What a book. I haven't felt this thrilled/compelled by book in a long time. Cho Haejin's writing (or at least Lee Jieun's English translation) was so beautiful and breath-taking to read. I had to read this book in chunks and take breaks here and there because of how heavy some of the content was.
“I had long decided I could never know exactly when another person’s suffering starts, when it peaks, how it proceeds, how it infiltrates the person’s life, and how it occupies his or her waking hours. Perhaps it was this habitual noncommitment that led Loh’s words to jar me so badly, call so deeply into question where I stood. After recounting an arduous journey bereft of comfort or warmth and clouded with fatigue, Loh told the reporter, ‘I traded my mother for my own survival. That’s why I had to live.’”
This idea, that suffering can’t be quantified, sometimes can’t even be identified, is such an interesting idea. That you won’t be able to understand how pervasive the suffering of another is, how much it invades a person’s being rings so true. The idea that you can't reform someone's suffering, that you can only try to offer support, raises the question: How much can words alter the reality of a crisis?
So much of this book, by exploring the complexities of the characters, by diving into the nuances of their decision making, the depths of their emotional toils and the despair of regret, forces the reader into introspection. By reading the book (and the afterword mentions this), the reader inherently becomes involved in the processing of emotion, the recognition of suffering and how lonely being alive can feel.
At multiple points I would think, How can I judge Kim? How do I know, if put in the exact same circumstances as her, that my decision making would be different, that I would have the courage to do what's right? Don't we all run from our problems, avoid confronting our worst mistakes, in the fear that it will reveal something ugly about ourselves, something irreversible?
This was also the first time I've read a work about a North Korean refugee that doesn't fall into tropes of North Korea as bad and South Korea/the West as "savior" countries—a trope that is so overused, so flat that it turns the nuances of a refugee's experience into a stereotype, weaponizes it as propaganda. I loved that Cho takes time to explore Loh's story, as an individual, and doesn't take sides but rather let's his story speak for itself, with all the crags and crevices that exist in a human life.
This was truly a remarkable, remarkable read.