An Apprentice To The Dark Side of Human Nature
Allen Kurzweil's 1992 historical novel "A Case of Curiosities" is set in the late 18th Century and tells the story of one Claude Page, born in 1780 to poverty in rural France. Page has both artistic and mechanical gifts, and the story describes how he ultimately if temporarily came to put his gifts to use. In the words of a defrocked Abby, Page's mentor, the hero learns to find a metaphor for his life.
The book is told by a narrator who purchases a dusty curio case with relics of Page's life at an auction in Paris in 1983. He becomes intrigued upon finding a biography of this elusive figure and spends six years in research on Page's life and career. In the words of the leading reader review of this book on Amazon, dated July 12, 2002. Page becomes "an apprentice to the dark side of human nature".
The story is recounted in a heavily mannered, idiosyncratic tone which carries the reader back to 18th Century France. While it is generally effective in carrying the reader into the time, the ornate, overwritten, and erudite writing often becomes wearisome. So too, the many characters, places, and historical references give a sense of place and historical distance while also clogging and slowing down the narrative. The author is given to reading, learning, and wordplay with his name "Kurzweil" making a cameo appearance late in the story.
The book begins when Page, age 10, loses a finger in an amputation to a malevolent surgeon. The heretical Abby takes an interest in the lad who shows marked talent for both enamel painting and science. The Abby, estranged from religion, offers the boy encouragement while steering his talents to painting pornographic scenes, seemingly in demand during all times and places. Page's life and fortunes change and as a young adolescent he runs off to Paris where he lives in squalor The book shows many aspects of the French underclass of the time.. Page secures an unhappy apprenticeship to a bookseller where he furthers his talents in pornography and at the age of 16 has an affair with an unhappily married woman. Ultimately Page's prodigious mechanical gifts, centering on what he learned from watchmaking, come through, as Page designs and creates a curious "talking head".
The story is lively and often humorous as it immerses the reader into the underbelly of pre-Revolutionary France, with the seeming twins of Enlightenment and pornography. The book shows some of the virtues and the costs of Enlightenment in terms of the abandonment of religious belief, exemplified most clearly in the Abby. The suggestion may be that progress and freedom of thought are counterbalanced by revolution, violence and a sense of purposelessness.
I had mixed feelings about the book. I did get a sense of place and time and enjoyed the author's immersion in the period, including his references to many of the pornographic books of the day. The book also is insightful on the rise of the scientific outlook and on its possible consequences. The book also became wearing and overdone as it went on. It became a chore to read and to finish. Some books may be better in reflection than in the actual process of reading. I became impatient with "A Case of Curiosities" but concluded that the book was worth the effort.
Robin Friedman