The narrative portions of this book deserve 5 stars, even 6. The instructional portions deserve 3. This book is definitely worth reading. Galanos is a DMM disciple, which is the theological equivalent of a HIT-jedi. DMM is a fine system for disciple making, though it tends to be a little too narrow in its understanding of mission and too focused on orthopraxy for me. The amount of jargon and terrible acronyms associated with DMM are legendary. So take the "how to" from this book with a grain of salt.
But the "what" and the "why" are both good, and the results that Galanos shares are so encouraging. Galanos lays out, in no uncertain terms, that the traditional American church model cannot reach the modern city. It is too costly to replicate, too resource hungry, too clergy driven. It is an attractional model, which stands in opposition to Jesus' command to Go and tell. It is clergy-centric, which stands in opposition to a theology of Holy Spirit-filled believers building each other up. The stories of personal transformation are worth wading through all the DMM jargon. The story of eLife's transformation, and what that looked like for staff and for members, is very helpful for those who might be considering a similar transition.
However, for the American Christian, I would offer this warning. Galanos, like most Americans, confuses what works with what is right. The Christian faith is most definitely NOT a pragmatic faith. It is based on the hope of things unseen, the belief that God blesses the just and the unjust. What works is often not right, and what is right often doesn't work. Jesus and all his disciples got murdered which is not exactly our definition of success, while St. Augustine rid the world of the Donatist heresy (great results) by convincing the Emperor to use the power of the state against them, leading to more than a few murders (less that stellar method). I would argue that the reason that we need to switch to small-scale, participatory, church planting movements is not because they are successful, but because they are more in line with the theology and practice of the New Testament. Something to keep in mind.
Here are a few of my favorite quotes:
The average cost per baptism in the typical American church is ... you may want to sit down for this ... $1.5 million. Yes, it costs, on average, an estimated $1.5 million per baptism in the American church. In other words, if you take all of the income American churches bring in each year and divide it by the number of baptisms, you get this number. Feel free to gasp in disbelief. - Ch. 3
One of the great tragedies of the American church model, and it's happened at our church too, is an attitude that results in suppressing the gifts, ambitions, and callings of ordinary believers. This attitude seems to suggest that ordinary people are supposed to just sit in church and watch while the real professionals do the work of the ministry. The average churchgoer's main job is to make sure he or she comes back to services nowt weekend and funds the buildings, salaries, and programs.
Pursuing DMM will cost you financially. It's almost a guarantee. As we began shifting to the DMM strategy, I was so thankful for how financially conservative eLife has been over the years, giving us the margin to follow the Lord however he would lead. For years, we've operated with a significant amount of money in reserve. ... Choosing to be financially conservative positioned our church to be able to make this change.