So let me preface this review by saying I re-read all four books along with the prequel before going into the fifth one. I’d listened to the audiobooks before but was so excited for the return of one of my favourite series I decided to re-read the e-books.
That said, re-reading the series and going into book five gave me a fresh perspective on the series as a whole. Including highlighting some of the faults that I could forgive in the first few books that I’ve found overemphasized and I have less tolerance for in this newest addition of the series.
I think the largest glaring issue, and in a way strength, that the author has done with the King Dark Tidings series is developing both a fascinating and grand world. However, in this book specifically, though she only focuses on a few locations around Rezkin’s growing empire, the world itself is growing too large to keep track of. Now I don’t think a large world is necessarily a bad thing for a high fantasy series. Fact, I think up until this point Kade has done a good job through books 1-4 not overwhelming the reader on all the different locations, gradually introducing them and referencing back to the other countries throughout. However, in this book, though it’s only around three or four new places she’s introducing, even after having refreshed myself with the series, I’m having trouble remembering all the locations, and most importantly all the characters.
I think the largest problem that King Dark Tidings has run into is that there are too many characters and the author isn't sure how to deal with the scale of including all of them. Particularly, the largest thing I found wrong with this book is Kade is brushing over characters we know and love that she’s previously established in the series. I'm not saying she has to focus on everyone we've met so far, but for the characters she does mention going on the adventures in this novel I would have liked a bit more interaction.
Take in point Reaylin. Though not my favourite character, I’ve found myself enjoying her arc from reluctant rebel warrior to accepting her powers as a healer. Then in this book, we have the privilege of meeting her father. However, because of the focus on the overwhelming number of characters being juggled inside this book, when Reaylin reunites with her father there’s barely any impact. If the author spent just a few extra paragraphs on building back Reylin’s character, reminding the reader of who she is by way of some quippy dialogue, this reunion would have been much more impactful overall.
The group that goes on the boat in search of Tam gets sidelined and I largely forgot who was there --besides Farson because of his pretty heart-warming character moments. A lot of their journey is brushed over to focus on the new characters and Nanessy-- who I admit, played as a good conscious to Rezkin in this book now that they've become 'friends'. The two foiled well against each other and it was nice to see Nanessy get a little of the spotlight in this novel.
However, besides the characters we get a perspective for (Frisha, Tam, Wesson) things feel a bit crowded for everyone else, and the author forgets to address characters during what I believe to be key moments (looking at you VERY dramatic and gut-wrenching scene before the epilogue). The last scene would have been so much more impactful had the author just spent a little more focus on everyone's reaction to what'd just taken place. Plus, considering what 'this' plot point might set up for Tieran, I wish we'd gotten just a few more scenes of him beside the one at the beginning. Would it have interrupted the pace so much to include a longer glimpse of what was happening with everyone in Cael? Their reaction to even finding out Tam is alive, that Frisha may be missing or is 'suspiciously gone'? What was happening there? Don't tell me Tieran would believe Frisha locked herself away for a few days as her assassin bodyguard implied.
Then, what I miss in this book the most—that I found was in all the previous books a lot more— is the characters bantering with each other to build up their dynamics. Kade does it a bit with Wesson and his perspective, but besides Azeria, Entris and Nanessy (and that I found with their group a lot more forced) there's a very serious tone in this novel. I found the comedic heart that was prevalent in the other books sorely lacking in this addition to the series, which was part of why I’ve grown to love the Kings Dark Tidings series. The misunderstandings with Rezkin have always been hilarious. There are a couple of misunderstanding scenes with Tam at the Quarry, but never once like in the other books did I find myself grinning because of a hilarious misunderstanding or reversal situation.
Now, the lack of misunderstanding for Rezkin does mean that as a character he is growing because he's understanding the world better. Fact this book gives him a lot of development in comparison to even the last book. But how the plot actually gives Rezkin that development I'm particularly not a fan of.
Now addressing the faults I’ve found before in the series, but largely ignored, was in regard to how the author has been setting up the romances.
***SPOILERS FOR THE NOVEL AHEAD***
There are no surprises with who people end up with in the King Dark Tiding Series, because Kade loves to lay out in her characters their internal thoughts of who exactly they yearn for. (Except for Tieran and Frisha, who even after re-reading book four I still do not think their relationship really developed, this book doing nothing to progress it; but I digress).
Now in this book, Rezkin is given a love interest in the newly introduced Azeria. And though he’s growing an attraction to her, their chemistry does not feel natural in the slightest. Fact from both sides it feels very forced, Rezkin’s internal thoughts around his newfound attraction he can barely recognize is feels forced from the dreams sequences forward. Now I don’t think Frisha and him were right for each other at all, but at least they foiled each other and had some chemistry and build-up from Rezkin's side.
With Azeria and Rezkin it’s a lot being 'told' from both sides through hints that they’re 'magically' meant to be together. However, the scenes where the two do try and make a somewhat of connection feel somewhat lacklustre. It's even more surprising when other people in Rezkin's group remark on the two's growing attraction when I feel as a reader that the two barely know each other besides this 'magic bond'.
They could still be a great couple, but it just doesn't seem right that Rezkin fell so easily in love (even if they are soulmates or whatever). Even if Rezkin never admits it's love out loud, it seems to be shoved down the reader's throat that I'm supposed to be rooting for this relationship that's barely developed.
I think where I would have liked more focus in this book is simply on Rezkin acknowledging his emotions. Like he's beginning to, for example, acknowledge his compassion for others. When he finds Tam—who I think recovered with little consequence despite that mind-hole build-up, I might add—Rezkin acknowledges he really cares for him and he is even able to heal him like he wasn’t able to do with newly introduced Entries. I love this character moment. Yet it's brushed over, and Tam and Rez have barely a moment together thanks to this large cast getting juggled. But their friendship is part of my investment in the series, and though I love the moment where Rezkin gives Tam the sheyalin sword and crowns him a general, it feels so brushed over. I barely remembered Tam was even with the group after they arrived on the plains. At one point Tam goes and practices his swordsmanship with Rez after he accidentally gives someone else a magical bond (oops) and goes to train to get out his frustration. This is great, it's showing Rez actually reacting to his situations, and growing as a character. Be cool if he could also talk to Tam about this, not just Azuria. We don't even get a scene of Tam and him talking, just a sentence that they trainned, then Tam leaves? What was the point? Why aren't you two talking? I miss your dynamic!
So, as a whole, I wish this book had more focus on Rezkin discovering these other emotions he's kept suppressed all this time, instead of diving deep first into the idea of his attraction for Azeria. I'm not saying this plot-thread can't exist in the book, but it got so repetitive every time Rezkin felt a pang of jealousy about Azeria and felt the need in his internal dialogue. I kind of wanted to see Rezkin explore some other emotions he's acknowledging. What would the impact have been if Rezkin and Farson had more time to acknowledge their relationship of 'love'-- and that was one of the characters who got 'more development'. What about sadness, happiness and fear? Could he have talked about these growing emotions and his fear of them (and growing madness) with anyone else besides Azuria?
To sum up my thoughts, this book reads a bit like the author's second draft. The world and character count of Rezkin’s kingdom and group of friends is getting way too big. And I think if the author actually spent more time expanding, focusing and reminding us of these previous relationships, this book would have been a lot easier and more enjoyable to digest. A lot of plot elements/characters were introduced without a refresher, and I was getting lost at times even after having just re-read the series before going into this book.
Not to mention ***EXTRA SPOILER SPOILER WARNING*** introducing Prince Thresson's location, and finally revealing King Caydean felt a little tagged on at the end. He's the big bad, he can be saved a little. I almost wish he hadn't had any dialogue during his scenes, it might have made him more menacing in his arc for the future. I mean it was cool to see him and his power considering what he did, but again, it felt kind of tagged on and he didn't get enough expansion. This was also the case with Thresson. His introduction was definitely something that could have been saved for the next book. Or at the very least, the reveal of his circumstances. It would have been so much more impactful if we just knew he was alive and not of his circumstance of why he was locked up with Frisha. That way he could get proper focus during the next book in the series, considering all the build-up around him being 'missing' thus far. We never even get to see his reaction to the revelation he has a little brother after that brushed-over conversation. I hope at least his and Rez's first meeting, if it ever happens, will get more than one paragraph.
***Spoiler Warning End***
To conclude, the author doesn't really know how to handle half the population of her characters that we’ve grown to love (except Pride, I always know where that horse is). And if she’s going to include characters we know on missions during the story, at least give them some dialogue, a couple of paragraphs even to let them have a moment to shine.
That said, even if I didn’t enjoy this book as much as the others, I still look forward to where Rezkin’s story will go and in what way he'll (or others) will claim more countries for the True King's empire.