3.5 stars rounded up. I have such mixed feelings about this book... the good points are very, very good, but it did lag for me in a couple of key areas.
First, the good! I did not read the author bio before buying and reading the book, but it doesn't surprise me at all to learn that he is from Texas and has a journalism background. The setting--both geographical and professional--came alive, and the little details made me feel like I was really there. Small-town, generational dynamics played a big role in the story, and those elements felt very truthful and honest in their portrayal.
The book was also very well-written, and most scenes were easy to follow (the possible exception being some of the action scenes during the climax... which might partially be me as a reader. I tend to get a little lost in descriptions of action or fight scenes in general, so it might not be an issue with this book at all!). The dialogue felt natural, and the writing style was enjoyable as a whole.
I also liked the premise and was intrigued by the central mystery. All of the character arcs and subplots were woven together in a way that made nothing feel extraneous or unnecessary, and I was genuinely surprised by a few of the twists along the way.
Now, for the not-so-great... as a female reader, some of the male POVs felt a little grating to me. The main character says that he "has to have" a married woman with whom he once had an affair, and their relationship sometimes felt genuine and sometimes felt a little creepy. There is also mention of rape and statutory rape, which is appropriately portrayed as traumatic and criminal.... but some of the actions of the GOOD guys also feel a little creepy when it comes to their relationships with women. Some assumptions are also made about the victim, RayLynn, that both come out of nowhere narratively and seem a little prejudiced. Rather than simply learning that she did drugs or was sexually active from her friends and family members, the main characters ASSUME this based on events from her past, which also rubbed me the wrong way.
Some of the transitions between scenes and chapters felt a little choppy... I was always able to figure out what was going on, and it was really only a minor annoyance, but those little moments of "What's going on here?" added up. I also got a little confused by the sheer number of characters, especially toward the end. While the leads and the main supporting characters were well-developed, there were a couple of places where a minor character was reintroduced and it took me awhile to figure out who they were in relation to the other characters. Again, that might just be me as a reader though.
One of the biggest things that brought this down from a solid four-star read, though, was the last 10% or so of the book. The mystery had been solved at that point, and it felt like a too-long epilogue, or even like something that could have been expanded into a sequel with a different but related goal and conflict. It felt like we had already reached a satisfying conclusion, and then there were quite a few chapters that felt extra and tacked-on.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read that provided some solid entertainment. I'd definitely be interested in reading more from this author in the future.