End of the Road! The Autobots are faced with multiple threats, one of them a danger not only to Cybertron, but to the whole universe! Trapped between Shockwave's attack and Unicron's onslaught, Optimus and the Autobots struggle to make sense of what's left of their world, as Optimus' colonist soldiers contend with a brutal reality–they have no homes to return to. Plus, Shockwave reveals ancient truths–as an old friend tries to reconnect with Cybertron. Collects the 2018 Annual and issues #22–25, which conclude the series.
Partly wrapping up threads from the previous Optimus Prime (and Robots in Disguise) run before this, but largely focused on being a companion piece (and epilogue) for the separate Unicron event. Note that you're expected to know what happened in Unicron to understand what's going on here, so this is best read after reading that. That all said, the highlight of the volume is actually the opening standalone Thundercracker story... (B)
Transformers: Optimus Prime Vol. 5 is Full of Neat Ties Ins, Three Dimensional Characters, Epic Developments, Cunning Plots, Daring Do, Crossovers, World Building Cooperation, Adventure and Action! :D Brilliant and Highly Recommended! :D Get it When You Can! :D
With this, the finale of the second of IDW's two Transformers lines, their continuity essentially comes to an end. It's been a hell of a trip, and overall I've thoroughly enjoyed it. But this review is about this volume in particular, and I've really got mixed feelings about it.
On the one hand, it has some great moments and is book ended by two fantastic stories. It opens with Starscream: the Movie, which is just a joy in every respect and is the epitome of why Thundercracker's arc is one of the best things IDW's done for the character. It's also just pure Starscream. It closes with Post, which along with the Lost Light finale How to Say Goodbye and Mean It: Part 2 concludes IDW's continuity and wraps up most of the remaining plot threads.
On the other hand, the middle of this volume really can be largely summed up with "and this stuff was happening during the Unicron miniseries," and not really in a good way. Mostly in the "it references and thereby spoils all the major plot points of the Unicron miniseries" way, and the TPB of that miniseries doesn't come out for another month. As such it's not really a unified story so much as a side story to a bigger story that I haven't read yet. And that really kind of brings the whole thing down overall.
It's almost cheating to include the Annual, The Starscream Move, here. It might be the single best story told in the run of IDW's universe. Thundercracker under John Barber is an utter joy.
The mainline issues though are another matter. A lot of Prime's critics are basically rehashing the same points over and over again. I get it Slide/Pyra Magna...
Still what's clever about Barber's run in the end is his approach to Optimus (and Cybertron in general) not at as a hagiography but rather as a the more fallible character that Arcee memorializes. We all know how Primes end... but Barber and company did try hard to achieve something something noteworthy compared to conventional "such heroic nonsense." :D
I don't know when it happened, but I fell out of love with Optimus Prime as a character. I haven't liked a version of him that I've read or seen since Animated. the messiah complex everyone insists on saddling him with makes for a character who sounds like he always giving a prepared speech. He's so pompous and full of himself that I just can't take it How much that contributed to this series being a constant chore for me to read is uncertain, but I can honestly say that I am glad it's over and I don't have to read anymore of it.
The forty page opener, 'Starscream: The Movie' is one of John Barber's finest with a spark premise that would write itself for best smarts and chuckles, yet also succeeds in political thought and nuanced characterisation. From there to epic IDW finale with highly skillful art by Kei Zama. In just story terms the Unicron arc is a mighty ambitious contest and suffers two slow chapters until its balanced it's pace in last act. However for wrapping up eight years of story the creatives plans, esp. around character threads, are executed well.
Finally, with one last heaving retch, the steaming pile of hot garbage that is the Optimus Prime series draws to a close. This was so much better in its previous guys of Robots in Disguise.
I read this simultaneously with Transformers: Unicron. A decent ending for a long arc, I suppose, but too many crossovers I didn’t care about. Also rehashing the same few points again and again, and never really going in depth when I expect/want it. This volume was saved by Starscream: The Movie and the very last issue (in other words, once again Thundercracker saves the day book.)