(Zero spoiler review for the deluxe edition this volume collects) 2.5/5
There is probably little need to keep this as a zero spoiler affair, as anyone looking for advice on whether to start this series or not isn't going to go all the way to book four to see whether Kirkman shat the bed or not. It's far more likely that people who read the story would like to see what others thought of it. That being said, I didn't think much of this at all, and that's being kind. This series was a blind buy for me, and I really fell for its small town narrative, supernatural/horror thriller. The slow burn mystery about Kyle, the priest and the estrangement from his family, not to mention his mother. It really sucked me in to the world Kirkman had created. There was nothing extraordinary going on. It was just a good story, being told pretty well, with some well suited art. This enjoyment continued all the way through book two, although the shift in tone from a a tense, near claustrophobic tale into some bland, gotta save the world nonsense was precisely what Kirkman should NOT have done with this. My interest and enjoyment nosedived throughout book 3 and has since flatlined in book 4. Everything that made this series special has been gutted from this book, with its limp, awful replacement seriously tarnishing my initial enjoyment for it. I have often lamented when great little stories inevitably go all big and bold at the finale. There is a right way to do this, and this certainly isn't it. No more characterisation. No more small time moments. No more atmosphere. Any sense of tension has been castigated for plot conveniences and contrivances that had me shaking my head with every page, asking why an accomplished comics writer would head in such an unappealing direction. The whole thing feels rushed, with far less care put into crafting it as the first half of the arc. This is a textbook example of how to wreck your series. I am genuinely mystified that Kirkman would think this was acceptable. This isn't about the ending itself, as bland as it is. This is all in the execution. I'm sure Kirkman could have executed this far more competently if he gave a shit. If in the years to come I reread this series, I will be stopping halfway through. Azaceta does his best, although is muted with the lack of horror. His art was neve dripping in detail. What he was able to do was really ramp up those small, scary moments with his illustrations. Needless to say, there is precious little of that here. How sad. A generous 2.5/5
OmniBen.