Probably between 3.5-4 again.
Once again, an enjoyable read that satisfied my longing for a human-elf pairing where the girl is the elf. The end was satisfying.
I do have somewhat mixed feelings.
Pros:
-My questioning-tradition-self loved Fyn and the breaking of traditions throughout the book. I also loved that this wasn't a story of "people who don't like their duty learn to accept it" but rather "people learn to accept their natural gifts and find other ways to live and serve that better fit their talents and personality."
-The story of Ben coming to realize that his first "love" was a childish fascination and not really love and coming to understand that love does not hide or make you pretend to be someone you're not and appreciates all of the person you love and wants the best for them was good. I feel like I haven't seen a romantic fantasy tackle the difference between juvenile infatuation and real love very often and I really liked it.
-In the same vein, the difference between "Ben lost any chance with Yvrea because he feared her seeing all of him" and "Ben loves Fyn in part because she doesn't shy away even though she sees all of him"...yeah, that was good.
-In general, I always love romances where the characters think "no one could love me for me" because they've been told their personalities or interests etc aren't "good" or "proper" or "desirable" but they find someone who does love them. And female characters who are afraid they are too much and find someone who isn't embarrassed or intimidated by them. So *adored* that!
-Ben deciding he is going to seduce his wife no matter how long it takes was hilarious and great.
-I wouldn't be surprised if some readers find Fyn and her special High Elf magic to be kind of Mary Sue-ish, but idc, I loved it and it was fun and awesome.
-The last scene with Lorius and Ben and Fyn's dad's reactions.
-The kings and their secrets. 🤣🤣
Cons:
-I did struggle with the basis of their relationship being a pretty cold and calculating marriage of convenience where Fyn essentially gives Ben permission to stay in love with her sister, and that Fyn spends most of the book thinking her husband is in love with her sister. It would have still been a bit uncomfy if Yvrea hadn't been her sister, just a past love who he still saw all the time, but it being her sister was so awkward. That said, it did make sense narratively, and at least it has been a one-sided thing and it's not as if Ben and Yvrea has ever been actually involved.
-Why are we doing "jealous of my brother and love interest's interactions" again? 😩 At least Ben never felt violent toward Arvel.
-It does finally make some sense once, many chapter later, we learn what Ben and Arvel had been discussing when Fyn walked in, but for a while there, Ben becoming so...affectionate...and thinking Fyn is "precious" did feel kind of like he was body-snatched. Who are you and what did you do with Ben? Overall, I feel like the middle didn't have enough of Ben's POV and thought processes to really track his character growth, and then we kind of get dumped explanation later--but the explanation did at least make sense.
-Arion is majorly overbearing and I'm honestly tired of books portraying guys being controlling when their wives are pregnant as funny or cute.
-Why is Fyn's magic that shape, though? A touch cringe for me. 😅🙈
Mixed:
-Fyn is kind of dense sometimes in missing obvious cues that Ben is falling for her, but, to be fair, there are cultural differences, and she was trying really hard not to get her heartbroken and so badly didn't want to trick herself into seeing something that wasn't there (since she believes he loves her sister) that she went too far and missed his obvious signs of love. It was realistic but also often frustrating, so I don't fully count it as a pro or con.
-Some worldbuilding confusion still, although starting to get a more logical picture. Lorius says early on that Tali and Arion's kid "will likely be the only half-elf-half-human in history." I was so confused I had to redownload book one to make sure I hadn't hallucinated Lesser Elves as the result of High Elf x human pairings. I had not. 😆 And then later, this book does, in fact, mention that being the case. Toward the end especially, this book did start explaining that a lot of the illogical things, such as how "impossible" it is for anyone outside of the Translator Circle to speak both languages and why elves are so "peaceful" and seemingly monolithic in their behavior, is just a result of rigid Lesser Elf traditions that strive to distance themselves from their High Elf "cousins" (er...ancestors?? Although calling them cousins is probably part of the distancing again). So as those traditions start to break down, so do those barriers and behavorial expectations, which made sense. I do find it a little funny Lessa has port cities that are ostensibly unprotected by Calnor and where, apparently, no other human countries have ever even attempted to dock, since no humans set foot in Lessa.
-Wulf. That was...kind of weirdly handled and I can't decide how I feel about it.
If you have read my essay thus far 😆😅: Overall, though, this was fun, satisfying, and also was a great book to enjoy while I wait for the next Elven Alliance book. If you enjoy Elven Alliance, you'll likely enjoy these (and vice versa)!