Operation Olive Tree

by Jemil Metti

Operation Olive Tree is about two opera-talented, Oasis of Peace High School teenagers, Irith Goldman, an Israeli, and Jamal Shaheen, a Palestinian. Their passion for opera grows into a friendship and a dream to sing for peace. Despite initial support from the Israeli Ministry of Education and intensive opera coaching from Tel Aviv University’s award winning voice trainer Susan Roth, they are frequently haunted by cultural prejudices related to decades of warfare over territory and religion. In addition, the support of family and friends is dormant because of their collective mistrust of Irith’s partnership with her Palestinian singing prodigy who has family ties to an uncle, a terrorist suspect, and a childhood friend, an abused risk taker with regular brushes with the law. On the other hand, Jamal’s father fears losing him to opera, preferring his career to advance along the path of his older siblings in the medical field. But, nobody could have predicted the direction their careers take following their exposure to the life of a Mossad agent in Baghdad, Iraq, where Irith emerges as Russian-Swiss opera star Tatyana Smirnoff, and Jamal an escaped fugitive from Israeli law!

Genres: Fiction, Historical Fiction, Ebooks, Middle East, Asia, Music, Israel

355 pages, Kindle Edition

Published December 4, 2018

About the author

Jemil Metti was born in Long Island, New York to an Iraqi father and a Hungarian mother who passed away when he was two months old. After two years of American boarding school commencing in 1954, he was transferred to Beirut, Lebanon for a one-year stint before ending up in Baghdad, Iraq in 1957.

After living there his entire teen years, he returned to the United States in 1970. Metti attended Northern Illinois University, S.U.N.Y.-Binghamton, and Wayne State University-Detroit to earn his B.A., M.A. and Ed.D. respectively.

Currently Michigan-based, Metti professionally worked in broadcast and print journalism, real estate sales and education. Though his professional focus had almost entirely shifted to education by 1978, he just couldn't stay away from writing, politics and global affairs. And thus began his bid to freelance for the Michigan-based Romeo Observer (1980-1981) and the Advisor Newspapers (1981-1990). Jemil Metti retired from teaching at the end of 2019. He is now a full-time writer.

Reviews

[Kathy Smitheman · Rating 5 out of 5]

I totally loved this book!
Such an unusual concept for a story, but the characters, even the secondary characters have such breadth & depth.
Excellent but unusual development of the traditional parental wishes for a child that become ‘denied’.
A few parts of the story seem to take a while to get through but by the end you are truly rooting for Jamal & Irith.
The author definitely appears to have intimate knowledge of the subject allowing details in the plot to totally seem possible.
I would highly recommend this book.

[Cathy · Rating 3 out of 5]

I was lucky enough to win this book in a Goodreads Giveaway. I appreciate the opportunity of being able to read a book I probably wouldn’t have selected myself.

I gave this book a 3.5 rating. It was very intense and hard to follow at times. I fear that it was written that way to mirror real life in the Middle East. I feel that the true meaning of this book was lost on me because I don’t keep up on foreign policy or politics.

On the other hand, I did learn a lot from reading this book. It made me better appreciate my life as a US Citizen, who can enjoy the freedoms that so many can only dream about.

[Brenda Keckeisen · Rating 3 out of 5]

Enjoyable

At first I was confused and went back to read it over again. Understanding the conflict each culture and countries have, and what it’s takes to over come, this is a deeply written book.

[Firetruckmama · Rating 2 out of 5]

I won a copy of this book in a Goodreads giveaway. I liked the premise of this book and was curious to learn more about the issues in the Middle East, particularly between Palestine and Israel. Unfortunately this book, which started off with promise, became mired down with a lot of characters and a jumping about plot that I found difficult to follow. Also, some of the situations/solutions in the book seemed rather odd and even if they did happen in real life, no one would believe they actually happened (e.g., proving the authorship of a poem). The book was an interesting idea, I just wish it had been written/executed better.

[Melissa T · Rating 4 out of 5]

I won this book on goodreads first reads, Thank you!
I really enjoyed reading this book. At times it was confusing with the amount of characters but I was able to get through it.

[Liz · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a very, very sad and disturbing book. The tragic story two talented and attractive young people on opposite sides of an unresolvable, unrelenting war illustrates how complicated the Israeli/Palestinian situation is. Despite the glimpse of hope at the book's end, I can't help but believe there is only more of the same ahead. Definitely worth reading if you want to put a personal perspective on the conflict.
I won a copy of this book in a Goodreads giveaway for this honest review.

[Trudy Wilson · Rating 4 out of 5]

Although fiction I believe that this writer was able to depict the strife that happens when familial and/or political influences prevent youth from achieving the changes in society that they believe will enhance the lives around them. I suspect that this is as pronounced in the Middle East as the author shows. The relationships between the characters shows how difficult it is to be respectful even when beliefs differ. I feel that I have gained some insights as to why some Middle East immigrants are mistrustful about peoples intentions. This book reinforces for me my gratitude for living in Canada.

[Gwen A. · Rating 4 out of 5]

I won this book from Goodreads. It’s a very relatable story. I really like the characters and I really like the fundamental nature of the story, but the plot twists and turns left me somewhat confused.Perhaps fewer characters so other roles in the plot could be more fully developed. A glossary of characters and how they interconnected with one another in a family tree in the beginning of the book would’ve been helpful. Otherwise, I think the book is very relevant for issues that are still playing this area of the world in many other areas throughout the world, and indeed, relationships in general in any society. I’d recommend this book to others.

[Katie Avalos · Rating 1 out of 5]

This book is an unreadable mess. I tried for 25 long pages then gave up. It suffers from a clear lack of copy editing, the author's shirking of the very basic "show, don't tell" principle, and an insistence upon rehashing the facts without moving the story forward an inch. I tried to stick with it hoping the story wouldn't be as cliche and overwrought as it appears to be at this early juncture, but there are simply too many really good books that require so much less mental energy on the part of the reader for me to continue pushing through this mess. The author would do well to hire an honest content editor and a talented, patient copy editor and try again.

[Csimplot Simplot · Rating 5 out of 5]

Excellent book!!!

[Mary · Rating 5 out of 5]

Throughly enjoyed this book

[Kathy Webb · Rating 3 out of 5]

I won this Kindle edition book in a GoodReads
Giveaway. Thank you to everyone involved.
This is a well written book. Great characters.

[Morgan Andrews · Rating 2 out of 5]

I won this book in a goodreads giveaway. I really wanted to love it, but found the plot to be very confusing as it skipped around a lot.

[✨ ੈ✩‧April ♡ ʚ♡⃛ɞ✨ · Rating 3 out of 5]

"Operation Olive Tree" by Jemil Metti is a novel that explores themes of war, peace, and the complexities of human relationships against the backdrop of the Middle East conflict. The book offers a thought-provoking narrative that attempts to shed light on the intricate dynamics between different cultures and ideologies.

One of the strengths of this novel is its ability to present multiple perspectives on a highly sensitive and complex issue. Metti skillfully weaves together the stories of various characters, each representing a different facet of the conflict. This multifaceted approach provides readers with a broader understanding of the challenges and emotions involved in such a contentious situation.

However, while the book's subject matter is undeniably important, the execution falls somewhat short of its potential. The pacing of the story is uneven, with some sections dragging on while others feel rushed. This inconsistency can make it difficult for readers to stay fully engaged with the narrative. Additionally, the characters, while well-developed, sometimes come across as more symbolic than relatable, which can create a sense of distance between them and the reader.

The writing itself is competent, though at times it feels more like a vehicle for conveying the author's viewpoints rather than a fully immersive storytelling experience. Some of the dialogue feels stilted, and there are moments when the narrative feels heavy-handed in its messaging.

Despite these drawbacks, "Operation Olive Tree" has its merits. It raises important questions about the nature of conflict, the possibility of reconciliation, and the power of human connection. For readers interested in the Middle East and the complexities of international relations, this book offers a valuable perspective, even if it doesn't fully hit the mark in terms of literary execution.

In conclusion, "Operation Olive Tree" is a decent read that provides food for thought, but it may not leave a lasting impact on all readers. It’s worth picking up for those who are deeply interested in the subject matter, but it might not appeal to a broader audience.

[Celine Italia · Rating 3 out of 5]

I received a free copy of this book from the author, Jemil Metti, as part of a giveaway through Goodreads!

"Operation Olive Tree" follows two opera-talented teens, Israeli Irith Goldman and Palestinian Jamal Shaheen, whose shared passion for opera sparks a friendship and a dream to sing for peace between their peoples. Despite support from Tel Aviv University, they face cultural prejudices and family mistrust. Their lives take an unexpected turn when they encounter a Mossad agent in Baghdad, Iraq.

"Operation Olive Tree" by Jemil Metti explores themes of war, peace, and human relationships within the conflict occurring in the Middle East in the 1980s/1990s. The novel offers multiple perspectives, enriching my understanding of Israeli and Palestinian cultural dynamics, amongst others (although it felt very based on stereotypes, which may have been intended by the author). However, its uneven pacing and sometimes symbolic characters created an emotional distancing for me. Its intensity made it challenging to follow, likely reflecting the complexities of Middle Eastern life.

While thought-provoking, the book's literary execution may not fully engage all readers or leave a lasting impact. The deeper meaning may elude some readers due to limited background knowledge provided on foreign policies affecting the events occurring in the book, but hopefully one would gain a greater appreciation for the freedoms enjoyed, especially as a US citizen, like I did.

I give this book a 3.5/5 stars! Would recommend this book to any readers looking for an exploration of complex cultural and political conflicts, particularly those interested in the Israeli-Palestinian current events.

[Tammy Cook · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book is about young people living within the Palestinian/Israeli conflict region and the difficulties they face while attempting to build a peaceful future. Circumstances beyond their control lead to chaos intersecting every aspect of their lives. The sense of peace that they seek is not only elusive, but deceptive.

I felt like this book portrayed an accurate sense of the complicated life faced by young people living in this part of the Middle East. The story had some uncomfortable plot twists that mirror a sense of hopelessness faced during their transition into adulthood. It is a book that asks us, "how would you have handled those dilemmas at that age?"

I would recommend this book to a young adult audience. Those who long to understand human conflict will find it insightful.

[Sofi · Rating 5 out of 5]

"Operation Olive Tree" by Jemil Metti is an absolute gem of a read, brimming with intrigue, suspense, and heart. Metti masterfully weaves a tale that not only captivates but also enlightens, offering a rich tapestry of characters against the backdrop of an intricately plotted narrative. From the very first page, readers are drawn into a world of mystery and adventure, where every twist and turn keeps you eagerly turning pages. Metti's prose is as lush as the olive groves of the Mediterranean, painting vivid scenes that transport you effortlessly into the story. With its impeccable pacing and unforgettable characters, "Operation Olive Tree" is a literary feast that will leave you craving for more. Truly a must-read for anyone who appreciates a finely crafted thriller with depth and substance.

[Regina Carlton · Rating 4 out of 5]

This one is set in present day of Israel. The main characters are students attending a school for Arabs, Israelis, Jewish and Palestinians all in one school. These students are brought together to learn about each other's cultures, languages, history etc. in hopes of bringing together their nations without war. Two of the students are encouraged to learn opera which is not a usual career for those nations. I'm learning how much the different nationalities have so much anger and hate towards each other and how they learn to live together. Lots of restrictions between the cultures and a difficult life to live without fear. Gave four stars because the end seemed rushed to finalize with some of the characters.

[Jemil Metti]

This book was the kind of work I had been looking for. After more than six decades of seesawing between endless wars and failed diplomacy, I felt it was time to step out of the conventional box of repeated failures, and experiment what it would be like if the task of finding an Israeli-Palestinian peaceful solution somehow fell on the musical, operatic voices of politically uninvolved idealists like students, and a brave unusual place like Neve Shalom High, located half way between Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. The more I played around with "what if" type questions, and thought of my Jewish, Christian, and Muslim friends I grew up with in Baghdad, Iraq, the more both factors played a significant role breathing life into my writing of Operation Olive Tree. Now you know what I think. Rating and reviewing Operation Olive Tree I leave up to you. I expect nothing less than your honesty.

[Christi M · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed this book. Great story and quite a few captivating and suspenseful moments. However, a lot of the time I found myself confused at who was what, where was where, and who was on whose side. Perhaps a lot of that has to do with my limited knowledge of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and lack of Judaism awareness. In aid of that, I felt like the book could have been more clear and helped potential readers who may not be familiar with those topics.

Dialogue between characters was often stilted and not "flowy." I also feel there are a lot of loose ends I'm left to wonder about.

Overall, though, I did enjoy this book a lot.

[Danielle · Rating 3 out of 5]

I won this in a Goodreads giveaway, and I'm happy I did because it's not something I would have normally read on my own. The story seemed very interesting; Israelis and Palestinians growing up and learning together in order to break the spell of war. Two kids, one Israeli and one Palestinian, become friends, much to their families' chagrin, and bond over their love of opera music.
That said the pacing was stilted at times, and the story felt like it kept going back on itself. They spent 60 pages discussing whether one of the characters was even allowed to take singing lessons. The dialogue was choppy and didn't feel natural to me, but that may have been intentional, I'm not sure.

[Kristi · Rating 3 out of 5]

Won in a giveaway

I really enjoyed the first half of this story. It may have been set in the 1980s but the conflict between Palestinians and Israelis continues to be an issue. It felt almost timeless and that I was reading a nonfiction story. Then the story took a very hard turn in a different direction. The realist replaced with the improbable. Characters, like people, are allowed to grow and change, but it felt like many of these characters became entirely different people after this point in the book. It was still an engaging and enjoyable read, but a very different feeling. The attempt to resolve this in the last few chapters felt forced and predictable.

[Crystal · Rating 4 out of 5]

Irish, an Israeli; and Jamil, a Palestinian share the same gift. Both of them are forced to live a life directed by their fathers. Both are expected to hate the other. They go to the same high school where they are given classes better than the other schools. They are both trained by the same person to sing operas. They both must be strong and deal with bullying and harassment. Eventually, Jamil flees seeking education in a place where his life and freedom are not in constant jeopardy. In the end each must follow their heart to end up where they belong.

#GoodreadsGiveaway

[Nadine Younger · Rating 5 out of 5]

The tension between Israel and Palestine

The fighting between Israel and Palestine is both national and individual, and this book describes it as the way of life. It portrays intensely how deep the conflict, hatred and mistrust goes, destroying lives and leading to so many deaths.

This is the story of two young people who want to live in peace and unity, exploring what life and their gifts and talent have to offer. Their lives collide, intersect, and leave a trail of deaths and sadness as they try to find a way to be true to their families and to themselves.

[Linda Hartlaub · Rating 2 out of 5]

Note: I received this book through a Goodreads giveaway.

The premise is interesting - two students, one Palestinian and one Israeli, are picked to study opera together to bring the population together in a moment of peace. The book morphs to a spy novel and goes downhill from there. Besides the fact that having a 17-year-old tapped for a high-level spy mission and some dialogue that bogs the book down, there are other problems like flat characters that keep it from succeeding. This book could have used some serious work by a competent editor.

[Kerri · Rating 1 out of 5]

I received this book from a Goodreads Giveaway. I know I am in the minority here, but I did not enjoy this book. The writing was a little chaotic and hard to follow with large leaps in time and a lack of cohesion. I do read about other countries/cultures and often seek out foreign authors to get more insight and generally find them to be very rewarding; unfortunately, I found the issues with the writing in this book to be too distracting to allow me to fully appreciate the story being told.

[Kelly · Rating 2 out of 5]

I received this kindle book as a goodreads giveaway. I was looking forward to a positive story about a Palestinian teenager and an Israeli teenager attempting to study music together in Israel. I expected family and friends to disagree, but the constant threat of violence from family members became extreme. And, the convoluted plot of government spies had too many unnecessary twists to be able to follow.

[Kelly · Rating 2 out of 5]

I received this as a goodreads giveaway. I was looking forward to a story of two teenagers (Jewis and Palestinian) making their world a better place through music, despite the opposition of their families and communities.
The constant threat of violence from their own families bothered me. The government spy plot became very convoluted and difficult to follow. I finished it, but would not recommend it.

[Michele Rice Carpenter · Rating 4 out of 5]

Difficult but excellent

Operation Olive Tree is a difficult read primarily for the prejudices that exist between groups. The reader may find it necessary to reread parts or to put the book down to think about what was read. This book would be perfect for a book club or a college class where open discussion would help with understanding.

I won this book in a Goodreads giveaway.

[Samantha Ohler · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book is very nicely written and brings to light the issues continuing to plague Israel and Palestine today. This is a little bit of a heavy read but not all great books are light and fluffy. I would recommend this book for readers that are historical fictions, political / religious fictions, or those who are interested in reading more serious topics.