Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Mr. Darcy's Enchantment: A Pride & Prejudice Variation

Rate this book
In a Regency England where magic and faeries are real…Fitzwilliam Darcy is a powerful magician who controls fire, water, and wind. What he cannot control is his growing attraction to Miss Elizabeth Bennet.Elizabeth’s sentiments towards Darcy are quite different. She detests his arrogance, and she fears he will expose her use of forbidden magic - forbidden to women, that is. He is the last man in the world she would choose to help her on a difficult and dangerous task.But when a magical war looms between the land of Faerie and their world, a Lord of Faerie demands that Darcy and Elizabeth serve together as his emissaries to make peace with the other mortals. That mission throws them into the middle of a chaotic power struggle between magicians whose power dwarfs their own, and everything Elizabeth has ever believed about her family, her friends, and her enemies will be called into question.

552 pages, Kindle Edition

Published November 27, 2018

267 people are currently reading
805 people want to read

About the author

Abigail Reynolds

67 books779 followers
Abigail Reynolds may be a nationally bestselling author and a physician, but she can’t follow a straight line with a ruler. Originally from upstate New York, she studied Russian and theater at Bryn Mawr College and marine biology at the Marine Biological Laboratory in Woods Hole. After a stint in performing arts administration, she decided to attend medical school, and took up writing as a way to retain her sanity during her years as a physician in private practice.

A life-long lover of Jane Austen’s novels, Abigail began writing variations on Pride & Prejudice in 2001, then expanded her repertoire to include a series of novels set on her beloved Cape Cod.Her most recent releases are A Matter of Honor, Mr. Darcy's Enchantment, and Conceit & Concealment. Her books have been translated into six languages. A lifetime member of JASNA, she lives on Cape Cod with her husband, her son and a menagerie of animals. Her hobbies do not include sleeping or cleaning her house.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
548 (46%)
4 stars
377 (32%)
3 stars
157 (13%)
2 stars
62 (5%)
1 star
22 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 201 reviews
Profile Image for Sheila Majczan.
2,688 reviews201 followers
November 29, 2018
I would give this 5+ stars if I were able. There is such imagination in the creation of this variation...even though it is far from a reflection of canon. This author gives us two worlds and many new characters/creatures, new behaviors and relationships within this tale.

We find ourselves in Kent where Elizabeth is treating a child who has been bitten by a "Redcap". She is afraid to use her magic due to the fact that Mr. Darcy, a Mage, is now residing at Rosings, and Elizabeth is not sure how far away he can detect the use of magic, which is forbidden to women.

As in all variations you must know JA's canon, as it is significant, i.e., Darcy separating Bingley and Jane, Darcy expected to marry Anne and Wickham’s lies to Elizabeth. Although we spend most of our time either at Rosings, in the Matlock’s residence or in the world of Faerie there are references to what happened in Hertfordshire and, of even greater significance, what happened at Rosings…to the de Bourgh family in the past.

This is a long story and I won’t even attempt to mention all the events. However when Elizabeth is called to Rosings after Lady Catherine falls deathly ill the manner of care Elizabeth provides opens up a whole "kettle of fish". One of the results is that she is cast out of the Hunsford vicarage by Collins and he refuses to even allow her to collect her belongings. A solution of settling her into the Rosings Dower House is found.

Part of the charm of this book is finding out (along with the characters) their relationships to other beings and just what that relationship means. Some demand obedience while other relationships provide protection. We learn what eliarinn, shurinn, & tiarinn signify. The fay, the sidhe, etc. who inhabit Faerie live for centuries and thus their memories of a past treaty are more fresh in their minds and they cannot understand nor tolerate the realm of humans who have broken that treaty in destroying their Faerie rings. They are at war with the humans while the humans not only don’t know about the ancient treaty they also are not aware of the war, only the fact that there have been a number of sad and destructive events in Britain. So we read of a small band on both sides learning of each other’s ways and how they must learn to work together.

Sorcery is forbidden! But as we read on we find that has been practiced by men in high places. We also find spells, good and bad, being used. One person, of very minor mention in canon comes out of “nowhere” and suddenly is front and center in a plan to take over the world of magic and the seat of government.

One thing I found very interesting was that the Fay do not look down on sexual relationships outside of marriage as humans do. They do count lineage to be of the greatest importance but the order of birth is also secondary.

I was charmed by Pepper whose role becomes much more important as we read on. Pepper, a phouka, takes on several animal shapes and can detect roles people play. Shakespeare’s characters, Oberon and Titania, from A Midsummer’s Night Dream appear and play lead roles.
I highly recommend this story to all.
Profile Image for ✨ Gramy ✨ .
1,382 reviews
January 19, 2019
.
This was a sweet and enchanting tale with a complex spellbinding plot, taking the cast of Pride and Prejudice through a mystical journey that included other bewitching characters and animals of otherworldly origin, such as:

* Brownies -Dryads - Fay Folk - Mages - Phoukas -Redcaps -Sorcerers + Gnome . . . More

Magic is an integral part of the story and is not limited to the fay folk, since many humans (some of whom discover they are partially otherworldly beings, such as part of the 'Fay') have magic too. There are different types of magic. For example, Darcy has "elemental magic," meaning he can control water, fire, and wind, while Elizabeth uses "wild magic, which is not limited to specific elements."

In the human realm of this alternate universe, the biggest obstacle between Mr. Darcy and Miss Elizabeth Bennett is the fact that only men are allowed to practice magic, since the men in that era were under the disillusion that women were too weak to handle it. Of course, this meant that the women were forced to hide their abilities to avoid being bound by the members of The Collegium of Mages. Although some practiced their abilities secretly, mostly aiding the poorer folks with healing. Different types of magic highlighted in this tale include: Elemental magic, Wild magic, Spellcasting, and Dark arts.

The writer's ability to weave together well-known characters coinciding with an enchanting world was indeed breathtaking. The magic, drama, and suspense all culminate to deliver an extraordinary tale that is well worth the time it takes to read it!

This is a clean read, which speaks highly of it on its own. However, it also delivers an adventure that leads to a conclusion of happiness and joy through the discovery of the unknown.
Profile Image for Debbie.
1,680 reviews79 followers
November 12, 2021
The title's enchantment certainly extends to the reader in this delightful mash-up of Pride and Prejudice with a bit of Irish, Scottish, German and Border folk lore, a wee bit of Shakespeare's Midsummer Night's Dream (Titania and Oberon are the King and Queen of Faerie here) and a large bit of Ms. Reynolds' own imagination.

Magic is an integral part of the story and is not limited to the fay folk; many humans have magic too. There are different types of magic. For example, Darcy has "elemental magic," meaning he can control water, fire and wind, while Elizabeth uses "wild magic." In this unenlightened society, women are barred from practicing magic in any form. Since Darcy is a member of the Collegium of Mages and always watches her so closely, Elizabeth is terrified that he will learn her secret and "bind" her powers, which she mostly uses in a healing capacity.

The book begins in Kent. Darcy makes his poorly-worded proposal and Elizabeth emphatically refuses him within the first chapter. But Lady Catherine is struck down by elfshot and Darcy doesn't know how to help her, so he must send for Elizabeth to nurse her at Rosings. Unbeknownst to mankind, the fay are waging a war against them, and Lady Catherine is just one casualty of this war. Once Colonel Fitzwilliam learns Elizabeth's secret, it doesn't take long before he shares this with his father, Lord Matlock, who is Master of the Collegium of Mages.

This is a (literally!) spellbinding tale that just keeps adding layers upon layers of intertwining plotlines. Elizabeth, of course, eventually comes to realize that she is, in fact, in love with Darcy. Their romance is beautifully incorporated into all the other storylines. Along with the fay attacks on humans and the law preventing Elizabeth's from using her magic, various other problems emerge: A Board of Inquiry from the Collegium looks into accusations that Darcy misused his magic. If found guilty, he must submit to having HIS powers bound. There's some evil sorcery (stealing others' magic) at work which will affect everyone if it continues unchecked. The Bennet family has some pretty intense secrets that Elizabeth uncovers. The tension builds to an almost unbearable degree with a whopper of a climactic scene.

There are encounters with various species of fay folk, especially Elizabeth's pet phouka Pepper (who usually appears as a cat). The story includes a few visits to Faerie, which very few mortals are allowed to see. Ms. Reynolds really outdoes herself in her descriptions of this mystical place. The fay have a very liberal attitude about relationships and sex. They don't understand humans' rules of etiquette either, preferring bluntness and disliking polite civilities.

What I particularly love (and I think is very Austenesque) is that more than one character is not as he/she first appears. Lewis de Bourgh has left behind a questionable legacy which must be investigated. Viscount Eversleigh is a fascinating addition, as are Prince Aelfric and Cathael. Georgiana and Anne de Bourgh get major roles here, and Colonel Fitzwilliam's sister, Lady Frederica, does, too. Mr. Wickham, as usual, is a villain, but watch out because he's not the only one. Although they don't appear a lot, Mr. and Mrs. Bennet are very integral to the story.

Ms. Reynolds' writing engages the reader completely, making this alternate universe feel as real as R.K. Rowling's Harry Potter world. She give us a perfect balance blending the fun and magic of these fanciful faerie creatures, the increasing seriousness of the developing situations, and the lovely romance between Darcy and Elizabeth. While there are some very sensual passages, things are either interrupted or fade to black without graphic details.

I strongly suggest you start with the Glossary (which appears at the end of the book). By the time I got there, I had been able to guess the meanings of most of these different faerie terms based on their context in the story, but it would have been helpful to understand them from the beginning. It's also interesting to learn where the various terms originated. Impressively, many are pure figments of the author's imagination.

Highly recommend!
Profile Image for Nicole Clarkston.
Author 29 books213 followers
November 29, 2018
This book was simply breathtaking! It swept our beloved couple into a world you’ve never imagined and had me on the edge of my seat for the whole ride. This is the very same Darcy and Elizabeth we have always known and loved, with their same brilliances and foibles, but sparkling and alive with fantastical new dimensions. It’s the kind of love that can shatter the foundations of society... really, that big and that good. Highly, highly recommend!
Profile Image for Sophia.
Author 5 books399 followers
December 12, 2018
When offered the opportunity to read a book that pairs Austen's Pride & Prejudice with magic and faeries, there really was only one answer. Of course, I snatched it up and was oblivious to the outside world for hours at a time- fey magic?

First of all, this book can be read by all comers. No prior history with Austen's P&P or Shakespeare's Midsummer Night's Dream are needed. If you like tales of the fey or historical fantasy romances, you'll do fine- better than fine, actually.

What a fascinating story! The author cleverly melded not just characters and settings in this story, but story themes and character traits: a proud Darcy, a prejudiced Elizabeth, a silly Mrs. Bennet, a revolting Mr. Collins, an enchanting King Oberon and Queen Titania, a vile Wickham, and so on.

The story is long, but reads swiftly. It does drop the reader right into a situation that obviously feels like an opening act has already taken place, but once the first chapter is finished, that feeling is gone because the reader is caught up in the characters and plot. Essentially, Regency England has magic and non-magic users, a knowledge that faery exists and the lesser fey live on the human side of the divide and are only visible to children. But, only men are allowed to have magic and be trained as mages. Gasp, yes! Does that mean women don't have magic? No, it means if they demonstrate it then their magic is bound and it has a poor effect on their mind. Our heroine is clever and incensed at this inequality. She loathes anyone associated with the Collegium of Mages who enforce this and perpetuate the falsities that women can't handle magic. And guess what group our hero is a member of? The sparks fly when Darcy learns swiftly just what Lizzy thinks of him and the Mages when he made the mistake of proposing. Not only does she hate him, but she is terrified that he will expose her for a magic user. Instead of slinking away to lick his wounds, this is when Darcy's character truly shines and he steps up as the hero- which, incidentally, was exactly what the wary Lizzy needed to see.

After part one that introduces the world, the characters, and the plot, there is a twist when the world of the fey and the war with the fey is introduced. Kudos for a good balance of description and plot during the visits in faery. It did slow down the story, but not ponderously so. The reader gets enough description and education in fey ways to see the whimsical differences, but the story keeps moving forward. This is when the author inserted some original worldbuilding about the fey, but also the human-magic using world. Nice twists how secrets came out in both Darcy's and Lizzy's families.

By the time the half-way point is reached, the story really takes off and through much of the last part, I was completely riveted and couldn't stop turning pages. At the high point, I was teary-eyed at a big sacrifice, at another point I was chuckling over the antics of a mischievous phouka, and oh yes, the romances (there are more than one just as there are several main players other than the main couple, but I don't want to do spoilers) were indeed swoonworthy.

All in all, this was as enchanting as the title states. What a spectacular story that left me satisfied and with the knowledge that this will be a re-read at some point. Those who enjoy historical and fantasy brought together with romance and thrilling magical action should not hesitate to reach for this book.

My thanks to the author for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for J. W. Garrett.
1,736 reviews133 followers
December 15, 2018
Rating: although clean, there are hints at mature adult themes and violence that may be squeamish to some, while the clash of religions may be unsettling to others. There is a paranormal aspect to this story that deals with the Kingdom coming to grips with magic, magicians, sorcerers, wise-women, mages and the rules that govern them. This review hopefully doesn’t contain spoilers.

“When someone from Faerie ever tells you something, you can see it—you can feel it—you believe it. For the true value of enchantment and its glamour, is in the imparting of a truth—by truth’s own persuasion it makes itself real.” –Gabriel Brunsdon, Azlander: Second Nature

This story was beautifully written. There can be no arguments with that. The world building took a bit of time but Reynolds made the reader want to visit these amazing places and talk to people and creatures that we have only heard of in fairy tales and mythology. On the surface it was beautiful, dreamy and otherworldly. But under the surface, there existed a riptide of evil that wanted to destroy and devour. It was amazing how the author spun this web of evil that spread farther than was first revealed. My goodness. I didn’t see the far-reaching grip this web encompassed. There were many, many secrets and atrocities that were generations old and needed to be revealed and settled. The treaty between the worlds was in jeopardy and the lives of many depended on our characters acting quickly.

“Whatever deceives man seems to produce a magical enchantment.” –Plato

Villains: OMG! Who wasn’t a villain? I’ve never seen such a web of villainy before in a JAFF story. Man, this was amazing. I can’t even mention anything without giving away a spoiler.

“Almost any sect, cult, or religion will legislate its creed into law if it acquires the political power to do so.” –Robert A. Heinlein

Religious aspect: A protestant England, with the threat of Catholicism just below the surface, had to acknowledge the nature-worshiping characters of mythology and superstitions of old. For centuries their stories of groves, fairy rings/circles, and fertility rites were whispered around campfires, before hearths, to children at bedtime and were passed from generation to generation. Suddenly, the natural order of society was put into question, propriety was ignored and a new set of rules applied to what Regency could tolerate or would accept. On the surface, this was just a fun story. Underneath, however, there were hints of behavior that might be considered unsettling.

“I was always interested in enchantment and magicians and still am.” –Christopher Lee

In Shakespeare’s ‘A Midsummer’s Night Dream,’ Titania, Queen of the Fairies and her Consort, Oberon king of the Fairies quarreled over the changeling boy. His mother had been a votaress of her order and died after giving birth to him. A votary was a monk or nun who made a vow of dedication to religious service. In this story, their quarrel was over another child entirely, whose identity wasn’t revealed right away. There was a lot implied on the births of several of our characters and their relations. Some of these implications were… disconcerting.

This was a fun read and that is how you should approach it. Otherwise, if you dig too deeply, you will bog down with the weight of trying to reconcile the religious and social aspects of this work. That is not what the author intended. Just simply enjoy the story.
Profile Image for wosedwew.
1,337 reviews125 followers
February 17, 2024
This is a work of fiction. All the characters in it, human and otherwise, are imaginary, excepting only certain of the fairy folk, whom it might be unwise to offend by casting doubts on their existence. Or lack thereof. ~ Neil Gaiman

Brownies! Dryads! Fay Folk! Mages! Phoukas! Redcaps! Sorcerers!

Count me with those who rarely read Fairy Tales. Even so, this book had me hooked from the opening sentences.

A complex plot that I won’t attempt to re-cap – and yet everything fits together and loose ends are not left untied.

I especially loved the explanation for Mrs. Bennet’s simple-mindedness and the marital relationship between the elder Bennets. You won’t find that in any other JAFF tale.

No half-hearted recommendations for this one – JAFF lovers; fairy tale lovers; well, really, any kind of lover: you gotta read it!

The Realm of Fairy is a strange shadow land, lying just beyond the fields we know. ~ Author Unknown
Profile Image for Meredith (Austenesque Reviews).
997 reviews345 followers
January 4, 2020
A Sensational and Spellbinding Saga!

TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation, Fantasy

TIME FRAME: Begins during Elizabeth’s stay at Hunsford Parsonage

SYNOPSIS: Taking us into a world were humans have magic (including Lizzy, Darcy, and Lord Matlock) and fae folk have existed for centuries (ruled by King Oberon and Queen Titania), Abigail Reynolds constructs a fascinating fantasy that entwines Jane Austen’s characters in an enchanted adventure filled with secrets, new prejudices, conflicts, corruption, and of course, magic. There is discontent rising in Faerie and a war against the humans is determined. Darcy and Elizabeth are caught in the middle of this dispute and it becomes their mission to end the unrest and violence. But family drama and new dangerous developments and cause no small amount of delays for them – (not to mention their own prejudices, fears, and personal struggles that get in the way.)

WHAT I LOVED:

- An Imaginative New World: Abigail Reynolds did an absolutely fantastic job constructing and introducing readers to this original alternate world. There was so much world building involved with this tale, and so much for readers to learn. I really appreciate how succinctly and clearly Ms. Reynolds imparts pertinent knowledge to readers. It never becomes too heavy, overly complex, or convoluted. The rules and realities of this alternate world are divulged gradually and relevantly in a well-balanced fashion.

- Creative and Plausible Intertwining: Since the story does veer off course a substantial amount in this magic-induced world, I really admired the connections Abigail Reynolds established that gave believable reasons and possibilities to some of Jane Austen’s characters, such as Mrs. Bennet, Mr. Bennet, Mr. Collins, and the de Bourghs. These plausible explanations were so clever and I had great fun believing them.

- The Fitzwilliam Family and Original Characters: Just like with Conceit and Concealment, various members of the Fitzwilliam family are integral to the action and development of this story. I think Abigail Reynolds has a partiality for the Fitzwilliams. 😉 In addition, we are introduced to a family friend, Viscount Eversleigh, who plays a vital role in this story and has some interesting connections to these characters. All these character additions were wonderfully well-drawn and are quick to earn readers’ interest and respect. My particular favorites were Eversleigh, Frederica Fitzwilliam, Aelfric, and Peper!.

- Fae Folk and Faerie: I’ve not read any other stories that included faes and I definitely haven’t come across Austenesque stories that integrate these creatures – dragons and phantoms?- yes, but not fae. I loved everything about the fae; like Lord Matlock and Frederica, I am obsessed with their culture and eager to learn all I can. I loved all the details and thought that went into establishing the fae in this story – some of which is inspired by traditional folklore. In this story readers can come to understand the difference between fae culture and Regency culture, and learn their history, customs, and etiquette. I especially loved seeing Jane Austen’s characters react to and adapt to fae etiquette when visiting Faerie…poor Mr. Darcy perhaps had the most learning and adjusting to do! 😉 LOL!

- All Things Combined: There was so much going on in this story, so much action, so many characters, so much history and culture – and not to mention the combining of Jane Austen’s characters and world with, not only the Fae world, but a little bit of William Shakespeare’s A Midsummer’s Night Dream! The mixture and balance of all these elements truly is an impressive accomplishment!

WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:

The only thing that I can complain about is that I want more! I loved this Fae-inspired Pride and Prejudice tale, will you take us back to Faerie, Ms. Reynolds?

NOTE:

While there are some references made to intimate embraces and violence, nothing graphic or explicit takes place on page. I’d recommend this book to readers over the age of 13.

CONCLUSION:

Whether or not you enjoy fantasy and believe in magic, this enchanting and compelling variation by Abigail Reynolds will cast you under its enigmatic spell. With Mr. Darcy’s Enchantment Ms. Reynolds once again displays her ingenuity, meticulous attention to detail, and riveting story-telling powers. We are so eager to see what she writes next!

Austenesque Reviews
205 reviews8 followers
December 2, 2018
A Delightful Book

This was just a delight to read. It makes the land of Faerie so real. It cleverly intertwines the Pride and Prejudice story with magic, sorcery, and heroics. There is lots of humour, and romance in this book. Well worth reading if you like Pride and Prejudice and fantasy. It in one of my new favourites.
Profile Image for James S.
1,432 reviews
December 11, 2018
Wonderful story

My goodness. I have no idea how to do justice to this amazing book. P&P meets Fayre land. I new imagined fantasy world conceived and written about by one of P&P variation best author’s.

Great story. I sincerely hope there will be more stories set in this new reality. I can imagine other authors asking permission to write story’s taking place in it.

I believe this would make a great series on Netflix and a great video game.

I recommend this book highly bow to Abigail Reynolds.
Profile Image for Talia.
970 reviews4 followers
June 27, 2021
JAFF meets the Dresden Files. My favorite Abigail Reynolds book yet.

Reread: My absolute favorite Abigail Reynolds book ever. LOVED IT!

Reread: I think there will be a sequel to this book. She talks of the previous Great Spell where the faye world was torn in half. Hoping!

Reread: Love it.
899 reviews70 followers
January 30, 2020

My Rating: 5+*

Beguiling...Bewitching...Bespelling! Enchanting...Enticing...Enthralling!

Oh I could go on and on with the adjectives, but I think you get how I feel about this provocative and magical novel that I could not stop reading! I did very little yesterday, just so I could sit and read this book! Thank goodness the weather cooperated...rain, snow, sleet. I wonder who couldn't control their elemental magic?

"How was it that the air around Elizabeth seemed brighter than anywhere else?" (quote from the book)

Yes, magic is the key to this saga. How could it not be with the Fae and all which encompasses that world. Weave in Pride & Prejudice with mages and sorcery, and you have a captivating tale that is completely mesmerizing! See, I can't stop with the adjectives!

"To think Darcy had once been proud of his prowess as one of the most powerful mages in England. Compared to the Sidhe, he was no more than a child playing with toys." (quote from the book)

I found the use of England's Inclosure (Consolidation) Act of 1801 cleverly done. And the lore of fairies brought back memories of my Granny in N. Ireland warning me as a child to stay away from the river behind the farmhouse..."the fairies may take you." I always felt my Granny could talk to them!

Ms. Reynolds you have certainly opened up a whole new world for us that I hope you continue. I am quite enchanted myself with all that you, yourself, have created as well as what you have incorporated into this saga from lore. Who cannot but love Pepper, Snowy, Bluebird, Aelfric, and so many others. I would love to go back again!

I also must say that the book cover, both front and back, are just as magical as the tale within.
Profile Image for Elin Eriksen.
Author 24 books158 followers
December 3, 2018
Oh my! This book blew my mind!
I was spellbound by Abigail Reynolds' book of the fay and faerie world, combined with the excruciating romance of PnP.

The battle between good and evil, between mortals and fay, intersped with toe-curling romance, made this a nail-bitingly thrilling read.

Heartily recommend this book!
Profile Image for E Brookhouse.
168 reviews7 followers
December 7, 2018
I really loved this and hope for a sequel!!

The new original characters are well created and the traditional fae characters are fascinating. The way the P&P characters are wound through the story is really fun and enjoyable. I would definitely read a sequel, and I hope there will one!!

Also, one of my favorite variation authors!!!
Profile Image for Madenna U.
2,149 reviews1 follower
December 11, 2018
In this Pride and Prejudice variation, there is a bit of extra magic as the story takes place in the world of mages and fairies. The story starts as Elizabeth visits Charlotte at Hunsford. It quickly creates a world were humans and fairies intermingle and are co-dependent, even though most don't know. Our usual pride and prejudices are not only about status in regency England but also within the magic world. Women being forbidden to use magic is a major player to start . . .

Family relationships, links through blood, evil sorcery, love, danger, etc. - this book has it all wrapped up in Elizabeth and Darcy finding each other in their happily ever after. The story is kept together with the action rather than through angst. The differences in customs and mode of conversation create a unique dialogue. The choices characters have to make are very thought provoking. It is a whole lot in one book! I loved it!
Profile Image for Dung.
477 reviews
December 25, 2018
Wow, what a page turner! Such a delightful, angst filled, magical adventure with our favorite P&P characters, not to mention some great additions.

Abigail Reynolds is such a great storyteller! With all the P&P variations out there, it still amazes me how authors are so creative.

There are other great reviews that sum up the story. All I have to say is it’s definitely one of my favorite books this year. Bravo to the author for such creative storytelling. The ending left you with a potential sequel/series, I hope you consider continuing it just a bit longer for us fans...

There is a glossary of terms at the end of the book, it would have been helpful if the terms were linked so you could go back and forth, but it doesn’t deter from the reading.
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
3,680 reviews327 followers
July 11, 2022
DNF around 48%. It’s just soooo long. And the longer it goes, the more it departs from canon. The author would have been better served by being inspired and then changing everyone’s names so it wouldn’t have evoked confusion about characters not being true to canon. It’s good-ish.

1. I can’t stand when two people “love each other” (though have they actually had a conversation where both have admitted it?) but “can’t be together” for one ridiculous reason or another.

2. Where is Elizabeth’s family!? She is so close to Jane and her aunt and uncle. Also, now her dad is a villain!? Well, that’s no fun.

3. What’s with the passionate kissing!? Such a modern thing to include but if you’re going to be basing it off P&P, it’s distracting.

Enh. I’m gonna read something else.
189 reviews10 followers
January 30, 2019
Well, I finally finished it! I started it and then the kids needed to go shopping, snow day, my mother needed me to run errands. So frustrating that life got in my way to read!
5 plus stars from me!
My Goodread friends...Sheila, Debbie, JW, Wosedwew, Sophia, and Charlene all wrote fantastic reviews.

This story involves a enchanting tale that involves the world of Pride and Prejudice with the land of Faerie. The world of magic, fantasy, and enchantment all wrapped into one. Never was I so engrossed with a fantasy book before. Abigail Reynolds wrote another fantastic book to be placed on the favorite reread shelf.
Before you read the story take a moment to glance in the glossary. It begins when Elizabeth is visiting Rosings staying with the Collins. Elizabeth has a special gift that is forbidden to be used by women. She needs to use it to help a young boy in need of the magic. Mr. Darcy also has magical gifts as well and is a mage. The world of Kent is not as it appears and takes a turn for the worst. You need to read the rest to find out if they can survive the world that has become full of the unknowns.
Profile Image for Ellen.
Author 4 books26 followers
August 1, 2021
This is an entertaining book which takes Pride and prejudice for inspiration. Darcy is a mage, there are faerie folk, and some laugh out loud moments.
652 reviews13 followers
December 16, 2018
I was a bit unsure about whether to read this book... I've read a few magical Pride and Prejudice variations and found I generally like the idea but then find myself disappointed - the ideas too complicated, names too difficult to remember and important plot lines explained by 'magic'.... but I love everything written by Abigail Reynolds so decided I couldn't give it it a miss!!

None of my usual complaints (outlined above!) were a problem in this book - although I found a glossary at the end which would have been much more helpful at the beginning. The characters were true to form, despite the magical elements, which I thought was really skilfully done. There are our favourite characters, as well as some new ones, and I liked all of them although Pepper was my favourite new addition! There is some great humour but also a lot of sadness and a hint at the darkness associated with the power and greed that could come with the misuse of magic.

I have no idea how to summarise the plot... it reaches far and wide whilst at the same time very cleverly loosely following the relationships between characters and the impact of events in Pride and Prejudice. Wickham was still a scoundrel and I thought his story was a fascinating idea.

I really liked this book, I enjoyed it and thought tremendous skill is evidenced in maintaining the personalities of the characters against such a different set of circumstances. But I didn't really love it... I don't know why... I don't know what's missing to give it that bit of extra something... but all that said, I'm glad I read it, it's good fun and definitely something different, yet totally familiar at the same time.
Profile Image for Julia M.
273 reviews4 followers
September 23, 2021
Magically Enchanting

Simply marvelous! Mrs Reynolds' lyrical writing is kept me transfixed until the very last sentence. I truly loved it and would hope there is a continuation to this storyline in more books.

This book can be classified as a few things, romance, historical fiction and fantasy. It can also be classified as JAFF. This would NOT be considered a re-telling of P&P perse. This story is a loosely re-imagined interpretation of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice mixed with some of William Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream.
Profile Image for Barbara K..
757 reviews21 followers
January 19, 2019
If I could have given this book 10 stars, I would have. That's how much I loved it. It is different from any other Pride and Prejudice variation I've read or even dreamed of. For one thing, it's a Faerie story. In fact I would call it Faerie first, and romance second, and Jane Austen fan fiction (JAFF) last of all, even though the characters that are common to both are true to those in Austen's original story.

While the author has used Titania and Oberon (from Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream) as the names of her Sidhe Queen and King of Faerie, many of the races of fay, such as the phouka, are taken from Celtic folklore, and some characteristics, customs, and abilities of her fay are made up. This book is a seamless tapestry woven from myth, folklore, classic story sources, and the author's imagination, into an epic tale with a complex plot, and it is beautifully painted and peopled.

There are portions that are somewhat terrifying, violent, and others that become almost torrid, though there are no graphic sex scenes. One must suspend any disbelief in the fay or magic, and any rigid religious inclinations, or great value placed on monogamy, in order to enjoy this to its fullest. But for the most part, it is a beautiful and wondrous journey to another world. After reading it, I returned to my life feeling as if I had actually stepped into Faerie for a few days, and I felt a serious yet reluctant need to reorient myself to the mundane world.

First you have to imagine, and the author has done this for us to an amazingly detailed degree, a Regency era England in which magic is real, including both the benign and darker kinds, and in which the otherworld of Faerie is real. It's also a world in which Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy are real, along with Rosings, Lady Catherine, Mr. Collins, Mr. Wickham, and so on. Most of the story takes place either in Faerie or at fictional Rosings, the de Bourghs' estate in Kent.

In this imaginary world, women are not allowed to do magic. If it becomes known that a woman does, she is likely to be put under a binding spell by members of the all-male Collegium of Mages, of which Mr. Darcy and all the other men of his family are members. In fact his uncle, the Earl of Matlock, holds the highest office in the Collegium. Elizabeth Bennet happens to be a woman who can do magic, though she is relatively untrained and has had to figure a lot out on her own, in isolation and secrecy. But she tries to help others with her magic, mainly by healing.

For the past two years, in various parts of England, there have been increasing attacks on humans by lesser fae beings, primarily elves and redcaps, and no one knows why. Some of these attacks prove fatal. While Elizabeth is visiting the Collinses at the Hunsford parsonage (where their nearest neighbor is Rosings), she is asked to help out some of the villagers who have been attacked. She pretends to simply know something about herbal healing, but secretly uses magic to aid her in healing.

Meanwhile Mr. Darcy and his cousin Colonel Fitzwilliam visit Rosings, and call at the parsonage. In a moment alone, Mr. Darcy makes his ill-fated marriage proposal to Elizabeth and is turned down, for similar but different reasons than in the original story. Later Elizabeth and Darcy wind up journeying through Faerie, which they've accessed by way of a ring in a grove on the grounds of Rosings. While in Faerie, they learn that the reason for the recent attacks on humans is that the fay consider themselves at war with humans for breaking a treaty that is so ancient the humans no longer remember it. Meanwhile humans have become so upset over the attacks that simply telling them to stop destroying groves might cause hostile backlashes and even further loss of groves.

That is where the journey begins, and it starts out oh so slowly, while we learn about this magical version of England, and then about the fay, and then about the main problems of the story. That slow start is absolutely essential for this complex story and the world building for the reader that has to take place. But even that slow start is fascinating.

This was a book in which it was easy to miss important details. They are there, so it is best read with an eye for every detail, for instance of Faerie life and ways, and while there were a couple of tiny bits of scenes that I would have liked explained more clearly, for the most part it is complete, with the happily ever after (HEA) we expect in JAFF, as well as many loose ends tied up and explained by the end of the story. The twists and turns in the plot kept me guessing nearly all the way to the astounding, epic conclusion. Then there is an epilogue with more ends tied up, which I appreciated, because even though I am frequently disappointed with epilogues, especially in JAFF, with this story it helped me reorient myself to my world again.

Very highly recommended. In fact there are some people I would insist must read it. If you love Jane Austen variations as well as fantasy, definitely open this one up. I used to read a lot of fantasy literature when I was younger, and have been disappointed by a lot of recent attempts at the genre that I've read, so the reader will hopefully understand when I rate this one at only a notch below Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, and maybe on a par with Adams' Watership Down or Pratchett's The Color of Magic. That's how good it is, in my opinion.
Profile Image for Teresita.
1,222 reviews12 followers
April 11, 2019
Wonderful!!

An incredibly interesting mix of adventure and magic, I especially enjoyed this marvelous story along with the characters, both from the fairy world and the original ones for this book.
Thoroughly entertaining and recommended!!
Profile Image for Charlene.
474 reviews
December 9, 2018
Wonderful wonderful wonderful!!

Loved this fantasy Pride and Prejudice. To have Darcy and Lizzy in Shakespeare “Midsummers night Dream “. Well maybe not but it is diverting to read the enchantment Ms Reynolds wrote and we all get to enjoy reading.

Well done 👍🏻 Couldn’t put the story down
Profile Image for Bronwen Chisholm.
Author 11 books35 followers
December 8, 2018
Beautiful pairing

This story seamlessly combined our favorite characters (and favorite villains) from P&P with the world of Fairy to create a fantasy story the reader never wants to leave. New prejudices and new prides, still a happy ever after. Well done!
Profile Image for Chelsea.
678 reviews229 followers
January 18, 2019
(Hey, Chelsea, how’d you spend your winter break?

Reading P&P variations, obviously. It’s cold out, what else is there to do?)

Such a creative take on familiar characters and dynamics. The world building was deft and the internal logic of an illogical system of magic felt solid. For all that these characters lived in a very different world than the one Austen originally placed them in, their established traits and faults were beautifully transferred.

(Without giving too much away, I particularly enjoyed Reynold’s take on Mrs. Bennet and Anne de Bourgh in this world.)
Profile Image for Misty.
796 reviews1,223 followers
December 29, 2018
This has a whole heap of 5 star ratings from JAFF fans, but for me, more like 3.75, maybe? There were things I really liked, but it also had a tendency to feel kitchen sink-y: there was a lot going on, and a LOT of quasi deus ex machina throughout, which I'll get more into when I fully review it.
But that said, I love seeing non-traditional P&P retellings, especially fantasy, and I liked the sort of Midsummer Night's Dream mashup aspect.


*Provided by the author.
Profile Image for Aly Schne.
60 reviews61 followers
February 9, 2022
Talk about Enchantment

This book was truly enchanting and had me from the start as the author delves into a world of Pride and Prejudice that takes on a very fae twist. It's definitely become one of my favorite JAFF stories to read, especially as I'm a fan of fantasy, magic and the like. Even having already read it twice in as many years, I already know I'll be reading it again before this year is out just to immerse myself in this special P&P world once again.
Profile Image for Laura Tolomei.
Author 34 books133 followers
February 21, 2019
The idea is original, but the execution was a bit dull. I particularly didn't like how the author changes Elizabeth's family dynamics and the relationship between Elizabeth and her father. This was the one great aspect of Mrs. Austen's book, which is why I didn't appreciate how Mrs Reynolds handled it.
Profile Image for Rita Deodato.
277 reviews13 followers
April 4, 2023
4,5 stars
Review Published at:
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...

Mr. Darcy’s Enchantment is a Pride and Prejudice variation where magic and faeries are real, but unlike many other fantasy novels, it does not simply add fantasy elements to a P&P variation, it creates its own storyline, rules and characters.

When fey attacks start occurring quite frequently, humans become concerned that a war between them is imminent, but Elizabeth Bennet discovers she has strong ties to the fey and together with Fitzwilliam Darcy tries to bring these two forces back together. They will get involved not only in this conflict, but also get caught in family secrets, dramas and schemes of powerful sorcerers.

As soon as I started listening to the audiobook of Mr. Darcy’s Enchantment I could tell this was a book written by a great writer because I am not overly enthusiastic about magical stories, but I was immediately interested in what was happening in this one. As the story progresses, and both fairy and human worlds are explored by both humans and fey, the multiple characters slowly unveil to others and to the reader the rules that exist in this alternative universe. Because the rules are explained progressively with the evolution of the story, it is easy for the reader to be immersed in this different world and to become absorbed with the tale.

I wouldn’t say this book is overly romantic but as always with Abigail Reynolds the tension between Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth is felt through the pages adding to the pleasure of getting engrossed in an epic storyline.

I particularly liked seeing so many new characters with their own backstory and interests. This book is not focused solely on Elisabeth and Darcy and even if I loved their scenes, I did enjoy having other characters to captivate me cheer for.

I also liked the fact that neither Elizabeth nor Darcy are incredibly powerful mages because that allowed other characters to come to life and gain a preponderance in the novel that was well deserved. It also allowed us to see several people using their skills and combine their forces in action packed scenes that could easily be part of an Hollywood production J I enjoyed the strategies these characters came up with, and especially the final resolution of the conflict that exposed the identity of their enemies. It was a very touching ending, and even if it made me cry, I really loved it.

Another detail I enjoyed in this book was Mrs. Bennet backstory, the explanation of her personality, and the transformations we saw occurring in her and those around her.

Summing up, Mr. Darcy’s Enchantment is an epic fantasy romance that will appeal to all who love magic and faeries. It is absorbing, entertaining and I recommend it to my fellow readers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 201 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.