In November our vice-principal e-mailed the faculty to ask if we were interested in reading this book within an adult bookclub setting. Most certainly. Serravallo is the educator-du-jour on reading. I have read some of her work previously. I have mixed feelings. This book is similarly viewed.
There's a lot of good stuff presented here. Like much in educational writing, common sense accounts for a lot of what is presented. This book attempts more than the surface-level approach, however. A different approach to reading is sought (and somewhat justified) in the book. But with any prescriptive approach comes the natural "How?" questions. Teachers are more and more limited in the freedom to freelance how education flows. The test schedule, the need to on a pacing guide to accommodate a transient population, etc. are all real-world concerns that the panacean author does not address.
Nevertheless, the message is good. Teach the student, not the text. Conferring with students should move them along the continuum of the strategy.
What would have been immensely helpful is a fleshed-out continuum for each strategy per grade/reading level. That would have required a lengthier volume. Doing so also opens one up to the charge of prescription, but it would have been helpful to the readers who are asked to take a leap to have a net to prevent disaster.
The length of the book is something I considered as I read the book; it's 110 pages replete with large photographs and pages that are a single statement. This would have worked quite well as an ebook. The 110 pages was mostly for the style selected, not the content presented.
There are online links to videos of Serravallo conferring with children that provide examples of the content she writes. Those are helpful, but (as one can surmise) represent a best-case scenario at each grade level. I was also stricken with the children in the background during the conferences. Every child was on task. Most seemed to be of one gender and one ethnic group. I gave up listening to podcasts from Heinemann because of their insistance of bringing political issues into educational topics. I found the videos at odds with that aspect of the company's mission.
All the forms Serravallo uses are available for download. While I don't think these will be much use to me, I think it was good to provide them. The forms provide more for one to consider how to implement a program when the tools are provided.
I suspect the lasting affect of this book on me will be to ensure that the reading strategy, not the book's text is what is always front and center. I have this nagging feeling that the guided reading time in the classroom will change as I think through this message as it blends with some other thoughts I am entertaining regarding how I teach reading.