Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
I know it’s wrong as hell. She’s off-limits and totally innocent, but I can’t tame my desire for her, not when one blink of those wide eyes gets me hard as a rock.

She ignites something inside of me, something that won’t be tamed and won’t be f*cking stopped. I’m going to be her first, and claim every single part of her. I’m going to breed her and make her mine, and I don’t care who knows.

He’s my forbidden fantasy, the unbelievably hot retired rock star next door. He looks at me like I’m already his, and it’s hard to ignore the pure, raw need he brings in out in me.

I’ve been saving my v-card until college for the right man, but I know it’s a matter of time before I let him take it all, even if he’s more than twice my age.

Then again, there’s my best friend - my other half, my confidant. We’ve done everything together our whole lives. Can I really lose it without her? And what happens when “friends” turn into so much more?

244 pages, Paperback

Published July 20, 2016

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Madison Faye

83 books3,664 followers
#1 bestselling contemporary romance author Madison Faye is the dirty alter ego of the very wholesome, very normal suburban housewife behind the stories. While she might be a wife, mom, and PTA organizer on the outside, there’s nothing but hot, steamy, and raunchy fantasies brewing right beneath the surface!

Tired of keeping them hidden inside or only having them come out in the bedroom, they’re all here in the form of some wickedly hot stories. Single-minded alpha hero, sinfully taboo relationships, and wildly over-the-top scenarios. If you love it extra dirty, extra hot, and extra naughty, this is the place for you! (Just don’t tell the other PTA members you saw her here…)

Join the mailing list for author updates, special prices, and a **TWO FREE BOOKS!**
http://www.madisonfayeromance.com/mai...

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
174 (26%)
4 stars
165 (24%)
3 stars
166 (24%)
2 stars
88 (13%)
1 star
74 (11%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews
Profile Image for Tink Magoo is bad at reviews.
1,299 reviews252 followers
February 19, 2016
Here's my fucking problem - nowhere in the description does it say that this is a FMF book. If I had known it was then I would never have read it.

Now MFM I love because the more cocks the merrier as long as they're all for the heroine. I'm a jealous person and I DO NOT like to share so that's were this book FUCKED ME RIGHT OFF. I just do not like that shit and yes I'm over reacting but I'm angry, warn me before I jump into that.

Complete and utter bollocks. The End

Oh and FYI I read all of it so piss off anyone that wants to moan at me for slatting this.


Profile Image for Fre06 Begum.
1,260 reviews205 followers
March 9, 2016
I read this when it first came out and I think I blocked it from memory....yeah it was that bad for me! Seriously why didn't this author put down a disclaimer that this was an mff book? I read a few of her books and enjoyed them for the most part, I enjoyed it because it was m/f. If I had known this was a ménage which I HATE I would not have read it! Unless her books in future state whether it's a m/f or m/f/f I will not read her books again. I can't understand the concept of sharing a man its one of my triggers in a Romans book, if I had been aware of it I would not have read it! I dnf when I realised where it was heading actually!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for EliseVioletReads.
244 reviews48 followers
June 18, 2016
This book deserves a rating lower than 1 Star, Goodreads should look into that.

Disgusting book with misleading blurb and cover.
There was no warning this was a f-m-f book and honestly I don't share my man, nop! I don't.
Also, this book was 50 shades of stupid and fucked up. What pregnant girl drinks? wtf! Stupid as fuck.
Also, how did the heroine turn into the ow at the end? WTF was that?

Bottom line, this book is NOT SAFE! Please don't waste your money and your brain cells on this.
Profile Image for Alaina.
7,772 reviews201 followers
February 26, 2018
WOW

I have no idea why I wanted to read this series but I'm kind of glad that I knocked it off of my TBR. Now I do love Madison Faye and her writing but this series was really weird. So, in Freshman, which is a dual POV, and its about Tyler Weaver basically getting off between two freshman college girls that also grew up on his street.

Now I love the friendship between Anna and Christina but it got really weird really quick. First off, I have nothing against people being bi but i was weird that they were turned on while watching the other person getting it on. I guess I just didn't really understand their friendship or relationship later. I didn't really care about this happy ending nor did I care about them having and endless supply of kids or smuttiness.

I just don't know how I feel about this book but then again I'm glad that I finished this series and can move onto the next one written by Madison. I did however like the change of pace of two girls and one guy instead of one girl with multiple guys.. but idk.. this book was just weird to me. I think if it was written different and nothing was so insta love or lust then I probably would've like this book a lot more.
Profile Image for MrsJoseph *grouchy*.
1,009 reviews81 followers
April 17, 2016
DNF


Wow. So. How did we end up here? O_O

Twice Driven and Kindle Unlimited. That's how.

Freshman was one of the three free books in the back of Twice Driven.

Freshman (like Twice Driven) sounds like an Alexa Riley book. It is not. What Freshman is is poorly edited. And filled to the brim with many, many paragraphs littered with many, many italics. FML.



And so I dressed to kill the next night when we were heading over to his house for dinner. Again, nothing overtly slutty - not like I even owned anything like that - but I did make sure I was looking completely irresistible. And of course, it was all for Jake. I let my hair down, wore a very pretty loose-fitting, strappy tank-top, and opted out of a bra; hey, there had to be some perks to not having big boobs. I put on one of my smaller, but again not slutty pleated skirts which showed off my long, tanned legs, and then grinned as I pulled a very small, very slutty sheer black lacy thong up my legs and snug across my slit. I’m not saying dinner at Jake’s house with my whole family and Karen - his fake date - was the perfect opportunity to try and seduce him again, but I was also running out of time and I knew I had to make something happen.
-location 1881




WHAT human female refers to her vagina as a slit???!? Or as "my tight, virgin slit"???????!? *gag* Or actually uses the words "hot, potent seed." FFS.





And just like that, I felt the very last shred of willpower drop from my face.
-location 1598



The last shred of reading willpower I had dropped from my face.

DNF

Profile Image for Nicole.
312 reviews42 followers
July 20, 2016
**4** naughty stars from me!!

"ARC kindly provided by the author in exchange for an honest review.

Before i start my review i have to say that i'm not a fan of FMF but this is an exception for me the author succeeded to made me like the story.. a lot. Been said that all the main characters were very lovable plus the naughty taboo theme and the sexy explicit scenes made it very hot.

It is a fast pace plot so you can read it all the way through the end without a pause and believe scene after scene i didn't got bored the author filled it with a lot of naughtiness in order to be very pleasurable reading it. Definitely recommend it especially for fans of FMF and i'm looking forward to the next naughty, hot story the author will create.
Profile Image for AWB.
843 reviews12 followers
February 23, 2016
This was not for me. Not even because of the ménage, what killed the book for me was the h. She KNOWS she's pregnant, and goes to a frat party gets drunk with her BFF, and that's when they go back to the dorm and have sex for the first time. Nope. No thanks. Even if she is a college student, an idiot knows not to drink while knocked up.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Chantal ❤️.
1,359 reviews946 followers
May 1, 2016
Should be under bisexual reading or with FMF heading cause I would have skipped the whole thing if I had known it was under this. I am not really into the that whole scene. Oh boy I have to say I did not like it at all. Never going to read this book again.
Profile Image for Danielle.
925 reviews145 followers
August 1, 2016
I started reading this book on a whim. I'm usually not the biggest fan of menage stories or stories with characters with big age differences but I found this one really hot and sexy. I will say that it's a little cheesy at times and that the author tends to bang you on the head with the fact that there is a significant age difference but I still really enjoyed it. Like I said, it was a pretty damn hot read. Looking forward to reading more from this author.
Profile Image for Mindy Lou's Book Review.
3,081 reviews816 followers
August 19, 2016
I'm not sure what the first version of this book was like, but this revised version was seriously hot! I'm not a fan of f/f/m. I don't get being able to share your man but I accepted this comlemintary book knowing that's what it was so I didn't hold it completely against my rating. I'll be honest, if it was m/f/m or just Tyler and Christina, I would have given this 5 stars. It was that hot! This started out just between Tyler and Christina and Anna didn't come in until later. I liked it much better with just the first couple but again, that's my preference. If you are someone who would enjoy the 3 together, you'll love this story. Also, if there wasn't warning enough, this also has the much older man vs younger girl(s) scenario.

***Complimentary copy provided by author in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Barb.
992 reviews16 followers
February 26, 2016
This one just did not do it for me. I'm usually a fan of an older man/younger woman story, but the hero here comes across a bit creepy. I also found the ménage unexpected and not as believable as I normally would. It came at an odd time, especially after the hero admitted he loved the heroine and only "saw" her, then told himself that he may have liked the heroine's friend instead if the friend had been the one cleaning his home the last few years instead of the heroine. The ending was very abrupt as well.
Profile Image for Chanette Mills.
152 reviews19 followers
July 5, 2016
What did I just read. I cannot believe I had no hint this was a f/f/m book, I DO NOT READ this type of book. When I read the description, I was under the impression is was a m/f book. If I had know this would not have been read...........so angry right now. This just shows I need to read the reviews before I start reading the books from now on.
Profile Image for Lisa.
422 reviews17 followers
July 27, 2016
OK, let me start out with some things before I get into what I thought about the book. I've read some reviews where the reader didn't know it was going to be a menage. If you read the blurb of the book, when the main girl talks about doing everything with her best friend, her "other half", and friends turning into something more, I think that should lead you to believe what will eventually happen. I could tell the two girls were going to be together pretty quickly. The author writes taboo books, so if you are not into that, don't read it. She shouldn't suffer because readers aren't paying attention to what they are going to read. With that being said...

I really enjoyed this book. This one was a little longer compared to her book, Professor, but that's good because it gave it more depth. In this book you have Tyler, a rocker that decided to settle down with his wife in a nice neighborhood to run and indie record label, only to find out years later, she didn't want any of that, cheated on him, and then they divorced. He's now been single for a few months, but he's focusing on his work and not women. His neighbor's daughter has been helping take care of his house while she was in high school after school and during the summer. This is the last summer that Christina will be taking care of his house before she goes off to college with her best friend Anna, and Tyler has noticed how the girls are turning into women. When Christina catches Tyler in a compromising position, it adds fuel to the fire of Christina's desire for the older man. When she reveals what she saw to Tyler, she goes off to college with a delicious secret.

There is a lot of hot and steamy scenes in this book, and I don't want to give away the story! Tyler and Christina start a secret affair, but where does that leave best friend Anna? Read the book, you won't be disappointed. Taboo older man/younger women, girl on girl, menage....it's all there. And wait till you see how it ends!!

**I was given a copy in exchange for an honest review**
Profile Image for Michelle Quintana.
1,912 reviews7 followers
August 8, 2016
Not quite what I was expecting. Tyler has fantasized about Christina and vice versa. When they start their relationship, of course it is hush hush. The first time they have sex is definitely a dumb place and the fact that Tyler couldn't show enough restraint was disappointing. When Christina finally lets Anna watch her and Tyler get it on, Tyler starts to fantasize about Anna to, even though he loves Christina. When he finds out that Christina cheated on him and with who, he is so upset. But when Christina gives him permission to have Anna, then all is fine. What kind of parents are going to forgive their daughter for carrying on with a man old enough to be her dad just because she is pregnant. the book was frustrating at times because I couldn't get over how dumb the characters were and the things they did.
Profile Image for Edit~A.
394 reviews26 followers
March 27, 2018
I thought of watching them.

I really enjoyed reading this book! First of all, I have a feeling, that this one unlike the previous two was edited, FINALLY! The language was not really that cringy, the characters did not say ridiculous things. However, I feel like something is wrong with me, lately I noticed that I like the secondary characters more than the main ones, and here as well I didn't like Christina, she was annoying me to be honest, the way she talked to Anna, but I liked Anna. I actually shipped Anna and Jake since the beginning, and I am glad it finally happened in the end. I like the twist, like the story, it finally felt that the author put lots of thought how to work this idea of hers out, and did not just write whatever came to her mind. It was a fun read, indeed.
Profile Image for Kristina.
1,613 reviews79 followers
April 18, 2016
The PREGNANT woman gets drunk enough to be tipsy. What the ever loving...
I WAS NOT enjoying what was turning out to be a f/f/m read, when this complete idiocy occurred.
First, I'm not into f/f, or sharing, but figured whatever, fine, it's a short read. But then the KNOWINGLY PREGNANT f-tard goes out drinking.
Second, I'm not into public displays, much less public sex. The fantasy doesn't turn me on, because the small issue of reality and CONSENT eliminates that. These innocents who find themselves a part of the couples sexual games never gave consent to be part of their kink, and that makes it not erotic and not ok.
NO. To all of it.
Profile Image for Rachel Wheeler.
1,644 reviews10 followers
July 29, 2016
HOT ... BUT NOT for me

Uh uh... I was ok until it became a serious thing... I often read two men loving one woman but two women loving one man drove me NUTS!!!! I guess I'm a double standard brat! I would be so jealous!!! Gah! Nope! At least I can say I tried...
I gave this book three stars because although, it was hot and had delicious smutt that was pretty much all it was... I was happy that it had an epilogue! If your in the mood for a raunchy quick read give it a try!
Profile Image for Kristy.
1,383 reviews
March 7, 2016
Not for me

FMF wasn't for me. Not much of a story line the older sexy neighbor hooks up with two younger college girls. The forbidden romance. It was mostly book up scenes and the characters were annoying.

Profile Image for Amber.
1,788 reviews12 followers
September 8, 2016
Defiantly not a fan of this one which was disappointing because the description drew me in :/ wondering why there wasn't a mention of a MFF relationship (not that it's a bad thing it just doesn't do anything for me Aka I don't share)
8 reviews
January 21, 2021
Tragic Madison Faye has stopped writing. A (relative) lot of thought and effort went into 'Freshman'. Erotica needs more voices like this one.
Profile Image for Uhleeseeuh.
476 reviews6 followers
April 22, 2019
Not for me

I love MFM and MMF stories, and a!so love Faye, so I wanted to give this book a chance. This is the first FFM book I have ever read, and it just wasn't for me. For one, I didn't like Chris. Her character irritated me from beginning to end. I also didn't care for one man two women. I have ZERO issue with MMF bisexual stories and reading about two men, but two women didn't work for me. I'm greedy, and am not trying to share anyone with another woman, including my fictitious heros. I also was creeped out that I had to hear about "my older lover" and "her young teenage..." There was a LOT of emphasis on both, and it started to become right-wing like I could turn this into a drinking game. I also did start to get creeped put, and it could be because of said emphasis, that the 18 year old GIRLS really were being taken advantage of by Tyler. I don't have issues suspending reality for these stories, but I had a hard time with this one. I really do blame the repeated comments and the fact that I hated the star heroine. Lastly, this is another story where the heroine doesn't understand consent, and refuses to respect the hero's wishes. No means no regardless of who is saying it. If the roles were reversed and it was the 40 year old OLDER LOVER man coming on to the 18 yr old YOUNG TEENAGE P after she tells him no repeatedly but he basically forced himself on her, readers would be screaming rape. As far as my enjoyment, I give this book a 1. I'm not going to lowball Faye's rating just because this book ended up not being my cup of tea. If Chris didn't suck as much as she did, I probably could have enjoyed the book more. ALas, she and her YOUNG TEENAGE P sucked
Profile Image for hottie men.
865 reviews3 followers
December 25, 2022
Freshman is the story of Christina or Chris, Tyler and Anna.

Tropes:
FFM OR MFM
ménage but women?
Neighbours daughter x hot ass rock band neighbours/ boss
Age gap (both girls are 18 and Ty is 40)
Best friends daughter x dads best friend
HEA and kids
EXHIBITIONIST KINK
ALSO A MASSIVE BREEDING KINK

So first Christina and Ty get together and fuck like rabbits every single chapter like in their dorm bathroom or the club they went to. But Anna was just the watcher and they were just exhibitionists. No touching jus watching. But then she changed her mind and slept with Anna and then she told Ty and was like I cheated on you and he hanged up on her and they went to his house and explained and that’s when Chris was like I’m preggers and he was like okay yay wow. So they fucked all three of them and then years later they have 2 daughters by Chris and they have one unborn with Anna. So it’s an our not an us yk. Anna is the mischievous redhead and Chris is the same but different like she does what he says and shit. She is obedient and playful while Anna is mischievous and sly. Don’t think Tyler had a good connection with her until the very end. It’s a very big push and pull like he comes for a weekend then leaves yk. And it’s due to the age gap they are iffy and also about her parents being friends with Tyler. Not to mention he’s 22 years older than them. BUT I LOVED IT THE SPICE AND THERE WAS LITTLE PLOT AND THEY ALL CAME TOGETHER AND THERE WERE STRINGS LEFT UNATTACHED AND THOSE CAME TOGETHER IN THE END AND JUS IT WAS SO GOOD😽😽.

Solid 3.95/5
1,146 reviews3 followers
November 16, 2024
Different paths... By MeemsAngel82

I absolutely love, love and miss this author! She writes so steamy that you most definitely cannot read her books at work! I knew going in what this would be like so it's on me, not her, but because of the mff angle I find this one to be my very least favorite of her books. She wrote this very well like usual, and this was hot!

She had feelings for her buddy, but she was liking her seemingly unattainable guy as well. But both liked her right back.

Now the writing was wonderful, like I said steamy is what this woman just DOES. And yes, folks, it IS hot. The characters and where they come from and end up were all done well. The connections are great but her bestie and her guy didn't know one another enough to take that step at that time. If they had waited I could totally understand. Because the ending? Well done. For this scenario to play out and for them to all have a very, apparently VERY satisfying ending-that was done wonderfully. How you have that conversation with the parents I have NO idea, but hey. You crazy kids do you. That the two didn't have enough of a connection at the time to take such a big step together is why the loss of one star. Otherwise, even this gal who does NOT do mff whatsoever is impressed the the steam level. And make no mistake, Madison doesn't do cheating and has great character chemistry. In fact her book Royal Brat is one of my favorites of hers. I do miss her so much. Sigh. Thank goodness we can reread! We miss you!!
Profile Image for Jessica CW.
1,108 reviews12 followers
December 20, 2017
Triad ffm

I love reading about all various relationships and forms of love. Its not necessarily just the erotica but also watching the characters open up, come to terms with and really bloosom.

It is incredibly hard to have a taboo relationship. Like an older man with much younger women. Or two women in love or threesomes or going as far as a triad relationship.

No one gets it but some people are strong enough to make it work.

What started off as some fantasy play and voyeaurism turned into something much deeper.

I loved the final piece of having Anna's pov. Knowing she secretly thought she was gay and in love with her best friend to seeing where things went i know none of these characters would have predicted.

I am very impressed how this story went. Sure it was mostly erotica but it still developed their relationship. And since there are barely any FFM stories out there this is a unique find bring a FFM triad menage romance.

Its fairly common to find mmf bisexuel romance menages but not the reversal.

I hope that there are more stories out there like this or others that really delve into the romance side too of a ffm triad relationship. Its a very slim market with lots of opportunity for growth.

Especially with how many women are bi and love two people.
Profile Image for Donna Feibusch.
1,798 reviews25 followers
February 21, 2017
An Awesome Read!

I loved reading Freshman, all about Christina Aimes a young eighteen year old girl who did odd jobs for my wife and I and her BFF Anna Riley who was basically joined at the hip with Christina. My name is Tyler Weaver and I used to be in a rock band, but have since given that up and just right song's and promote other young musicians from my home studio. My wife Rebecca Weaver is a Realtor and she also works from home selling homes. But recently just found out my wife has been cheating on me and wants a divorce, okay showed her the pre-nip and divorced her and she went on her merry way with half the furniture in our big mansion. Now I'm forty years old and have an EX and just want to sit in my living room and drink a beer and contemplate life! The author wrote a very unique story that will keep you on the edge of your seat for most of the story! Read this story and fall in love with the characters, and see where things go once the girls go off to college!
Profile Image for Cheyenne.
898 reviews
July 2, 2016
This is a sexy story about a girl next door named Chris whose heading off to college with her best friend Anna. Tyler is her sexy neighbor who is just recently divorced and is friends with her parents. Chris has been doing work for Tyler for a while since she's waiting for her freshman year to start. She always found him attractive no matter that he is old enough to be her father. Tyler has been watching Chris for a while prancing around his house and has fantasized about her. Chris and Anna made a pact to lose their virginity in college to older more experienced. What happens when Chris breaks the pact and looses it to her hot neighbor Tyler? What happens when Anna wants a piece of this sexy couple? This is a sexy story that has f/f/m sex. I really loved Chris with Tyler. The only thing I couldn't get past was how Anna fit into this. Why wasn't Chris jealous? Overall, it was crazy hot in a dirty way. Taboo at it's finest. **received an arc in exchange for a review**
149 reviews1 follower
March 2, 2016
I don't really have too much to say about this book. I can't say that I enjoyed it, but I also cannot say that I hated it. I guess it was right in the middle. There were plenty of times I was shaking my head and asking myself what the hell did I just read. Then there were times that I needed to cool off from the hotness coming out of the book. Honestly, it was pure smut. No, actually it was porn. Straight up porn. And it's ok, because there are some out there that love this kind of stuff. I wasn't offended by any of it, nor was I put off by any of it. It is what was, that being porn. Just being honest. I have nothing bad to say about this book. What I can say is if you're in to pure smut, this is your book.
13 reviews
January 19, 2017
Love it

I belatedly realized that I'd never rated or reviewed Freshman - so here it is

Freshman was one of the very first Kindle books I'd picked up, and since then I've read it and re-read it more than a handful of times. There's something about it that just keeps drawing me back, and I keep hoping Madison Faye ends up writing more F/M/F stories. Or throw in more people, I'm just fine with that.

Freshman spurred me onto the relentless hunt for menage and polyamorous books, and since then I've found a very large number of truly brilliant books and authors. For that and that alone, I'd give props to Freshman. That it is also cute as hell, sexy in the best ways, and a good, fun read is a hell of a bonus.
Profile Image for T Van.
1,637 reviews37 followers
April 22, 2017
Not My Favorite, March 19, 2016

This review is from: Freshman: A First Time Novel (Kindle Edition)
This was not my favorite, but I actually enjoyed the element of surprise when I found out this was a multiple partner story. The author built that detail into the plot in a way that was borderline suspenseful, in that there were several hints that it would go in that direction, but I wasn't sure until it happened. In my opinion, the story was less offensive, and more tried to do too much in a shorter novella format; and in doing so, the plot and characters suffered.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews