This is the first part of the 1999 published edition with the second parts "Tulips: The Species" and "Tulip Cultivars" only appearing in the original hardcover edition. Why I mention that is because some of the items that I felt was a drawback may have been part of those sections.
I would be completely surprised if Ms. Pavord is not considered an authority on tulips and the history of the tulip in Europe considering the tremendous amount of information relayed in her book. From personally searching the hills of Turkey as well as Crete for wild versions of the tulip. The history of the popular flower in Ottoman Turkey as it eventually migrated into Italy, Germany, the Netherlands, France, England and eventually America. There is a tremendous amount of information not only on growers, variants, painters of the catalogs and books, buyers and gardens which could have tens of thousands of bulbs. Fortunately, the author includes a chronology which after all the information, it helped keep the timeline clear.
Today, tulips are grown commercially in Japan, Washington State, Chile, Australia, Tasmania, the North Island of New Zealand, South Africa, and of course, the Netherlands. The devotees are trying to re-discover some of the antique versions of these lovely flowers but it's mostly known from the amateurs and general public that desire to have tulips available each spring.
There are three negatives as far as my being the reader:
One - Ms.Pavord would quote historic resources from French growers and owners. Unfortunately, the paragraphs (yes, paragraphs) are still in French with no translation available. Not even amidst the notes. She may think it's important but I certainly don't know why and was not willing to type entire paragraphs lasting nearly an entire page of the book into the web and request a translation.
Two - A glossary of terms as well as the anatomy of a tulip would have been very helpful to the reader. It took until page 76 until 'breaking' was defined. 'Feathered' on page 195. The types of Bizarres on page 87, Marquettines on page 78 and Parrots on page 255. I never did find definitions for striped, flamed, smudge-bottomed or bottom blots among others. And that doesn't include that some terms changed over the centuries from one to another. As a person not already familiar with the tulip terminology, it created confusion while reading.
Three - There were occasions when Ms. Pavord just listed books, catalogs, people, locations, etc and it's as interesting as reading a phone book. I understand she was being detailed and complete but it was . . . . just a section to jump over.
It is vastly interesting if you want to know more about the history of tulips but be prepared to be overwhelmed with details.
2020-087