We're back for round three of Peanuts, a collection covering all of 1955 and '56. No major new characters are introduced, but we get to know Linus and "Pig-Pen" better, Snoopy has more solo adventures, and the strip continues refining its wisdom and humor. January begins with a few snowy scenes. Lucy fights with Linus over his security blanket on January 4 (page three), leading to an amusing visual after Lucy finally wins. Linus will not relinquish his blanket easily. Fresh snowfall is perfect for playing outdoors, but that can be a burden, as Charlie Brown muses on January 8 (page four). Some days he doesn't feel like making snowmen, and the pressure to take advantage of the snow before it melts can be annoying. What should you do when a somewhat rare opportunity arises, but you'd rather do something else right now? January 10 (page six) is one of the funniest strips in the book, Lucy's reaction to Schroeder adding a metronome atop his piano. The question she asks is quintessential Lucy van Pelt, and made me laugh out loud. Lucy builds a snowman on February 2 (page fifteen), a short, stout figure she declares the "world's largest snowman". Charlie Brown begs to differ, but Lucy is indignant: "Well, it's the largest snowman that I've ever built!" We tend to assign our own accomplishments outsized merit; objectively evaluating your own work is a tall order.
Lucy often laughs when Charlie Brown tells her a fact she didn't know about the world, dismissing him as a boy with a wild imagination. February 11 (page nineteen), Lucy feels sure Charlie Brown is inventing names for the constellations when he points to one he calls the "Big Dipper". Does he expect her to believe such an obvious fabrication? March 13 (page thirty-two) might be the funniest Sunday of this collection. Charlie Brown sees Lucy flying a kite, and admires the extreme height at which she's keeping it afloat. His esteem changes in the final two panels of the strip, however. It's one of the best sight gags from the first half decade of Peanuts. Charlie Brown and Lucy are reading in a big, comfortable chair on April 5 (page forty-two) when he mentions that people used to think the earth was flat, and you could sail over the edge and be consumed by sea beasts. Lucy scoffs at mankind's former foolishness, but isn't sure herself what we believe nowadays. It's easy to reflexively deride our predecessors for their failings, but we shouldn't be too hasty. In some ways their wisdom was superior, and we, too, will eventually be subject to the unthinking criticism of our descendants. Taking a charitable view of those who came before is a sign of integrity.
Linus isn't perfect, but his "naughty" deeds are not those of an average boy. Other toddlers draw on the walls, but how many do so with the flair Linus exhibits on April 19 (page forty-eight)? It's hard to stay angry at a rebel when they act with artistic ingenuity. Imaginative rogues get away with more than their less whimsical counterparts. In June, Charlie Brown and Schroeder engage in the eternal debate: who was greater, Davy Crockett or Beethoven? June 7 and 8 (page sixty-nine) are hysterically funny parts of this storyline. A simple remark between Charlie Brown and Lucy on August 23 (page one hundred two) results in a potent punchline about a rich man who earned a hundred dollars every second of the day, and on September 19 (page one hundred fourteen), Snoopy dabbles in physical comedy when Charlie Brown tries to get him to smile while they play fetch. The beagle's exaggerated smile is amusing, but a subtle point is made. Personal enjoyment has little to do with whether our expression of the feeling satisfies others. It looks weird when someone has to express their enjoyment in a way that's unnatural for them. October 23 (page one hundred twenty-eight) is one of the more philosophical comics in the book. Charlie Brown is agitated to see Patty and Violet talking and laughing just out of his earshot. He decides they're ridiculing him, and steps in to challenge the pair. Violet yells back that their conversation had nothing to do with Charlie Brown; they weren't even thinking about him. But that doesn't make him any happier. Humans are like that: we worry about others criticizing or mocking us, but going unnoticed feels just as bad. Is happiness possible if we obsess over things we can't control?
A new city ordinance requires dogs to be tied up (November 3, page one hundred thirty-three), and Charlie Brown's method of compliance for Snoopy is hilarious. November 16 (page one hundred thirty-eight) is a classic demonstration of what makes "Pig-Pen" who he is. What other kid can get messy with no dirt in sight? Snoopy's talent for doing impressions results in several good strips in November. November 26 (page one hundred forty-two) is my favorite, as the witty beagle does an uncredited impression of Mickey Mouse. There's no mistaking those ears and nose! December 3 (page one hundred forty-five) is a punchline right out of the 1965 television special, A Charlie Brown Christmas. What does Linus think of the taste of falling snowflakes? Sunday, December 11 (page one hundred forty-nine) is an example of the snowman humor that provides some of the best fodder for Peanuts over the years. December 16 (page one hundred fifty-one) is a bit of philosophy with Biblical roots, Charlie Brown and a friend noticing how cold Snoopy is outside and deciding to help. Their "comfort" isn't much good; encouraging him to "be of good cheer" does nothing to keep our favorite beagle from shivering in the snow. True charity requires action, not platitudes. January 7, 1956 (page one hundred sixty) is another joke from It's a Charlie Brown Christmas, Pig-Pen's quippy response when Violet suggests he should be ashamed of how filthy he is. Violet tries to make Charlie Brown feel inferior on March 12 (page one hundred eighty-nine), pointing out that her parents and extended relatives all graduated college, but he doesn't take the bait. The antidote to the smugness of others just might be happily acknowledging their achievements and not inferring that they make you any less than you are.
Charlie Brown spots Violet and Patty whispering on March 24 (page one hundred ninety-three). Thinking they're making fun of him, his mood darkens, and he wonders why people are always ruining his day. When our default assumption is that others constantly speak badly of us behind our back, it's a sign we lack modesty; people don't focus on us as much as we might fear. Keeping that perspective guards us from getting worked up for no reason. Linus enthuses on May 5 (page two hundred eleven) about life's potential in the future, after he turns six. He'll cross the street unattended, get his own food and drink from the refrigerator... "Unlimited opportunity!!" he proclaims. Every stage of life seems to look that way before you enter it, as though you're leaving the mediocrity of today for an exciting expanse of challenges and responsibilities. But that rosy picture is never fully accurate, and around the next corner there will always be another new stage we expect to save us from life's doldrums. On May 9 (page two hundred thirteen) Charlie Brown and Lucy observe a colony of black bugs marching along the ground. Lucy points out the queen, who sits and watches her subjects slave away, but Lucy is in for a surprise when Charlie Brown takes a closer look. The two-panel punchline is superb. Violet and Patty argue over what physical trait is most winsome in a dog on May 10 (page two hundred fourteen). Violet goes gaga for sad eyes and droopy ears; Patty loves to look at a happy dog. Wanting to please both, Snoopy demonstrates how strange it looks when you're preoccupied with satisfying everyone; most of the time, you come off as unappealing.
Snoopy is stylish and innovative even when playing fetch; he has the finesse to catch a soap bubble in his mouth without popping it. But Sunday, July 1 (page two hundred thirty-six) reveals that Snoopy isn't always light on his feet. Charlie Brown's remark to cap the strip is insightful; people with incredible skills in one area may be tactless in another, and the incongruity is jarring. It's how people are built, talents counterbalanced by ineptitudes. Charlie Brown and Snoopy are similar on that score. Charlie Brown's lack of aplomb in debating an opposing viewpoint is humorously obvious on September 7 (page two hundred sixty-five), but aren't many of us just as unreasonable? He laments that "It's almost impossible to get people to change their minds these days!", but no one is convinced by you screaming at them. Controlling your temper is hard, but essential for effective reasoning, which is the only way to sway someone to consider your point of view. A variation of this theme shows up September 11 (page two hundred sixty-seven). Charlie Brown pleads with friend after friend to "Believe in me!", but what good will begging do? Better to work on your flaws and develop your strengths, becoming someone that others believe in automatically.
Violet and Patty are conversing again on September 14 (page two hundred sixty-eight), agreeing that people should be more gentle and considerate. These sentiments evaporate when Charlie Brown bungles onto the scene; they yell at him to scram. It's easy to applaud flowery statements about kindness and selflessness, but not so easy to apply those concepts with someone who gets on our nerves. Public discourse would be more pleasant and productive if we treated everyone decently, but we're typically blind to our own faults in this regard. Sunday, September 16 (page two hundred sixty-nine) is classic Peanuts, Lucy tricking Charlie Brown so he jumps into a big pile of leaves. The pile isn't what it seems, as becomes apparent right after Charlie Brown's dramatic leap. September 28 (page two hundred seventy-four) is one of Snoopy's funniest imitations. He mimics Lucy behind her back as she angrily stomps away. October 30 and 31 (page two hundred eighty-eight) are bits familiar to fans of the 1966 television special It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown. The poignancy of Charlie Brown's youth drives the November 10 (page two hundred ninety-two) strip. Childhood is surely the hardest part of life, he speculates. "Then, after you grow up, all your troubles are over!" Charlie Brown may not be correct that adulthood is the end of all problems, but neither are adults right who forget that their childhood was at least as harrowing as post-adolescence. Life is overwhelming at times regardless what stage you're in.
November 15 (page two hundred ninety-five) sees Snoopy dance past Charlie Brown and Lucy, a huge smile on his face. Charlie Brown says he wishes he were that happy, but Lucy doesn't say the same for herself. "It's too hard to feel sorry for yourself when you're happy". We think we want things to go our way, but the dark pleasure in resentment is powerful. At least Lucy admits she'd rather feel sorry for herself than be content. An iconic scene unfolds on December 16 (page three hundred eight) with Lucy persuading Charlie Brown to attempt to kick a football she holds for him. He suspects a trick, but Lucy wouldn't do that to him...would she? 1956 concludes with another strip that inspired a scene in a Peanuts television special (December 30, page three hundred fourteen), followed by a New Year's Eve gag, and then we're ready to move into 1957 for three hundred sixty-five days of new jokes, surprises, and wisdom with Charlie Brown and friends. I wouldn't miss it.
The quality of the early Peanuts comics measures up to the television specials in most ways. Charles Schulz's humor is subtle and genuinely funny, but Peanuts wouldn't be as strong a work of literature if not for the undercurrent of philosophy. Schulz respects his readers' capacity for thought whether they're young or old, which is why Peanuts is loved by all ages. I'd rate this book at least two and a half stars, maybe the full three, and I can't think of many better reads with which to celebrate the lost art of the daily newspaper comic. I'll always love Peanuts.