I actually have to amend this as I re read and highlighted parts of this book last night and I am actually angry. Angry for how the heroine was made to feel neglected and guilty for being alive and returning to her family! She was treated horrendously by her husband and best friend when she returned! The author then sloppily tried to blame the evil OW for all the bad behaviour and manipulating the husband! I also found so much of what happened to be contradictory ! The husband tells the OW he will always love her, even when the wife has returned! But then he tells the Wife he never forgot her, and it was Always her that he loved? Really? The heroine kept saying she had no right to feel betrayed? Really because I disagree! The hero was pathetic, he kept putting the feelings of the OW first and neglected his wife who nearly died, lost her memory, who was then abused and hospitalised, and came back to him! She should of been his priority! I am sorry but he struck out for me, I wanted her to dump him and find a man who actually understood what having the love of your life means, and what loyalty meant! Sawyer was a sorry excuse of a husband, and I don’t know how Quinn stayed with him as I lost all trust and respect for him in this book. The best friend was a joke. Also shame on both Sawyers and Quinns mothers for not doing more. Quinn is home after being believed dead, and she is broken hearted to find out her best friend and husband were soon to be married. So when Sawyer and Bree walk in looking like a couple and being tactile, the women make excuses and leave? Sorry what? If that was my daughter and son I would be talking to the other two and speaking some Sense to them, not leaving Quinn to fend for herself! This is not a love story, and this is not how anyone should act if they lost their wife! Also, quick ending with no issues resolved! Like Quinn must have been hella angry about their boat being renamed after Bree, but does that get talked out? Nope! The boat just gets re named Quinn! They just return to a happy couple and Create a new child! Woo hoo, because that won’t come back to bite them on the ass, as if! Yeah, no thanks. I am sorry but I don’t want to see a happy couple who apparently have true love done dirty. So the wife is believed to be dead, but shock horror it turns out she isn’t! So why the husband is grieving, her ass of a best friend moves in uninvited to help with the kids! So their relationship goes from him tolerating her to him falling for her? Really? Is that believable? Nope. Chances are if the hero is in an absolute state with grief, and the heroine’s best friend is looking after the children and keeps making moves, then love is not what is going on between these two! I may be judgmental, but to me it’s either one of two things, either, the hero did not love the wife as much as he claimed, because if he did he would not move on the her best friend, and be having a relationship with her 18 months later, then quickly renaming his boat after her (previously named after his wife), and getting engaged to her. 18 months may be a long time to some, but not to me when it involves losing the ‘love of your life’. Or, he does not love the OW at all. Because they originally did not get on, she is obsessive and keeps trying it on with him, and he is grieving and grows to depend on her support and attention, and uses her as a crutch, which is most likely to me and not at all romantic.
I am also not a fan of weak MCs, which we have here! The husband just seems to let everything happen and goes along with it. Losing the wife, letting himself get entangled with the best friend, renaming the boat, and getting engaged! Do not get me wrong he tells the OW he will always love his wife, and he ultimately chooses the wife, but he is too passive for my liking, and how could you ever trust his judgement again? The OW was pretty nasty going for the husband of her apparently deceased best friend! Then when the poor wife has the cheek to return from the dead/amnesia hell, the OW tells her that she has ruined their happy bliss! Excuse me? This imposter takes over her life and her children and she is going to dish out abuse to the injured wife? I think not! Too much going on, quite unlikeable characters, ridiculous plot, so it’s a big bust for me. When presented with a strong couple and love story, I actually want those things included, not just drama. It’s a shame as I love the book I’m With You, by this author, but this just did not work for me.