It seems to me that reviews, as they are now commonly used, can cover a quite a bit of ground. They can, for example, be pretty much just a recommendation. They can be a purely statement of how a reader feels about a book, and how that book made them feel. Or they can be a more detailed assessment of the perceived strengths and weakness of a work. Or, of course, all three.
In this review of Ryleigh Sloan’s debut novel, Cliché, I’m going to attempt all three.
First, the easiest part: the recommendation. Buy it. If you love romance, just ignore the rest of this, click on the link for Cliché, and buy it. You will be happy you did.
Second, the next easiest part: how I feel about the book and how made me feel. I love it. Pure and simple. It made me feel the full gamut of emotions, intensely and viscerally. Most of all, it made me feel joyful that I read it and others will also, and be touched as much as I was.
The last part is more difficult to find words for, but I’ll try. Cliché is a beautifully written story about people I instantly connected with and who I wholly believed in; people who entirely real, fully alive, and intensely human. The writing is exceptional. The story is told economically and powerfully, never overworked, never striving to impress, using perfect, poignant details to capture the heart of scene in a way that is brilliant yet seems effortless and doesn’t intrude. The flow and the rhythm of the writing moves along naturally and immersed me completely.
The plot you should discover for yourself, but it is a wonderful journey and (despite the title) an unexpected one. The best journeys take us places we didn’t think to go, but should have, and show us things we didn’t expect to see, but needed to. They make us grow, make us richer people, capable of living fuller lives. And that is what this story is ultimately about.
Finally, Ryleigh Sloan is able to convey the whole range of human emotions, in all their rawness and beauty, better than any author I know. She lays them out simply and perfectly for us, with nothing to dull or blur them. It’s beautiful and, at times, heart wrenching, but livened with humor throughout, so they are never melodramatic or maudlin. This, I think, is the strongest past of the story.
Oh yes. One last thing: parts are scorchingly hot. Quite a few parts, in fact. So be aware of that.
With all these exceptional strengths, does Cliché have any weaknesses?
Yes, it has one.
It ended.
Note: I received an advance copy of the this book as a gift. The decision to review it was my own.