What do you think?
Rate this book
The Outlaw Chronicles #2
Holy Warrior
Heroes will fall... Legends will survive... Richard the Lionheart has launched his epic crusade to seize Jerusalem from the cruel Saracens, and marching with the vast royal army is Britain's most famous, most feared, most ferocious warrior: the Outlaw of Nottingham, the Earl of Locksley - Robin Hood himself. With his band of loyal men at his side, Robin cuts a bloody swathe on the brutal journey east. The crimson battlefields of the Holy Land are the ultimate proving ground, but within Robin's camp lurks a traitor - a stealthy enemy determined to slay the ultimate outlaw before the trumpets fade.
480 pages, Hardcover
First published July 22, 2010
93 people are currently reading
1269 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 136 reviews
June 10, 2019
The second book in the outlaw chronicles, reputedly about Robin Hood, although we follow the story of Alan Dale and the rest of the gang he encounters. Ok semantics maybe as Robin, Earl of Locksley is featured in most scenes with Alan.
I enjoyed the first in the series with it’s historical detail & portrayal of Robin Hood, not as the dashing likes of Errol Flynn that we all know of legend but a hard & brutal Lord to his people, often cruel & at times governed by greed & ambition. Certainly a man for the times.
The front cover depicts that of a Holy warrior & talks of the forthcoming crusade (it’s the 3rd one) to recover Jerusalem....... However we start in England with Robin looking to fund his part in the crusade, which leads neatly to the Jewish quarter in York & an old acquaintance of his, Alan of course comes along for the ride. I say neatly as it’s well documented in history that along the way various crusades set about & slaughtered the local Jewish population, mostly through central Europe & the Balkans but our story takes place locally in York featuring the chief villain, a knight called Malbete, who becomes Robin’s nemesis for the tale. The episode in York is played well, showing the rancour between religions & the brutality that goes with it. The historical fiction depicted feels realistic too giving a good sense of the era.
The second part of the book sees us in Sicily before Cyprus on route to Outremer, which was the collective term for the Crusader States in the Levant. The year is 1190AD. A few events occur within both regions which give substance to the overall historical content of the 3rd Crusade as well as the storyline revolving around Robin Hood & now King Richard too as ever told by Alan Dale. Scenes of battle against the Tyrant of Cyprus are skilfully portrayed, brutal in their telling.
The final part finally sees us in Outremer, the confrontation with Saladin by the army of Christianity. The machinations of the Christian alliance is touched upon along with battle tactics between the two sides as the armies moved towards battle at Arsuf which is relayed in this tale.
Overall the story revolves around Robin, his motives for being in Outremer & the evolvement of Alan Dale’s character/interactions from the first book, there is no real plotline per say which I only really realised come the final quarter of the book but it’s fair to say I’ve enjoyed it nevertheless mainly down to my liking of the MC’s in the book.
3.75 rounded up to a four score.
I enjoyed the first in the series with it’s historical detail & portrayal of Robin Hood, not as the dashing likes of Errol Flynn that we all know of legend but a hard & brutal Lord to his people, often cruel & at times governed by greed & ambition. Certainly a man for the times.
The front cover depicts that of a Holy warrior & talks of the forthcoming crusade (it’s the 3rd one) to recover Jerusalem....... However we start in England with Robin looking to fund his part in the crusade, which leads neatly to the Jewish quarter in York & an old acquaintance of his, Alan of course comes along for the ride. I say neatly as it’s well documented in history that along the way various crusades set about & slaughtered the local Jewish population, mostly through central Europe & the Balkans but our story takes place locally in York featuring the chief villain, a knight called Malbete, who becomes Robin’s nemesis for the tale. The episode in York is played well, showing the rancour between religions & the brutality that goes with it. The historical fiction depicted feels realistic too giving a good sense of the era.
The second part of the book sees us in Sicily before Cyprus on route to Outremer, which was the collective term for the Crusader States in the Levant. The year is 1190AD. A few events occur within both regions which give substance to the overall historical content of the 3rd Crusade as well as the storyline revolving around Robin Hood & now King Richard too as ever told by Alan Dale. Scenes of battle against the Tyrant of Cyprus are skilfully portrayed, brutal in their telling.
The final part finally sees us in Outremer, the confrontation with Saladin by the army of Christianity. The machinations of the Christian alliance is touched upon along with battle tactics between the two sides as the armies moved towards battle at Arsuf which is relayed in this tale.
Overall the story revolves around Robin, his motives for being in Outremer & the evolvement of Alan Dale’s character/interactions from the first book, there is no real plotline per say which I only really realised come the final quarter of the book but it’s fair to say I’ve enjoyed it nevertheless mainly down to my liking of the MC’s in the book.
3.75 rounded up to a four score.
April 30, 2021
The sequel to Outlaw is as thrilling as the first, fast paced, violent, in parts horrifying, eventful and erotic.
The novel takes off from when Robin (the ruthless godfather of Sherwood Forest) and his band are pardoned by King Richard and dispatched to go on the crusade to free the Holy Land from the Saracens.
This Robin Hood is far removed from the traditional altruist in green, robbing from the rich to give to the poor. He is ruthless, vengeful, self-serving, and cynical.
But he has his own code and is loyal to those in his inner circle.
His most heroic moment is helping the Jews try to fight off the pogroms carried out at York by hate-filled mobs against the community mirroring the events in 1190. The events are described in graphic horror, Richard Malbete aptly described as the Evil Beast as well as some diabolical bishops direct the crowd into a hateful frenzy and leads some really foul acts of cruelty to the men, women and children of the Jewish settlement in York.
Alan (our narrator and protagonist), Robin and his Jewish benefactor Reuben, help the Jews of York to defend themselves but it all ends in tragedy.
And Robin bitterly dissapoints us and wounds Alan by failing to rescue Reuben's comely young daughter, Ruth.
The action takes us through France to Messina and Cyprus (where in both places King Richard battles and massacres the local populations, and finally to the Holy Land. Knowing modern Israel well and it being aland I love, it was fascinating to revisit that country in this period, from Haifa, Akko, Jaffa, and Jerusalem itself.
The battle scenes are riveting, the action is nailbiting, lots of blood, gore and brutality as well as raw emotion.
Strongly erotic and raunchy sex. Alan has a Jewess and later a Muslim Lebanese rescued slave among his love interests,
Again it must be stressed Robin dissapoints us many times through the eys of the narrator, the man is an enigma.
but he inspires total loyalty in his followers.
Captures the locations vividly as well as the sights, smells and sounds of the place and period.
Merged review:
he sequel to Outlaw is as thrilling as the first, fast paced, violent, in parts horrifying, eventful and erotic.
The novel takes off from when Robin (the ruthless godfather of Sherwood Forest) and his band are pardoned by King Richard and dispatched to go on the crusade to free the Holy Land from the Saracens.
This Robin Hood is far removed from the traditional altruist in green, robbing from the rich to give to the poor. He is ruthless, vengeful, self-serving, and cynical.
But he has his own code and is loyal to those in his inner circle.
His most heroic moment is helping the Jews try to fight off the pogroms carried out at York by hate-filled mobs against the community mirroring the events in 1190. The events are described in graphic horror, Richard Malbete aptly described as the Evil Beast as well as some diabolical bishops direct the crowd into a hateful frenzy and leads some really foul acts of cruelty to the men, women and children of the Jewish settlement in York.
Alan (our narrator and protagonist), Robin and his Jewish benefactor Reuben, help the Jews of York to defend themselves but it all ends in tragedy.
And Robin bitterly dissapoints us and wounds Alan by failing to rescue Reuben's comely young daughter, Ruth.
The action takes us through France to Messina and Cyprus (where in both places King Richard battles and massacres the local populations, and finally to the Holy Land. Knowing modern Israel well and it being aland I love, it was fascinating to revisit that country in this period, from Haifa, Akko, Jaffa, and Jerusalem itself.
The battle scenes are riveting, the action is nailbiting, lots of blood, gore and brutality as well as raw emotion.
Strongly erotic and raunchy sex. Alan has a Jewess and later a Muslim Lebanese rescued slave among his love interests,
Again it must be stressed Robin dissapoints us many times through the eys of the narrator, the man is an enigma.
but he inspires total loyalty in his followers.
Captures the locations vividly as well as the sights, smells and sounds of the place and period.
The novel takes off from when Robin (the ruthless godfather of Sherwood Forest) and his band are pardoned by King Richard and dispatched to go on the crusade to free the Holy Land from the Saracens.
This Robin Hood is far removed from the traditional altruist in green, robbing from the rich to give to the poor. He is ruthless, vengeful, self-serving, and cynical.
But he has his own code and is loyal to those in his inner circle.
His most heroic moment is helping the Jews try to fight off the pogroms carried out at York by hate-filled mobs against the community mirroring the events in 1190. The events are described in graphic horror, Richard Malbete aptly described as the Evil Beast as well as some diabolical bishops direct the crowd into a hateful frenzy and leads some really foul acts of cruelty to the men, women and children of the Jewish settlement in York.
Alan (our narrator and protagonist), Robin and his Jewish benefactor Reuben, help the Jews of York to defend themselves but it all ends in tragedy.
And Robin bitterly dissapoints us and wounds Alan by failing to rescue Reuben's comely young daughter, Ruth.
The action takes us through France to Messina and Cyprus (where in both places King Richard battles and massacres the local populations, and finally to the Holy Land. Knowing modern Israel well and it being aland I love, it was fascinating to revisit that country in this period, from Haifa, Akko, Jaffa, and Jerusalem itself.
The battle scenes are riveting, the action is nailbiting, lots of blood, gore and brutality as well as raw emotion.
Strongly erotic and raunchy sex. Alan has a Jewess and later a Muslim Lebanese rescued slave among his love interests,
Again it must be stressed Robin dissapoints us many times through the eys of the narrator, the man is an enigma.
but he inspires total loyalty in his followers.
Captures the locations vividly as well as the sights, smells and sounds of the place and period.
Merged review:
he sequel to Outlaw is as thrilling as the first, fast paced, violent, in parts horrifying, eventful and erotic.
The novel takes off from when Robin (the ruthless godfather of Sherwood Forest) and his band are pardoned by King Richard and dispatched to go on the crusade to free the Holy Land from the Saracens.
This Robin Hood is far removed from the traditional altruist in green, robbing from the rich to give to the poor. He is ruthless, vengeful, self-serving, and cynical.
But he has his own code and is loyal to those in his inner circle.
His most heroic moment is helping the Jews try to fight off the pogroms carried out at York by hate-filled mobs against the community mirroring the events in 1190. The events are described in graphic horror, Richard Malbete aptly described as the Evil Beast as well as some diabolical bishops direct the crowd into a hateful frenzy and leads some really foul acts of cruelty to the men, women and children of the Jewish settlement in York.
Alan (our narrator and protagonist), Robin and his Jewish benefactor Reuben, help the Jews of York to defend themselves but it all ends in tragedy.
And Robin bitterly dissapoints us and wounds Alan by failing to rescue Reuben's comely young daughter, Ruth.
The action takes us through France to Messina and Cyprus (where in both places King Richard battles and massacres the local populations, and finally to the Holy Land. Knowing modern Israel well and it being aland I love, it was fascinating to revisit that country in this period, from Haifa, Akko, Jaffa, and Jerusalem itself.
The battle scenes are riveting, the action is nailbiting, lots of blood, gore and brutality as well as raw emotion.
Strongly erotic and raunchy sex. Alan has a Jewess and later a Muslim Lebanese rescued slave among his love interests,
Again it must be stressed Robin dissapoints us many times through the eys of the narrator, the man is an enigma.
but he inspires total loyalty in his followers.
Captures the locations vividly as well as the sights, smells and sounds of the place and period.
August 17, 2017
Less of A Robin Hood story then a crusade story. In this installment Robin and Alan join ol' Lionheart to rescue the Holy Land from itself. As a crusader story this book excels. As a Robin Hood story it falls flat.
The worst thing about this series is the awful Robin Hood character. I have criticized the horrible Robin in my last review and he only gets worse from here. This is a feat because Robin barely makes an appearance.
Besides a terrible Robin Hood I enjoyed this book. Much of it is because of my enjoyment of most crusader novels. Also I enjoyed the portrayal of King Richard. In most historical novels Richard is portrayed as a selfish, psychotic homosexual. Though he may have been these things that Richard has worn thin with me. In this book Richard is a man's man and a lover of the arts. A nice departure.
These books are enjoyable but not if you are looking for a good Robin Hood story.
Recommended.
The worst thing about this series is the awful Robin Hood character. I have criticized the horrible Robin in my last review and he only gets worse from here. This is a feat because Robin barely makes an appearance.
Besides a terrible Robin Hood I enjoyed this book. Much of it is because of my enjoyment of most crusader novels. Also I enjoyed the portrayal of King Richard. In most historical novels Richard is portrayed as a selfish, psychotic homosexual. Though he may have been these things that Richard has worn thin with me. In this book Richard is a man's man and a lover of the arts. A nice departure.
These books are enjoyable but not if you are looking for a good Robin Hood story.
Recommended.
August 16, 2017
Excellent adventure as Alan Dale follows Robin Hood on the crusades to free Jerusalem. Lots of gory battles, revenge, love and loss and a rollicking pace. All great fun - even if Robin is a total bastard.
July 22, 2013
Robin Hood, Robin Hood
Riding through the glen.
Robin Hood, Robin Hood
With his band of men.
Feared by the bad, loved by the good.
Robin Hood, Robin Hood, Robin Hood.
(lyrics written by American composer Carl Sigman.)
Oh that catchy tune from the old Robin Hood TV show starring Richard Greene. That was the Robin Hood I grew up with. That is not the Robin Hood of this magnificent series by Angus Donald. In this, the second book, Holy Warrior, we find Robin and his merry men as part of King Richard's retinue on Crusade to free Jerusalem from the Saracens. This despite Robins total disdain for the Christian Church but as a man of honor he is bound to his word.
Once again the tale is told in the voice of Alan Dale, personal musician or trouvere to Robin as well as one of his most trusted advisers. Alan is an old man as he recounts his adventures with Robin. I really enjoy the way the author has Alan not only reminiscent but also has him paint his life as a respected Lord of a manor. This also affords Alan a chance to bare his soul about some of the horror he has witnessed or even helped commit.
The first part of the book revolves largely around Robin and Alan stuck in a siege by Christians against Jews in York. The climatic finish to this chapter is just one more grim reminder of the dangers of dogmatic religious hatred. The author does not shy away from the portrayal of the brutality and malice born of the fear and ignorance of the peasantry and also of the greedy, glory seeking nobility and church. Twas indeed a brutal time to be on the wrong side of bias.
Assassins, intrigues, you name it, the author has it going full blazes throughout the story. The characters of Robin and Alan reveal more and more of their true selves during the course of this second installment. It will be of great interest and pleasure to discover how these two survive not only the perils of the age but also the perils of their differences.
Riding through the glen.
Robin Hood, Robin Hood
With his band of men.
Feared by the bad, loved by the good.
Robin Hood, Robin Hood, Robin Hood.
(lyrics written by American composer Carl Sigman.)
Oh that catchy tune from the old Robin Hood TV show starring Richard Greene. That was the Robin Hood I grew up with. That is not the Robin Hood of this magnificent series by Angus Donald. In this, the second book, Holy Warrior, we find Robin and his merry men as part of King Richard's retinue on Crusade to free Jerusalem from the Saracens. This despite Robins total disdain for the Christian Church but as a man of honor he is bound to his word.
Once again the tale is told in the voice of Alan Dale, personal musician or trouvere to Robin as well as one of his most trusted advisers. Alan is an old man as he recounts his adventures with Robin. I really enjoy the way the author has Alan not only reminiscent but also has him paint his life as a respected Lord of a manor. This also affords Alan a chance to bare his soul about some of the horror he has witnessed or even helped commit.
The first part of the book revolves largely around Robin and Alan stuck in a siege by Christians against Jews in York. The climatic finish to this chapter is just one more grim reminder of the dangers of dogmatic religious hatred. The author does not shy away from the portrayal of the brutality and malice born of the fear and ignorance of the peasantry and also of the greedy, glory seeking nobility and church. Twas indeed a brutal time to be on the wrong side of bias.
Assassins, intrigues, you name it, the author has it going full blazes throughout the story. The characters of Robin and Alan reveal more and more of their true selves during the course of this second installment. It will be of great interest and pleasure to discover how these two survive not only the perils of the age but also the perils of their differences.
January 15, 2026
3 @ 1/2 stars…
This book was good, but not as good as the first in the series, Outlaw. Mr. Donald is a good author who tells engaging stories, but this one fell a little flat compared to the first book. When the mood strikes, I'll move on in the series, as it won't be a waste of time, as these are well written, but I feel no urgency to do so any time soon.
This book was good, but not as good as the first in the series, Outlaw. Mr. Donald is a good author who tells engaging stories, but this one fell a little flat compared to the first book. When the mood strikes, I'll move on in the series, as it won't be a waste of time, as these are well written, but I feel no urgency to do so any time soon.
January 3, 2026
Būdams ienaidnieku ielenkts un pie nāves un sakāves bezdibeņa, Robins dod savu vārdu par atlīdzību par palīdzību no Templiešu bruņinieku vienības, tas apņemas pievienoties karaļa Ričarda armijas vienībām, kad tas dosies atbrīvot Svēto zemi no neticīgajaiem sarāceņiem. Un ja vārds dots, tad, kā vīram un vēl jo vairāk kā karaļa amnestiju nopelnījušam grāfam/Earl of Locksley, tas ir jātur, lai cik maz pašam visa veida reliģiskās paražas, svēto kārtā esošo un cita veida goda lietu aizstāvēšana nu jau ne vairs Robinam Hudam, bet Robinam tas nešķistu.
https://poseidons99.com/2026/01/03/an...
https://poseidons99.com/2026/01/03/an...
January 16, 2023
Holy Warrior is the second instalment of "The Outlaw Chronicles"
I rated this 4 stars, as with book 1, but on my broken down scoring system this book was bang on 4 and an increase from 3.8 in the previous outing
The best aspect of this book is the MC, Alan is really coming into his own and is no longer a man being led by a "hero" but a man with his own views, morals and emotions. I enjoy the complexity he has with Robin and the way the story makes Alan assess his own beliefs on what is right and wrong.
Enjoying the series
I rated this 4 stars, as with book 1, but on my broken down scoring system this book was bang on 4 and an increase from 3.8 in the previous outing
The best aspect of this book is the MC, Alan is really coming into his own and is no longer a man being led by a "hero" but a man with his own views, morals and emotions. I enjoy the complexity he has with Robin and the way the story makes Alan assess his own beliefs on what is right and wrong.
Enjoying the series
October 7, 2013
Aproximación interesante al mito, en la que el legendario Robin Hood no sólo tiene más de humano que de leyenda, sino que se nos revela como un personaje completamente terrenal y a menudo falto de escrúpulos. La narración desde el punto de vista de uno de sus hombres hace que el propio Robin no sea por completo protagonista de la saga, pero Allan es lo suficientemente interesante por sí mismo como personaje como para que el lector no se resienta de este hecho.
En esta segunda entrega, como el propio título indica, el autor centra la historia en el marco de las Cruzadas, no siendo la trama particularmente innovadora desde tal punto de vista. No obstante, el argumento hilvana con acierto las pequeñas historias con la gran Historia, y no faltan intrigas y venganzas a vida o muerte que hacen la lectura más amena.
En general, novela histórica en la media. No especialmente memorable pero que se deja leer sin mayor problema. Algún día caerá la tercera parte, pero la verdad es que no me urge... de ahí el tres del término medio :)
En esta segunda entrega, como el propio título indica, el autor centra la historia en el marco de las Cruzadas, no siendo la trama particularmente innovadora desde tal punto de vista. No obstante, el argumento hilvana con acierto las pequeñas historias con la gran Historia, y no faltan intrigas y venganzas a vida o muerte que hacen la lectura más amena.
En general, novela histórica en la media. No especialmente memorable pero que se deja leer sin mayor problema. Algún día caerá la tercera parte, pero la verdad es que no me urge... de ahí el tres del término medio :)
December 10, 2013
Holy Warrior continues the gritty re-telling of Robin Hood's life and adventures - all the way to the Holy Land and the Third Crusade.
This is most definitely not Walt Disney's version of Robin Hood. Robin is a cruel, selfish man who fosters a populist image because it suits his purposes. He couldn't give a damn about the people. "... the monstrous Earl of Locksley." Enough said. And here's the thing: I like this Robin and this story. It is dirty, gritty and messy. Much like I imagine the 12th century was.
This is most definitely not Walt Disney's version of Robin Hood. Robin is a cruel, selfish man who fosters a populist image because it suits his purposes. He couldn't give a damn about the people. "... the monstrous Earl of Locksley." Enough said. And here's the thing: I like this Robin and this story. It is dirty, gritty and messy. Much like I imagine the 12th century was.
January 10, 2018
Actual rating: 4,25
August 19, 2018
Finally working my way through this series courtesy of Audible. I thoroughly enjoyed Outlaw, the first in the series, and was intrigued to see where this one would go. The idea of taking Robin to the Holy land is genius, and really helps differentiate this book from the first.
Through our narrator, Alan Dale, we follow Robin, now an Earl, through France and Sicily to Acre, where they begin their long march south to Jerusalem.
The story is packed with plot. From a siege in York as fanatic Christians try to oust the Jews from their city, to assassination attempts on Robin, to the story of the great crusade itself, each chapter is packed with action, driving the plot forward. There is never a 'slow' moment, a chapter where the book breathes and allows the characters to catch up. I found it engrossing, and was disappointed every time I had to get out of my car and turn it off! Looking forward to number three.
Through our narrator, Alan Dale, we follow Robin, now an Earl, through France and Sicily to Acre, where they begin their long march south to Jerusalem.
The story is packed with plot. From a siege in York as fanatic Christians try to oust the Jews from their city, to assassination attempts on Robin, to the story of the great crusade itself, each chapter is packed with action, driving the plot forward. There is never a 'slow' moment, a chapter where the book breathes and allows the characters to catch up. I found it engrossing, and was disappointed every time I had to get out of my car and turn it off! Looking forward to number three.
August 5, 2021
Second in the series, interesting take on Robin Hood & the Crusades.
February 18, 2023
Another excellent instalment (#2) in the author’s Outlaw series.
Each of the books in this series can stand alone in its plot and character development, the series needn’t be read in any particular order to thoroughly enjoy it.
Each of the books in this series can stand alone in its plot and character development, the series needn’t be read in any particular order to thoroughly enjoy it.
August 18, 2012
A powerful, provocative and thought-provoking read, this is the second installment in Angus Donald's re-interpretation of the Robin Hood myth.
Even though you are prepared for this not being your usual Robin Hood story, Angus Donald still keeps you gripped and surprises you at nearly every turn. Mainly, I'd say, because like the first in the series, 'Outlaw', whilst of course headlined as a Robin Hood story, it was in reality more about the tale of Alan Dale, than of Robin Hood.
'Holy Warrior' is the same and more so.
Angus Donald's Robin Hood is a dark and fairly mysterious presence, often in the background of the story. When taking the lead, he is an interesting enigma; a pragmatic, powerful figure, an idealist, but also a realist. Happily for me though, he is still the pagan Robin from 'Outlaw'. He hasn't a lot of time or patience for Alan's 'new' Christian preaching, preferring I thought, to steer his own course through his own beliefs and ideals. Here, he seems to be what I hope I interpret correctly; a coalescence of the pagan history, legends and folk heroes of old Britain (older than 'England'), an honourable man, of and for the people.
It's a harsh book in some ways. The first one I thought, was necessarily harsh in its description of Robin Hood and his earthy, matter-of-fact paganism. Some incidents which, for me, were integral in both separating this Robin Hood from the one we think we knew (thanks to tradition, Hollywood and the Nottingham tourist people) and emphasising the fact that the Robin Hood legend has developed out of a strong, much more ancient British pagan tradition - encompassing, amongst other traditions, the Green Man - was not to everyone's taste. And those who found a certain 'sex' scene too much in book one, will certainly find plenty to enjoy being shocked about here. Better stay indoors with your Mills & Boon 'histories' the rest of your life then, because this is how it was. Not always as nice as Errol Flynn would have you believe.
But, as I've said before, this is really the story of - and of course, by - Alan Dale. Alan worships the ground Robin walks on, especially you could say - as Alan is a good God-fearing Christian - when they reach The Holy Land. But, as Robin confuses, insults, disappoints and angers Alan on a regular basis, the hero worship is often also against Alan's better judgement. He cannot leave him, though he sometimes wishes he could.
We learn more about Robin and what he believes in, partly because he is taken away from his comfort zone of England and Sherwood. The story roams through the Mediterranean, from the Norman stronghold of Scicily, to Cyprus and on to The Holy Land with The Third Crusade. Robin and his band of men are at the beck and call of King Richard, in repayment of a debt and clearly against his better judgement. But who is using who? It seems that Robin has his own agenda to follow out in The Holy Land. And it is, shall we say, more about pennies, than pennitence.
There is no way Robin is the title's 'Holy Warrior'. Maybe Richard is and Alan would probably like to think he is.
Whilst the next book in the series is called 'The King's Man', I would say that title actually was more relevant here, as a reference to Alan's relation to Robin. Robin is the 'king' of Alan's world and Alan is, though he might frequently say he wishes it wasn't so, is always going to be his man.
Looking forward to the next one. Ooh! I just downloaded it!
Even though you are prepared for this not being your usual Robin Hood story, Angus Donald still keeps you gripped and surprises you at nearly every turn. Mainly, I'd say, because like the first in the series, 'Outlaw', whilst of course headlined as a Robin Hood story, it was in reality more about the tale of Alan Dale, than of Robin Hood.
'Holy Warrior' is the same and more so.
Angus Donald's Robin Hood is a dark and fairly mysterious presence, often in the background of the story. When taking the lead, he is an interesting enigma; a pragmatic, powerful figure, an idealist, but also a realist. Happily for me though, he is still the pagan Robin from 'Outlaw'. He hasn't a lot of time or patience for Alan's 'new' Christian preaching, preferring I thought, to steer his own course through his own beliefs and ideals. Here, he seems to be what I hope I interpret correctly; a coalescence of the pagan history, legends and folk heroes of old Britain (older than 'England'), an honourable man, of and for the people.
It's a harsh book in some ways. The first one I thought, was necessarily harsh in its description of Robin Hood and his earthy, matter-of-fact paganism. Some incidents which, for me, were integral in both separating this Robin Hood from the one we think we knew (thanks to tradition, Hollywood and the Nottingham tourist people) and emphasising the fact that the Robin Hood legend has developed out of a strong, much more ancient British pagan tradition - encompassing, amongst other traditions, the Green Man - was not to everyone's taste. And those who found a certain 'sex' scene too much in book one, will certainly find plenty to enjoy being shocked about here. Better stay indoors with your Mills & Boon 'histories' the rest of your life then, because this is how it was. Not always as nice as Errol Flynn would have you believe.
But, as I've said before, this is really the story of - and of course, by - Alan Dale. Alan worships the ground Robin walks on, especially you could say - as Alan is a good God-fearing Christian - when they reach The Holy Land. But, as Robin confuses, insults, disappoints and angers Alan on a regular basis, the hero worship is often also against Alan's better judgement. He cannot leave him, though he sometimes wishes he could.
We learn more about Robin and what he believes in, partly because he is taken away from his comfort zone of England and Sherwood. The story roams through the Mediterranean, from the Norman stronghold of Scicily, to Cyprus and on to The Holy Land with The Third Crusade. Robin and his band of men are at the beck and call of King Richard, in repayment of a debt and clearly against his better judgement. But who is using who? It seems that Robin has his own agenda to follow out in The Holy Land. And it is, shall we say, more about pennies, than pennitence.
There is no way Robin is the title's 'Holy Warrior'. Maybe Richard is and Alan would probably like to think he is.
Whilst the next book in the series is called 'The King's Man', I would say that title actually was more relevant here, as a reference to Alan's relation to Robin. Robin is the 'king' of Alan's world and Alan is, though he might frequently say he wishes it wasn't so, is always going to be his man.
Looking forward to the next one. Ooh! I just downloaded it!
March 28, 2013
Donald's follow up to OUTLAW is not as good, but still entertaining if you're into medieval history and care enough about the Crusades to slough through endless scenes of violence and mayhem. Unlike OUTLAW, HOLY WARRIOR does little to offset the blood and carnage, with scant character development and more time placed on history or detailed battle recounts than the characters themselves. As a result, there is virtually no tension in the book, or drive to keep reading. The central mystery of who might be trying to kill Robin Hood is undercut by the question of "Who cares?" as Donald makes him such an unattractive, uncomplicated figure that we're not really invested in if he lives or dies. Similarly, Alan is rather hard to like or relate to, and since we know he makes it out okay (he is telling the story after all), there's really not much reason to keep reading aside from the pageantry and historical detail that seems to be Donald's ultimate strength. By all means, not an unreadable book, but a bit of a shrug when all is said and done. I'll still probably read the next one all the same.
July 19, 2014
https://30dediferencia.wordpress.com/...
Siguen las aventuras de Robin Hood, ahora de camino a Jerusalén para intentar recuperar esta ciudad en manos de Saladino. Entretenido, fácil de leer, pero a la vez una historia un tanto simplona y plana. Si decía que al primero de la trilogía le faltaba algo aquí vuelve a haber más de lo mismo. No es una historia redonda, supongo que esperaba más épica, más batalla, pero no, no lo hay, de hecho lo que más me gustó de este libro es todo lo que cuentan a Alan Dale, el narrador porque él, herido, no lo ha vivido al estar convaleciente. Como en el anterior posiblemente lo mejor de la historia está en mostrarnos a un Robin Hood alejado de la idílica idea que tenemos de él. Aquí volvemos a verle como un personaje sin escrúpulos, malvado y movido únicamente por sus propios intereses, lo que probablemente se acerca más a la realidad de la época que las historias que nos han llegado y que conocemos a través del cine.
Sólo recomendable para los muy fan de la historia.
Siguen las aventuras de Robin Hood, ahora de camino a Jerusalén para intentar recuperar esta ciudad en manos de Saladino. Entretenido, fácil de leer, pero a la vez una historia un tanto simplona y plana. Si decía que al primero de la trilogía le faltaba algo aquí vuelve a haber más de lo mismo. No es una historia redonda, supongo que esperaba más épica, más batalla, pero no, no lo hay, de hecho lo que más me gustó de este libro es todo lo que cuentan a Alan Dale, el narrador porque él, herido, no lo ha vivido al estar convaleciente. Como en el anterior posiblemente lo mejor de la historia está en mostrarnos a un Robin Hood alejado de la idílica idea que tenemos de él. Aquí volvemos a verle como un personaje sin escrúpulos, malvado y movido únicamente por sus propios intereses, lo que probablemente se acerca más a la realidad de la época que las historias que nos han llegado y que conocemos a través del cine.
Sólo recomendable para los muy fan de la historia.
May 17, 2017
My favourite of Angus Donald's 'Outlaw Chronicle' series, I literally couldn't put it down. It had me gripped from the first page, and it was great to see Robin, Alan and co taken out of Nottingham and placed within the Holy Land, at the height of the Third Crusade.
In regards to the historical backdrop, Donald has the ability to transport the reader into the violent, unpredictable 12th century and the language is, at times, mind-blowing. It really feels like you are there, fighting beside Alan and Robin, experiencing their pain, anguish and joy. And that can also be said for the entire series.
A page turner, likeable characters, this book has everything from violence to romance and for fans of Bernard Cornwell the whole series is a must-read.
In regards to the historical backdrop, Donald has the ability to transport the reader into the violent, unpredictable 12th century and the language is, at times, mind-blowing. It really feels like you are there, fighting beside Alan and Robin, experiencing their pain, anguish and joy. And that can also be said for the entire series.
A page turner, likeable characters, this book has everything from violence to romance and for fans of Bernard Cornwell the whole series is a must-read.
November 12, 2013
Outlaw series finally delivers! It presents quite a refreshing angle on events described in Lionheart. It introduces many interesting details from the lives of different classes and ethnicities, throughout England, France, Sicily, and Holy Land. It is a bit funny if I think about it - in the first book I had a feeling that watching movies about Robin Hood presented me with lots of spoilers. In this book, the situation was a bit similar because of my reading of Lionheart. Yet, it did not bother me much in this book. This series definitely shows quite a bit of promise.
November 10, 2021
The second book in the series and it did not dispappoint. I am a fan of Robin Hood and this series is great. I must say, this series is not for the faint of heart. There is gore and sexual situations. If you are sensitive to such things I would not revommend it. if not, you should read these. The story telling is amazing and it is so exciting and full of adventure! If you are looking for an action packed adventure, you should give this series a try.
September 3, 2017
As quickly as I read the first one, I struggled with this one. The plot felt like mostly filler, even though there were certain narratives I would have liked to see developed more. Unsure if I will try the rest in the series.
June 1, 2018
Robin sinks to delicious new lows in this instalment. I enjoy characters with gall, and this guy has it by the spade. It was great seeing more of King Richard too, and I adored the strange friendship between him and Alan.
I love this series.
I love this series.
March 4, 2017
Yippee for a wonderful book 2! Blood, guts, a great human non-perfect main character, & of course Robin Hood = my kinda book! :D Top marks to Mr. Angus Donald for such awesome storytelling, graphic violence, interesting characters both "good" and "bad", & historical accuracy. Some writers just can't pull it off, but he sure did.
I actually wrote an essay about King Richard the Lionheart and his leadership of the 3rd for my final research paper is high school. I loved the topic and I did a ton of research, so I knew exactly what was going on through out the book, how the battles would go . . . what was going to happen to those poor Muslim prisoners in Acre. :( It was fun (in a dark depressing sort of way, if that makes sense) to read such a good fictionalized version of the events.
King Richard was spot on. :D which is great for the historical fiction part of the story, but not so much if you're one of those fans who loves the happy go lucky kings that always show up at the end of the robin hood story and pardon him as a thank you for saving all his poor peasants from the nasty Prince John. if you are , my dear review reader, a die hard Hoodie like me, you know the exact type of fictional King Richard I'm talking about. :D
Personally, I prefer History's blood thirsty, sociopathic King to today's romanticized one. it's more realistic. One doesn't get to be such a great and powerful and warrior king by going around and pardoning robbers for taking his taxes. (even if it does make a nice story.) The Lionheart of the history books and of "Holy Warrior" was a blood thirsty maniac looking for his shot at fame and glory. To be written into the world's memory as the great king who freed Jerusalem from the heathens. (I don't think his "great pilgrimage" was ever really about Christianity. despite whatever tales he spun for his followers; it was about power.)
He never actually gets what he wanted but, in the end of the war, he does come pretty damn close.
he loved war. and he was nuts. but he was one of those charismatic, inspirational sort of nuts that people love to follow. he's actually one of England's most beloved - and famous - kings. which is probably why he's been romanticized and "niced up" so much in modern culture. Pus he was a great general; he won of A LOT of battles.
And like I said before, he was a sociopath. that part about slaughtering 2700 people, including women and children, that's real, dude. as fucked up and horrible as it sounds it's real. go look it up. he even had his men disembowel them to check and see if they'd swallowed any gold. talk about sick and twisted, huh? but that's medieval warfare for you.
As I mentioned in my review of "Outlaw" the first book of the series, I love the author's writing style. it's so beautiful and descriptive. :) Angus Donald's your guy if you want well-written battles. bring on the gore! And guts! and blood! Lots of blood. it's like the lord of the rings battles. on steroids. times twenty. >:D
So! Onwards! besides the battles and an awesomely violent King, what else did I like? I loved the dog! XD so cute. & The plot of course. This is the first Robin Hood novel I've read that takes place during the crusade. where Robin joins it AFTER he's pardoned. Most modern stories like to depict him returning from the Holy war and coming back to Prince John's England. And there was the part about York. Well, I can't say that I actually LIKE that part. In fact, the whole mob mentality of the Christians getting all crazy and killy, and think that it's all okay because "God will's it". . . .oh, it pissed me off. But, despite the brutality of it, it was an interesting situation to up Alan and Robin in.
I also loved the "who dun it" part about the traitor among Robin's men. I spent the whole book trying to guess who it between two people. it was fun, and I was guessing most the book. which is really good for Mr. Donald, cause honestly, he's not very good with foreshadowing. and my guesses proved right. one did, anyway. but not the reasoning behind why they all that they did. that was a suprise they had a pretty good reason though. but still. even with that good reason and my usual understanding and compassion for bad guys, I couldn't feel the least bit sorry for this one.
This book is EPIC! and I totally recommend the series to EVERYONE!
But, sadly, there are just a couple little things that annoyed me.
Mainly, the horrific behavior of the Christians. I know, I know, as a historical novel there's no way to get around the behavior, but it's still annoy! I mean, these guys march around preaching about the righteousness of Christendom, how their belief is the only True Faith, and how basically everyone who doesn't believe exactly what they believe is a disgusting uncivilized dog. (this coming from people who think it's okay to throw shit right out their windows and ruin the water supply.) It's just so hard to comprehend. God is love and mercy and kindness. Jesus loved everyone. he hung out with a prostitute. and tax collectors. and on the cross he begged God to forgive the people torturing him because "They know not what they do." One of the freakin' ten commandments is "thou shalt not kill." . . . . .and yet the church whipped up all theses hundreds of thousands of people from all across Europe and convinced them to travel half way across the world to slaughter people because "God wills it."
No. just not. this is Christianity's worst moment in history. I don't care what the pope and priests told them. it is NOT god's will for you to go freaking MURDER people because you want control over a hole in the ground which may or may not be where Jesus was buried. Come on, let's face it people, it's been over a thousand years since he was buried. can we REALLY be sure that that cave is where they left his body? :/ God said to love, remember? to be kind and caring. slaughtering people is NOT the way to convert them.
human stupidity really, really amazes me sometimes.
Speaking of human stupidity! this brings me to my 2nd biggest issue with the story. (thankfully it wasn't enough to take away from my enjoyment of the story. or bring down my rating.) . . . .Alan.
Don't get me wrong. I absolute adore Alan. he's funny, talented, a great fighter - a prodigy almost, he's human. you know, not a Mary sue/Marty stew main character who can do no wrong. And I use to think he was pretty smart, but now. . . . . .
I'm not so sure. :/
So, Our gloriously violent Earl of Locksley, Robin Hood does something pretty damned awful about 3/4 of the way through the book. Oh, god, what a surprise! . . . .:/ :/ :/ :/ NOT after 1.75 books of sociopathic behavior, I have come to expect this exact sort of behavior from the "godfather" of Sherwood. The Robin Hood of "the outlaw chronicles" is a really logical guy. he's cold and calculating and self-interested and dangerous. everything he does he does for reason. and in his twisted view of the world it's always a good reason. he wants what he wants. and he'll get it by the fastest and most brutal way necessary. the ends justifies the means. The part about York showed us that. it was written quite clearly. and in blood. Woe to anyone who stands in his way. even old allies. (and some how, among all this barbarity there is still room for him to be likable, charming, & charismatic.)
I know this. little john knows it. Mary Anne knows it. Hell, even Friar Tuck knows it! he knows that robin is a murderer and a heretic. and he STILL likes him, and respects him. and has enough damned sense to understand what Robin is Capable of.
But young Alan, who's been under his wing for YEARS now -years- is horrified by what Robin orders out there in the desert? After human sacrifices, cutting all but one limb off a man, murdering and sodomizing a priest with a crucifix, the battle in York, allowing his own brother to be murdered by his best friend . . . . .and Alan is STILL Horrified by this?
THIS one little scene is what sets Alan off? THIS is what makes the boy question his loyalty?
seriously? THAT? I get that it was wrong and awful, pointless and cruel, and all that jazz. but seriously Alan, after all the stuff you've seen, you've silently watched & not stopped, you shouldn't have been that worked up over THIS! Robin's done plenty of other stuff that, in my opinion, is a hell of a lot worse than this. why didn't you get this pissy over the other stuff? because cause you were sick at this point, and the fucking fever caused you to loose your cool.
>:( yeah, Alan Dale of Westbury has a lot of fucking room to try and preach to somebody about honor and right & wrong. that self-righteous little speech coming from a thieving little gutter rat outlaw? Towards the man who gave you EVERY-FUCKING-THING you have today? (I don't totally agree with either one during this little feud. but I do understand both. and as bad as it must seem, I honestly was leaning a little more towards Robin's side.:( he had a good point & a good, twisted, reasoning for his awful, deplorable actions)
yep. he picked a great time to get all high and might after everything you've helped this man do. because you are SOOOOO perfect. (what about how awfully he treated poor Nur? HUH? after what happened to her? where was the honor n goodness then?!?!?) he needs to take a good long look at himself first, because he's at fault to for going along with all the bad stuff for so long and not saying ANYTHING until he's half mad with a fever.
Alan: you knew all along that you were dealing with a sociopath. it's time to grow up and accept that Robin Hood does not think like you do! He's mentally fucked up! He doesn't understand right and wrong like you do! the man doesn't even see grey zones of right and wrong. it's just the whole you're with Robin or Against Robin. one try and you're done. Get that through your thick skull!
P.S. I hope this review wasn't to confusing or to ranting. and that I didn't give anything really important away. I try! but I was pretty tried when I wrote this, so my ending part about Alan might not make a lot of sense. But it's true don't you think? like my review or comment me if you agree with or liked my ranting and raving review! I get very few likes and comments and stuff and I'd love to hear from my Goodreads friends. :)
now, onward to my next good read. :) lol at myself.
I actually wrote an essay about King Richard the Lionheart and his leadership of the 3rd for my final research paper is high school. I loved the topic and I did a ton of research, so I knew exactly what was going on through out the book, how the battles would go . . . what was going to happen to those poor Muslim prisoners in Acre. :( It was fun (in a dark depressing sort of way, if that makes sense) to read such a good fictionalized version of the events.
King Richard was spot on. :D which is great for the historical fiction part of the story, but not so much if you're one of those fans who loves the happy go lucky kings that always show up at the end of the robin hood story and pardon him as a thank you for saving all his poor peasants from the nasty Prince John. if you are , my dear review reader, a die hard Hoodie like me, you know the exact type of fictional King Richard I'm talking about. :D
Personally, I prefer History's blood thirsty, sociopathic King to today's romanticized one. it's more realistic. One doesn't get to be such a great and powerful and warrior king by going around and pardoning robbers for taking his taxes. (even if it does make a nice story.) The Lionheart of the history books and of "Holy Warrior" was a blood thirsty maniac looking for his shot at fame and glory. To be written into the world's memory as the great king who freed Jerusalem from the heathens. (I don't think his "great pilgrimage" was ever really about Christianity. despite whatever tales he spun for his followers; it was about power.)
He never actually gets what he wanted but, in the end of the war, he does come pretty damn close.
he loved war. and he was nuts. but he was one of those charismatic, inspirational sort of nuts that people love to follow. he's actually one of England's most beloved - and famous - kings. which is probably why he's been romanticized and "niced up" so much in modern culture. Pus he was a great general; he won of A LOT of battles.
And like I said before, he was a sociopath. that part about slaughtering 2700 people, including women and children, that's real, dude. as fucked up and horrible as it sounds it's real. go look it up. he even had his men disembowel them to check and see if they'd swallowed any gold. talk about sick and twisted, huh? but that's medieval warfare for you.
As I mentioned in my review of "Outlaw" the first book of the series, I love the author's writing style. it's so beautiful and descriptive. :) Angus Donald's your guy if you want well-written battles. bring on the gore! And guts! and blood! Lots of blood. it's like the lord of the rings battles. on steroids. times twenty. >:D
So! Onwards! besides the battles and an awesomely violent King, what else did I like? I loved the dog! XD so cute. & The plot of course. This is the first Robin Hood novel I've read that takes place during the crusade. where Robin joins it AFTER he's pardoned. Most modern stories like to depict him returning from the Holy war and coming back to Prince John's England. And there was the part about York. Well, I can't say that I actually LIKE that part. In fact, the whole mob mentality of the Christians getting all crazy and killy, and think that it's all okay because "God will's it". . . .oh, it pissed me off. But, despite the brutality of it, it was an interesting situation to up Alan and Robin in.
I also loved the "who dun it" part about the traitor among Robin's men. I spent the whole book trying to guess who it between two people. it was fun, and I was guessing most the book. which is really good for Mr. Donald, cause honestly, he's not very good with foreshadowing. and my guesses proved right. one did, anyway. but not the reasoning behind why they all that they did. that was a suprise they had a pretty good reason though. but still. even with that good reason and my usual understanding and compassion for bad guys, I couldn't feel the least bit sorry for this one.
This book is EPIC! and I totally recommend the series to EVERYONE!
But, sadly, there are just a couple little things that annoyed me.
Mainly, the horrific behavior of the Christians. I know, I know, as a historical novel there's no way to get around the behavior, but it's still annoy! I mean, these guys march around preaching about the righteousness of Christendom, how their belief is the only True Faith, and how basically everyone who doesn't believe exactly what they believe is a disgusting uncivilized dog. (this coming from people who think it's okay to throw shit right out their windows and ruin the water supply.) It's just so hard to comprehend. God is love and mercy and kindness. Jesus loved everyone. he hung out with a prostitute. and tax collectors. and on the cross he begged God to forgive the people torturing him because "They know not what they do." One of the freakin' ten commandments is "thou shalt not kill." . . . . .and yet the church whipped up all theses hundreds of thousands of people from all across Europe and convinced them to travel half way across the world to slaughter people because "God wills it."
No. just not. this is Christianity's worst moment in history. I don't care what the pope and priests told them. it is NOT god's will for you to go freaking MURDER people because you want control over a hole in the ground which may or may not be where Jesus was buried. Come on, let's face it people, it's been over a thousand years since he was buried. can we REALLY be sure that that cave is where they left his body? :/ God said to love, remember? to be kind and caring. slaughtering people is NOT the way to convert them.
human stupidity really, really amazes me sometimes.
Speaking of human stupidity! this brings me to my 2nd biggest issue with the story. (thankfully it wasn't enough to take away from my enjoyment of the story. or bring down my rating.) . . . .Alan.
Don't get me wrong. I absolute adore Alan. he's funny, talented, a great fighter - a prodigy almost, he's human. you know, not a Mary sue/Marty stew main character who can do no wrong. And I use to think he was pretty smart, but now. . . . . .
I'm not so sure. :/
So, Our gloriously violent Earl of Locksley, Robin Hood does something pretty damned awful about 3/4 of the way through the book. Oh, god, what a surprise! . . . .:/ :/ :/ :/ NOT after 1.75 books of sociopathic behavior, I have come to expect this exact sort of behavior from the "godfather" of Sherwood. The Robin Hood of "the outlaw chronicles" is a really logical guy. he's cold and calculating and self-interested and dangerous. everything he does he does for reason. and in his twisted view of the world it's always a good reason. he wants what he wants. and he'll get it by the fastest and most brutal way necessary. the ends justifies the means. The part about York showed us that. it was written quite clearly. and in blood. Woe to anyone who stands in his way. even old allies. (and some how, among all this barbarity there is still room for him to be likable, charming, & charismatic.)
I know this. little john knows it. Mary Anne knows it. Hell, even Friar Tuck knows it! he knows that robin is a murderer and a heretic. and he STILL likes him, and respects him. and has enough damned sense to understand what Robin is Capable of.
But young Alan, who's been under his wing for YEARS now -years- is horrified by what Robin orders out there in the desert? After human sacrifices, cutting all but one limb off a man, murdering and sodomizing a priest with a crucifix, the battle in York, allowing his own brother to be murdered by his best friend . . . . .and Alan is STILL Horrified by this?
THIS one little scene is what sets Alan off? THIS is what makes the boy question his loyalty?
seriously? THAT? I get that it was wrong and awful, pointless and cruel, and all that jazz. but seriously Alan, after all the stuff you've seen, you've silently watched & not stopped, you shouldn't have been that worked up over THIS! Robin's done plenty of other stuff that, in my opinion, is a hell of a lot worse than this. why didn't you get this pissy over the other stuff? because cause you were sick at this point, and the fucking fever caused you to loose your cool.
>:( yeah, Alan Dale of Westbury has a lot of fucking room to try and preach to somebody about honor and right & wrong. that self-righteous little speech coming from a thieving little gutter rat outlaw? Towards the man who gave you EVERY-FUCKING-THING you have today? (I don't totally agree with either one during this little feud. but I do understand both. and as bad as it must seem, I honestly was leaning a little more towards Robin's side.:( he had a good point & a good, twisted, reasoning for his awful, deplorable actions)
yep. he picked a great time to get all high and might after everything you've helped this man do. because you are SOOOOO perfect. (what about how awfully he treated poor Nur? HUH? after what happened to her? where was the honor n goodness then?!?!?) he needs to take a good long look at himself first, because he's at fault to for going along with all the bad stuff for so long and not saying ANYTHING until he's half mad with a fever.
Alan: you knew all along that you were dealing with a sociopath. it's time to grow up and accept that Robin Hood does not think like you do! He's mentally fucked up! He doesn't understand right and wrong like you do! the man doesn't even see grey zones of right and wrong. it's just the whole you're with Robin or Against Robin. one try and you're done. Get that through your thick skull!
P.S. I hope this review wasn't to confusing or to ranting. and that I didn't give anything really important away. I try! but I was pretty tried when I wrote this, so my ending part about Alan might not make a lot of sense. But it's true don't you think? like my review or comment me if you agree with or liked my ranting and raving review! I get very few likes and comments and stuff and I'd love to hear from my Goodreads friends. :)
now, onward to my next good read. :) lol at myself.
April 23, 2018
I really enjoyed this book.
This book takes Robin and his band of loyal men to the Crusades. At the end of Outlaw, Robin is pardoned and made Earl of Locksley. As part of the deal he made for assistance in the battle of Linden Lea he agrees to join King Richard on the crusades to Jerusalem.
The book was well written and kept my attention and the story flowed well. There were various things going on including an assassin amongst Robin's men who kept trying to kill him as well as the crusades. Throughout the book there was the odd skirmishes leading to the last 100 pages for the Battle of Arsuf.
Again, the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars was the same as book 1 and is what I see as a kind of flaw in how the author has decided to approach the series.
They are advertised as being "Robin Hood" books which essentially they are. I am guessing to be different he has done them from Alan Dale's point of view, but for me it causes a couple of problems. Firstly, it is being narrated by Alan as an old man from his manor at Westbury, so I've actually found I have gotten a bit apathetic towards him - he goes on about being in mortal danger - but I can't worry about him - because you know he is going to be okay - because he is the narrator - kind of a flaw really!
Also, because it is done from Alan's first person perspective, I again found that for me there was not enough Robin because unless Alan was with Robin you don't know what happens. Sometimes when Robin went off with the King and left Alan behind it was really irritating! I actually really didn't give a toss what Alan got up to -I wanted to know what was going on with Robin!
Also, I hate to say it but Alan also got a little sanctimonious for his own good in this particular book. He kept moaning about Robin and how he was evil and would kill anyone to further his own means - but Alan himself was thief, a cut-purse and a killer himself and really had no right to be so judgemental and should take a good look in the mirror!
Overall though I did love this book and am happily going to keep on with series and carry on the story of Robin and his men. Highly enjoyable.
This book takes Robin and his band of loyal men to the Crusades. At the end of Outlaw, Robin is pardoned and made Earl of Locksley. As part of the deal he made for assistance in the battle of Linden Lea he agrees to join King Richard on the crusades to Jerusalem.
The book was well written and kept my attention and the story flowed well. There were various things going on including an assassin amongst Robin's men who kept trying to kill him as well as the crusades. Throughout the book there was the odd skirmishes leading to the last 100 pages for the Battle of Arsuf.
Again, the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars was the same as book 1 and is what I see as a kind of flaw in how the author has decided to approach the series.
They are advertised as being "Robin Hood" books which essentially they are. I am guessing to be different he has done them from Alan Dale's point of view, but for me it causes a couple of problems. Firstly, it is being narrated by Alan as an old man from his manor at Westbury, so I've actually found I have gotten a bit apathetic towards him - he goes on about being in mortal danger - but I can't worry about him - because you know he is going to be okay - because he is the narrator - kind of a flaw really!
Also, because it is done from Alan's first person perspective, I again found that for me there was not enough Robin because unless Alan was with Robin you don't know what happens. Sometimes when Robin went off with the King and left Alan behind it was really irritating! I actually really didn't give a toss what Alan got up to -I wanted to know what was going on with Robin!
Also, I hate to say it but Alan also got a little sanctimonious for his own good in this particular book. He kept moaning about Robin and how he was evil and would kill anyone to further his own means - but Alan himself was thief, a cut-purse and a killer himself and really had no right to be so judgemental and should take a good look in the mirror!
Overall though I did love this book and am happily going to keep on with series and carry on the story of Robin and his men. Highly enjoyable.
September 17, 2023
58 year old Alan Dale remembers his time with Robin Hood and his men, the Jewish massacre at York on 16th March, 1190, as Robin tries to get money to fund his participation in the THIRD CRUSADE, to try and get Jerusalem back from Saladin and his muslim men.
Robin has joined the Crusade in honour of a promise made late in the previous book. The details of how he, Alan, Little John and others including King Richard got to the Holy Lands and details of the battles they fought there are taken from what history we know of those times and events, so are as accurate as can be.
Sir Richard Malbete is the villain of this story, who is loosely based on a real person. Alan comes up against the butcher a number of times before their final battle. Robin himself is a villain of sorts and will kill any who stand in the way of his goals, which is why a mystery person wants to kill him. Tired of battle they leave Richard and his army to continue the fight, and head back to England.
Robin has joined the Crusade in honour of a promise made late in the previous book. The details of how he, Alan, Little John and others including King Richard got to the Holy Lands and details of the battles they fought there are taken from what history we know of those times and events, so are as accurate as can be.
Sir Richard Malbete is the villain of this story, who is loosely based on a real person. Alan comes up against the butcher a number of times before their final battle. Robin himself is a villain of sorts and will kill any who stand in the way of his goals, which is why a mystery person wants to kill him. Tired of battle they leave Richard and his army to continue the fight, and head back to England.
March 25, 2025
LO BUENO
-Es un libro de rápida lectura, es fácil y dinámico. Es entretenido.
-Robin Hood sigue siendo la mejor versión que he leído del personaje, oscuro, manipulador, más real a lo que debió haber sido el mito.
-Tiene una buena base histórica y el escenario de fondo se siente claro. Es la edad media no romantizada.
-Es un libro entretenido y simple para pasar el rato después de una lectura pesada.
LO MALO
-Los personajes secundarios son demasiado simples, no me generó empatía por lo que les pasa. Prácticamente son relleno que ayudan a la historia nada más. (mismo error que el libro primero).
-Los sucesos tristes o traumantes pasan de largo, no generan un cambio en el protagonista, se dice que sufre pero no se muestra, se cambia el capitulo y ya todo sigue igual. No veo una evolución, exceptuando al relación del protagonista para con Robin Hood, esa la única interacción donde se ve una evolución, aunque después llega al mismo punto.
-Es un libro de rápida lectura, es fácil y dinámico. Es entretenido.
-Robin Hood sigue siendo la mejor versión que he leído del personaje, oscuro, manipulador, más real a lo que debió haber sido el mito.
-Tiene una buena base histórica y el escenario de fondo se siente claro. Es la edad media no romantizada.
-Es un libro entretenido y simple para pasar el rato después de una lectura pesada.
LO MALO
-Los personajes secundarios son demasiado simples, no me generó empatía por lo que les pasa. Prácticamente son relleno que ayudan a la historia nada más. (mismo error que el libro primero).
-Los sucesos tristes o traumantes pasan de largo, no generan un cambio en el protagonista, se dice que sufre pero no se muestra, se cambia el capitulo y ya todo sigue igual. No veo una evolución, exceptuando al relación del protagonista para con Robin Hood, esa la única interacción donde se ve una evolución, aunque después llega al mismo punto.
May 9, 2017
Part II of the Outlaw series leads Robin and the gang off to fight in the Third Crusade with Richard the Lionhearted. Robin is not a willing participant, however, but he made a deal to go and will honor it. Alas, as sly Robin is keen to do, he captures an opportunity to make some money while double crossing the good Knights of the Temple. A guy's gotta make a buck right? Anyway, there is again plenty of war fighting, lots of treachery, dirty dealing, and general messed up shenanigans. It's entertaining though. If anyone is looking for any sort of happy ending...a spark of goodness...a glimmer of honor, there is little to be found here. I do think that this series more accurately depicts the dealings and motivations of most of the nobility (and the church) in the 1300s. Good story. I will come back to this series.
June 15, 2022
In this book, Robin, his men and the tale's narrator, Alan Dale are headed for the Holy Land as they join King Richard on the Third Crusade.
The tale is split between adventures in England, their journey to the Holy Land, and events when they arrive and head for Jerusalem.
As with the first book, the characters are all richly brought to life, some are lovable, some you will hate, while others will have you conflicted.
Again the action and events are portrayed in a realistic and brutal manner and the narrative pulls no punches.
Possible Mild Spoliers
The description of Nur when she last saw Alan has haunted me since I read it, which together with Sir Richard At Lea's last meeting with Robin are powerful emotional moments which just strike home.
An excellent continuation of the series which leaves you wanting more.
The tale is split between adventures in England, their journey to the Holy Land, and events when they arrive and head for Jerusalem.
As with the first book, the characters are all richly brought to life, some are lovable, some you will hate, while others will have you conflicted.
Again the action and events are portrayed in a realistic and brutal manner and the narrative pulls no punches.
Possible Mild Spoliers
The description of Nur when she last saw Alan has haunted me since I read it, which together with Sir Richard At Lea's last meeting with Robin are powerful emotional moments which just strike home.
An excellent continuation of the series which leaves you wanting more.
April 30, 2019
Can’t say I enjoyed this. Without the anchor of the legends of the “merry men” to pique my interest I found this story to be a dry, overly detailed chronicle of the march to and battles preceding the attempt to retake Jerusalem in the Third Crusade. Robin, Earl of Locksley, came across as a not very nice fellow and was hardly central to this chronicle. In fact there was more history and battle action than character development overall. Too much gore, far too much of battle tactics, privations, injuries, heat and dust. Just ick. I skimmed a lot and despite a final set-up for bk 3, I’ll likely not go there. (2019 tbr challenge: Feb-shelf 10)
July 2, 2017
I loved the first book in this series, Outlaw, but the follow up was disappointing. It's more a story about the crusades (and how hateful, horrid and violent they were all in the name of "my God is better than yours").
The one part the author does really well in my opinion, is his portrayal of Robin Hood himself and Alan's reaction to him. This part of the story rang true to how I can imagine it happening in reality. His characters are wonderful, but this book is INCREDIBLY violent. I'm looking forward to reading the next book in this series since it isn't about the crusades.
The one part the author does really well in my opinion, is his portrayal of Robin Hood himself and Alan's reaction to him. This part of the story rang true to how I can imagine it happening in reality. His characters are wonderful, but this book is INCREDIBLY violent. I'm looking forward to reading the next book in this series since it isn't about the crusades.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 136 reviews