of felt like, "Let's just go with it!!" and, well. I don't know how to "fix" that. Because the point of the novel wasn't really the time travel. Still. It ended up feeling a bit too . . . random. And their conclusion on how to get back . . . I don't know. That felt too random as well.
I didn't quite connect with the characters or their motivations. I never felt like I quite got to understand the specific things they were struggling with. And I don't believe they grew and changed that much in the course of the book.
Still, by the end, I was satisfied with the read.
May 21, 2015
I have a personal rule that if a book uses the f-bomb more than two times in the first chapter, then I will not finish the book. Sometimes I can deal with less major cussing (I.e. Also Known As by Robin Benway). But this book started with innuendos AND cussing, so I stopped. Look, I just cannot read a book with tons of cussing.
I feel a little bad, because this isn't a proper review. Needless to say, I didn't finish book. I'll go ahead with the normal lists.
THE GOOD
1. Eye-catching cover
2. Pretty good synopsis.
3. The endorsement by Jennifer E. Smith. That's basically why I read this book.
THE BAD
1. Pretty major cussing
2. Innuendos
3. Well, this was misleading. It was supposed to be about some best friends. Eh. Not so. Cussing. Innuendos. Uh-oh.
One star.
I feel a little bad, because this isn't a proper review. Needless to say, I didn't finish book. I'll go ahead with the normal lists.
THE GOOD
1. Eye-catching cover
2. Pretty good synopsis.
3. The endorsement by Jennifer E. Smith. That's basically why I read this book.
THE BAD
1. Pretty major cussing
2. Innuendos
3. Well, this was misleading. It was supposed to be about some best friends. Eh. Not so. Cussing. Innuendos. Uh-oh.
One star.
April 18, 2015
This is a lovely book about friendship, second chances, love and loss.
I love the magic and learning to recognize the great moments in your life. A good read.
I love the magic and learning to recognize the great moments in your life. A good read.
July 23, 2015
Actual rating: 3.5 stars
I'm pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this.
I'm pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this.
June 17, 2015
This was a super fun read! Really enjoyed it. Review to come! <3 (By the way, my current rating may change as I'm writing my review... still deciding between a 4 and 4.5 star rating...)
June 27, 2023
3.5 ⭐️
i liked this book! but the reason it’s only 3.5 is because i didn’t feel at all connected to the characters and the plot felt a little choppy. there was nothing i extremely disliked about this book, though. i grew up at summer camp and this was slightly nostalgic for me 😂
i liked this book! but the reason it’s only 3.5 is because i didn’t feel at all connected to the characters and the plot felt a little choppy. there was nothing i extremely disliked about this book, though. i grew up at summer camp and this was slightly nostalgic for me 😂
July 19, 2015
Ringrazio immensamente De Agostini per avermi regalato la splendida opportunità di leggere questo libro in anteprima in cambio della mia onesta opinione. Ve ne sono immensamente grata!
Recensione anche sul mio blog:
http://pleaseanotherbook.tumblr.com/p...
“Per un attimo e per sempre” è la traduzione italiana di ”Proof of Forever” di Lexa Hillyer uscita lo scorso giugno per De Agostini Young Adult. Devo dire che non sapevo cosa aspettarmi, perché avevo scorso velocemente la trama ma mi ero completamente innamorata della cover originale, che insomma, dovevo averlo questo libro (ma dai Anncleire il solito vizio eh?). Tra l’altro in America il libro porta la firma di HarperCollins, la mia CE preferita, che fino ad ora non mi ha mai delusa. E non lo ha fatto neanche in questo caso. L’atmosfera estiva, un gruppo di amiche che cercano la consistenza della loro amicizia, mi hanno incantata e portata ad immergermi completamente in questa storia.
Vi è mai capitato di desiderare di rifare qualcosa da capo, sperare ardentemente di tornare indietro e ricominciare tutto, riallacciare legami spezzati, cambiare le carte in tavola? È quello che in fondo in un’altra dimensione provano a fare quattro amiche, che un po’ per abitudine un po’ per incomprensioni si sono allontanate spezzando un legame che sembrava indistruttibile. Il cambiamento è all’ordine del giorno ma nessuna delle quattro poteva immaginare che in due anni si sarebbero perse in maniera tanto definitiva. Ognuna di loro ha un ruolo, ha delle aspirazioni, dei sogni e inevitabilmente quando il collante del gruppo le abbandona iniziano le recriminazioni. L’estate al campo estivo, sembra un mondo parallelo, distaccato nel tempo e nello spazio, in cui tutte riescono a coagularsi in un’unità perfetta fatta di sleepover, successi e sconfitte, unificate dalla comprensione e dall’affetto reciproco. Joy è l’ascoltatrice, colei che silenziosamente capta tutti i segnali, immortalandoli, nella sua mente. Con il sorriso sempre pronto e la soluzione ai problemi a portata di mano, colei che davvero tiene insieme le altre con fiducia, perché sa quanto sia importante avere delle amiche fidate al fianco. Ma nasconde anche un terribile segreto, segreto che la porta ad allontanarsi e mettere da parte tutto quello in cui ha sempre creduto. Luce è la responsabile del gruppo, la brava ragazza, la maniaca dell’ordine e dell’organizzazione, quella che ha sempre tutto sotto controllo. La ragazza con il ragazzo perfetto, la media scolastica perfetta, la famiglia perfetta. Eppure Luce non ha tutto così sotto controllo, non è sempre responsabile per ogni minimo dettaglio. Tenere a mente tutto è estenuante e faticoso, difficile e non riceve quasi mai i riconoscimenti che merita. Chi le sta intorno, soprattutto la sua famiglia, pretende il massimo da lei, e lei decisamente mette la testa sotto la sabbia. Tali invece è la fashion del gruppo, dedita alla moda, al suo corpo, a essere popolare, all’essere accettata dalla gente che conta, al liceo, nel gruppo figo, con i quarterback, o i capitani di qualsiasi squadra del liceo o comunque i belli e impossibili, quegli stronzi a cui non è facile rifiutare qualcosa, con il loro bel faccino. Tali è tanto bella quanto insicura, tanto carismatica quanto incosciente, e Blake, il suo sogno fin da ragazzina, resta l’obiettivo da raggiungere, la tacca da aggiungere alla sua virtuale cintura. In un paio d’anni, quelli dello sviluppo, Tali ha ottenuto le curve che voleva e la sicurezza di avere ai suoi piedi chiunque le interessi, quando da ragazzina era un ammasso di inconsistenza. Zoe, invece, è la sportiva del gruppo, campionessa di scherma, si veste come un ragazzo, incurante del suo aspetto fisico, ma che fondamentalmente teme il giudizio delle persone che la circondano. Coraggiosa e solare, Zoe non si accetta e si nega, nella speranza, vana, di essersi sbagliata.
Tutte e quattro devono fare i conti con loro stesse, con i loro sentimenti e le loro paure, accettarsi per come sono e realizzare che la loro amicizia è più forte di quello che credono. Ed è molto interessante vedere come queste quattro ragazze interagiscono, cadono, sbagliano, si scaglino l’una contro l’altra ma alla fin fine restano unite, a consolidare i loro legami, a rendersi conto che la vita è fatta di piccoli momenti e gesti, che apparentemente non significano niente e invece racchiudono più di mille parole.
L’ambientazione, quella del campo estivo, è spettacolare con il lago che fa da sfondo alle loro disavventure, ai loro problemi di cuore e di vita e che insieme le accompagnerà, alla scoperta del mondo che non si ferma e va avanti.
Il particolare da non dimenticare? Delle fototessera…
Quattro ragazze alle prese con un viaggio in se stesse, spirituale e magico, che si perde tra altri adolescenti, in cerca di una direzione. Una storia che scivola, con la freschezza dell’estate e alcuni spunti di riflessione interessanti. Il soffio di una storia in cui nulla è come sembra e che porta quattro adolescenti a riscoprire un’amicizia che credevano sopita.
Buona lettura guys!
Recensione anche sul mio blog:
http://pleaseanotherbook.tumblr.com/p...
“Per un attimo e per sempre” è la traduzione italiana di ”Proof of Forever” di Lexa Hillyer uscita lo scorso giugno per De Agostini Young Adult. Devo dire che non sapevo cosa aspettarmi, perché avevo scorso velocemente la trama ma mi ero completamente innamorata della cover originale, che insomma, dovevo averlo questo libro (ma dai Anncleire il solito vizio eh?). Tra l’altro in America il libro porta la firma di HarperCollins, la mia CE preferita, che fino ad ora non mi ha mai delusa. E non lo ha fatto neanche in questo caso. L’atmosfera estiva, un gruppo di amiche che cercano la consistenza della loro amicizia, mi hanno incantata e portata ad immergermi completamente in questa storia.
Vi è mai capitato di desiderare di rifare qualcosa da capo, sperare ardentemente di tornare indietro e ricominciare tutto, riallacciare legami spezzati, cambiare le carte in tavola? È quello che in fondo in un’altra dimensione provano a fare quattro amiche, che un po’ per abitudine un po’ per incomprensioni si sono allontanate spezzando un legame che sembrava indistruttibile. Il cambiamento è all’ordine del giorno ma nessuna delle quattro poteva immaginare che in due anni si sarebbero perse in maniera tanto definitiva. Ognuna di loro ha un ruolo, ha delle aspirazioni, dei sogni e inevitabilmente quando il collante del gruppo le abbandona iniziano le recriminazioni. L’estate al campo estivo, sembra un mondo parallelo, distaccato nel tempo e nello spazio, in cui tutte riescono a coagularsi in un’unità perfetta fatta di sleepover, successi e sconfitte, unificate dalla comprensione e dall’affetto reciproco. Joy è l’ascoltatrice, colei che silenziosamente capta tutti i segnali, immortalandoli, nella sua mente. Con il sorriso sempre pronto e la soluzione ai problemi a portata di mano, colei che davvero tiene insieme le altre con fiducia, perché sa quanto sia importante avere delle amiche fidate al fianco. Ma nasconde anche un terribile segreto, segreto che la porta ad allontanarsi e mettere da parte tutto quello in cui ha sempre creduto. Luce è la responsabile del gruppo, la brava ragazza, la maniaca dell’ordine e dell’organizzazione, quella che ha sempre tutto sotto controllo. La ragazza con il ragazzo perfetto, la media scolastica perfetta, la famiglia perfetta. Eppure Luce non ha tutto così sotto controllo, non è sempre responsabile per ogni minimo dettaglio. Tenere a mente tutto è estenuante e faticoso, difficile e non riceve quasi mai i riconoscimenti che merita. Chi le sta intorno, soprattutto la sua famiglia, pretende il massimo da lei, e lei decisamente mette la testa sotto la sabbia. Tali invece è la fashion del gruppo, dedita alla moda, al suo corpo, a essere popolare, all’essere accettata dalla gente che conta, al liceo, nel gruppo figo, con i quarterback, o i capitani di qualsiasi squadra del liceo o comunque i belli e impossibili, quegli stronzi a cui non è facile rifiutare qualcosa, con il loro bel faccino. Tali è tanto bella quanto insicura, tanto carismatica quanto incosciente, e Blake, il suo sogno fin da ragazzina, resta l’obiettivo da raggiungere, la tacca da aggiungere alla sua virtuale cintura. In un paio d’anni, quelli dello sviluppo, Tali ha ottenuto le curve che voleva e la sicurezza di avere ai suoi piedi chiunque le interessi, quando da ragazzina era un ammasso di inconsistenza. Zoe, invece, è la sportiva del gruppo, campionessa di scherma, si veste come un ragazzo, incurante del suo aspetto fisico, ma che fondamentalmente teme il giudizio delle persone che la circondano. Coraggiosa e solare, Zoe non si accetta e si nega, nella speranza, vana, di essersi sbagliata.
Tutte e quattro devono fare i conti con loro stesse, con i loro sentimenti e le loro paure, accettarsi per come sono e realizzare che la loro amicizia è più forte di quello che credono. Ed è molto interessante vedere come queste quattro ragazze interagiscono, cadono, sbagliano, si scaglino l’una contro l’altra ma alla fin fine restano unite, a consolidare i loro legami, a rendersi conto che la vita è fatta di piccoli momenti e gesti, che apparentemente non significano niente e invece racchiudono più di mille parole.
L’ambientazione, quella del campo estivo, è spettacolare con il lago che fa da sfondo alle loro disavventure, ai loro problemi di cuore e di vita e che insieme le accompagnerà, alla scoperta del mondo che non si ferma e va avanti.
Il particolare da non dimenticare? Delle fototessera…
Quattro ragazze alle prese con un viaggio in se stesse, spirituale e magico, che si perde tra altri adolescenti, in cerca di una direzione. Una storia che scivola, con la freschezza dell’estate e alcuni spunti di riflessione interessanti. Il soffio di una storia in cui nulla è come sembra e che porta quattro adolescenti a riscoprire un’amicizia che credevano sopita.
Buona lettura guys!
February 14, 2016
Not a long review, just a short one to express my thoughts. I would go into it more, but this book is build on surprises and I don't want to ruin any of them.
I always have a soft spot for books about camps, they do seem like a good deal of fun. Lakes, swimming, cabins, games, talent shows, too bad about the food though, but oh well, making friends and meeting each other each year, and much much more. But what if you add time travel to the equation? What if you add: 'You get a second chance' to the mix? Well then you get this book.
We have 4 characters, each with their secrets, their goals and their feelings. These girls had been best friends, until 2 years ago when stuff happened and the girls quickly lost sight of each other.
With each page and each time a character gets their say we find out slowly what is going on with them, and why they are doing what they are doing. It was really interesting to find out what truly happened between the group of close friends. What made them break up? Did they just drift apart or is it something different? What is Joy hiding and why did she break off all communication 2 years ago?
I did like the fact that when they time travelled, the only thing that changed was how they looked, they reverted back to 15-year old. Which brought on some hilarious situations, one lost her boobs, the other regained her long hair, and a few other things.
I did like how they tried to keep things the same, but I was more delighted when I found out that they also didn't want to keep everything the same, that they were trying to change stuff, that they were seeing this as a second chance to do things differently. They also learned several things while being in there, things that they didn't see when they were 15, but can now see with all that they know now. But, there were also revelations. Things that they didn't know back then, things that festered and that slowly boiled until it was revealed.
Since this might be a bit spoilerish, I will hide it behind spoiler tags. I know, I said I would keep it spoiler free, but I just have to mention it.
I didn't entirely like that it seemed like all these girls were doing at the camp was flirting and trying to get into the pants of boys. At times it distracting quite a bit. I was like: "Hey you guys, you have to get back to the future, no time to screw around." I knew they were trying their best, but at times it just felt like they weren't. Like they suddenly discovered that hot boys were more important. And yes, I still liked the romance, but I just didn't expect it to be this much.
I can also say that I was a tiny bit disappointed that they tried to go back. I know, they had to get back, but I just felt sad. Sure, not everything went ok in this world, but for most of the book I felt like the girls changed (often for the better), and that they should take this chance to change more.
Ah yes, the drama was at times just too much, it was just silly how these girls don't care to listen to each other, don't care to just for once shut up, open up and let the other party tell you what happened.
What happened near the end (not the actual ending yet) was nice, but it was also a small reason for me to drop the rating a bit. I don't know exactly what I had hoped, but it wasn't really this. That I know for sure. It doesn't match with most Time Travel books I know. Now it all seemed like this wasn't that, but instead something totally different. And that is all I can and will say. You will have to read the book to find out what happens. :)
The ending was terribly sad, and I will warn you, you will probably cry your eyes out. I had my suspicions, but I was hoping it was just a lie. Sadly, it turned out it wasn't. Dear Lord, that ending it just broke my heart. :(
All in all, this book was really great and I truly enjoyed myself even though there were some parts that were just overdramatic and cliché. If you are looking for a good summer camp story with an extra bonus of Time Travel, then I would recommend this book.
Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
I always have a soft spot for books about camps, they do seem like a good deal of fun. Lakes, swimming, cabins, games, talent shows, too bad about the food though, but oh well, making friends and meeting each other each year, and much much more. But what if you add time travel to the equation? What if you add: 'You get a second chance' to the mix? Well then you get this book.
We have 4 characters, each with their secrets, their goals and their feelings. These girls had been best friends, until 2 years ago when stuff happened and the girls quickly lost sight of each other.
With each page and each time a character gets their say we find out slowly what is going on with them, and why they are doing what they are doing. It was really interesting to find out what truly happened between the group of close friends. What made them break up? Did they just drift apart or is it something different? What is Joy hiding and why did she break off all communication 2 years ago?
I did like the fact that when they time travelled, the only thing that changed was how they looked, they reverted back to 15-year old. Which brought on some hilarious situations, one lost her boobs, the other regained her long hair, and a few other things.
I did like how they tried to keep things the same, but I was more delighted when I found out that they also didn't want to keep everything the same, that they were trying to change stuff, that they were seeing this as a second chance to do things differently. They also learned several things while being in there, things that they didn't see when they were 15, but can now see with all that they know now. But, there were also revelations. Things that they didn't know back then, things that festered and that slowly boiled until it was revealed.
Since this might be a bit spoilerish, I will hide it behind spoiler tags. I know, I said I would keep it spoiler free, but I just have to mention it.
I didn't entirely like that it seemed like all these girls were doing at the camp was flirting and trying to get into the pants of boys. At times it distracting quite a bit. I was like: "Hey you guys, you have to get back to the future, no time to screw around." I knew they were trying their best, but at times it just felt like they weren't. Like they suddenly discovered that hot boys were more important. And yes, I still liked the romance, but I just didn't expect it to be this much.
I can also say that I was a tiny bit disappointed that they tried to go back. I know, they had to get back, but I just felt sad. Sure, not everything went ok in this world, but for most of the book I felt like the girls changed (often for the better), and that they should take this chance to change more.
Ah yes, the drama was at times just too much, it was just silly how these girls don't care to listen to each other, don't care to just for once shut up, open up and let the other party tell you what happened.
What happened near the end (not the actual ending yet) was nice, but it was also a small reason for me to drop the rating a bit. I don't know exactly what I had hoped, but it wasn't really this. That I know for sure. It doesn't match with most Time Travel books I know. Now it all seemed like this wasn't that, but instead something totally different. And that is all I can and will say. You will have to read the book to find out what happens. :)
The ending was terribly sad, and I will warn you, you will probably cry your eyes out. I had my suspicions, but I was hoping it was just a lie. Sadly, it turned out it wasn't. Dear Lord, that ending it just broke my heart. :(
All in all, this book was really great and I truly enjoyed myself even though there were some parts that were just overdramatic and cliché. If you are looking for a good summer camp story with an extra bonus of Time Travel, then I would recommend this book.
Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
June 14, 2018
I want to start off by saying the I LOVED Spindle Fire and am currently also really enjoying Winter Glass. But this just goes to show that authors improve over time and as they find their niche.
I truly believe that while Lexa's writing is still beautiful in Proof of Forever, it's MUCH more suited for fantasy. It seemed like she sometimes struggled for metaphors that would resonate with the characters (ie. comparing the crescent moon to a toenail clipping....?? Like...why?) and the addition of time travel seems to prove that Lexa just wanted to write something fantastical from the beginning.
The concept was strange....it felt like a weird mashup between Pretty Little Liars (more to come on that) and Hot Tub Machine....at camp?
As a fair warning the rest of the review will be littered with SPOILERS. You have been warned.
Let's talk about the characters. This is where the Pretty Little Liars comparison becomes super apparent:
We have Joy (Allison in PLL): the one who 'holds the group together'. The 'glue'. And, when she moves away without explanation, the group falls apart. She's the one who everyone feels they can tell her secrets and yet she keeps the MOST secrets. I mean, come on girl. You don't even tell your own friends that you're dying?
Then there's Tali (Hanna in PLL): The pretty girl who's obsessed with hair and makeup, a former 'ugly duckling' by her own words, and became friends with the popular kids when Allison *coughs * I mean Joy leaves.
Next is Luce (Spencer in PLL): The smartypants who's obsessed with acceptance into Princeton, who has a strict family and is obsessed with her own perfection but also does drugs in a moment of weakness.
Lastly is Zoe (a mix of Aria and Emily): The book nerd, the athlete, the lesbian. She doesn't have a filter but always has a plan. Her love interest is found through her sport of choice just like Emily and Paige. This time with fencing.
The comparisons were uncanny.
Probably what I disliked most though was that this book is made for teens and yet it kinda encourages a lot of negative things...(drinking, drugs, sneaking out, hooking up a few days after meeting a guy at the age of 15, stealing, lying—so much lying). I know kids do these things anyway but is it really a good idea to encourage it? Maybe I'm just oblivious to the point of contemporary books but I didn't like that Proof of Forever painted these things with a more positive than negative vibe.
Overall, it was a mediocre book with a surprising ending and cookie-cutter characters. Let me reiterate though: Spindle Fire is AMAZING. I need more books like it. Lexa has improved, as authors do. This book just wasn't for me and I don't think it highlights just how amazing of an author Lexa really is.
I truly believe that while Lexa's writing is still beautiful in Proof of Forever, it's MUCH more suited for fantasy. It seemed like she sometimes struggled for metaphors that would resonate with the characters (ie. comparing the crescent moon to a toenail clipping....?? Like...why?) and the addition of time travel seems to prove that Lexa just wanted to write something fantastical from the beginning.
The concept was strange....it felt like a weird mashup between Pretty Little Liars (more to come on that) and Hot Tub Machine....at camp?
As a fair warning the rest of the review will be littered with SPOILERS. You have been warned.
Let's talk about the characters. This is where the Pretty Little Liars comparison becomes super apparent:
We have Joy (Allison in PLL): the one who 'holds the group together'. The 'glue'. And, when she moves away without explanation, the group falls apart. She's the one who everyone feels they can tell her secrets and yet she keeps the MOST secrets. I mean, come on girl. You don't even tell your own friends that you're dying?
Then there's Tali (Hanna in PLL): The pretty girl who's obsessed with hair and makeup, a former 'ugly duckling' by her own words, and became friends with the popular kids when Allison *coughs * I mean Joy leaves.
Next is Luce (Spencer in PLL): The smartypants who's obsessed with acceptance into Princeton, who has a strict family and is obsessed with her own perfection but also does drugs in a moment of weakness.
Lastly is Zoe (a mix of Aria and Emily): The book nerd, the athlete, the lesbian. She doesn't have a filter but always has a plan. Her love interest is found through her sport of choice just like Emily and Paige. This time with fencing.
The comparisons were uncanny.
Probably what I disliked most though was that this book is made for teens and yet it kinda encourages a lot of negative things...(drinking, drugs, sneaking out, hooking up a few days after meeting a guy at the age of 15, stealing, lying—so much lying). I know kids do these things anyway but is it really a good idea to encourage it? Maybe I'm just oblivious to the point of contemporary books but I didn't like that Proof of Forever painted these things with a more positive than negative vibe.
Overall, it was a mediocre book with a surprising ending and cookie-cutter characters. Let me reiterate though: Spindle Fire is AMAZING. I need more books like it. Lexa has improved, as authors do. This book just wasn't for me and I don't think it highlights just how amazing of an author Lexa really is.
June 21, 2016
Quick review for a not so quick read despite the length of the narrative. To be honest, I'm still struggling over my end thoughts on Lexa Hillyer's "Proof of Forever". I definitely liked the concept of the novel and the intent behind it. Four girls who have had estranged relationships are provided an odd chance to relive their experiences during the one summer when they were all friends and coming to terms with a number of examinations within their relationships, with each other, and with the crossing of their present and past lives. Zoe, Tali, Joy and Luce are all very distinctive, identifiable characters, and I'll admit that I liked being able to examine their experiences and unique traits as they try to recreate pieces of their past for the possibility of returning to the present. Of course, it isn't so easy considering various obstacles get in their way - what with changing timelines, circumstances, misunderstandings, even the clashes they have between each other that eventually bubble to the surface for them to deal with on their own terms.
I would say that this is very light sci-fi with a chiefly coming of age aspect to it and sugary sweet doses of humor and romance. So with that in mind, I guess you would be wondering "Rose, why weren't you more enthused about this narrative?" Answer: it's hard for me to say, because in theory and on paper, I should've liked this book more than I did. I felt like it didn't provide me with as strong of a connection as I was hoping for. Maybe it was because it tried to take on too many themes in such a short span of time; maybe it was the style of the narration Hillyer used to illuminate each of the girls' POVs; maybe it was the fact that it could've gone even more fun directions for the interesting premise instead of opting for the obvious cheese humor. But it had cute moments, it had some nice narratives for the coming to terms, it had some great points of self-realization and identification. I just...feel like I wasn't as completely immersed in this as much as I wanted to be. I really wanted that experience too. :(
It was good for a one time read and I'm glad I took the time to peruse it, but honestly thinking about it - it's not the type of narrative I'd return to more than once or twice. I wish it'd been as memorable as "Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants" or Lauren Oliver's "Before I Fall" or narratives that present a flawed cast of characters with coming of age elements, humor, and identification. Alas, it didn't quite hit above the mark with me.
Overall score: 3/5 stars.
I would say that this is very light sci-fi with a chiefly coming of age aspect to it and sugary sweet doses of humor and romance. So with that in mind, I guess you would be wondering "Rose, why weren't you more enthused about this narrative?" Answer: it's hard for me to say, because in theory and on paper, I should've liked this book more than I did. I felt like it didn't provide me with as strong of a connection as I was hoping for. Maybe it was because it tried to take on too many themes in such a short span of time; maybe it was the style of the narration Hillyer used to illuminate each of the girls' POVs; maybe it was the fact that it could've gone even more fun directions for the interesting premise instead of opting for the obvious cheese humor. But it had cute moments, it had some nice narratives for the coming to terms, it had some great points of self-realization and identification. I just...feel like I wasn't as completely immersed in this as much as I wanted to be. I really wanted that experience too. :(
It was good for a one time read and I'm glad I took the time to peruse it, but honestly thinking about it - it's not the type of narrative I'd return to more than once or twice. I wish it'd been as memorable as "Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants" or Lauren Oliver's "Before I Fall" or narratives that present a flawed cast of characters with coming of age elements, humor, and identification. Alas, it didn't quite hit above the mark with me.
Overall score: 3/5 stars.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 345 reviews