What do you think?
Rate this book


31 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 19, 2000
I had a new Monday slot and Batgirl pointed me to stories about Spoiler in this series so I thought I’d try. I’ve been pretty impressed by Batman Confidential.
On the radio, they say "Go Discreet" but then they use each other’s first names!
That was really good. A solid detective story. The thing that keeps it from being a five is that all through the story they have a ‘narrator’ keeping a file on Batman and psycho-analyzing him all the way through the story.
It was completely unnecessary and the story would have had more emotional kick if it hadn’t been there. We can see what Batman’s going through and it would have been nice to figure it out ourselves instead of being told Batman’s mental state.
Of course, we’re supposed to wonder ‘who’ is keeping this file on Batman, but it greatly weakens the story and what supervillain isn’t keeping a file on Batman?!
The art was by Dale Eaglesham and John Floyd and very good. I hope the writing and art keep this high standard but we know #1 issues can be a bait and switch (looking at you Batgirls. )
4****